Where are the stars that we can see?

The Universe is theorised to have expanded at faster than light speed in the distant past: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation_(cosmology)

Just to be clear, the universe is expanding at faster than light speed right now. More precisely, it is possible to choose points in space (lots of them) that are receding from us at greater than the speed of light due to the expansion of the space between us. The difference is that that rate of expansion was greater than the speed of light for much closer points in the past.
 
Just to be clear, the universe is expanding at faster than light speed right now. More precisely, it is possible to choose points in space (lots of them) that are receding from us at greater than the speed of light due to the expansion of the space between us. The difference is that that rate of expansion was greater than the speed of light for much closer points in the past.

If I remember correctly, objects at the outer edge of the current observable universe are currently receding from us faster than the speed of light. However, at the time we are seeing them from our perspective, they were receding at a considerably slower rate. This is why the observable universe is still growing.

As for inflation, the flip side of this is that locations in the observable universe would have also been in very close proximity pre-inflation. This is an explanation for why the cosmic microwave background radiation looks so homogeneous.
 
If I remember correctly, objects at the outer edge of the current observable universe are currently receding from us faster than the speed of light. However, at the time we are seeing them from our perspective, they were receding at a considerably slower rate. This is why the observable universe is still growing.

The theory is we will never see those galaxies disappear, we will just continue to see an older and older version of the galaxy. For want of a better phrase "Fossil light"
 
After that we are looking at the next big event around 100 quadrillion years when gravity starts to fail
Dear Heavens! What's going to happen to it? Will things start to fall upwards? Or will gravity simply "run out of steam"?

I don't think that's in Paul Davies, The Last Three Minutes. But do you have a source? It's interesting.
 
Dear Heavens! What's going to happen to it? Will things start to fall upwards? Or will gravity simply "run out of steam"?

I don't think that's in Paul Davies, The Last Three Minutes. But do you have a source? It's interesting.

Paul Davie's book pre-dates the growth in understanding of dark matter. My comments come from a conversation with Stephen Baxter about 15 years ago when we were discussing his book "Time" Baxter's thoughts may well be out of date by now as well **shakes hand** curse you science lol
 

The stars we see can't be in the circle since this is not the Milky Way Galaxy. All the stars that we see with the unaided eye are in the Milky Way Galaxy.

This can't be a picture of the Milky Way Galaxy because it shows the spiral arms. We are in the Milky Way Galaxy right in the sagittal plane. Therefore, there is no way we can see the spiral arms of the Milky Way galaxy while being in it.

This is most probably a picture of the Andromeda Galaxy, which is about 2.2 MLY from the Milky Way Galaxy. The spiral arms of the Andromeda Galaxy have been frequently photographed. The Andromeda has structure similar to that of the Milky Way Galaxy, although it has diameter twice as large as the Milky Way Galaxy. So photographs of the Andromeda Galaxy are often used to illustrate what the Milky Way Galaxy looks like.

The article you site probably is referring to scale, not to the actual stars. However, it can't be precisely correct for scale since the Andromeda Galaxy is twice as wide as the Milky Way Galaxy.

There are very few stars in Andromeda that can be seen with the unaided eye. I believe there are a few stars in Andromeda that can be seen with powerful telescopes. However, these are not likely to be the stars that the article talks about. Most likely, the authors are using a photograph of the Andromeda Galaxy as a scale picture of the Milky Way.

The picture may possibly represent a galaxy other than either the Andromeda galaxy or the Milky Way galaxy. However, the authors were reasonable in assuming their audience would accept this as a scale model of the Milky Way Galaxy.

The 'stars we see' probably refers to the 'stars we see with the unaided eye. The picture represents a scale model of the Milky Way, even if it is really a picture of Andromeda.

This is probably correct as a very rough estimate of the size of the region of space with stars that can be seen with the unaided eye provided we accept this picture as a scale model of the Milky Way Galaxy. I have no way to tell if the implied scale is precisely correct. I conjecture that the scale is probably a ball part estimate, correct within a factor of two.

I wouldn't navigate my starship using this picture. However, it is probably accurate for purposes of historical exposition.
 
If I'm understanding all the over-my-head comments right, all the stars I can see at night are in that circle, but some dots of light (that I consider to be stars) are actually other galaxies?
 
This can't be a picture of the Milky Way Galaxy because it shows the spiral arms. We are in the Milky Way Galaxy right in the sagittal plane. Therefore, there is no way we can see the spiral arms of the Milky Way galaxy while being in it.

This is most probably a picture of the Andromeda Galaxy, which is about 2.2 MLY from the Milky Way Galaxy. The spiral arms of the Andromeda Galaxy have been frequently photographed. The Andromeda has structure similar to that of the Milky Way Galaxy, although it has diameter twice as large as the Milky Way Galaxy. So photographs of the Andromeda Galaxy are often used to illustrate what the Milky Way Galaxy looks like.

That image is a digital representation of the Milky Way. The Solar System is actually in a small spur of the Orion arm, which is correctly depicted here. Also the galaxy shown is known as a barred spiral and at this stage we do not know if the Andromeda galaxy is barred or not, but we do know the Milky Way is
 
If I'm understanding all the over-my-head comments right, all the stars I can see at night are in that circle, but some dots of light (that I consider to be stars) are actually other galaxies?

Galaxies or clusters within our own galaxy. Every star you can see as a star is in that circle. Some collections of stars outside the circle are also visible.
 
If I'm understanding all the over-my-head comments right, all the stars I can see at night are in that circle, but some dots of light (that I consider to be stars) are actually other galaxies?

Well actually only two of those stars may be galaxies. M33 and M31. A couple of globular clusters can be seen naked eye and a couple of nebular such as the sword of Orion. But odds are extremely high you see a light in the sky it is a star :)
 
The stars we see can't be in the circle since this is not the Milky Way Galaxy. All the stars that we see with the unaided eye are in the Milky Way Galaxy.

This can't be a picture of the Milky Way Galaxy because it shows the spiral arms. We are in the Milky Way Galaxy right in the sagittal plane. Therefore, there is no way we can see the spiral arms of the Milky Way galaxy while being in it.

This is most probably a picture of the Andromeda Galaxy.
As I already said in post #22, this is in fact Milky Way. Or as close as astronomers can construct it, given they are looking at it from the inside:

Milky Way diagram

Location and shape of Milky Way's spiral arms is more or less known, and they even have names.

Here is more detail: http://galaxymap.org/drupal/node/171
 
The objections that the picture isn't a picture of the Milky Way are pretty silly. It doesn't purport to be a picture of the Milky Way.
Please read the links from my previous post. The picture in them is obviously the same one as in OP. So yes, it does "purport" that.
 
Paul Davie's book pre-dates the growth in understanding of dark matter. My comments come from a conversation with Stephen Baxter about 15 years ago when we were discussing his book "Time" Baxter's thoughts may well be out of date by now as well **shakes hand** curse you science lol

Brian Cox series a year or two ago covered the gradual wind down of the universe. It did appear to talk an awfully long time.

Ah, wiki covers it to some extent.
 
The objections that the picture isn't a picture of the Milky Way are pretty silly. It doesn't purport to be a picture of the Milky Way.

Please read the links from my previous post. The picture in them is obviously the same one as in OP. So yes, it does "purport" that.

It's not literally a picture, as in taken with an optical telescope, but an illustration of what we believe the Milky Way looks like (like a map). I think everybody is on the same page here.
 
Please read the links from my previous post. The picture in them is obviously the same one as in OP. So yes, it does "purport" that.

I'm sorry, I don't see anything at your links that claims that and your description of your own links doesn't seem to support that either. It's a diagrammatic reconstruction based on best knowledge (which is, I think, a paraphrase of what you said earlier). There is no reason for rejecting the image as invalid due to us not being able to take a picture from that perspective. It does not claim to be that.
 
The theory is we will never see those galaxies disappear, we will just continue to see an older and older version of the galaxy. For want of a better phrase "Fossil light"

I am unsure what you mean by that. In my understanding, the light we receive from objects that are currently part of the observable universe will experience an ever increasing redshift ("fade" from our point of view). Eventually, the wavelength of the light emitted by these objects will become larger than the observable universe, at which point they will be undetectable in principle. These objects will then have left the observable universe.
 
For goodness sakes guys, it doesn't really matter what the image actually is.

The OP has used it to represent the Milky Way, and to indicate the relatively tiny part of it that we can see with the naked eye. He could have used a line drawing like this for all it matters in relation to the thread!

MWDrawing.png
 
For goodness sakes guys, it doesn't really matter what the image actually is.

The OP has used it to represent the Milky Way, and to indicate the relatively tiny part of it that we can see with the naked eye. He could have used a line drawing like this for all it matters in relation to the thread!

[qimg]https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/98915197/JREF/MWDrawing.png[/qimg]
He couldn't have used that. There's only four dots in your circle, and there's more than four dots in the sky at night.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom