Where are the stars that we can see?

If it were, wouldn't we see some of the same stars, looking in opposite directions?

Only if the degree of curvature was high enough such that the universe was smaller than the visible distance. Since that diagram being discussed is larger than we can see it raise the possibility of curvature that wouldn't cause us to see "repeats". If it's only the outer regions of that diagram that overlap no repetition would be visible to us (or to any region of that universe).
 
Interesting question.

Problem is: The "distance to the furthest objects we can detect with a telescope" are quasars, which are billions of lightyears away, and hence what we see there is billions of years in the past, when the universe was much smaller. We don't know what happened to them and the light they emitted to the other side, so I am not sure it can be stated with certainty that the universe has at least expanded as far to the other side as we are away from them.
Thirteen billion years ago they were all close together, so should all be in one place seen from here surely, yet they are seen in all directions. :confused:.
 
As I thought, thanks. A neutron star would have a solid surface, right? Can other cool stars have a solid surface?
Theoretically yes -- a white dwarf (star which no longer undergoes fusion) or a brown dwarf will eventually cool down to a "black dwarf", and ultimately solidify. However the universe is not old enough for this to have happened yet.
 
Saying that a neutron star would have a solid surface is quite an understatement. It's a degenerate collection of atoms packed to nuclear densities on the surface of a city sized atomic nucleus. By any measure it will be millions, maybe billions, of times more "solid" than any solid we've ever experienced directly.
 
Saying that a neutron star would have a solid surface is quite an understatement. It's a degenerate collection of atoms packed to nuclear densities on the surface of a city sized atomic nucleus. By any measure it will be millions, maybe billions, of times more "solid" than any solid we've ever experienced directly.

Solidity is not a matter of density. Think of mercury vs. titanium.

While the surface of a neutron star (where there are still atoms, namely iron) is indeed supremely solid, underneath there is a big layer consisting of nothing but neutrons, which, lacking protons, are not like an atomic nucleaus at all; instead, they are a superfluid, i.e. "liquid", having no viscosity at all.
 
The fact that distant objects presumably also radiated away from us as well as toward us does not mean that there is at least the same distance on the other side for that radiation to have gone. If that added space is out there, then where does the radiation from the objects in there go? Sooner or later, this idea requires either an infinite universe, or a vast shell of empty space with no light sources in it that completely surrounds our section in the middle, which is where all of the light sources are.

If the universe has a boundary somewhere shorter distance beyond those farthest objects we can see, even if it is closer to them than they are to us, we just don't know what it's like there, so we don't know what light would do when it gets there. Maybe it bounces back. Maybe it scatters at various angles based on something unpredictable like its polarization. Maybe it vanishes or is absorbed into something else we can't describe. Maybe there's not exactly even a boundary at all but the path isn't straight so it curves away somewhere else instead of continuing straight away from its source.
 
The fact that distant objects presumably also radiated away from us as well as toward us does not mean that there is at least the same distance on the other side for that radiation to have gone. If that added space is out there, then where does the radiation from the objects in there go? Sooner or later, this idea requires either an infinite universe, or a vast shell of empty space with no light sources in it that completely surrounds our section in the middle, which is where all of the light sources are.

If the universe has a boundary somewhere shorter distance beyond those farthest objects we can see, even if it is closer to them than they are to us, we just don't know what it's like there, so we don't know what light would do when it gets there. Maybe it bounces back. Maybe it scatters at various angles based on something unpredictable like its polarization. Maybe it vanishes or is absorbed into something else we can't describe. Maybe there's not exactly even a boundary at all but the path isn't straight so it curves away somewhere else instead of continuing straight away from its source.

Thank you. That was a very well considered answer.
 
The fact that distant objects presumably also radiated away from us as well as toward us does not mean that there is at least the same distance on the other side for that radiation to have gone. If that added space is out there, then where does the radiation from the objects in there go? Sooner or later, this idea requires either an infinite universe, or a vast shell of empty space with no light sources in it that completely surrounds our section in the middle, which is where all of the light sources are.

Mainstream cosmology models describe the universe as unbounded. Depending on its global geometry and topology, the universe is understood as either infinite or compact but unbounded. A globally flat or hyperbolic (negative curvature) universe may, depending on its topology, be infinite. A universe with positive curvature (spherical) would be compact but unbounded. A common analogy is the surface of the earth which has a finite size but no boundaries.

In a compact scenario, light could eventually return to its source, given enough time to “circle” the universe (likely not possible in our universe due to the expansion of space, unless the universe is smaller than the observable universe). In neither scenario would it ever reach an edge.

In our neighborhood, the geometry looks flat, but there currently is no (and never may be) way of determining the global geometry of the universe.
 
Thirteen billion years ago they were all close together, so should all be in one place seen from here surely, yet they are seen in all directions. :confused:.

This is a common mistake, to think of the Big Bang as something we can see from the outside. The Big Bang has no "outside" and we are inside it.
As the space between the quasars expanded, the Sun and Earth formed in amongst them. Thus we see them at a great distance in all directions.
 
This is a common mistake, to think of the Big Bang as something we can see from the outside. The Big Bang has no "outside" and we are inside it.
As the space between the quasars expanded, the Sun and Earth formed in amongst them. Thus we see them at a great distance in all directions.
This is no doubt correct, but does not prevent me posing what must be a paradox.
I see two 13 billion year old quasars which from my vantage point are at opposite ends of a straight line that passes through my observation position. Therefore, ignoring accelerating expansion of space, these quasars are 26 billion light years separated. And yet they are about 800 million years old, and started from the same point. Therefore in 800 million years they have become separated by 26 billion light years.
While this is clearly wrong, I can't identify the obvious fallacy.
 
This is no doubt correct, but does not prevent me posing what must be a paradox.
I see two 13 billion year old quasars which from my vantage point are at opposite ends of a straight line that passes through my observation position. Therefore, ignoring accelerating expansion of space, these quasars are 26 billion light years separated. And yet they are about 800 million years old, and started from the same point. Therefore in 800 million years they have become separated by 26 billion light years.
While this is clearly wrong, I can't identify the obvious fallacy.

One simple thing: at the time they were formed the stuff they were formed from had already been travelling for billions of years.

BTW I'm also guessing your question isn't well formed. 800 million year old measured by who?
 
Last edited:
One simple thing: at the time they were formed the stuff they were formed from had already been travelling for billions of years.

BTW I'm also guessing your question isn't well formed. 800 million year old measured by who?

The universe is 13.8 billion calendar years old, thus a 13 billion year old quasar was born when the universe was 800 million years old. My understanding is that we ignore expansion of the universe when describing the ages of objects. I am seeing two quasars as they were when the universe was 800 million years old, and since I am seeing things as they were, these quasars were 26 billion light years apart then.
My question is formed as well as I could.
 
You actually don't see them as they appeared then (although in casual language people probably say that a lot). You have to compensate for the expansion of the universe. Their spectrum is shifted and their distance from each other has changed.
 
You actually don't see them as they appeared then (although in casual language people probably say that a lot). You have to compensate for the expansion of the universe. Their spectrum is shifted and their distance from each other has changed.

Thanks, I am doing more thought experiments, but I think it's bad for my brain.
 
You actually don't see them as they appeared then (although in casual language people probably say that a lot). .

In terms of a frame of reference it is simply easier to describe things that way, unless you are Sheldon Cooper lol
 
Thanks, I am doing more thought experiments, but I think it's bad for my brain.

One of the best ways to look at it is to consider an unbaked raisin cake. Each of the raisins is X distance from each other. During the cook process the raisin appear to be rushing away from each when in fact it is not the raisin but the cake mix that is expanding.

Hope that helps a little
 
One of the best ways to look at it is to consider an unbaked raisin cake. Each of the raisins is X distance from each other. During the cook process the raisin appear to be rushing away from each when in fact it is not the raisin but the cake mix that is expanding.

Hope that helps a little
Thanks MG1962
I assume the universe is probably finite and spherical. (Finite because it has always been finite or always been infinite, and I best picture the grapefruit sized "object" at 10 - 32 seconds after inflation as being finite). I am now picturing the solar system as being the centre most raisin in the cake, as there must be one, and why not us.
My two quasars are thus on opposite points on my spherical observable universe, beyond which is a much larger part of a finite universe I will never see. The two quasars have probably evolved into galaxies like mine, but we probably were fledgelings in the same nest.

Does that work? Are there any big mistakes in that model?
 
Thanks MG1962
I assume the universe is probably finite and spherical. (Finite because it has always been finite or always been infinite, and I best picture the grapefruit sized "object" at 10 - 32 seconds after inflation as being finite). I am now picturing the solar system as being the centre most raisin in the cake, as there must be one, and why not us.
My two quasars are thus on opposite points on my spherical observable universe, beyond which is a much larger part of a finite universe I will never see. The two quasars have probably evolved into galaxies like mine, but we probably were fledgelings in the same nest.

Does that work? Are there any big mistakes in that model?

I imagine the spherical model a bit differently, more like a (4D?) bubble with the 3 spacial dimensions on and tangential to the surface so theres no centre point. So more like things drawn onto the surface of a balloon then inflating it rather than raisins in a cake. No idea if thats the way to think of it or not though.
 
The universe is 13.8 billion calendar years old, thus a 13 billion year old quasar was born when the universe was 800 million years old. My understanding is that we ignore expansion of the universe when describing the ages of objects. I am seeing two quasars as they were when the universe was 800 million years old, and since I am seeing things as they were, these quasars were 26 billion light years apart then.
My question is formed as well as I could.

You see them as they appeared then (or almost, as RY said the spectrum is shifted), but that doesn't mean that they were 26 billion light years apart then.

Imagine that instead of getting an image from light you got an image from some slower moving particle. We could imagine that the image came in the form of a video recording carried on a slow moving spacecraft. In that case you'd still see the same image of an 800 million year old quasar, but it wouldn't arrive until much later, at which point the two galaxies would be even further apart.

At the time that the light that you're seeing left the quasar on it's way to you, the two quasars that you are seeing were much closer together than they are now. We can, because of the the red-shift that the light undergoes on it's journey, tell how long it took to get here, but that doesn't equal the distance away that it was when the light first set out. The universe expanded quite a bit in the meantime and thus it's much further away now.

So those two quasars weren't 26 billion light years apart 13 billion years ago.
 
You see them as they appeared then (or almost, as RY said the spectrum is shifted), but that doesn't mean that they were 26 billion light years apart then.

Imagine that instead of getting an image from light you got an image from some slower moving particle. We could imagine that the image came in the form of a video recording carried on a slow moving spacecraft. In that case you'd still see the same image of an 800 million year old quasar, but it wouldn't arrive until much later, at which point the two galaxies would be even further apart.

At the time that the light that you're seeing left the quasar on it's way to you, the two quasars that you are seeing were much closer together than they are now. We can, because of the the red-shift that the light undergoes on it's journey, tell how long it took to get here, but that doesn't equal the distance away that it was when the light first set out. The universe expanded quite a bit in the meantime and thus it's much further away now.

So those two quasars weren't 26 billion light years apart 13 billion years ago.

I think I get it. There can be no doubt I am seeing the quasars as they were, but I am not seeing the distance between them as it was.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom