Why do they regard religion as being exempt from skeptical scrutiny?

It is a perfectly reasonable term. Why do you object to it?


It is being used in a manner that reminds me of creationists' use of 'Darwinism'.

I'll ponder on this for a while...

I may have jumped too quickly.

I've heard 'scientism' be used in a perjorative fashion in the past.

Will continue to ponder...

I've looked at the wiki article briefly. I agree that the use of the term in a neutral sense describes my position. I reject its use in a perjorative sense, which is also discussed early on in the article.
 
Last edited:
It is being used in a manner that reminds me of creationists' use of 'Darwinism'.

I'll ponder on this for a while...

Also, calling something "scientism" doesn't actually addresses whether or not it's true. It's a lovely bit of dishonest rhetoric. That's kind of like one politician saying about another, "My opponent says that unemployment rates are way up - that's socialism!"
 
Sure it’s a supernatural claim, and of course it’s almost impossible to make a scientific study about it. But I would submit that that’s not the relevant question; the relevant question is: why should anyone take those claims seriously in the first place?

Well - if you thought Jesus might be important and it might be important to know some of the things taught and believed about him. That might one reason to consider them. If their true - what that would mean - might be another reason to consider them.

If you don't believe in God and if you don't even think you care about believing in Jesus then I don't know why anything there would be relevant.
 
Well - if you thought Jesus might be important and it might be important to know some of the things taught and believed about him. That might one reason to consider them. If their true - what that would mean - might be another reason to consider them.

If you don't believe in God and if you don't even think you care about believing in Jesus then I don't know why anything there would be relevant.

Excuse me, but you cannot argue that since it would be bad if something were false then it must be true. Reality doesn't work that way. It'd be a much better world if rape were physically impossible, and I'd like to live in a world where that is true, but it simply isn't that way.

You cannot start from the conclusion that Christianity is true just because it'd be nice if it were. If you could, I say it'd be nice if I were a millionaire exiled prince of Monaco, and every day is a holiday where people mail be candy.
 
Last edited:
Yet the parentage of Jesus is seemingly not treated as a scientific question by A Christian Skeptic, as he/she advocates Gould's NOMA principle.

If we found that Jesus did not have a father, there is absolutely no question that it would be held as evidence for divine power in the universe. I'm sure you would too.

And that, I'm afraid to say, is where the religous hypocrisy lies.

But we aren't talking about religious hypocrisy. We're talking about a specific invalid argument.

It's always possible for science to refute individual claims that encroach on it's field. That doesn't allow people to claim that science can overstep its boundaries.
 
A Christian Sceptic said:
Well - if you thought Jesus might be important and it might be important to know some of the things taught and believed about him. That might one reason to consider them. If their true - what that would mean - might be another reason to consider them.

But here’s the crux of the matter (in my opinion): What do you think is more important; the claims made about Jesus or the teaching ascribed in the name of a figure called Jesus? The former requires a belief in the supernatural whereas the latter part does only require an acknowledgment of the message. Furthermore, you don’t have to ascribe to the totality of the message but only to the parts that resonate with you.

Is there any reason to automatically ascribe to the totality of the narrative?
 
But we aren't talking about religious hypocrisy. We're talking about a specific invalid argument.

It's always possible for science to refute individual claims that encroach on it's field. That doesn't allow people to claim that science can overstep its boundaries.

Science needs no excuse excuse to push its boundaries. That's what science is for. If you claim that science cannot determine whether or not something is true, than religion cannot either. If you discard science, you cannot tell which propositions are false.
 
ImaginalDisc said:
If you discard science, you cannot tell which propositions are false.

Neo says whoa! That’s actually a very good point… a very good point indeed, although, one should never say ‘indeed’ without striving for a Teal’c voice.
 
Science cannot disprove the existence of most gods.

But we can apply skepticism to claims that gods exist. The first thing we look at is the lack of evidence for the existence of said god or gods.
 
Well - if you thought Jesus might be important and it might be important to know some of the things taught and believed about him. That might one reason to consider them. If their true - what that would mean - might be another reason to consider them.

I just have to add something here. One could very well think that Jesus was important in some sense, and even believe it important to know some of the things taught and believed about him, without subscribing to any of the obviously fictional claims made about him.

Given that the earliest accounts of his life (Mark) do not speak of any miraculous parentage, given that claims of a virgin birth for religious leaders was ubiquitous in the ancient world, given the mistranslation the author of Matthew was using to reconstruct the virgin birth as "prophecy" in the Hebrew Bible, and given the conflicting birth stories in Mat and Luke, there is simply no credible nor _necessary_ reason to subscribe to a mythical account of Jesus' birth. It is no more necessary to believe that then it is to believe that all the graves in the city opened up and the dead walked around yet no other ancient historian noticed it.

To think otherwise is to believe that the creator of the Universe decided to reveal an important truth about a critical religious figure in the most unreliable fashion possible, and then peppered the surrounding circumstances with an abundance of disconfirming evidence, and yet expects reasonable people to believe it. That hardly seems like a good way to run a railroad.
 
Because religion doesn't have a methodology. It simply states "truth is here." This is why Jesus, for example, doesn't describe himself in the Gospels as a truth but "the truth." "Faith makes blessed," how does one insert skepticism here? There is a reason why priests have invented concepts such as "miracles," "sin," "revelations"--they deny cause and effect. Consider "revelation": knowledge that is not discovered by humanity but revealed. Who shall reveal it? A priest? Not even his ego would go that far. A priest needs a being that infallible, eternal--most important, one that cannot be scrutinized: he needs a God. How does one exercise skepticism in the presence of a God?
 
Because religion doesn't have a methodology. It simply states "truth is here." This is why Jesus, for example, doesn't describe himself in the Gospels as a truth but "the truth." "Faith makes blessed," how does one insert skepticism here? There is a reason why priests have invented concepts such as "miracles," "sin," "revelations"--they deny cause and effect. Consider "revelation": knowledge that is not discovered by humanity but revealed. Who shall reveal it? A priest? Not even his ego would go that far. A priest needs a being that infallible, eternal--most important, one that cannot be scrutinized: he needs a God. How does one exercise skepticism in the presence of a God?

By thinking that skepticism itself is a revelation? Just a thought. :)
 
By thinking that skepticism itself is a revelation? Just a thought. :)

No. Skepticism is a methodology. It's a step-by-step process which does something no other system of thought does - it starts with evidence and arrives at a conclusion later.
 
I just have to add something here. One could very well think that Jesus was important in some sense, and even believe it important to know some of the things taught and believed about him, without subscribing to any of the obviously fictional claims made about him.

You are right. My reply wasn't about why you should accept anything, but was in response why someone might want to consider them. That's all. I'm sure there are lot's of reason in addition to those that I wrote to why someone might want to consider them.

Here's some other off-the-cuff reasons you might want to consider them:

1) To prove they are not real
2) To make someone doubt they are real
3) You find religions fascinating
4) You're doing a thesis on miracles on the ancient world
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom