Where are the stars that we can see?

Is it off topic to ask whether it is a valid argument against the universe being infinite that the sky is not a complete white-out of starlight?
Partly valid argument.

The sky would be a complete white-out of starlight if the universe were infinitely large AND infinitely old AND homogenously dense at some (no matter how large) scale. The fact that the sky is NOT filled with blazing sunlight only proves that at least one of the above conditions is false. It does not prove they are all false. (Although I am quite sure they are.)
 
That claim is mostly true for stars with visual magnitudes < +2.5 -- List of brightest starsWP

The farthest of those stars is Deneb, at 2600 lyr / 800 pc. The median is at about 150 lyr or 50 pc.

Getting down to Mvis < +5, the human visibility limit, means going out in distance by a factor of 3.

I think I have the Hipparcos catalog on hand, so I may be able to get better numbers with it.
 
Partly valid argument.

The sky would be a complete white-out of starlight if the universe were infinitely large AND infinitely old AND homogenously dense at some (no matter how large) scale. The fact that the sky is NOT filled with blazing sunlight only proves that at least one of the above conditions is false. It does not prove they are all false. (Although I am quite sure they are.)

As long as the universe is expanding, all of those could be true without the night sky lighting up.
 
As long as the universe is expanding, all of those could be true without the night sky lighting up.


Not possible because of the "infinitely old" part. Unless you think it is possible for it to expand faster than the speed of light. Then sure. :D
 
With respect to the highlighted star, I'm guessing that it's not visible to the naked eye in part due to the fact that it's part of a binary system. Were it a out on it's own at that distance, perhaps it would be visible?
But I'm just guessing...

Proxima is not part of a binary system. There are 3 stars in the system, Alpha Centauri A, Alpha Centauri B, and Proxima.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alpha_Centauri
 
Unless you think it is possible for it to expand faster than the speed of light.


As I understand it, unless something comes along to slow down the ever-increasing rate of expansion of the universe, space will eventually be expanding faster than the speed of light.
 
As I understand it, unless something comes along to slow down the ever-increasing rate of expansion of the universe, space will eventually be expanding faster than the speed of light.
Is it not in a sense doing so, in that there is a speed of recession proportional to distance and the limit to how far out we can see is set by the distance at which this speed of recession is equal to or greater than the SOL?

The volume of space inside this limit is the "Observable Universe".
 
Last edited:
Yes, I believe that not one of the commonest type of stars is visible to the naked eye. All we see are the closest exceptionally bright stars. And the nearest big galaxy apart from our own, as a faint smudge.

But when stars go pop they can sometimes be seen at distances wildly in excess of 1,500 light years. How about this Gamma Ray Burst? http://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2008/21mar_nakedeye/
OK, it was visible for only a matter of seconds, but still ...

A few more than that actually.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magellanic_Clouds
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omega_Centauri
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triangulum_Galaxy

And the Magellanic Clouds are way more than faint smudges!
 
Last edited:
It's a valid argument against the universe being infinitely old. Much of the light simply has not reached us yet.

ETA: To be more precise, it is an argument against the universe being infinitely old and also homogeneous (filled with stars everywhere, similar to our neighbourhood) and infinitely large. Because our universe is not infinitely old, the fact the the night sky is dark does not help us to decided whether the universe is infinitely large.

In addition, from my understanding, our current model of the universe would predict that most of the light will never reach us and the sky will stay dark forever. Most objects that emit visible light (i.e. stars) will be pushed over the edge of the observable universe relatively soon, due to the expansion of space.

Ah, this question often comes up in dscussions about stars and their brightness.

This is known as "Olbers' Paradox"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olbers'_paradox

Thanks guys.
 
And the Magellanic Clouds are way more than faint smudges!
Yes, though I've never seen them. But I was treating them as mere adjuncts of our own galaxy which of course we can see too as the Milky Way. But yes, we can see a few more thins than I first listed.

Have you thought of this? The typical average random place in the universe is presumably a point in one of the huge voids remote from any cluster of galaxies. If you were transported to such a place, it would surely be impossible to see anything at all with the naked eye, except a flash associated with the occasional GRB event. Is that not so?
 
Not possible because of the "infinitely old" part. Unless you think it is possible for it to expand faster than the speed of light. Then sure. :D

Then I guess "sure" is correct. Everything beyond the cosmic horizon is receding faster than the speed of light. And the observable universe is, and always will be, finite.

In an infinitely old and large universe with this same expansion, you'd still have a finitely large observable universe bounded by a horizon beyond which you couldn't see (or to put it differently, from beyond which light could not arrive to you eye). Thus no need to worry about Olber's paradox.
 
Yes, though I've never seen them. But I was treating them as mere adjuncts of our own galaxy which of course we can see too as the Milky Way. But yes, we can see a few more thins than I first listed.

The Magellanic clouds do appear very detached from the Milky Way. It is a common question from people seeing them for the first time to ask why those clouds in the sky are not moving.

The large Magellanic cloud (At 160,000 light years) contains a nebula so bright it can be see with the naked eye and was originally cataloged as a star.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tarantula_Nebula

I have seen a single report from a very experienced observer high in the mountains of Chile of seeing a similar nebula in the previously mentioned galaxy M33 naked eye

The furthest thing ever seen naked eyed is a galaxy M81 at 12 million light years. A couple of very experienced observers under exceptional conditions have reported seeing this galaxy.
 

Damien there was an interesting paper a few years ago postulating that the two clouds were actually the same galaxy in the act of being torn up by the Milky Way. Seems a fair substantial bridge of material was found linking the two structures. If that turns out to be true, then back in the day the Magellanic could have been a fairly substantial galaxy in their own right
 
Not possible because of the "infinitely old" part. Unless you think it is possible for it to expand faster than the speed of light. Then sure. :D

You can't measure expansion with a speed. The universe doesn't expand at a speed. Speeds can only be assessed between points within the universe. The universe is expanding at some percentage rate per time. It's completely analogous to a balloon. An expanding balloon doesn't have a speed of expansion, and the speed you measure between any two points on the balloon while it's expanding will vary depending on how far apart the points are.

As someone else pointed out, we expect the edge of our visible universe isn't an edge. As far as we can tell it's all the same as far as we can see so we have no reason to expect there aren't galaxies beyond the farthest/fastest ones we can see.
 
You can't measure expansion with a speed. The universe doesn't expand at a speed. Speeds can only be assessed between points within the universe. The universe is expanding at some percentage rate per time. It's completely analogous to a balloon. An expanding balloon doesn't have a speed of expansion, and the speed you measure between any two points on the balloon while it's expanding will vary depending on how far apart the points are.
That is expressed as a particular speed per unit of distance apart. Isn't that the Hubble Constant which I believe is now determined to be about 72 km per second per megaparsec? A megaparsec being about 3.26 million light years. So that is where the "speed" comes in. https://www.ras.org.uk/publications/other-publications/2038-cosmology-hubble-constant
 
That is expressed as a particular speed per unit of distance apart. Isn't that the Hubble Constant which I believe is now determined to be about 72 km per second per megaparsec? A megaparsec being about 3.26 million light years. So that is where the "speed" comes in. https://www.ras.org.uk/publications/other-publications/2038-cosmology-hubble-constant
Can't tell if you're thinking that illustrates what I said or contradicts it.

Right, you've expressed the Hubble constant in a way that's convenient for determining the speed between any two points. You'll note however that the Hubble constant isn't a speed. Expressed the way you did it has distance in both the number and denominator which cancel out. The Hubble constant is a ratio per unit time. It has units of reciprocal time. It is not a speed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom