Where are the stars that we can see?

"Retain" is ambiguous, and I think Craig B took the opposite of what you meant. Brown Dwarfs contain deuterium, and they consume deuterium - until they run out of deuterium, at which time they
a) will not have retained deuterium in their last stage
b) don't contain any deuterium
c) cease to be stars (if you define "star" as a heavenly body that fuses atoms by way of its mass)
The word "retain" could be construed, I think (but I am not a native speaker), as meaning "do not consume".

You meant to ask if deuterium has been observed to exist in these smallest stars, so that they plausibly fuse it as their fuel, right?

Yes. Craig B seems to have read it correctly.
 
Yes, so it's likely these "stars" aren't current "burning". So they might either be dead stars or no longer considered to be stars.
Yes. Craig B seems to have read it correctly.

Huh???
No and no!?

Craig B links to an article that explains that Brown Dwarfs ARE burning deuterium! So when he answers your question ("...retain...?") with "No", I figer he means that "no", they do not "retain" deuterium, rather they consume it, which means they DO contain deuterium.

So they are by no means dead!

But... the question is whether Brown Dwarfs are to be classified as "stars". If the criterion were "fuses elements", then they would be. But it seems that is not the criterion. Wikipedia lists them as "substellar objects", on account of them not fusing protons. And "A star is a massive, luminous sphere of plasma held together by its own gravity", however that would exclude Neutron Stars.
 
The three sentences he quoted from his link appear to be the most relevant from his link. The last sentence clearly states they consume their supply of deuterium within 100 million years or less. Unless you have some information that these stars are less than that age they would be out of deuterium and no longer fusing.
 
The three sentences he quoted from his link appear to be the most relevant from his link. The last sentence clearly states they consume their supply of deuterium within 100 million years or less. Unless you have some information that these stars are less than that age they would be out of deuterium and no longer fusing.

They are still warm.
Wikipedia on brown dwarfs:
"Brown dwarfs heavier than about 13 MJ [Masses of Jupiter] are thought to fuse deuterium and those above ~65 MJ, fuse lithium as well.[2] Brown dwarfs may be fully convective, with no layers or chemical differentiation by depth.[3]

The defining differences between a very-low-mass brown dwarf and a giant planet (~13 MJ) are currently being debated.[4] One school of thought is based on formation; the other, on the physics of the interior.[4]

Part of the debate concerns whether "brown dwarfs" must, by definition, have experienced fusion at some point in their history."​
They use the present tense "fuse" in the first paragraph, but then suggest that fusion may have happened only in the past. Later on:

"One brown dwarf, DENIS-P J082303.1-491201 b, from an ultracool binary system, has a mass of about 28 MJ, making it the largest known exoplanet (as of March 2014)."​

...

What the heck, just read and browse! Brown Dwarfs and their classifications between stars proper and planets is an ongoing research topic with lots of grays.
And indeed it appears that the cool BDs stopped fusion eons ago - even though the smallest may retain deuterium.
 
A question from obvious ignorance. If a brown dwarf was cool enough to allow humans to tolerate it, wouldn't Gravity crush them.
 
Back to the OP and the picture posted. If we mark the distance to the furthest objects we can detect with a telescope, is the assumption that the universe has to be at least twice as big, since those objects would have sent light away from us as well as towards us?

(Twice as big can't be right because we have objects in all directions, so maybe I should say "double the diameter" as measured with us at the center.)

In any case, does that set a lower bound for the size of the universe?
 
As I thought, thanks. A neutron star would have a solid surface, right? Can other cool stars have a solid surface?
Yes, but this problem of being crushed by gravity would manifest itself in an extreme form.
Neutron Stars actually exert a lot of gravity for objects as small as they are (about 10 kilometers in radius). In fact, if you stood on the surface of a neutron star you would feel about 200 Billion times more gravity than here on Earth
https://van.physics.illinois.edu/qa/listing.php?id=1081
 
Yeah, I realise that.

What I have learnt from this thread is that there are cool stars which are nevertheless powered (if that's the right word) by fusion reactions. That, to this layman, but science lover, is utterly amazing.
The neutron stars aren't powered by fusion. They're what's left when fusion stops.
Though Neutron stars do not "burn" anything, for the most part, they DO shine, thanks to the fact that they are the remnants of the core of a star, and thus, when they are born, are roughly as hot as the center of a star. They will thus shine in the same way that a hot poker shines when you stick it in a fire.
http://physics.stackexchange.com/qu...-burn-is-it-decay-or-fusion-or-something-else And like a hot poker, they will cool off gradually I suppose.
 
Yeah, I realise that.

What I have learnt from this thread is that there are cool stars which are nevertheless powered (if that's the right word) by fusion reactions. That, to this layman, but science lover, is utterly amazing.

Actually, I now think that the cool brown dwarfs are no longer powered by fusion reactions which stopped a long time ago. They are in various stage of cooling from a formerly hotter stage.
Another source of heat is their gravitational collapse / shrinking, which sets in after the internal pressure that fusion provides subsides. Same is true by the way for Jupiter and possibly Saturn and Neptune.
 
Back to the OP and the picture posted. If we mark the distance to the furthest objects we can detect with a telescope, is the assumption that the universe has to be at least twice as big, since those objects would have sent light away from us as well as towards us?

(Twice as big can't be right because we have objects in all directions, so maybe I should say "double the diameter" as measured with us at the center.)

In any case, does that set a lower bound for the size of the universe?

Interesting question.

Problem is: The "distance to the furthest objects we can detect with a telescope" are quasars, which are billions of lightyears away, and hence what we see there is billions of years in the past, when the universe was much smaller. We don't know what happened to them and the light they emitted to the other side, so I am not sure it can be stated with certainty that the universe has at least expanded as far to the other side as we are away from them.
 
Back to the OP and the picture posted. If we mark the distance to the furthest objects we can detect with a telescope, is the assumption that the universe has to be at least twice as big, since those objects would have sent light away from us as well as towards us?

(Twice as big can't be right because we have objects in all directions, so maybe I should say "double the diameter" as measured with us at the center.)

In any case, does that set a lower bound for the size of the universe?

Hmm, interesting, you've got me thinkin ...

'Doubling' one dimension is x2 = 2
'Doubling' two dimensions is 2 x 2 = 4
'Doubling' three dimensions is 2 x 2 x 2 = 8

But it's a sphere that's doubling on each 'side', double on the left and double on the right

So would that be ... a 'tripling' ?

'tripling' one dimension is x3 = 3
'tripling' two dimensions is 3 x 3 = 9
'tripling' three dimensions is 3 x 3 x 3 = 27

So the universe is at least 27 times the spherical volume we can see around us.

:boggled: I think that's right ... :covereyes

Cheers,
Happy Holidays,
Jeff
 
Last edited:
...
So the universe is at least 27 times the spherical volume we can see around us.

:boggled: I think that's right ... :covereyes

Cheers,
Happy Holidays,
Jeff

Perhaps in a tetraedical universe... :boxedin:
 
Hmm, interesting, you've got me thinkin ...

'Doubling' one dimension is x2 = 2
'Doubling' two dimensions is 2 x 2 = 4
'Doubling' three dimensions is 2 x 2 x 2 = 8

But it's a sphere that's doubling on each 'side', double on the left and double on the right

So would that be ... a 'tripling' ?

'tripling' one dimension is x3 = 3
'tripling' two dimensions is 3 x 3 = 9
'tripling' three dimensions is 3 x 3 x 3 = 27

So the universe is at least 27 times the spherical volume we can see around us.

:boggled: I think that's right ... :covereyes

Cheers,
Happy Holidays,
Jeff

27 times uni.jpg

And of course in three dimensions, there'd be front and back too. So, times 3 in each dimension ...
 
View attachment 32251

And of course in three dimensions, there'd be front and back too. So, times 3 in each dimension ...

Arrr that brings us to the idea that the earth is in the center of the universe - but so is every other place in the universe, not? I couldn't fathom that this apparent position of our little blue ball can be used to construct an argument for the size of it all.

Oh, and the image is wrong. I think.


We are the blue spot in the middle. The black circles are the light that the red quasars emitted billions of years ago, as it reaches us today.

The minimum volume of the universe would thus be a sphere the radius r of which is twice the distance d to the farthest observed object:
V = 4/3 * pi * r^3 = 4/3 * pi * 8 * d^3 - or 8 times the volume of the observable universe. If marplots' suggestion holds water.
 
Last edited:
Arrr that brings us to the idea that the earth is in the center of the universe - but so is every other place in the universe, not? I couldn't fathom that this apparent position of our little blue ball can be used to construct an argument for the size of it all.

Significant nitpick here. Not the size of it all, but a lower bound. Not, "it's this big" but "it's at least this big."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom