Why do they regard religion as being exempt from skeptical scrutiny?

If it feels good, do it, eh?

Well you either fail to understand moral relativism or you're deliberately being an obtuse git. Which is it?

Technically this IS what the universe says about morality. That is, there IS o morality, and therefore we could, all things considered kill anyone we wanted for any reason, rape people in the streets, loot, pillage and steal.

However this is not what moral relativism states WILL happen unless the universe is populated by utter morons who do not understand game theory really does apply.
Imagine that the whole world consists of two people, and they both have a pistol. Now imagine that they are in one room, and are stood opposite one another.

In this situation in order to promote their safety the best thing to do would to remove the threat, and thus kill the other. However, this is not logical, as the moment that it seemed that one would shoot the other, then the second person would lift their gun too, and the stalemate would ensue. The people therefore agree that while they don't have to leave the other alive, it is in their best interests not to remove their opposite, because then they would not face the possibility of being removed themselves. There would be a permanent stalemate whereby the people would not harm the other on the promise they would not be harmed, thus is the basis for all civilisation. Don't harm me or you yourself will be punished, and while it would theoretically be best to take everything, understand that this will be prevented, and you are better off accepting a slice of the pie rather than the whole thing, and we will do the same.
 
Which is what I am actually saying. Obviously moral systems cannot just be based on other moral systems. At base there must be an assertion. In the same way that Euclidean Geometry rests on its five axioms, any moral system must rest on certain assumptions. In a materialist worldview, any such moral axioms cannot be held as being necessarily true, and hence the moral system cannot be considered as being well founded.

I'm not actually disagreeing here - I'm just trying to point out the implications of a materialistic worldview. There are other posters claiming that it's possible to derive morality and ethics from pure reason. I'm saying that it isn't. You have to have some axiomatic base, and any such moral contention has to be non-materialistic.

I still don't see the area of disagreement here.

I guess most of us here are fully aware that any moral axiom is ultimately arbitrary. Since we already know that, what’s the point of pretending?

Understanding why we behave as we do is a fundamental property leading to acceptance. A moral foundation does not have to be non-materialistic (that doesn’t make sense anyway), it only needs to be regarded as valuable, and followed.

By using rational thinking and science (which go hand in hand), we certainly have a powerful tool for weeding out the obvious ill-based moral axioms (like homosexuality as sin or whatever crap it’s touted to be).

To pinpoint what indeed is valuable and should be regarded as a foundational principle is more difficult, but it makes more sense, again, to start building that via an understanding of why we behave as we do, than simply pretend such moral knowledge is directly derived from any ludicrous proposition based on superstition. Basically it’s about taking responsibility and waking up to reality.
 
Well you either fail to understand moral relativism or you're deliberately being an obtuse git. Which is it?

I'm referring to the Articulett's description of her actions as being motivated by what makes her feel good. As she is blessed with empathy, her actions are benevolent. The flaw with this approach for everyone is that some people feel bad doing bad things to other people.
 
Well you either fail to understand moral relativism or you're deliberately being an obtuse git. Which is it?

Technically this IS what the universe says about morality. That is, there IS o morality, and therefore we could, all things considered kill anyone we wanted for any reason, rape people in the streets, loot, pillage and steal.

However this is not what moral relativism states WILL happen unless the universe is populated by utter morons who do not understand game theory really does apply.
Imagine that the whole world consists of two people, and they both have a pistol. Now imagine that they are in one room, and are stood opposite one another.

In this situation in order to promote their safety the best thing to do would to remove the threat, and thus kill the other. However, this is not logical, as the moment that it seemed that one would shoot the other, then the second person would lift their gun too, and the stalemate would ensue. The people therefore agree that while they don't have to leave the other alive, it is in their best interests not to remove their opposite, because then they would not face the possibility of being removed themselves. There would be a permanent stalemate whereby the people would not harm the other on the promise they would not be harmed, thus is the basis for all civilisation. Don't harm me or you yourself will be punished, and while it would theoretically be best to take everything, understand that this will be prevented, and you are better off accepting a slice of the pie rather than the whole thing, and we will do the same.

What if there is just one pistol in the room. Each person has access to it for five minutes every day. What does game theory recommend then?

The trouble with game theory is that it sets up idealised small scale situations. What happens in real life is that people have hundreds of small choices to make every day. In many cases, they can act selfishly without personal consequences. It may be the case that if everyone acted the same way, that everyone would be worse off. However, that doesn't mean that game theory tells someone to act in a way harmful to himself in the hope that everyone else will do the same thing and hence benefit everyone equally. Game theory is no panacea.
 
The trouble with game theory is that it sets up idealised small scale situations. What happens in real life is that people have hundreds of small choices to make every day. In many cases, they can act selfishly without personal consequences. It may be the case that if everyone acted the same way, that everyone would be worse off. However, that doesn't mean that game theory tells someone to act in a way harmful to himself in the hope that everyone else will do the same thing and hence benefit everyone equally. Game theory is no panacea.


Game theory is not a recommendation, it is useful as a model of how things work, though.

We make selfish and altruistic choices all day long, many without even thinking about them. Sometimes we keep found money, sometime we turn it in. Sometimes we grab the last cookie, sometimes we offer it to another. Sometimes we work to send money or food to those in need, sometimes we choose not to. There is no one "right" or "wrong" in any given situation. We rationalize our actions all the time.

Often people behave selfishly without knowing, and only change their behavior after realizing that they have inadvertently harmed someone or something. Our moral code is constantly being reevaluated and altered to fit our knowledge about the world, and our place in it, as well as our value system. Slavery, racism, ecological destruction.. there are many examples of things we once thought were acceptable but now consider wrong.
 
Reason is one of the most important tools that science uses.

My remark was intended to contradict the suggestion that reason, being carried out apart from the context of science, can arrive at discoveries about reality that science can not address - that philosophy can achieve what science can not.

Science is how we learn about reality. Our best models of reality - our best understanding of how the world works and how it will work - are constructed through science.

Anything that we imagine or dream of, whether born of whimsy or years of careful reason, can be admitted to the collection of ideas that we hold to be 'true' only by being tested against the touchstone of science. Even then, its admission is provisional and it remains subject to retesting and reconsideration as long as we endure.

Reasoning, creative leaps, gut feelings, irrational associations, imagination - all can lead to ideas that can contribute to scientific advances and, thereby, improvements in our understanding of reality.

If they remain untested, however, if they are not subjected to the intense skeptical scrutiny and tested against our best understanding of reality, if they are not subjected to science, no claim regarding their truthfulness or accuracy should be made.
Thanks for amplifying your remark.
 
Not necessarily well founded, no - but one moral system can still be better founded than another moral system, if the first moral system is based on an assumption, but the second moral system is based on an incorrect assumption.

No, moral systems are never fundamentally based on assumptions, incorrect or otherwise. There is always, at base, an "ought". It is this which determines the moral system.

Ironically, it is possible to determine when an assumption is incorrect, but not when it is correct (I discussed this a bit in the other thread). Moral systems could, in that regard, be subject to Popperian falsification (though I'd rather not get into that idea here - keep the topic reasonably focused).



You have to have some kind of axiomatic base, yes - those are the values I discussed. But why on earth would you say that any moral contention has to be non-materialistic? A non-materialistic foundation is the worst possible type of foundation, because it is not based in reality as we understand it, and is thus unjustified.

A non-materialistic foundations is always the basis of a moral system. It is never based in reality as we understand it. In a materialistic universe such a choice is effectively arbitrary.

A moral system asserts that certain things ought to happen in preference to other things. A materialistic universe does not prefer one state over another. It is a matter of indifference to science, reason or the universe as a whole whether I live or die. When I construct a moral system which considers it better that I live, I am adding to materialism.

This is fairly fundamental, and I thought we had all this sorted out already.
 
No, moral systems are never fundamentally based on assumptions, incorrect or otherwise. There is always, at base, an "ought". It is this which determines the moral system.

...snip...

An "ought" in this context is an assumption.
 
Slavery, racism, ecological destruction.. there are many examples of things we once thought were acceptable but now consider wrong.

I consider that such things can be considered as being explicitly wrong. I'm interested in establishing the basis of morality without divine commands.
 
Understanding why we behave as we do is a fundamental property leading to acceptance. A moral foundation does not have to be non-materialistic (that doesn’t make sense anyway), it only needs to be regarded as valuable, and followed.

But there is no materialistic meaning for value. It is an imaginary human construct without scientific justification. In a materialistic universe, value is just something we choose to assign. All choices are equally valid.

By using rational thinking and science (which go hand in hand), we certainly have a powerful tool for weeding out the obvious ill-based moral axioms (like homosexuality as sin or whatever crap it’s touted to be).

It's impossible to use reason to root out moral axioms since the axioms are never based on reason. That's not to say that reason can't be used to figure out what axioms might lead to particular results. However, rational thinking and science don't care whether we all vanish in a cloud of radioactive dust. The universe is indifferent.

To pinpoint what indeed is valuable and should be regarded as a foundational principle is more difficult, but it makes more sense, again, to start building that via an understanding of why we behave as we do, than simply pretend such moral knowledge is directly derived from any ludicrous proposition based on superstition. Basically it’s about taking responsibility and waking up to reality.

Reality is that either we believe that right and wrong have some kind of independent existence - which is every bit as mystical as praying to little baby Jesus - or we recognise that moral systems are just arbitrary ways of getting along, and that one has as much intrinsic value as another.
 
But there is no materialistic meaning for value. It is an imaginary human construct without scientific justification. In a materialistic universe, value is just something we choose to assign. All choices are equally valid.
...snip...

This is just an assertion - can you back it up?

I'm also going to have to ask you to provide a define for your use of the word "materialistic". I had thought you were using it in the usual philosophical sense but there is no way that can fit how you've used it in your last few posts.
 
No, moral systems are never fundamentally based on assumptions, incorrect or otherwise. There is always, at base, an "ought". It is this which determines the moral system.

A non-materialistic foundations is always the basis of a moral system. It is never based in reality as we understand it. In a materialistic universe such a choice is effectively arbitrary.

A moral system asserts that certain things ought to happen in preference to other things. A materialistic universe does not prefer one state over another. It is a matter of indifference to science, reason or the universe as a whole whether I live or die. When I construct a moral system which considers it better that I live, I am adding to materialism.

This is fairly fundamental, and I thought we had all this sorted out already.



I don't think it's either/or. It's both. Everyone's moral system is constructed with the premise that "it is better if I live". That's programmed into us by nature. But there's more to it than that. It includes "and this is how the world I live in works". Our morals are conditional.

When food is plentiful, we tend to think it's better for everyone to have an equal share.

When food is scarce, we think up reasons to justify why we should get more than other people.
 
I don't know about a materialistic universe but I do know that "ought" exists in this universe!

If you believe that certain events are objectively preferable to other events, then you have moved away from a universe based purely on science and reason. Which is OK by me - I believe that certain events are objectively preferable to other events. But if you do believe that the universe has such preferences, it's not possible to discover them using reason and science.
 
This is just an assertion - can you back it up?

I'm also going to have to ask you to provide a define for your use of the word "materialistic". I had thought you were using it in the usual philosophical sense but there is no way that can fit how you've used it in your last few posts.

I'm not entirely clear on the precise philosophical use. I'm not a professional philosopher, so some terms are going to need to be defined.

In this case, when I refer to a materialistic universe, I'm referring to one which is entirely governed by the laws of science. There seems to be a consensus among a number of atheists posting here that this is an accurate description of the universe. I'm interested in exploring the implications of that belief, and the possibility that other atheists have a different view.
 
If you believe that certain events are objectively preferable to other events, then you have moved away from a universe based purely on science and reason. Which is OK by me - I believe that certain events are objectively preferable to other events. But if you do believe that the universe has such preferences, it's not possible to discover them using reason and science.
This is just an assertion - can you back it up?

I'm also going to have to ask you to provide a define for your use of the word "objective". I had thought you were using it in the usual philosophical sense but there is no way that can fit how you've used it in your last few posts.

Sorry for the seemingly parroting of my question but either you are just posting nonsense or you are using many words with quite different meanings to their standard usage.
 
westprog said:
But there is no materialistic meaning for value. It is an imaginary human construct without scientific justification. In a materialistic universe, value is just something we choose to assign.
westprog said:
All choices are equally valid.

There’s no meaning to values except when we regard them as meaningful. We should maybe try to find such values that don’t require meaningless fairytales to support them. I.e. we don’t need to believe in some fairytale in order to regard the golden rule as perhaps a valuable principle.

It's impossible to use reason to root out moral axioms since the axioms are never based on reason. That's not to say that reason can't be used to figure out what axioms might lead to particular results. However, rational thinking and science don't care whether we all vanish in a cloud of radioactive dust.
The universe is indifferent.

As I already said, and you alluded to, reason and science go hand in hand. The more we understand the less obvious ill-based moral axioms can be justified. Homosexuality is a good example in this regard; there’s no foundation to the notion of sin, thus no foundation to regard homosexuality as something punishable. Understanding is the key, and rationality is a basic tool for understanding.

Reality is that either we believe that right and wrong have some kind of independent existence - which is every bit as mystical as praying to little baby Jesus - or we recognise that moral systems are just arbitrary ways of getting along, and that one has as much intrinsic value as another.

There are no intrinsic values anyway; we should stop pretending there are. That knowledge doesn’t stop us from following some values however. The more rational we are, and the more knowledge and understanding we have, the less there’s going to be ill-based values. Ultimately, morality is what we read between the lines.
 
I'm not entirely clear on the precise philosophical use. I'm not a professional philosopher, so some terms are going to need to be defined.

In this case, when I refer to a materialistic universe, I'm referring to one which is entirely governed by the laws of science. There seems to be a consensus among a number of atheists posting here that this is an accurate description of the universe. I'm interested in exploring the implications of that belief, and the possibility that other atheists have a different view.

Thanks for the clarification but then it is as I said - all you have done is asserted your views, so far you have not supported your claims.
 
In this case, when I refer to a materialistic universe, I'm referring to one which is entirely governed by the laws of science. There seems to be a consensus among a number of atheists posting here that this is an accurate description of the universe. I'm interested in exploring the implications of that belief, and the possibility that other atheists have a different view.

Just want to clarify something here. Science does not "govern" the laws of the universe. Science is the method we use to discover and understand the laws of the universe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom