Why do they regard religion as being exempt from skeptical scrutiny?

This is just funny. Of course it’s not scientific, thus science it’s not even interested in the claim in the first place.

Then why pretend that it does?

The relevant question seems to be: why make such a claim in the first place, what good does it do? What’s the point of claiming there’s some kind of original creator? If there were some kind of creator – which is extremely doubtful – what good does it do; it’s not like we could make any use of that conviction. :rolleyes:


That's interesting. There seem to be an unending series of posts claiming that such a belief is inherently terribly harmful. Presumably it either makes a difference or it doesn't.

In any case, the people who do hold such beliefs tend to think that the possibility that the universe was created actually matters to them.
 
One problem, westprog, is that you really don't understand what skepticism or science is.

A second is that you are trying to set up the discussion so that you'll be able to weasel out the answer that you want.

(I don't think they're going to let you get away with it.)
 
In principle I happen to agree with Westprog on this: I do not think science has anything to say about philosophy or religion: nor about much of morality. I accept Gould's Non-overlapping Magisteria, and so we can all be happy in the nest.

Sadly, there is the bit where the religious say it: and the bit where they take it back. I have absolutely no quarrel with religious believers who quietly get on with their believing. But they don't, do they? They have always had views about how the material world works: and this is fine because then science has claims to test - no bad thing.

But the material world is fuzzy round the edges and the religious have no qualms about attempting to impose their particular morality in tangible ways which affect my life. If they accept that it is not in the realm of science because it is not refutable ( which is not really arguable, in my view: the burden of proof argument is also not in play on this scenario) then they must also accept it is not demonstrable in any way either. At this point they have absolutely no locus to impose their views on anybody else. Do I take it you are a quietist, Westprog?
 
One problem, westprog, is that you really don't understand what skepticism or science is.

That's quite possible.

A second is that you are trying to set up the discussion so that you'll be able to weasel out the answer that you want.

Yes, that might be the case.

(I don't think they're going to let you get away with it.)

Maybe they aren't, but you certainly did. I think something other than the above is required to rebut the very specific points that I made.
 
I knew that questioning deeply held personal beliefs would upset people. I look forward to more of the same.

I don't have any deeply held personal beliefs. If you had evidence that there is a god, I'd be tremendously interested.

Instead what you present is more disappointing rhetoric.



That seems a fairly clear example of the extrapolation fallacy.

The point is not that science hasn't come up with an explanation for the purpose of the universe is that it isn't a scientific matter.

That science and religion have become disentangled is a good thing. The Good Scientist should support this, rather than getting re-entangled.

False. False. And, false.

Religions makes claims about the universe. Whether or not there is a god who effects the universe is an inherently scientific question - because it involves effects which can be observed and measured.



Which is similarly the claim of most modern religions, which regard God as external and additional to the universe.

Incorrect. The only faintly religious idea similar is deism, not Hinduism, Shinto, Christianity, or Scientology.




Anything that is unfalsifiable is nonsense? Is that the claim? Just want to be sure.

Yes.



You know, there might be people out there who'll be convinced by the abusive posts, but I think that it's mainly playing to the home supporters.

I'm not trying to convince you. You're a disgusting liar. You're dragging out old, tired, and long since refuted arguments. You haven't brought up a single original point.
 
I accept Gould's Non-overlapping Magisteria, and so we can all be happy in the nest.

Gould is quite wrong.

As I said earlier, Jesus either had a father or he didn't.

As Dawkins noted, if we managed to dig up Jesus' remains and determine he did not have a father, could you possibly imagine Christians, or our own forum Christians declaring that this find means nothing to their faith? The notion is absurd.

As A Christian Skeptic adheres to Goulds words, I would like to ask him(her??):

Did Jesus have a father or not?
 
Last edited:
In principle I happen to agree with Westprog on this: I do not think science has anything to say about philosophy or religion: nor about much of morality. I accept Gould's Non-overlapping Magisteria, and so we can all be happy in the nest.

And I have no problem with atheists or believers willing to argue on those terms.

Sadly, there is the bit where the religious say it: and the bit where they take it back. I have absolutely no quarrel with religious believers who quietly get on with their believing. But they don't, do they? They have always had views about how the material world works: and this is fine because then science has claims to test - no bad thing.

And anything that is scientifically testable is open for science. That should be as acceptable for religion as for science - because the believers are on a hiding to nothing stopping the scientists doing their thing. Well, maybe no in Iran.

But the material world is fuzzy round the edges and the religious have no qualms about attempting to impose their particular morality in tangible ways which affect my life. If they accept that it is not in the realm of science because it is not refutable ( which is not really arguable, in my view: the burden of proof argument is also not in play on this scenario) then they must also accept it is not demonstrable in any way either. At this point they have absolutely no locus to impose their views on anybody else.

The issue of moral views, where they come from, and to what extent they can be imposed is a whole other issue. I've kicked off two threads today, maybe that one can wait till Monday.

Do I take it you are a quietist, Westprog?

Yes. No. I don't know. What's a quietist?
 
@ Undesired Walrus. Yes, where claims which address the material world enter into it you are correct. As Westprog has conceded. But his position in this thread is different. It may be that science can eventually answer all questions about the creation of the universe. I doubt it myself but I will be delighted if they do. Then the religious will have no claim to make, but until then they can in fact reasonably decide to believe godidit. So long as they keep it out of the material realm why would you object? Nothing at all hangs on it
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quietism_(Christian_philosophy)

Quietism states that man's highest perfection consists of a self-annihilation, and subsequent absorption, of the soul into the Divine, even during the present life. In this way, the mind is withdrawn from worldly interests to passively and constantly contemplate God. Quietists would say that the Bible describes the man of God as a man of the tent and the altar only, having no part or interest in the multitudinous affairs, pursuits, and pleasures of the world system.
 
Last edited:
westprog said:
Then why pretend that it does?

Don’t be silly, what scientific field does?

That's interesting. There seem to be an unending series of posts claiming that such a belief is inherently terribly harmful. Presumably it either makes a difference or it doesn't.

In any case, the people who do hold such beliefs tend to think that the possibility that the universe was created actually matters to them.
It matters to them! So what? Whatever matters to them doesn’t change the fundamental state of the universe.
 
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. The claim that "the universe was created by an omnipotent, omniscient being" is the most extraordinary claim I know of.
 
Gould is quite wrong about his magisteria, though not about many other things.

However, Gould's magisteria are relevant to this discussion, and in that area he was wrong.

Science is the best means we have of discovering the nature of reality.

There is only one reality, and science is the most effective means we have of modeling and understanding it.

This reality is also referred to as 'nature'. The natural world is reality.

Far too many believe that there are things that are supernatural, that are above or apart from nature, that are outside of reality.

These people are woo and these people are wrong.

The claim is often made that there are issues that science may never consider because they involve gods, morality, ethics, the purpose of life, philosophy, religion, or unicorns.

This claim is wrong. Some of the things in that list do not exist; some are claimed to be apart from reality, which is not possible; some are claimed to involve an aspect of reality but not susceptible to science.

This last claim I hold to be false - science may be used to better understand any aspect of reality.

There are, I think, limits on what the human mind can conceive of, though we will most likely remain ignorant of what these limits are.

Philosophy, at its best, is consistent with science, both in approach and outcome; at its worst, it is ignorable.

There is only one 'magisterium', in Gould's unfortunate borrowing from catholic terminology.
 
Darat said:
I have to disagree with you - if the terms can be defined then it could be a scientific claim.

However a claim such as "which regard God as external and additional to the universe" is of course nothing more than an example how in English you can make up sentences that appear to be sentences but are in fact meaningless or indeed just nonsense.

Fair enough. “If it can be defined” seems to be the problem thou. Have you stumbled upon any researchable suggestion which a scientific field has taken seriously?
 
I don't have any deeply held personal beliefs.

Then you must have an extremely short fuse. I hate to think how you'd react if someone spilled your drink or scratched your car.

If you had evidence that there is a god, I'd be tremendously interested.


If you had scientific evidence that there isn't a god, you'd be able to claim scientific backing for what you assert.

I've made no claim about the existence of God. I'm critiquing shoddy, careless thinking. If that's a painful process, I'm sorry, but it's probably good for you.

Instead what you present is more disappointing rhetoric.

I think an example of disappointing rhetoric is calling someone else's claims disappointing rhetoric without backing it up.


False. False. And, false.

Religions makes claims about the universe. Whether or not there is a god who effects the universe is an inherently scientific question - because it involves effects which can be observed and measured.

Then no doubt you'll be able to give an example of a scientific experiment, given unlimited resources, which could perform such an observation and measurement.


Anything unfalsifiable is nonsense? That's scientism run amuck.



I'm not trying to convince you. You're a disgusting liar. You're dragging out old, tired, and long since refuted arguments. You haven't brought up a single original point.

Then your abject failure to effectively address my tired old arguments must be deeply embarassing.
 
Did Jesus have a father or not? This is a scientific question, not a philosophical one.

Did Jesus rise from the dead? This is a scientific question, not a philosophical one.

Did Jesus turn water into wine? This is a scientific question, not a philosophical one.

But why seek out such things which are extremely difficult to imagine solving? There's no need to look for Jesus clones and time machines. There's a very specific religious claim - that the universe is six thousand years old and that all species were created seperately.

Such a claim is open for scientific rebuttal. The fallacy is to imagine that because one religious claim impinges on the realm of science, that they all do.

Westprog, why do you feel the universe needs a 'meaning' or a purpose? What is the non-scientific meaning of thunder?

Did I claim that the Universe "needed a purpsose"? I wasn't aware of doing so.

My contention is that issues of meaning and purpose are not part of science in any way shape or form.
 
Ah, a terrible argument. Aside from H. L. Mencken's - and Epicurus' logical argument from evil that the god you propose is actually logically impossible,

I think we can all agree that neither Mencken or Epicurus were scientists.

If you want to argue on philosophical terms, fine. But don't do philosophy and claim to be doing science.
 
Last edited:
Then you must have an extremely short fuse. I hate to think how you'd react if someone spilled your drink or scratched your car.

I'm insulting you because you're degrading reason. I'm also meticulously refuting your idiotic noises because it's easy.




If you had scientific evidence that there isn't a god, you'd be able to claim scientific backing for what you assert.

You obviously have no idea what a burden of proof is.


I've made no claim about the existence of God. I'm critiquing shoddy, careless thinking. If that's a painful process, I'm sorry, but it's probably good for you.

False.



I think an example of disappointing rhetoric is calling someone else's claims disappointing rhetoric without backing it up.

I've been quite careful to refute each claim you've actually made.




Then no doubt you'll be able to give an example of a scientific experiment, given unlimited resources, which could perform such an observation and measurement.

Again - see burden of proof. If a religious claimant says "god heals the sick if they pray" that is false, because prayer studies show now such correlation. If a religious person says "god cannot be detected" that's gobbledygook, and has no meaning.



Anything unfalsifiable is nonsense? That's scientism run amuck.

Again, you are wrong. If you can entertain a single unfalsifiable idea, you must entertain all unfalsifiable ideas, because without scientific thinking you have no other tool for finding truth. If you are prepared to accept god, you're prepared to accept the Saturn dwelling lemur - there's no way to differentiate them.





Then your abject failure to effectively address my tired old arguments must be deeply embarassing.

It's spelled "embarrassing."
 
Off-topic comment:
"a shot to the knees of a target 120 kilometers away using an Aratech sniper rifle "
.
The recoil, the recoil! 120 kilometers and a rifle?
YGBSM.
 
Did Jesus have a father or not?

I believe God can do miracles and currently have no reason to believe the incarnation didn't happen the way traditionally it's held it happened.

This would be a case of the supernatural world infringing upon the natural world. I'm not sure how it could be repeatedly tested scientifically though. Miracles only happen once for each instance.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom