Why do they regard religion as being exempt from skeptical scrutiny?

The claim is often made that there are issues that science may never consider because they involve ... morality, ethics, the purpose of life...

This claim is wrong. Some of the things in that list do not exist; some are claimed to be apart from reality, which is not possible; some are claimed to involve an aspect of reality but not susceptible to science.

This is where scientism - the application of scientism to areas where it emphatically does not apply - can be so dangerous.

I've restricted the list to items which I think concern atheists as much as theists.

There is simply no basis for imagining that science can determine morality or ethics. To consider it can is to show deeply confused thinking.
 
But why seek out such things which are extremely difficult to imagine solving? There's no need to look for Jesus clones and time machines. There's a very specific religious claim - that the universe is six thousand years old and that all species were created seperately.

Such a claim is open for scientific rebuttal. The fallacy is to imagine that because one religious claim impinges on the realm of science, that they all do.

Yet the parentage of Jesus is seemingly not treated as a scientific question by A Christian Skeptic, as he/she advocates Gould's NOMA principle.

If we found that Jesus did not have a father, there is absolutely no question that it would be held as evidence for divine power in the universe. I'm sure you would too.

And that, I'm afraid to say, is where the religous hypocrisy lies.
 
Last edited:
Science cannot determine a person's morality or ethics, but reason can,- or should.
 
You see no reason to to disbelieve that a child could be concieved without a sperm?

A male child no less.



If that doesn't seem doubly odd to you, take off the religious blinders - it's genetically impossible for a human female to parthenogetically give birth to a human male, leaving aside the fact that humans don't undergo parthenogenesis.
 
Yet the parentage of Jesus is seemingly not treated as a scientific question by A Christian Skeptic, as he/she advocates Gould's NOMA principle.

If we found that Jesus did not have a father, there is absolutely no question that it would be held as evidence for divine power in the universe. I'm sure you would too.

And that, I'm afraid to say, is where the religous hypocrisy lies.

The Incarnation of Jesus is definitely a claim of a miracle. The Virgin Conception of Jesus (if that's the correct way of interpretting what happened - and it does seem to be the consensus for Christians) is definitely a miraculous claim in the natural world.

Not sure how a one time event like that can be scientifically studied - feel free to try.
 
I believe God can do miracles and currently have no reason to believe the incarnation didn't happen the way traditionally it's held it happened.

What reason do you have for believing the incarnation happened the way it's traditionally held it happened?
 
The Incarnation of Jesus is definitely a claim of a miracle. The Virgin Conception of Jesus (if that's the correct way of interpretting what happened - and it does seem to be the consensus for Christians) is definitely a miraculous claim in the natural world.

Not sure how a one time event like that can be scientifically studied - feel free to try.

If he had been conceived of a virgin, had raised the dead, healed the sick, transformed scraps of food into enough to stuff thousands, had been resurrected, and did answer prayers someone contemporaneous with him might have actually mentioned him. Instead, we have more evidence for Julius Caesar's epilepsy and adultery than we do for a supposed miracle working messiah cruising around a highly literate area for three years before finally popping back from the grave and flying into the sky.

And still, prayers go unanswered despite Jesus, allegedly, saying that they would be answered. Are there no people with sufficient faith to cast down mountains - or is there no god? You be the judge? NO. Shut your face. Let science be the judge.
 
This is where scientism - the application of scientism to areas where it emphatically does not apply - can be so dangerous.

I've restricted the list to items which I think concern atheists as much as theists.

There is simply no basis for imagining that science can determine morality or ethics. To consider it can is to show deeply confused thinking.


Science can and will discover how concepts of morality and ethics have evolved. Science will be able to explain why some of these concepts have thrived and others have not.

Science will also be able to explain why specific people hold the moral and ethical beliefs that they hold, as well as why they are susceptible to some memes and not to others.

I obviously disagree with you on these issues.

In the future, please do not edit quoted material - you risk confusing things.

ETA: Your term 'scientism' is silly.
 
Last edited:
A Christian Sceptic said:
The Incarnation of Jesus is definitely a claim of a miracle. The Virgin Conception of Jesus (if that's the correct way of interpretting what happened - and it does seem to be the consensus for Christians) is definitely a miraculous claim in the natural world.

Not sure how a one time event like that can be scientifically studied - feel free to try.

Sure it’s a supernatural claim, and of course it’s almost impossible to make a scientific study about it. But I would submit that that’s not the relevant question; the relevant question is: why should anyone take those claims seriously in the first place?
 
The typical answer atheists hate:
I believe in God and since I also believe in miracles why couldn't he?

Do you believe in all the miracles listed in the bible? The waters that became blood? Plagues of frogs, lice, flies, boils, murrain, locusts, etc? Red Sea dividing? Water coming out of the rock at Horab? Balaam's talking ass? Uzziah struck with leprosy? Fire from the heavens? etc etc
 
Last edited:
DNA.

ImaginalDisc, as much as I'd like to sex you up, I felt "Shut your face" was a stepping over the line slightly.

In my defense, everyone should shut their face when tempted to spout off things that science refutes. We're error prone beings easily capable of believing things that are manifestly false. Science is a glorious tool for self-correction.

Hence, shut your face. Let science do the talking. You don't get to subjectively judge whether something is true or not, the scientific process does. I don't either.

I swear, not having slept in two days isn't making me cranky.
 
Last edited:
Do you believe in all the miracles listed in the bible? The waters that became blood? Plagues of frogs, lice, flies, boils, murrain, locusts, etc? Red Sea dividing? Water coming out of the rock at Horab? Balaam's talking ass? Uzziah struck with leprosy? Fire from the heavens? etc etc

I particularly like the bit in Matthew where all the dead in Jerusalem get up, walk around, and chill with their friends - and no one but Matthew noticed - decades later.
 
In my defense, everyone should shut their face when tempted to spout off things that science refutes. We're error prone beings easily capable of believing things that are manifestly false. Science is a glorious tool for self-correction.

Hence, shut your face. Let science do the talking. You don't get to subjectively judge whether something is true or not, the scientific process does. I don't either.

I swear, not having slept in two days isn't making me cranky.


 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom