Why do they regard religion as being exempt from skeptical scrutiny?

Of course you think it's a convenient label. It fits your preconceived notions of 'scientific boundaries' without any of that pesky need to justify your position - just say that something is scientism run amok and you seem to be making a valid point, even though all you're doing is spouting useless unjustified rhetoric. It's a similar thing as to what the creationists do when they call people 'Darwinists'.

Mind you, the irony is off the charts here. I take it you shant be complaining when Articulett or Complexity call people 'apologists' anymore, eh? After all, they use it as a term that is convenient for them!

There seems to be a bit of confusion here. Moby7 is ruling out any use of the term scientism as being unhelpful. I'm claiming that it's a valid description of inappropriate uses of science. For example, a claim that moral systems can rest on science is an example of scientism. As Moby7 has said, moral systems just rest on other moral systems. It's a matter of which one we choose. Moby7 wants to rule the term out of the language altogether

As for Articulett's use of "apologist" - I'm sure I'm not the only person to note that when she makes such claims she doesn't ever quote the offending post, or describe the offence in any detail. It's thus very difficult to say whether she's using it appropriately or not. Since her anger seems to be aimed, in this case, at heretical atheists, I'm not too pushed either way.
 
Sorry for not referencing you directly as I was crunched for time/bandwidth this morning. :)

And reading your clarification, here's my take on it. General religious claims cannot be tested by the scientific method, but specific religious claims and most supernatural claims (ghosts, which I don't consider a religious claim for example) can be tested. I don't consider the claim that God created the Earth or that the Himilayas are Shiva's braided hair to be testable within the scientific method. That the Earth and all life on it was spontaneously created 6,000 years ago or that a particular child is the reincarnation of a deceased person is definately testible and falsifiable.

I don't believe the metaphysical claims about God or Shiva mentioned above, but I cannot falsify them with the scientific method.

I agree with the above. It's quite possible for religious claims to spill over into the scientific arena, and it's then entirely appropriate for science to test the claims, and confirm or rebut them. If that ends up upsetting somebody's beliefs, then that's not the fault of science.

If somebody attempts to put the imprimatur of science on a claim that is not testable or verifiable, then that is a misuse of science.
 
No, I would not agree with that, so don't go about presuming anything. What I would say is that when I judge an action to be right or wrong, I recognise that I am judging it based upon what values I personally hold to be most important.

Moreover, I am perfectly open to adjusting my view of what is and isn't moral, and am better able to discuss morality with those whose values differ to mine, as I may be able to frame the argument in terms of their values, and not in terms of 'right' and 'wrong'.

However, if you are talking to someone who insists that a particular act is wrong, not according to her personal viewpoint, but in some absolute sense, then I presume you will regard them as being mistaken in precisely the same sense as a theist is mistaken about the nature of reality.

I will continue to make presumptions based on what you're saying, and you're entirely welcome to clarify your meaning.

Not entirely sure what you mean by that. If one person values 'the rights of the individual' and another values 'the rights of society', then on what basis can the first person promote their value to the second?

If there is no acceptance of any fundamental moral values, then it's entirely possible to have total disagreement. However, the rights of society are normally held to derive from the rights of all the people within that society, so coming up with a solution isn't that difficult. Most moral systems are based on some version of the Golden Rule, and most societies are loosely based around that principle.

There are things that I consider to be universal human rights based upon my moral system. However, as there are a number of things that some people consider to be universal human rights and some people do not consider to be a right at all - that itself serves as an example of how different values can divide moral opinion, even in Western civilisation.

But your moral system has no firmer basis than another, which might not recognise universal human rights.
 
There seems to be a bit of confusion here. Moby7 is ruling out any use of the term scientism as being unhelpful. I'm claiming that it's a valid description of inappropriate uses of science. For example, a claim that moral systems can rest on science is an example of scientism. As Moby7 has said, moral systems just rest on other moral systems. It's a matter of which one we choose. Moby7 wants to rule the term out of the language altogether

Mobyseven finds it polite when people talk to him, not about him as though they are delivering a lecture to a class. Mobyseven would also appreciate it if people would stop misrepresenting his position, especially replacing it with nonsense ideas such as moral systems resting on other moral systems. Mobyseven thinks that scientism is a nonsense term, as an 'inappropriate use of science' already has a name. It's called 'not actually doing science', and while not as catching or pejorative as 'scientism', it actually conveys meaning rather than acting as a silly little put down.
 
...
Yeah... Westprog is an apologist; I have him on ignore.
...
opinions... if people dish them out, I do hope they can take them in.
...
Your double standard is showing, US

It's a shame that articulett has me on ignore. Too much irrationality, I suppose.
 
Mobyseven finds it polite when people talk to him, not about him as though they are delivering a lecture to a class.

I proclaim the OP a...
FAIL

Westprog might find it easier to be polite to Moby7 if he hadn't kicked off his entry into the discussion as if he were marking an exam. If you don't like it, don't dish it out - is that good game theory?

Part of the time a one-on-one discussion is taking place. However, it's an open forum, and ignoring the other people involved in the debate is also impolite. So there's a balance involved.

Mobyseven would also appreciate it if people would stop misrepresenting his position, especially replacing it with nonsense ideas such as moral systems resting on other moral systems.

Which moral decision we use is, for all intents and purposes, arbitrary: If we had a system that told us which moral system we should use, then that system would itself be a moral system, and we would be begging the question.

I'm trying to be fair here, but I cannot see how I am misrepresenting the M7 position.

Mobyseven thinks that scientism is a nonsense term, as an 'inappropriate use of science' already has a name. It's called 'not actually doing science', and while not as catching or pejorative as 'scientism', it actually conveys meaning rather than acting as a silly little put down.

There are a lot of words in the English language for which alternatives exist. Scientism doesn't simply refer to 'not actually doing science' but to 'claiming scientific justification when not actually doing science', as with Scientology, Christian Science, Scientific Socialism, Economics, Creation Science and so on.
 
Last edited:
However, if you are talking to someone who insists that a particular act is wrong, not according to her personal viewpoint, but in some absolute sense, then I presume you will regard them as being mistaken in precisely the same sense as a theist is mistaken about the nature of reality.

Indeed, the person who claims there is an absolute moral right and wrong is mistaken. What is your point?

If there is no acceptance of any fundamental moral values, then it's entirely possible to have total disagreement. However, the rights of society are normally held to derive from the rights of all the people within that society, so coming up with a solution isn't that difficult. Most moral systems are based on some version of the Golden Rule, and most societies are loosely based around that principle.

A person who values society above the individual is probably going to adhere to some form of utilitarianism. A person who values the individual above society is probably going to adhere to some form of liberalism. Sure, they may agree on a number of issues (e.g. 'murder is bad'), but there are likely an even greater number of moral issues that they will disagree about. You are projecting your own moral system onto the issue by saying that, "...the rights of society are normally held to derive from the rights of all the people within that society," as in many societies, past and present, that is not the case.

But your moral system has no firmer basis than another, which might not recognise universal human rights.

Is that a problem?
 
There are a lot of words in the English language for which alternatives exist. Scientism doesn't simply refer to 'not actually doing science' but to 'claiming scientific justification when not actually doing science', as with Scientology, Christian Science, Scientific Socialism, Economics, Creation Science and so on.

I would also think that the word should refer to people that "use pieces of science to justify moral beliefs while ignoring others."

Case in point, I was talking with one of the "abstinence only" counselors at my kid's school a year or so ago, and she had several studies she made a big point to talk about, which attempted to "prove" that adolescents should not have sex, and that waiting until marriage was the right thing to do. One of those studies linked early sexual activity to delinquent behavior, and said that adolescents that had sex early were more likely to try drugs or engage in criminal behavior.

The other day I was surfing the net and came upon this: http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/11/071112140723.htm
A new study by University of Virginia clinical psychologists has found that teens who have sex at an early age may be less inclined to exhibit delinquent behavior in early adulthood than their peers who waited until they were older to have sex. The study also suggests that early sex may play a role in helping these teens develop better social relationships in early adulthood.

One of the things about understanding and using science is knowing that things change. That new developments, new research can sometimes show up which challenges previously held beliefs about what is "true".

I've forwarded the link to the counselor, but I'm guessing that she won't be planning on changing her mind any time soon. To be honest, I will be surprised if she even reads past the first paragraph. I think what she wants is for kids not to have sex, and she doesn't actually care whether her reasoning is sound or not.

This kind of thing is why I have a problem with the whole NOMA concept. There are many places in which we can use science and reason to help us decide what strategies might help us achieve our sociological goals. The trick is getting people to realize that "living within god's law" is not a particularly good or useful goal. A more useful goal might be to ask "what strategies can we employ to help our children to grow up to be healthy, well adjusted, happy, and productive adults?" With that goal, we can study, for example healthy, well adjusted, happy, productive adults and ask them what they were like as adolescents. Or we can look at countries that seem to produce more healthy, well adjusted, happy, productive adults and modify some of our child rearing techniques to mirror theirs. Maybe, also, we will find, after enough study, that the age at which a kid has sex really doesn't matter; that the relationships they develop as adults are more a product of the types of relationships their parents had and modeled to them as children. Who knows?

I'd write more, but I've got to get to work..
 
Last edited:
Westprog might find it easier to be polite to Moby7 if he hadn't kicked off his entry into the discussion as if he were marking an exam. If you don't like it, don't dish it out - is that good game theory?

I'm sorry - you don't like it when people point out that you've engaged in logical fallacies. That's fine, I get it. I'm not going to stop doing it though - perhaps you could stop using them in your arguments instead?

Part of the time a one-on-one discussion is taking place. However, it's an open forum, and ignoring the other people involved in the debate is also impolite. So there's a balance involved.

Absolute nonsense. Yes, it's an open forum...in which you and I are having a discussion. You don't just turn around and ignore me so you can address some perceived audience with a discourse on a position I don't hold. It's rude.

I'm trying to be fair here, but I cannot see how I am misrepresenting the M7 position.

You don't see it? Let's try this again, shall we?

"If we had a system that told us which moral system we should use, then that system would itself be a moral system, and we would be begging the question."

Now, for ten points: What is begging the question? Don't worry, I know you've had trouble spotting these things before (or else you'd stop using them) - it's a logical fallacy. And that would make the argument invalid. Hence, my entire point (which you have unsurprisingly missed and mistaken for it's exact opposite) is that moral systems cannot be founded on other moral systems.

There are a lot of words in the English language for which alternatives exist. Scientism doesn't simply refer to 'not actually doing science' but to 'claiming scientific justification when not actually doing science', as with Scientology, Christian Science, Scientific Socialism, Economics, Creation Science and so on.

We already have a word for that too. It's "pseudoscience". "Scientism" is ugly, useless, and is generally used in a derogatory fashion. Not only that, but you are taking the word - which evidently means both "not doing science" and "pseudoscience", and are applying it to situations which are neither. What you are doing is analogous to me saying that "******" is a reasonable thing to call a black person, and then turning around and using it on a man from Thailand.
 
Indeed, the person who claims there is an absolute moral right and wrong is mistaken. What is your point?

Simply that the topic should possibly be "Why do they regard religion and moral certainty as being exempt from skeptical scrutiny?". I've seen plenty of criticism of religion - little of fixed moral codes.

A person who values society above the individual is probably going to adhere to some form of utilitarianism. A person who values the individual above society is probably going to adhere to some form of liberalism. Sure, they may agree on a number of issues (e.g. 'murder is bad'), but there are likely an even greater number of moral issues that they will disagree about. You are projecting your own moral system onto the issue by saying that, "...the rights of society are normally held to derive from the rights of all the people within that society," as in many societies, past and present, that is not the case.

There's a difference between a moral code, and the political means of implementing it. There's also the fact that many people don't regard the fact that they believe certain actions are wrong as justification for their legislative outlawing.
 
Simply that the topic should possibly be "Why do they regard religion and moral certainty as being exempt from skeptical scrutiny?". I've seen plenty of criticism of religion - little of fixed moral codes.

...snip...

There have been plenty of such discussions here - use the search engine and don't confine yourself to just this section since such issues are often discussed in the "Social Issues & Current Events" section. (Also in the past in what is now the "Politics" section as that used to include the social issue discussions.)
 
I'm sorry - you don't like it when people point out that you've engaged in logical fallacies. That's fine, I get it. I'm not going to stop doing it though - perhaps you could stop using them in your arguments instead?

You know what you said, and it wasn't a matter of pointing out a logical fallacy - it was a case of gratuitous incivility as an opening gambit in the discussion. And you know what - I let it go, because I really don't care any more. It wasn't worth bothering with. But to kick off the discussion with a deliberate insult, and then to start complaining a few posts later because you weren't treated with the respect to which you think you're due - well, that's just hypocrisy.

Absolute nonsense. Yes, it's an open forum...in which you and I are having a discussion. You don't just turn around and ignore me so you can address some perceived audience with a discourse on a position I don't hold. It's rude.

I see. But when you stand up, turn around and address the audience and tell them what a jerk I am, that's OK? Because you didn't quote me directly, just summarised it in your own words?

Look - I don't care. If you want to complain that you aren't being treated right, go ahead. But it's not a topic that I'm going to spend more time on.
 
You don't see it? Let's try this again, shall we?

"If we had a system that told us which moral system we should use, then that system would itself be a moral system, and we would be begging the question."

Now, for ten points: What is begging the question? Don't worry, I know you've had trouble spotting these things before (or else you'd stop using them) - it's a logical fallacy. And that would make the argument invalid. Hence, my entire point (which you have unsurprisingly missed and mistaken for it's exact opposite) is that moral systems cannot be founded on other moral systems.

Which is what I am actually saying. Obviously moral systems cannot just be based on other moral systems. At base there must be an assertion. In the same way that Euclidean Geometry rests on its five axioms, any moral system must rest on certain assumptions. In a materialist worldview, any such moral axioms cannot be held as being necessarily true, and hence the moral system cannot be considered as being well founded.

I'm not actually disagreeing here - I'm just trying to point out the implications of a materialistic worldview. There are other posters claiming that it's possible to derive morality and ethics from pure reason. I'm saying that it isn't. You have to have some axiomatic base, and any such moral contention has to be non-materialistic.

I still don't see the area of disagreement here.
 
There have been plenty of such discussions here - use the search engine and don't confine yourself to just this section since such issues are often discussed in the "Social Issues & Current Events" section. (Also in the past in what is now the "Politics" section as that used to include the social issue discussions.)

I doubt if any of this stuff is entirely original. I try to make my arguments sound, but I don't expect them to be brand new.
 
"Scientism" is ugly, useless, and is generally used in a derogatory fashion.

However, it does have a meaning. And if I misused it (which I may well have) then that goes to show that it has a precise enough meaning that one can be corrected for using it carelessly.
 
Quote:
A new study by University of Virginia clinical psychologists has found that teens who have sex at an early age may be less inclined to exhibit delinquent behavior in early adulthood than their peers who waited until they were older to have sex. The study also suggests that early sex may play a role in helping these teens develop better social relationships in early adulthood.
.
Didn't have early sex, and didn't go delinquent. :)
Moderately asocial thouigh.
 
Which is what I am actually saying. Obviously moral systems cannot just be based on other moral systems. At base there must be an assertion. In the same way that Euclidean Geometry rests on its five axioms, any moral system must rest on certain assumptions. In a materialist worldview, any such moral axioms cannot be held as being necessarily true, and hence the moral system cannot be considered as being well founded.

Not necessarily well founded, no - but one moral system can still be better founded than another moral system, if the first moral system is based on an assumption, but the second moral system is based on an incorrect assumption.

Ironically, it is possible to determine when an assumption is incorrect, but not when it is correct (I discussed this a bit in the other thread). Moral systems could, in that regard, be subject to Popperian falsification (though I'd rather not get into that idea here - keep the topic reasonably focused).

I'm not actually disagreeing here - I'm just trying to point out the implications of a materialistic worldview. There are other posters claiming that it's possible to derive morality and ethics from pure reason. I'm saying that it isn't. You have to have some axiomatic base, and any such moral contention has to be non-materialistic.

You have to have some kind of axiomatic base, yes - those are the values I discussed. But why on earth would you say that any moral contention has to be non-materialistic? A non-materialistic foundation is the worst possible type of foundation, because it is not based in reality as we understand it, and is thus unjustified.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom