Why do they regard religion as being exempt from skeptical scrutiny?

And it's not a "belief", it's a method-- the best one we have actually. There is no evidence that anything supernatural guides anything--

All "belief systems" are the equivalent of telling you what color clothes you should see when you look at the naked Emperor. We don't need to imagine clothes on the Emperor--we just avoid looking at him-- it's easy when he doesn't exist.
 
Last edited:
No, moral systems are never fundamentally based on assumptions, incorrect or otherwise. There is always, at base, an "ought". It is this which determines the moral system.

No, there is not. Where, for example, is the 'ought' in, "Human life is sacred," or, "Pleasure is good,"? These things can be values on which we base a moral system, but they are not themselves normative statements. Value judgments, yes - but that's the entire point!

A non-materialistic foundations is always the basis of a moral system. It is never based in reality as we understand it. In a materialistic universe such a choice is effectively arbitrary.

Absolute crap. The basis of a moral system is always going to be subjective, but subjective statements are not 'non-materialistic'. You're trying to say that just because something isn't objective it is non-materialistic, ignoring the fact that it is entirely possible to have subective materialistic statements. There is nothing 'non-materialistic' about the statement, "I like cheese," for example.

A moral system asserts that certain things ought to happen in preference to other things. A materialistic universe does not prefer one state over another. It is a matter of indifference to science, reason or the universe as a whole whether I live or die. When I construct a moral system which considers it better that I live, I am adding to materialism.

Again, pure nonsense. How can science, reason or the universe be indifferent to whether you live or die? You are projecting human attributes onto things that are not capable of thought - science, reason and the universe are incapable of being indifferent!

You seem to think that if one accepts a materialistic view of the universe, then one must accept a moral system that is 'objective' in the grand scheme of things: The universe doesn't care about anything, therefore neither should you. That is the exact opposite of the actual, logical conclusion: That our moral systems will necessarily be subjective, as there is no objective yardstick by which we can measure them. We can take our subjective assumptions, and build our moral systems from there.

In other words, when you construct a moral system that considers it better that you live, you are constructing a moral system based on a subjective opinion - there is nothing non-materialistic about it. And you certainly aren't adding to materialism - indeed, I have no idea what you mean by that. It seems to be no more than a nonsense statement.

This is fairly fundamental, and I thought we had all this sorted out already.

Indeed, it is fundamental, and if your head weren't so firmly lodged in your nether regions you might understand it. Unfortunately, you seem hell bent on insisting everybody play by your, incorrect, rules, so as of yet we haven't made any progress.

Honestly, take your smug, condescending tone to someone who gives a damn. I you want to have a discussion, you need to stop patronising those who disagree with you - because I guarantee you, I can dish it all right back out at you and not blink twice.
 
Just want to clarify something here. Science does not "govern" the laws of the universe. Science is the method we use to discover and understand the laws of the universe.

But I didn't say that science governed the universe. I said that the Laws of science governed the universe - such laws being considered to be fundamental to the way the universe works. They aren't subservient to science - it's the job of science to figure out how they work. Incidentally, it's never (or almost never) the case that science claims to have the final word on what the laws are.
 
In this case, when I refer to a materialistic universe, I'm referring to one which is entirely governed by the laws of science. There seems to be a consensus among a number of atheists posting here that this is an accurate description of the universe. I'm interested in exploring the implications of that belief, and the possibility that other atheists have a different view.
Alright, I'll bite. I subscribe to that world view. - That the universe is completely governed by the laws of science. What implications of that belief are you attempting to explore?
 
I'm also going to have to ask you to provide a define for your use of the word "objective". I had thought you were using it in the usual philosophical sense but there is no way that can fit how you've used it in your last few posts.

When I say that something is objectively wrong, I mean that it is wrong regardless of what someone's opinion is. I mean that it is wrong in the same sense that an electron has a negative charge, and that it is impossible to accelerate faster than the speed of light.

As far as I can tell, MobySeven does not believe this to be true. It is, as far as I can tell, incompatible with the materialist viewpoint.
 
No, there is not. Where, for example, is the 'ought' in, "Human life is sacred," or, "Pleasure is good,"? These things can be values on which we base a moral system, but they are not themselves normative statements. Value judgments, yes - but that's the entire point!

The statement "Human life is sacred" becomes a meaningless platitude unless it can be developed into an imperative of some kind. "Human life is sacred, hooray" means nothing. "Human life is sacred, thou shalt not kill" becomes the basis of a moral system. The moral code starts with the "ought". Up till then, we have very little - possibly the basis of a belief system, but not one that changes anything.

Absolute crap. The basis of a moral system is always going to be subjective, but subjective statements are not 'non-materialistic'. You're trying to say that just because something isn't objective it is non-materialistic, ignoring the fact that it is entirely possible to have subective materialistic statements. There is nothing 'non-materialistic' about the statement, "I like cheese," for example.

"I like cheese" can be considered as a valid statement in a materialistic universe. "Cheese is good" cannot.

Again, pure nonsense. How can science, reason or the universe be indifferent to whether you live or die? You are projecting human attributes onto things that are not capable of thought - science, reason and the universe are incapable of being indifferent!

And your point is?

You seem to think that if one accepts a materialistic view of the universe, then one must accept a moral system that is 'objective' in the grand scheme of things: The universe doesn't care about anything, therefore neither should you. That is the exact opposite of the actual, logical conclusion: That our moral systems will necessarily be subjective, as there is no objective yardstick by which we can measure them. We can take our subjective assumptions, and build our moral systems from there.

In other words, when you construct a moral system that considers it better that you live, you are constructing a moral system based on a subjective opinion - there is nothing non-materialistic about it. And you certainly aren't adding to materialism - indeed, I have no idea what you mean by that. It seems to be no more than a nonsense statement.

But how can a moral system based on one preference be better founded than a moral system based on another preference? If systems are based on preferences, then one preference is as good as another.

It may be that a moral system is improperly derived from an initial preference. It may be that the derivation of the moral code relies on facts that aren't well founded. But a preference is not a fact, and de gustibus non est disputandum.

This is precisely the grey area that I am picking away at. If a moral code is based on preferences, then it cannot be said to have a firm base in reason. That is not to say that it doesn't exist entirely in the materialistic universe. Of course it does. But the preferences have no extrinsic meaning.

What is strange about this is that there seems to be general acceptance of this point in principle, but in practice, most of the atheists posting here seem to regard the existence of an objective moral code as to be taken for granted. The "faith is evil" thread is based on a statement that is nonsensical in a materialistic analysis. If moral codes are a matter of preference, how can "evil" be considered as something real?

HUHA snipped.
 
Alright, I'll bite. I subscribe to that world view. - That the universe is completely governed by the laws of science. What implications of that belief are you attempting to explore?

In the succession of discussion with Mobyseven, it seems that a moral code in such a universe is derived, ultimately, from preferences. Someone who believes in such a universe cannot believe in inherent moral values.

(Darat seems to disagree with me about this. He says that he can't follow my arguments, and I can't see what his objections are, so I'll leave that aside for now).

I'm interested to see how atheists deal with this. In the thread "faith is evil" I note that Volatile and ThaiBoxerKen both use "evil" as a term having an objective meaning. They don't specifically state that "evil" is a property of the universe - but neither do they treat it as if it were a matter of their own personal choices.

I'm delving into this.
 
Oh, ffs. I'm through with this. When you're prepared to actually have a mature discussion about this, I'm perfectly happy for you to PM me, but at the moment I may as well be talking to a broken record. If I wanted to address the same points over and over again I'd post on Loose Change forums.

Have a read over what I've already said, and this time read for comprehension. Use the brain that evolution gave you.
 
I'm interested to see how atheists deal with this. In the thread "faith is evil" I note that Volatile and ThaiBoxerKen both use "evil" as a term having an objective meaning. They don't specifically state that "evil" is a property of the universe - but neither do they treat it as if it were a matter of their own personal choices.

I do not believe Volatile is saying that at all.
 
I do not believe Volatile is saying that at all.

I went back and scanned through Volatile's posts, and I think you're right. My apologies to Volatile for mischaracterising him. He seems to be a reasonable person, and I don't want to put the wrong opinions into people's mouths.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom