Why do they regard religion as being exempt from skeptical scrutiny?

Of course there's a correct answer to the question "can/should i shoot my neighbour if he annoys me?"...the answer is NO!

I'm basing this opinion on self interest

Which is a clear and reasonable answer.
 
What slingblade said.

I don't know why I don't injure people or why I give blood and care for animals and people-- it makes me feel good when I'm good to others and I hurt if I hurt someone. I never needed religion to tell me not to hurt people any more than my dog needs religion not to hurt me or others. Are theists running around with impulses to do cruel things, but then they stop because it's a sin? If so, I don't think this method is working very well--otherwise we wouldn't need jails nor would there be pedophiliac priests. I think we can control our actions and instincts via reason... but even without reasoning it appears that we are hard wired to be moral-- at least I am. I didn't need to "learn" empathy... I can't help but have it. I don't think we choose our feelings-- but our feelings help us choose our actions and most people feel good in being neighborly to their neighbors and it appears to be the best way to get neighborly behavior in return-- you scratch my back; I'll scratch yours. It's a nice feedback loop.

Cooperation works better than competition in most cases-- both in families and societies and across borders. Does Westprog avoid shooting his neighbor because it's a "sin"? Is there no other reason he has for behaving? That is terribly sad, isn't it? I've never wanted to kill, rape, or pillage... if I was a thief or a liar or a cheater... I would have to live knowing that about myself... and wonder about that it everyone. I don't see the "benefits" to myself or anyone for illegal behavior or treating people in ways I would not want to be treated. I value being a role model to others to further their knowledge and their development and happiness. I never understood how god was supposed to fit into all this or how the hell you were supposed to know what his rubric was given the bizarre discrepancy between faiths and the glaring hypocrisy in many of the faithful.

I think by 14 I had figured out that the faithful only seem to be more moral in their head...it didn't translate to the reality I observed. There were plenty of great non religious people; and I didn't find most religious people as "moral" as they saw themselves.

Regarding teen sex... it's my experience that the educated kids have far fewer abortions and teen pregnancies than their scientifically ignorant counterparts. And statistics bear out my observations.

There is evidence that within the U.S. strong disparities in religious belief versus acceptance of evolution are correlated with similarly varying rates of societal dysfunction, the strongly theistic, anti-evolution south and mid-west having markedly worse homicide, mortality, STD, youth pregnancy, marital and related problems than the northeast where societal conditions, secularization, and acceptance of evolution approach European norms.
http://moses.creighton.edu/JRS/2005/2005-11.html
 
Last edited:
No, Compo, I'm trying to tease out exactly what you think, and getting you to address the implications of what you say.


Oh, my - you're not nearly up to that task.

The only reason that you weren't put on ignore before now is that, according to the settings I've selected, all threads that you started disappear once I do.

I was hoping something interesting might happen in this thread. For me, it's run its course.

I've said what I wanted to say.

Plonk.
 
Last edited:
Bingo. The answer to that question may well differ if evaluated in a number of different moral systems. Which moral decision we use is, for all intents and purposes, arbitrary: If we had a system that told us which moral system we should use, then that system would itself be a moral system, and we would be begging the question.

In reality, the moral systems that people adopt are based around what they value: Themselves; Society as a whole; Pleasure; Art, and so on. People who have moral systems that clash with society as a whole tend to be selected out - they wind up in jail, or ostracised by society. It may well be that we can evaluate different moral systems to determine which system produces the best functioning society (ironically, such a thing would be studied via the scientific method), but even if we were to determine what the 'best' moral system is, the decision to adopt it would still be essentially arbitrary.

Then I presume that you would agree that anyone calling any action right or wrong is as deluded as a theist. The most they can do is to promote certain shared values, not as an absolute, but as a convenient modus vivendi.

These truths are not self-evident. There are no universal human rights.

PS: Scientism is still a silly word. I don't care if it has a wikipedia page.Ayurvedic medicine has a wikipedia page, but that doesn't stop it from being silly.

I think it's a convenient label.
 
Oh, my - you're not nearly up to that task.

No, Comps, it's not up to me to show exactly what you believe. It's up to you.

The only reason that you weren't put on ignore before now is that, according to the settings I've selected, all threads that you started disappear once I do.

There's solipsism for you.

I was hoping something interesting might happen in this thread. For me, it's run its course.

I've said what I wanted to say.

Plonk.

Declare victory and withdraw. I had hoped that a skeptical scrutiny of beliefs might be possible but apparently not.
 
Who is this mythical "they" to which the OP refers to because while I wish some of my more militant fellow atheists would give religious skeptics a confrontational break on the religion issue if they're not raving fundy lunatics.. it's a myth that skepticism "exempts" religion from skeptical scrutiny.

I'm the OP, but the title of the thread is a quote from another thread. I wanted to discuss certain issues that arose - in particular, whether applying the same criteria for untestable as to testable claims is justifiable.
 
I'm sure you do... having a convenient label for the falsehoods you prefer over reality must simplify your life immensely.

Having a label which refers to something having certain properties is what we call language. While it necessarily involves certain simplifications, it remains a useful tool.
 
If she sees it, I doubt you could prevent her from posting a long diatribe about how stupid people are if they believe that god might possibly exist. Of course, it will only tangentially touch upon the subject you requested. I was going to quote this so she'd see it, but then I remembered she has me on ignore too so it won't help you. So I'll just take this opportunity to thank you for a great series of posts and threads. I'm quite enjoying reading through them. Thanks and keep em up please.

The important point is that I'm actually interested in investigating what people actually believe, and why. I think it's fair enough to ask how religious people come by their beliefs. It's also fair to subject unreligious people to the same scrutiny. Some find it more painful than others.
 
On the other hand, often people must make decisions on which their future depends without access to further knowledge. For example: Should girl A marry boy B or boy C or stay single for a while longer? She can't go to the library and check out a book on which decision will work out best for her. The best she can do is reflect on her knowledge of herself and the other people in her life. Prayer is a wonderful way to meditate and reflect on the problem. It allows you to talk it over between the various voices in your head and decide which path to take.


Most of us don't hear voices in our heads. And those who do, at least those who are still somewhat lucid, recognize the voices as a symptom of mental illness, poisoning, or other cognitive anomaly.

Don't dismiss prayers just because god doesn't actually intervene. Prayer has it's benefits without any supernatural results.


Ugh, well, not so much for those who aren't victims of schizophrenia or similar lack of grip on reality. But whatever it takes to keep you stable, Beth. :)
 
Don't dismiss rational decision making over magical thinking when the option is available:

http://www.exmormon.org/mormon/mormon439.htm

Magical thinking makes you believe you are having your choices influenced by god or other magical sources... it does not make any god real or any god actually influence your choices... it makes you come to a decision in the way most people come to decisions while imagining god gave you guidance or sent you a sign.
 
Last edited:
Don't dismiss prayers just because god doesn't actually intervene. Prayer has it's benefits without any supernatural results.


Might you be comparing prayer to meditation here ?

I'm not trying to disagree because I neither pray nor meditate but in a conversation with a Buddhist about aspects of "religion" the topic of "sitting quietly" came up and we both were speculation whether meditation and prayer provided similar opportunities for self reflection.
 
Might you be comparing prayer to meditation here ?
Indeed I am. That's my point.
I'm not trying to disagree because I neither pray nor meditate but in a conversation with a Buddhist about aspects of "religion" the topic of "sitting quietly" came up and we both were speculation whether meditation and prayer provided similar opportunities for self reflection.
They are not exactly the same, but I think they provide similar opportunities for the mind to quiet itself and allow one's unconscious inclinations to percolate up into the conscious mind. I have find both helpful in that regard, but I didn't pray near as often after I learned some basic meditation techniques. Still, when dealing with an emotional situation, I prefer prayer because that's what I was taught to do as a child. Not because I think some supernatural god will make everything all right, but because I find the act of prayer calming.
 
Last edited:
I'm the OP, but the title of the thread is a quote from another thread. I wanted to discuss certain issues that arose - in particular, whether applying the same criteria for untestable as to testable claims is justifiable.

Sorry for not referencing you directly as I was crunched for time/bandwidth this morning. :)

And reading your clarification, here's my take on it. General religious claims cannot be tested by the scientific method, but specific religious claims and most supernatural claims (ghosts, which I don't consider a religious claim for example) can be tested. I don't consider the claim that God created the Earth or that the Himilayas are Shiva's braided hair to be testable within the scientific method. That the Earth and all life on it was spontaneously created 6,000 years ago or that a particular child is the reincarnation of a deceased person is definately testible and falsifiable.

I don't believe the metaphysical claims about God or Shiva mentioned above, but I cannot falsify them with the scientific method.
 
If someone claims that something exists...

And that "something" is indistinguishable from the nonexistance of that something... or a delusion of that "something", a consistent skeptic assumes nonexistence until or unless evidence warrants belief.

Otherwise all invisible entities mythological beings and unprovable notions are on the table as far as likelihood goes... and you are just using confirmation bias to prop up the magic you've been indoctrinated to believe in.
 
And of course, game theory works best for you when you are the only person to break the kind and trusting method.

Said the person who quite clearly has no understanding of game theory. 'Tit for tat' isn't just a cute name, you know.

Then I presume that you would agree that anyone calling any action right or wrong is as deluded as a theist.

No, I would not agree with that, so don't go about presuming anything. What I would say is that when I judge an action to be right or wrong, I recognise that I am judging it based upon what values I personally hold to be most important.

Moreover, I am perfectly open to adjusting my view of what is and isn't moral, and am better able to discuss morality with those whose values differ to mine, as I may be able to frame the argument in terms of their values, and not in terms of 'right' and 'wrong'.

The most they can do is to promote certain shared values, not as an absolute, but as a convenient modus vivendi.

Not entirely sure what you mean by that. If one person values 'the rights of the individual' and another values 'the rights of society', then on what basis can the first person promote their value to the second?

These truths are not self-evident. There are no universal human rights.

There are things that I consider to be universal human rights based upon my moral system. However, as there are a number of things that some people consider to be universal human rights and some people do not consider to be a right at all - that itself serves as an example of how different values can divide moral opinion, even in Western civilisation.

I think it's a convenient label.

Of course you think it's a convenient label. It fits your preconceived notions of 'scientific boundaries' without any of that pesky need to justify your position - just say that something is scientism run amok and you seem to be making a valid point, even though all you're doing is spouting useless unjustified rhetoric. It's a similar thing as to what the creationists do when they call people 'Darwinists'.

Mind you, the irony is off the charts here. I take it you shant be complaining when Articulett or Complexity call people 'apologists' anymore, eh? After all, they use it as a term that is convenient for them!
 
I'll continue complaining about them lying when they inappropriately appellate people with it, but if you want to be an apologist for their lies, knock yourself out.

You appear to have misunderstood my position. I do not agree with the way Articulett uses the word 'apologist' - while I agree with her on a great many things, I think that her use of this term creates confusion about what she means by it, as her definition does not jibe with the definition commonly used. I also sometimes disagree with who she considers (by her own definition) apologists.

I thought I had made my point clear, especially considering that I compared her use of 'apologist' to the use of the term 'scientism', for which I have a clear disdain, but evidently I had not. Sorry.
 
An opinion isn't a lie... however misrepresenting what people said and arguing a straw man version of that-- is dishonest. And so I say that the term liar is more fitting of Unrepentant Sinner.

I think we'd all know what I meant if I said a Scientologist Apologist... such a person would exaggerate the words of a critic of Scientology to make the critic sound worse than what he was criticizing... while dismissing and arguing away harms caused by Scientology.

I think there are people on this forum who do that with religion/faith. You cannot criticize religion without them hearing you say "all believers are bad". You cannot ask them to examine their own biases by plugging in another woo because they are so enraged that you might even consider them biased-- apparently in their mind they are much smarter and more diplomatic than anyone else seems to see them.

Moreover I think these people promote a kind of atheist bigotry in the name of some cause or other that only they seem to be aware of. They hear what isn't there... faith is never to blame for anything, and everything the outspoken atheist says is a sign of evil intent--death camps and militancy and immorality and who knows what else.

I call these people "apologists". I think that's a very nice word considering what they've called me (liar, for one). I like the people they regularly insult much more than I like them. These people, often who use terms like "god hater" imagine themselves to be givers of "helpful criticisms" while being completely unaware that few people would go to them for social advice. Moreover, these same people tend to criticize people with criticism that could be better aimed at themselves. They complain that others don't take their criticism well, while being a piss poor model for "how to take criticism".

They imagine and hear evil and intent and attack and lies and stridency in the words of others while imagining their own words are gentle little flowers of wisdom and guidance from diplomatic and warm people. They pretend to be diplomats but they are divisive and always trying to promote divisiveness while accusing others of doing such.

Yeah... Westprog is an apologist; I have him on ignore. I think the apologists deserve each other. I prefer to hang out with those they find strident and awful and militant. I think the people they criticize are much finer people than apologists myself. But we don't all need to like everybody. I certainly see no one in the apologist camp as someone whom I want to be like-- I find them smarmy and irrational for the most part-- but, hey -- opinions... if people dish them out, I do hope they can take them in.

Such people often criticize people I like-- other posters and Dawkins, for example... and they hear all this militancy that isn't there... so yeah... since the things they call me and say about the people I respect tend to be rather loathsome and bigoted-- I think "apologist" is a rather nice term reflecting my "opinion" of them --and I find it amusing that it makes them so damn mad.

I guess it touches a sore spot. Sometimes people need to get their feathers ruffled to evolve. Isn't that what this thread is about?

ETA
I believe Moby was pointing out the irony of someone demanding to use the word "scientism" while getting upset with someone using the word "apologist"... apparently you see one word as a LIE... and the other as nothing even worth commenting upon. Not only that, you missed Moby's point to accuse him of taking "sides" when there doesn't need to be "sides", Mr. divisive. Remember, people can disagree with you without "worshiping Dawkins" being a "fanboy" or deserving the ridiculous appellate "god hater".

Your double standard is showing, US...
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom