Where are the stars that we can see?

Oh, whatever!

Anyone who stopped to think about it for more than a millisecond ought to have understood what the OP was getting at. I just don't see the value of pointless bickering over irrelevant minutiae when the subject of the thread itself is so damned interesting.
Yes it is. We see so little of the universe with the naked eye, that until relatively modern times it was believed that the stars were absolutely unchanging, and that nothing ever happened further away than the "sublunary sphere". Now we know a lot better.
 
Yes it is. We see so little of the universe with the naked eye, that until relatively modern times it was believed that the stars were absolutely unchanging, and that nothing ever happened further away than the "sublunary sphere". Now we know a lot better.

I was talking about people pulling up the OP for his illustration not being a photo of the actual Milky Way (as if that is even possible anyway).....

Post #7 - I can dis-confirm it since that isn't a picture of the Milky Way galaxy.

post #86 - The stars we see can't be in the circle since this is not the Milky Way Galaxy. All the stars that we see with the unaided eye are in the Milky Way Galaxy.

This can't be a picture of the Milky Way Galaxy because it shows the spiral arms. We are in the Milky Way Galaxy right in the sagittal plane. Therefore, there is no way we can see the spiral arms of the Milky Way galaxy while being in it.

This is most probably a picture of the Andromeda Galaxy, which is about 2.2 MLY from the Milky Way Galaxy. The spiral arms of the Andromeda Galaxy have been frequently photographed. The Andromeda has structure similar to that of the Milky Way Galaxy, although it has diameter twice as large as the Milky Way Galaxy. So photographs of the Andromeda Galaxy are often used to illustrate what the Milky Way Galaxy looks like.


.....followed by numerous replies


I have no idea what it is that you are talking about !
 
I am unsure what you mean by that. In my understanding, the light we receive from objects that are currently part of the observable universe will experience an ever increasing redshift ("fade" from our point of view). Eventually, the wavelength of the light emitted by these objects will become larger than the observable universe, at which point they will be undetectable in principle. These objects will then have left the observable universe.

This is how I understand it.

Lets say a galaxy is 10 billion light years away and is one billion years old. Tomorrow from our relative position it slips beyond the realm of the observable universe. If we came back in 10 billion years time we would still be able to see that galaxy as a 1 billion year old artifact of itself rather than a galaxy that has aged a further 10 billion years.
 
Is it off topic to ask whether it is a valid argument against the universe being infinite that the sky is not a complete white-out of starlight?

Because the light of stars gets more and more red-shifted the farther away from us they are, this is due to the expansion of space. It should also be noted that the universe is a complete "white-out" and filled with light but just not the kind of light that humans can see with our own eyes. This is the so called cosmic microwave background.
 
Galaxies or clusters within our own galaxy. Every star you can see as a star is in that circle. Some collections of stars outside the circle are also visible.

Well actually only two of those stars may be galaxies. M33 and M31. A couple of globular clusters can be seen naked eye and a couple of nebular such as the sword of Orion. But odds are extremely high you see a light in the sky it is a star :)

Thanks!
 
Damien there was an interesting paper a few years ago postulating that the two clouds were actually the same galaxy in the act of being torn up by the Milky Way. Seems a fair substantial bridge of material was found linking the two structures. If that turns out to be true, then back in the day the Magellanic could have been a fairly substantial galaxy in their own right

Yes, I've heard the suggestion they used to be one medium sized barred spiral that got ripped apart in an encounter with our galaxy.
 
Yes, I've heard the suggestion they used to be one medium sized barred spiral that got ripped apart in an encounter with our galaxy.

Yes the whole structure of the two clouds is pretty unique. Combined they are close to the biggest dwarf galaxy anyone has seen or the smallest spiral galaxy any one has seen. Exciting times indeed.
 
This is how I understand it.

Lets say a galaxy is 10 billion light years away and is one billion years old. Tomorrow from our relative position it slips beyond the realm of the observable universe. If we came back in 10 billion years time we would still be able to see that galaxy as a 1 billion year old artifact of itself rather than a galaxy that has aged a further 10 billion years.

Thanks for explaining. This makes sense to me. The 1 billion year old 'image' of the galaxy would then experience ever increasing redshift.
 
Thanks for explaining. This makes sense to me. The 1 billion year old 'image' of the galaxy would then experience ever increasing redshift.
In practice, how long would it take to "fade" into invisibility?
 
Well actually only two of those stars may be galaxies. M33 and M31. A couple of globular clusters can be seen naked eye and a couple of nebular such as the sword of Orion. But odds are extremely high you see a light in the sky it is a star :)

M31 M33 do not look like stars at all. They are surprisingly expansive on the night sky. M31 (the Andromeda galaxy) spans 190 arc minutes, and M33 (the Triangulum galaxy) 70 arc minutes. The moon, for comparison, only 29 to 34 arc mninutes. Andromeda appears 6 times larger than the moon! It just is very faint, otherwise it would be the most amazing thing to behold in the sky.
 
Quick back of the envelope calculation

Assume maximum visible range = 2 MLY

Diameter of the Universe = 14 BLY give or take

2 MYL/14 BLY = .000143

1/.000143 = 6993

You probably have about a 1 in 7000 chance of being somewhere where you could see visible light if you were randomly materialised anywhere in the known universe. OK, the stats gurus are going to tell me that I haven't taken various statistical terms into account, but that won't change much.

The gist of it is that the chances of you seeing anything are slim.

Uhm - I have two issues with this calculation:

1. "Assume maximum visible range = 2 MLY" is my minor issue. We can see M31 and M33 which are both slightly farther away; and I guess we could still see them if they were a little farter away still. But are they (and our Milky Way) average size and visibility galaxies, or could there be a somewhat common class of galaxies much larger or denser and thus visible from farther away? I think 10 MLY is a better approximation.

2. Bigger issue: You implicitly assume that on any "straight" (for feasible definitions of "straight" in a warped universe) path across the universe there will be, on average, 1 galaxy within 2 MLY of it. Is there any justification for that assumption? Why couldn't be there 100? Or 0.01?
 
M31 M33 do not look like stars at all. They are surprisingly expansive on the night sky. M31 (the Andromeda galaxy) spans 190 arc minutes, and M33 (the Triangulum galaxy) 70 arc minutes. The moon, for comparison, only 29 to 34 arc mninutes. Andromeda appears 6 times larger than the moon! It just is very faint, otherwise it would be the most amazing thing to behold in the sky.

Yes they would look that big in perfect conditions but there is virtually no one on this forum will ever get that opportunity.
 
Yes they would look that big in perfect conditions but there is virtually no one on this forum will ever get that opportunity.

Two years ago, when I first learned about Andromeda's size, I put my SLR on a tripod in what passes as a "starry night" in this low-lying part of the industrialized world, aperture 3.5, exposed 30 seconds, and got a bright center of the galacy (which might be mistaken for a single star) surrounded by almost imperceptible fog. I just reviewed my original photos, and am never quite sure if this really IS M31 or just a faint cloud, but it is (correct location, and doesn't move from picture to picture).

At 48 mm focal length, 30 seconds exposure, 36x24 mm sensor format and 4256x2832 pixels,all stars are about 4 pixels longer than wide (the brighter ones appear larger in both dimensions - is that "bleeding" due to overexposure?), and I tend to believe this shows actual movement of the stars on the firmament, rather than bad tripod.

I wonder why I never tried a longer focal length...
 
In practice, how long would it take to "fade" into invisibility?

Keep in mind that this only applies to objects that are not gravitationally bound to us (i.e. our supercluster).

Everything else in the observable universe will be gone in about 2 trillion years.

Sounds like a lot, but is actually less then the lifetime of small main sequence stars. For example, one of our current neighbours, Barnard's Star, would still be around at this time.
 
Two years ago, when I first learned about Andromeda's size, I put my SLR on a tripod in what passes as a "starry night" in this low-lying part of the industrialized world, aperture 3.5, exposed 30 seconds, and got a bright center of the galacy (which might be mistaken for a single star) surrounded by almost imperceptible fog. I just reviewed my original photos, and am never quite sure if this really IS M31 or just a faint cloud, but it is (correct location, and doesn't move from picture to picture).

At 48 mm focal length, 30 seconds exposure, 36x24 mm sensor format and 4256x2832 pixels,all stars are about 4 pixels longer than wide (the brighter ones appear larger in both dimensions - is that "bleeding" due to overexposure?), and I tend to believe this shows actual movement of the stars on the firmament, rather than bad tripod.

I wonder why I never tried a longer focal length...

This is one of the reasons astro photography is becoming so popular. People without access to good skies can capture some pretty amazing images with a camera.

If you want to past the photos I can tell you if you hit M31 or not but I am definitely not the person to advise you on exposure questions
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom