Where are the stars that we can see?

Except that a mass of that size at that distance would mess up the orbits of the planets, or at least I suppose so.
Well, your supposition is wrong. :)

It would however, mess up an awful lot of the orbits in Oort Coud, sending a shower of comets into inner solar system. Which would not be good for Earth.
 
Except that a mass of that size at that distance would mess up the orbits of the planets, or at least I suppose so.
The gravitational effect on Neptune (and Pluto) would only be about one sixty-fourth of one percent of that of the Sun. I don't think it would make much difference.

The orbital period of the red dwarf (and the Sun as they would orbit around their common centre of gravity) would be about three-and-a-half million years.
 
All the people who have ever lived are in that circle, including whatshisname.

Yes, for a certain definition of "are". ;)

In fact, since modern humans developed 250,000 years ago, earth has travelled less than 200 ly on its way around the galaxy. A mere fraction of the circle shown.
 
So, were are the stars that make up the so-called "Backbone of Night" that appear to be a linear concentration of stars as if you were looking toward the center of the galaxy?
 
The gravitational effect on Neptune (and Pluto) would only be about one sixty-fourth of one percent of that of the Sun. I don't think it would make much difference.
That's remarkably small, unless the cumulative effect over aeons of time might end up having some effect.
The orbital period of the red dwarf (and the Sun as they would orbit around their common centre of gravity) would be about three-and-a-half million years.
Again, remarkably small.
 
So, were are the stars that make up the so-called "Backbone of Night" that appear to be a linear concentration of stars as if you were looking toward the center of the galaxy?
Pretty much in that circle also. The nebula that cause dark patches in that band are under 1,000 LY away. (The "Coalsack" for example).
 
So, were are the stars that make up the so-called "Backbone of Night" that appear to be a linear concentration of stars as if you were looking toward the center of the galaxy?

Most of those are actually outside the circle. The stars that make up the "band" of the Milky Way in the sky are too far away to be discerned individually by the naked eye. That's why it appears as a diffuse (and not very bright) glow.
 
To further reinforce my point in Post #18

As I said Sirius is the brightest star in our night sky, and it is a very bright star in its own right. Its "absolute magnitude" (that is the measure of how bright it would be at the standard distance of 10 parsecs or 32.6 light years) is 1.42. By comparison, if our Sun was that far away it would be mag. 4.83, 23 times dimmer.

So, how far away would Sirius have to be in order for it to fall off the edge of the average person's naked eye visibility (about mag. 6.5)

The answer is 339 light years. On the astronomical scale of things, that is not very far for the brightest star we see to disappear entirely from view!
 
Strictly speaking, one can see a lot of the Milky Way with the naked eye. However, the stars are too far away to resolve individually as stars. It looks like a streak of milk across the sky, hence the name.
 
So, were are the stars that make up the so-called "Backbone of Night" that appear to be a linear concentration of stars as if you were looking toward the center of the galaxy?

Pretty much in that circle also. The nebula that cause dark patches in that band are under 1,000 LY away. (The "Coalsack" for example).

Most of those are actually outside the circle. The stars that make up the "band" of the Milky Way in the sky are too far away to be discerned individually by the naked eye. That's why it appears as a diffuse (and not very bright) glow.

Strictly speaking, one can see a lot of the Milky Way with the naked eye. However, the stars are too far away to resolve individually as stars. It looks like a streak of milk across the sky, hence the name.

What is a "lot of the Milky Way"? In our region of the galaxy, looking through the plane of the Galaxy, attenuation is about 2 magnitudes per kiloparsec. That says something rougly 1%-ish of the galaxy contributes to the light we call the Mily Way.

ETA: and we can split an Amiglion Major Cow burger there.
 
Last edited:
What is a "lot of the Milky Way"? In our region of the galaxy, looking through the plane of the Galaxy, attenuation is about 2 magnitudes per kiloparsec. That says something rougly 1%-ish of the galaxy contributes to the light we call the Mily Way.

Shouldn't that be Milliway's? (The Restaurant at the End of the Universe :D)
 
What is a "lot of the Milky Way"? In our region of the galaxy, looking through the plane of the Galaxy, attenuation is about 2 magnitudes per kiloparsec. That says something rougly 1%-ish of the galaxy contributes to the light we call the Mily Way.

Not to mention that the combination of stellar brightnesses also has to be taken into account. Magnitudes combine when stars are in close optical proximity, that's why globular clusers can appear as naked-eye objects. For example, Omega Centauri is visible to the naked eye (apparent mag. 3.6) even though it is about 17,000 light-years distant.

An eleventh magnitude star is well below the brightness required to be visible with the naked eye; its about 100 times too dim. But if you drop 1000 eleventh magnitude stars into a small globular cluster, then that cluster will be about mag. 3.5, easily visible.

In an earth-bound example, if a group of people lit two candles a half mile apart on the ridge line of a hill, then in perfect seeing conditions on a very dark, very calm night, you might be able to see them up to 30 miles away. If they lit 100,000 candles in the same half mile space, it would be unmissable.
 
Infinity

Is it off topic to ask whether it is a valid argument against the universe being infinite that the sky is not a complete white-out of starlight?

And what do the astronomers think of Kant's idea that the past cannot be infinite because it would take an infinite amount of time before anything happened?
 
Is it off topic to ask whether it is a valid argument against the universe being infinite that the sky is not a complete white-out of starlight?

It's a valid argument against the universe being infinitely old. Much of the light simply has not reached us yet.

ETA: To be more precise, it is an argument against the universe being infinitely old and also homogeneous (filled with stars everywhere, similar to our neighbourhood) and infinitely large. Because our universe is not infinitely old, the fact the the night sky is dark does not help us to decided whether the universe is infinitely large.

In addition, from my understanding, our current model of the universe would predict that most of the light will never reach us and the sky will stay dark forever. Most objects that emit visible light (i.e. stars) will be pushed over the edge of the observable universe relatively soon, due to the expansion of space.
 
Last edited:
Is it off topic to ask whether it is a valid argument against the universe being infinite that the sky is not a complete white-out of starlight?

And what do the astronomers think of Kant's idea that the past cannot be infinite because it would take an infinite amount of time before anything happened?

Ah, this question often comes up in dscussions about stars and their brightness.

This is known as "Olbers' Paradox"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olbers'_paradox
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom