Where are the stars that we can see?

Samson has me confused now. :(

Quasar whose light we see now is 13 billion light years away.
Thus, the light travelled 13 billion years.
It emenated from quasar when universe was 0.8 billion years young.
Distance frrom earth to quasar was then, ignoring >c inflation of universe, 0.8 billion light years or less!?
Why then did it take that light to travel 13 billion years to get here? :confused:
The inflationary epoch, I understand, ended a tiny fraction of a second after the big bang, so it should not (?) play a role for light that emenated 0.8 bilion years later.
 
It took 13 billion years to get here because space expanded. And anything that appears 13 billion light years away to us now is actually much further away (40-ish light years) and we are not going to know about that additional travel for a long time.
 
Samson has me confused now. :(

Quasar whose light we see now is 13 billion light years away.
Thus, the light travelled 13 billion years.
It emenated from quasar when universe was 0.8 billion years young.
Distance frrom earth to quasar was then, ignoring >c inflation of universe, 0.8 billion light years or less!?
Why then did it take that light to travel 13 billion years to get here? :confused:
The inflationary epoch, I understand, ended a tiny fraction of a second after the big bang, so it should not (?) play a role for light that emenated 0.8 bilion years later.

As RY pointed out, this quasar would now be significantly farther away from us than 13 billion lightyears. The light reaching us now has covered 13 billion lightyears but in the meantime, space expanded. When the light was emitted, the quasar was much closer to us, however it was farther away then 0.8 billion lightyears (one would have to do the math on this to find out how far exactly). There is no reason to think that an object we see at an age of 0.8 billion years cannot have been farther away from our location at the time of the emission. The CMB which we see at an age of about 380.000 years, was tens of millions of lightyears from our location when it was emitted.

Maybe part of the confusion also arises by thinking about the expansion of space as a velocity (which is incorrect), rather than a rate. I think this has been covered further up in the tread.

I found this video a pretty good explanation of what happens when light travels towards us while space expands:

https://www.khanacademy.org/science...pansion-topic/v/radius-of-observable-universe
 
As RY pointed out, this quasar would now be significantly farther away from us than 13 billion lightyears. The light reaching us now has covered 13 billion lightyears but in the meantime, space expanded. When the light was emitted, the quasar was much closer to us, however it was farther away then 0.8 billion lightyears (one would have to do the math on this to find out how far exactly). There is no reason to think that an object we see at an age of 0.8 billion years cannot have been farther away from our location at the time of the emission. The CMB which we see at an age of about 380.000 years, was tens of millions of lightyears from our location when it was emitted.

Maybe part of the confusion also arises by thinking about the expansion of space as a velocity (which is incorrect), rather than a rate. I think this has been covered further up in the tread.

I found this video a pretty good explanation of what happens when light travels towards us while space expands:

https://www.khanacademy.org/science...pansion-topic/v/radius-of-observable-universe

No luck signing up to log in, is there another pathway to the video?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom