Why do they regard religion as being exempt from skeptical scrutiny?

No. Skepticism is a methodology. It's a step-by-step process which does something no other system of thought does - it starts with evidence and arrives at a conclusion later.

I know, my comment was a bit tongue in cheek and perhaps a lame attempt at humor.
 
You are right. My reply wasn't about why you should accept anything, but was in response why someone might want to consider them. That's all. I'm sure there are lot's of reason in addition to those that I wrote to why someone might want to consider them.

Here's some other off-the-cuff reasons you might want to consider them:

1) To prove they are not real
2) To make someone doubt they are real
3) You find religions fascinating
4) You're doing a thesis on miracles on the ancient world

No one here has argued that one should not consider religion. I encourage it. The fastest way to get more people to become atheists is by encouraging them to consider their religion and all its vapid, cancerous claims.
 
If that doesn't seem doubly odd to you, take off the religious blinders - it's genetically impossible for a human female to parthenogetically give birth to a human male, leaving aside the fact that humans don't undergo parthenogenesis.

The answer, obviously, is that Jesus was a she-male. Given that God was allegedly the parent of Jesus, and God must be androgynous if you believe the bible, then it stands to reason that Jesus inherited the trait.
Although the virgin birth claim is moot to begin with because "almah" means young woman whereas "bethulah" means virgin.


Also, to anyone claiming that one cannot disprove the existence of God, I would direct you to the following thread. QED :D
 
Science can and will discover how concepts of morality and ethics have evolved. Science will be able to explain why some of these concepts have thrived and others have not.

Science will also be able to explain why specific people hold the moral and ethical beliefs that they hold, as well as why they are susceptible to some memes and not to others.

That is a totally different question. Explaining morality and explaining why people hold particular beliefs are very different things.

I obviously disagree with you on these issues.

In the future, please do not edit quoted material - you risk confusing things.

I think that the occasional cut is necessary. In this case, no change to the meaning was caused.

ETA: Your term 'scientism' is silly.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientism
 
I believe God can do miracles and currently have no reason to believe the incarnation didn't happen the way traditionally it's held it happened.
You see no reason to to disbelieve that a child could be concieved without a sperm?
Once one believes in a God who can violate physical laws, there's no reason to disbelieve anything.
OK, and why should one believe such a thing?


I don't know why. All I know is that CS stated that he believed in the miracles described in the New Testament. Once he did so, there's really no reason to quiz him on each and every miracle.
 
The answer, obviously, is that Jesus was a she-male. Given that God was allegedly the parent of Jesus, and God must be androgynous if you believe the bible, then it stands to reason that Jesus inherited the trait.

Given the Hebrew predeliction for male infant genital mutilation, Jesus having been secretly a woman would be highly inconsistent.

Although the virgin birth claim is moot to begin with because "almah" means young woman whereas "bethulah" means virgin.

Yes, but let's let them compound stupidities.
 
That is a totally different question. Explaining morality and explaining why people hold particular beliefs are very different things.


The question 'How did moral and ethical positions evolve?' has valid answers and science can discover them.

The question 'Why do people believe what they believe?' has valid answers and science can discover them.

The question 'Which moral and ethical positions are correct?' has no valid answers.

The question 'What should I believe?' has no valid answers.


I think that the occasional cut is necessary. In this case, no change to the meaning was caused.


I've made the request. We'll see if you'll honor it.
 
Last edited:
Go Imaginal Disc... same ol' religious apologist rhetoric. Westprog disprove the Matrix theory or Fairies or Scientology...

Just because no one can prove your self important assertions false, doesn't mean that any person interested in what is true should take it seriously. I can't disprove Imaginal Disc's Lemur theory or the Mormon's Kolob... but that sure isn't a reason to "believe".

After a while all the woo and their apologist buddies sound the same to me...

Randi said that at TAM6... all the tricks and excuses and so forth are all the same... there's nothing new in the world of woo. Semantics, smoke and mirrors, demonizing the opponent, imagining yourself an expert on some "divine secret"... same ol'; same ol.
 
Last edited:
The question 'How did moral and ethical positions evolve?' has valid answers and science can discover them.

The question 'Why do people believe what they believe?' has valid answers and science can discover them.

The question 'Which moral and ethical positions are correct?' has no valid answers.

The question 'What should I believe?' has no valid answers.





I've made the request. We'll see if you'll honor it.

It appears that westprog is standard variety self-important apologist. Maybe he and Claus can get into a conversation and leave the rest of us alone as they implode into a frenzy of pedantic digressions and straw man.

And scientism is a woo term to try to put evidence based knowledge on par with faith based knowledge...

He's also doing that goofy thing as if having 2 possibilities (Xenu or no Xenu) means that there's a 50/50 probability of each...

I think these arguments must work well on a brain made irrational by faith because they all seem to use the same word games and vapid nonsense. (I guess it's the best they have.)
 
Last edited:
The answer, obviously, is that Jesus was a she-male. Given that God was allegedly the parent of Jesus, and God must be androgynous if you believe the bible, then it stands to reason that Jesus inherited the trait.
Although the virgin birth claim is moot to begin with because "almah" means young woman whereas "bethulah" means virgin.


Also, to anyone claiming that one cannot disprove the existence of God, I would direct you to the following thread. QED :D

Or this:

http://www.400monkeys.com/God/

Of course, here's a nice compendium of semantic "proofs of god' using logical fallacies common to theists:

http://www.godlessgeeks.com/LINKS/GodProof.htm
 
I know. I already included a link to the latter list in the topic of mine that I linked to. :p

It's more fun to make up my own though.
 
Last edited:
Gould is quite wrong.

As I said earlier, Jesus either had a father or he didn't.

As Dawkins noted, if we managed to dig up Jesus' remains and determine he did not have a father, could you possibly imagine Christians, or our own forum Christians declaring that this find means nothing to their faith? The notion is absurd.

As A Christian Skeptic adheres to Goulds words, I would like to ask him(her??):

Did Jesus have a father or not?
Walrus, what did you mean by "determining that he did not have a father?" Are you implying spontaneous gestation within Mary, or a confirmation of something other than a standard male seed as the trigger to his growing within Mary, that something being . . . . what? Evidence of the divine zygote?

I rather lost you there, and hope you'll amplify. (Am I on the right track?)

DR
 
I disagree - reason can not advance farther than science.

Complexity, I think that's backwards.

Science, to advance, requires reasoning to ask the next question, take the next step, form the next hypothesis, design the next experiment, come to conclusions, test and or confirm them, and thus advance science to the next state.

It seems to me more correct to say "science can advance no farther than reason allows" but we may not be talking about the same thing.

DR
 
Last edited:
:It seems to me more correct to say "science can advance no farther than reason allows" but we may not be talking about the same thing.
.
Giordano Bruno ran into the limits that reason would permit.
 
The question 'How did moral and ethical positions evolve?' has valid answers and science can discover them.

The question 'Why do people believe what they believe?' has valid answers and science can discover them.

The question 'Which moral and ethical positions are correct?' has no valid answers.

The question 'What should I believe?' has no valid answers.

So presumably the question "should I shoot that guy next door playing his stereo too loud" has no valid answer?

I've made the request. We'll see if you'll honor it.

I'll snip like Edward Scissorhands if I think it warranted. What, we're going to include everybody's entire past history in every post?
 
It appears that westprog is standard variety self-important apologist. Maybe he and Claus can get into a conversation and leave the rest of us alone as they implode into a frenzy of pedantic digressions and straw man.

Did I invite you in? You don't want to talk to me, don't talk to me. There's really no need to have a long discussion about not talking to me.

And scientism is a woo term to try to put evidence based knowledge on par with faith based knowledge...

Scientism is not nearly as much a threat to religion as it is to science.

He's also doing that goofy thing as if having 2 possibilities (Xenu or no Xenu) means that there's a 50/50 probability of each...

I forget just where I referred to probability. Could you quote that please?

I think these arguments must work well on a brain made irrational by faith because they all seem to use the same word games and vapid nonsense. (I guess it's the best they have.)

How can Articulett produce such endless streams of verbiage without constructing something like an argument? Calling people goofballs and irrational is not as impressive as actually demonstrating that they are irrational goofballs.
 
Walrus, what did you mean by "determining that he did not have a father?" Are you implying spontaneous gestation within Mary, or a confirmation of something other than a standard male seed as the trigger to his growing within Mary, that something being . . . . what? Evidence of the divine zygote?

I rather lost you there, and hope you'll amplify. (Am I on the right track?)

DR

In any case, there are plenty of Christians for whom the virgin birth is of no great significance.

In any case, digging up Jesus would have far more significance than finding out his parentage.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom