Where are the stars that we can see?

Keep in mind that this only applies to objects that are not gravitationally bound to us (i.e. our supercluster).

Everything else in the observable universe will be gone in about 2 trillion years.

Sounds like a lot, but is actually less then the lifetime of small main sequence stars. For example, one of our current neighbours, Barnard's Star, would still be around at this time.
No, I mean, once an image has become "fossilised" how much longer after that would it become in practice invisible, as perceived by observers here? How long until, as Wordsworth wrote of the extinction of the Venetian Republic
... even the shade
Of that which once was great is passed away?
 
No, I mean, once an image has become "fossilised" how much longer after that would it become in practice invisible, as perceived by observers here?

That's how I understood your question. Two trillion years until the object becomes, in principle, unobservable. In practice, obviously earlier but not that much earlier I would think, since the redshift increases exponentially.
 
At 48 mm focal length, 30 seconds exposure, 36x24 mm sensor format and 4256x2832 pixels,all stars are about 4 pixels longer than wide (the brighter ones appear larger in both dimensions - is that "bleeding" due to overexposure?), and I tend to believe this shows actual movement of the stars on the firmament, rather than bad tripod.

I wonder why I never tried a longer focal length...

30 seconds is enough to show star-trailing due to the Earth's rotation.

Its amazing what you can do with a digital camera now. You can combine separate images in a technique called "image stacking" to get nothing short of great results from a relatively modest camera.

Here is a photograph of M31 in Andromeda, taken by an Amateur Astronomer in Portugal.

http://www.space.com/26742-amazing-andromeda-galaxy-night-sky-photo.html

He achieved this by taking 51 separate photos with his Canon 60D fitted with a Canon 200mm L telephoto lens. Settings ISO 2000, Exposure 45 seconds at f/2.8. He then stacked the images using image stacking software.

Here's a little information about stacking...

http://www.instructables.com/id/Astrophotography-Star-Photo-Stacking/?ALLSTEPS

The free software package "Deep Sky stacker" is a good place to start.

http://deepskystacker.free.fr/english/index.html
 
If you're going to get into things like image registration and averaging (which is all that "stacking" is), I'd heartily recommend jumping into the deep end with Fiji:
http://fiji.sc/wiki/index.php/Fiji

It's what scientists use to process science images. For science.
 
Nonetheless, that photo of M31 is impressive for an amateur, and taken with an off-the-shelf prosumer Digital camera.

Did you look at the full sized image?

http://i.space.com/images/i/000/041/183/original/AdndromedaGalaxy-Polarie-Net.jpg?1407292322

To be honest the astronomy forum I hang out with is top heavy with AP people, and I think I see better images than that on a daily basis. Here are a few images to compare it with

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/...phs-of-the-past-four-years.html?frame=2374476
 
30 seconds is enough to show star-trailing due to the Earth's rotation.

Its amazing what you can do with a digital camera now. You can combine separate images in a technique called "image stacking" to get nothing short of great results from a relatively modest camera.

Here is a photograph of M31 in Andromeda, taken by an Amateur Astronomer in Portugal.

http://www.space.com/26742-amazing-andromeda-galaxy-night-sky-photo.html

He achieved this by taking 51 separate photos with his Canon 60D fitted with a Canon 200mm L telephoto lens. Settings ISO 2000, Exposure 45 seconds at f/2.8. He then stacked the images using image stacking software.

Here's a little information about stacking...

http://www.instructables.com/id/Astrophotography-Star-Photo-Stacking/?ALLSTEPS

The free software package "Deep Sky stacker" is a good place to start.

http://deepskystacker.free.fr/english/index.html
If you're going to get into things like image registration and averaging (which is all that "stacking" is), I'd heartily recommend jumping into the deep end with Fiji:
http://fiji.sc/wiki/index.php/Fiji

It's what scientists use to process science images. For science.

Thanks guys! You are putting the "E" back into JREF IntErnational SkEptics Forum :cool:

Therefore: #oysteinbookmark

I'm impressed. If I'd taken that picture, I'd be pretty much insufferable for weeks.
Yes yes, my friends are gonna hate me, and my girl's gonna leave smile forgivingly at me, but it's worth a try! :o
 
Last edited:
This is one of the reasons astro photography is becoming so popular. People without access to good skies can capture some pretty amazing images with a camera.

If you want to past the photos I can tell you if you hit M31 or not but I am definitely not the person to advise you on exposure questions

Here is the original photo:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/3bg0j4gx79qwy90/700_1981.NEF?dl=0 (NEF = Nikon Raw)
https://www.dropbox.com/s/4d1b493eiw1cnlb/700_1981.JPG?dl=0 (JPG)
(The center of M31 is at (2717,2034) pixels)

and I cropped the region that contains the galaxy - I think:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/e0ebj94nr9tm3tb/700_1981_cropped_800x600_Andromeda.jpg?dl=0

Here's a simple try at "enhancing" the image - just to show there is "something" around the center - I take out all of the red and some og the green (to remove much of the background of artificial city light reflected from the hazy atmosphere), and greatly increase gamma (3.5) and contrast (+80) using IrfanView:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/zghn38sm44s3bok/700_1981_croppedAndEnhanced_800x600_Andromeda.jpg?dl=0
 
Last edited:
As I already said in post #22, this is in fact Milky Way. Or as close as astronomers can construct it, given they are looking at it from the inside:

Okay, I was wrong. It is a digital reconstruction. One of the links specifically says that.
Here is a link and relevant quote.

http://galaxymap.org/drupal/node/171
‘Robert Hurt's famous diagram of the Milky Way. (Rotated for this site by engrafi.)’

Hey, I think I can see my house from here !-)
 
Here is the original photo:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/3bg0j4gx79qwy90/700_1981.NEF?dl=0 (NEF = Nikon Raw)
https://www.dropbox.com/s/4d1b493eiw1cnlb/700_1981.JPG?dl=0 (JPG)
(The center of M31 is at (2717,2034) pixels)

and I cropped the region that contains the galaxy - I think:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/e0ebj94nr9tm3tb/700_1981_cropped_800x600_Andromeda.jpg?dl=0

Here's a simple try at "enhancing" the image - just to show there is "something" around the center - I take out all of the red and some og the green (to remove much of the background of artificial city light reflected from the hazy atmosphere), and greatly increase gamma (3.5) and contrast (+80) using IrfanView:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/zghn38sm44s3bok/700_1981_croppedAndEnhanced_800x600_Andromeda.jpg?dl=0

The second image looks very much like I see M31 naked eye. As far as the other stuff you mentioned - thats well beyond me. I am strictly a visual observer. If "I Rant" sees thread he may offer some advice. I have seen him occasionally delve into the black arts of AP
 
Have any of those cool stars been shown to retain deuterium?
Surely not. Is deuterium not what the coolest stars and sub stellar objects consume?
Since hydrogen burning requires much higher temperatures and pressures than deuterium burning does, there are objects massive enough to burn deuterium but not massive enough to burn hydrogen. These objects are called brown dwarfs, and have masses between about 13 and 80 times the mass of Jupiter. Brown dwarfs may shine for a hundred million years at most before their deuterium supply is burned out.
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deuterium_burning
 
Unless you know of some way these stars could produce deuterium or never have had any I don't see any practical distinction between retain or contain.

"Retain" is ambiguous, and I think Craig B took the opposite of what you meant. Brown Dwarfs contain deuterium, and they consume deuterium - until they run out of deuterium, at which time they
a) will not have retained deuterium in their last stage
b) don't contain any deuterium
c) cease to be stars (if you define "star" as a heavenly body that fuses atoms by way of its mass)
The word "retain" could be construed, I think (but I am not a native speaker), as meaning "do not consume".

You meant to ask if deuterium has been observed to exist in these smallest stars, so that they plausibly fuse it as their fuel, right?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom