Where are the stars that we can see?

Is it not in a sense doing so, in that there is a speed of recession proportional to distance and the limit to how far out we can see is set by the distance at which this speed of recession is equal to or greater than the SOL?

The volume of space inside this limit is the "Observable Universe".

The size of the observable universe is currently limited by how much time has passed since its beginning. With increasing age, the observable universe will increase in size, since more light will have had sufficient time to reach us. Thus, at the moment, the rate of recession at the edge of the observable universe is slower than then speed of light.

Based on the current models however, this will change eventually and the growth of the observable universe will come to a halt (in the not too distant future). In addition, objects now within the observable universe will eventually be "pushed out" of it (or as we see them, they will fade away until they are undetectable).
 
We can see the Andromeda galaxy, so no. Also, don't we see the galactic plane ?
But those aren't stars and even though they are composed of stars the human eye doesn't see them as stars. There are other objects we can see outside that circle, but not individual stars.

It's also not clear how much of the light we see of the galactic plane originates outside that circle. My SWAG based on the attenuation figures I posted above is that it's not much larger than that circle.
 
:confused: no kidding
I don't think it has to be confusing. If you say something like "The universe is expanding by 0.0000000074% per year" this would be more intuitive. Depending on the audience you might be more precise and say "The linear dimensions of the universe are expanding by 0.0000000074% per year".

Don't quote me on that exact number. I come up with about 2 billion km/year from the 72km/s part of the constant. Then there are 3x10^19 km in a megaparsec. Dozens of opportunities to slip a decimal place or five.

Even if I got the number wrong, the basic idea is more people will get the right understanding if it's expressed as a percentage* rather than dimensionless constants, reciprocal time, or units that have distances in both the numerator and denominator.

* Percentages are a dimensionless constant but there's no need to confuse the innumerate with that bit of pedantry.
 
Last edited:
:confused: no kidding
I have pictured it this way, which I hope is not misleading. No doubt I will be told if it is.

Imagine a long measuring rod, like an endless metre stick. It's stretching, getting longer, in such a way that points initially one centimetre apart, after one second are two centimetres apart. What does that mean? It means that, in that same second, points which were initially a metre apart are now two metres apart. The "speed" for the points separated by one cm is one cm per second; and for those separate by a metre, the "speed" is one metre per second. So no point is travelling at any particular speed at all; it is the separation that is increasing, by the same proportion in the same time, for any two points, however near or far they may be from each other.

Two points initially separated by more than 299,792,458 metres would recede from each other by more than that distance in one second, which is a "speed" greater than the speed of light. But there is in reality no "speed" that can be attributed to any object, just a stretching of the interval separating one point from another.

ETA RecoveringYuppy. Our posts crossed. I see you got in first.
 
Last edited:
The large Magellanic cloud (At 160,000 light years) contains a nebula so bright it can be see with the naked eye and was originally cataloged as a star.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tarantula_Nebula

In 1987, a star on the edge of the Tarantula Nebula went supernova (or more correctly, the light from this supernova reached the Earth in 1987, the actual supernova happened 160,000 years ago). That star, Sanduleak -69° 202, rose in brightness to become about magnitude 2.9, putting it inside the top 160 brightest stars at that time.

To put that in perspective, if that supernova had been at the standard distance of 10 parsecs (32.6 light years) it would have peaked at magnitude -15.5; we would have seen it as a point of light 10 times brighter than the full moon. We'd still be here to see it, but the blast wave that would likely wipe out life on this planet would be on its way.

SN1987a was a relatively small supernova, only about 1/10 as energetic as is typical for a star that size. However, the LMC also contains a star called S-Doradus, a hypergiant that is about ready to blow. Hypergiants only live for about 10 million years before their lives end in a cosmic blast, and S-Doradus is nearing the end. If it goes supernova in our lifetimes, it is expected to briefly become the brightest star in our sky, perhaps even brighter than Venus at is brightest
 
In 1987, a star on the edge of the Tarantula Nebula went supernova (or more correctly, the light from this supernova reached the Earth in 1987, the actual supernova happened 160,000 years ago). That star, Sanduleak -69° 202, rose in brightness to become about magnitude 2.9, putting it inside the top 160 brightest stars at that time.

To put that in perspective, if that supernova had been at the standard distance of 10 parsecs (32.6 light years) it would have peaked at magnitude -15.5; we would have seen it as a point of light 10 times brighter than the full moon. We'd still be here to see it, but the blast wave that would likely wipe out life on this planet would be on its way.

SN1987a was a relatively small supernova, only about 1/10 as energetic as is typical for a star that size. However, the LMC also contains a star called S-Doradus, a hypergiant that is about ready to blow. Hypergiants only live for about 10 million years before their lives end in a cosmic blast, and S-Doradus is nearing the end. If it goes supernova in our lifetimes, it is expected to briefly become the brightest star in our sky, perhaps even brighter than Venus at is brightest

I didn't want to mention supernova cause thats kinda cheating lol
 
I didn't want to mention supernova cause thats kinda cheating lol
I've already mentioned the visible element of a Gamma Ray Burst, that could have been perceived by the naked eye at a distance of 7.5 billion light years, if anyone had happened to be watching during the few seconds when it was emitting a flash of visible light. So that's kinda cheating too.

ETA A supernova, and therefore an individual star, in Andromeda galaxy, was theoretically just visible to the naked eye in 1885.
SN 1885A reached magnitude 5.85 on 21 August 1885 and faded to magnitude 14 half a year later.
 
Last edited:
I didn't want to mention supernova cause thats kinda cheating lol

Its not really cheating? The OP is about "stars"; a supernova isn't really a star any more, its the remains of a star spreading out in all directions across the cosmos. Its like a stick of gelignite. Once it explodes, its not really a stick of gelignite any more, is it?
 
Its not really cheating? The OP is about "stars"; a supernova isn't really a star any more, its the remains of a star spreading out in all directions across the cosmos. Its like a stick of gelignite. Once it explodes, its not really a stick of gelignite any more, is it?

Never mind, beaten to the punch
 
Last edited:
I don't think it has to be confusing. If you say something like "The universe is expanding by 0.0000000074% per year" this would be more intuitive. Depending on the audience you might be more precise and say "The linear dimensions of the universe are expanding by 0.0000000074% per year".

Don't quote me on that exact number. I come up with about 2 billion km/year from the 72km/s part of the constant. Then there are 3x10^19 km in a megaparsec. Dozens of opportunities to slip a decimal place or five.

Even if I got the number wrong, the basic idea is more people will get the right understanding if it's expressed as a percentage* rather than dimensionless constants, reciprocal time, or units that have distances in both the numerator and denominator.

* Percentages are a dimensionless constant but there's no need to confuse the innumerate with that bit of pedantry.

I have pictured it this way, which I hope is not misleading. No doubt I will be told if it is.

Imagine a long measuring rod, like an endless metre stick. It's stretching, getting longer, in such a way that points initially one centimetre apart, after one second are two centimetres apart. What does that mean? It means that, in that same second, points which were initially a metre apart are now two metres apart. The "speed" for the points separated by one cm is one cm per second; and for those separate by a metre, the "speed" is one metre per second. So no point is travelling at any particular speed at all; it is the separation that is increasing, by the same proportion in the same time, for any two points, however near or far they may be from each other.

Two points initially separated by more than 299,792,458 metres would recede from each other by more than that distance in one second, which is a "speed" greater than the speed of light. But there is in reality no "speed" that can be attributed to any object, just a stretching of the interval separating one point from another.

ETA RecoveringYuppy. Our posts crossed. I see you got in first.

Thanks both. Craig's image is particularly effective for me.
 
...
Have you thought of this? The typical average random place in the universe is presumably a point in one of the huge voids remote from any cluster of galaxies. If you were transported to such a place, it would surely be impossible to see anything at all with the naked eye, except a flash associated with the occasional GRB event. Is that not so?

Good question - anyone got an answer?

If you happened to be dropped somewhere in a group of galaxies like our own Local Group, you'd very likely be able to see several galaxies.

If you find yourself outside of a group, but inside one of the larger clusters, like our own Virgo Supercluster, I'd guess that you'd miss most galaxies and clusters, but that the larger or denser clusters still provide some visible aggregations. The Virgo Cluster (member of the Virgo Supercluster, but not to be confused with it) is said to have some galaxies that can be seen from here with a "small" telescope, despite it being about 50 million ly away. Wouldn't you stand an exellent chance to find yourself closer than that to a cluster and near enough to some galaxy to see it?

Now if you go beyond that, I guess all becomes dark, and overall the chance of finding yourself outside of a cluster is very high.

But I am only investiwikiing.
 
I think the furthest non-transient thing visible to the naked eye is the Andromeda Galaxy at 2 MLY. If you plop down at a random point in the universe you're likely to be more than 2 MLY away from anything like that. So I'd expect most of the universe is black in visible light.
 
Good question - anyone got an answer?

If you happened to be dropped somewhere in a group of galaxies like our own Local Group, you'd very likely be able to see several galaxies.

If you find yourself outside of a group, but inside one of the larger clusters, like our own Virgo Supercluster, I'd guess that you'd miss most galaxies and clusters, but that the larger or denser clusters still provide some visible aggregations. The Virgo Cluster (member of the Virgo Supercluster, but not to be confused with it) is said to have some galaxies that can be seen from here with a "small" telescope, despite it being about 50 million ly away. Wouldn't you stand an exellent chance to find yourself closer than that to a cluster and near enough to some galaxy to see it?

Now if you go beyond that, I guess all becomes dark, and overall the chance of finding yourself outside of a cluster is very high.

But I am only investiwikiing.

I think the furthest non-transient thing visible to the naked eye is the Andromeda Galaxy at 2 MLY. If you plop down at a random point in the universe you're likely to be more than 2 MLY away from anything like that. So I'd expect most of the universe is black in visible light.

Quick back of the envelope calculation

Assume maximum visible range = 2 MLY

Diameter of the Universe = 14 BLY give or take

2 MYL/14 BLY = .000143

1/.000143 = 6993

You probably have about a 1 in 7000 chance of being somewhere where you could see visible light if you were randomly materialised anywhere in the known universe. OK, the stats gurus are going to tell me that I haven't taken various statistical terms into account, but that won't change much.

The gist of it is that the chances of you seeing anything are slim.
 
Quick back of the envelope calculation

Assume maximum visible range = 2 MLY

Diameter of the Universe = 14 BLY give or take

2 MYL/14 BLY = .000143

1/.000143 = 6993

You probably have about a 1 in 7000 chance of being somewhere where you could see visible light if you were randomly materialised anywhere in the known universe. OK, the stats gurus are going to tell me that I haven't taken various statistical terms into account, but that won't change much.

The gist of it is that the chances of you seeing anything are slim.
That's remarkable, if so, that the universe should be so dark. We live in a bright bit, needless to say. Things may be even gloomier than your calculation suggests, because the universe is seemingly bigger than that. It has been continuing to expand while the light from the distant regions has been on its way to us; if I understand the principle correctly.
The best estimate of the age of the universe as of 2013 is 13.798 ± 0.037 billion years, but due to the expansion of space humans are observing objects that were originally much closer but are now considerably farther away (as defined in terms of cosmological proper distance, which is equal to the comoving distance at the present time) than a static 13.8 billion light-years distance. It is estimated that the diameter of the observable universe is about 28 billion parsecs (93 billion light-years), putting the edge of the observable universe at about 46–47 billion light-years away.
So that's a diameter, not of c14 billion ly, but 93 billion ly. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Observable_universe.
 
Last edited:
That's remarkable, if so, that the universe should be so dark. We live in a bright bit, needless to say. Things may be even gloomier than your calculation suggests, because the universe is seemingly bigger than that. It has been continuing to expand while the light from the distant regions has been on its way to us; if I understand the principle correctly. So that's a diameter, not of c14 billion ly, but 93 billion ly. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Observable_universe.

The thing to remember the Universe is still very much in its infancy. If things bang along as they are now, the universe will enter the degenerate phase in something like 100 trillion years. After that we are looking at the next big event around 100 quadrillion years when gravity starts to fail

Stephen Baxter in his novel "Time" writes an enthralling description of this process after he falls through a time gate ala 2001
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom