Where am I ?

" If there is a thouht in our heads, it exists in the physical world "
In my opinion, that's a big mistake.
Do not get angry, I said " in my opinion " !!
As far as I know about philosophy, this should be the position of philosopher Hegel who stated that " what is rational [ i. e. exists in our heads ] is real [ i. e. exists in the physical world ]"
Hegel has been heavily criticized for this assumpt by other philosophers ( Nietzsche among others ) and this claim is not true in my opinion, as we can think about things that do not exist in the physical world ( a pink elephant, a green sky, a dragon, etc. )
As a coincidence, I am reading ( well, trying to read as the book is difficult ) the book of German philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer " World as will and idea " which is about the things we are discussing in this forum.
As far as I understood about Schopenhauer' s thought, he claimed that the world ( the " object " ) and the person ( the " subject ", close to what I called " self-consciousness ) exist one because of the other.
That is, if there was no subject ( no self-conscious entity ) the world would disappear !!
Also, if there was no world, there could be no self-conscious entity alone.
Moreover, as the subject ( the self-conscious entity, the " ego " of each of us or the " soul " ) is not a part of the object ( the outstanding world ) anyone of us can not find himself in the world.
According to S., time and space are not properties of the physical world, but means of the subject to get in touch with the outstanding world ( the object ); that is, time and space belong to us and not the the physical world.
This seems like an extreme ideas to me, but I am still in the first chapters of the book.

" I understand that identical twins are quite often intuitive and have been known to read each other's thoughts "
It seems to me that, proving this claim, you could win Randi's challenge.
 
Since I tend to assume that physical things are real things, this position, that the objective requires the subjective to exist, seems ludicrous and extremely egotistical to me. After all, the Universe has existed for billions of years prior to the appearance of any self-conscious entity; why would it suddenly vanish in the absense of any self-conscious entity?

This level of philosophy is so very grade-school in maturity. But it is quite clear that many philosophers are merely theists or humanicentrists who are desperately seeking a way to place Man back at the center of the universe. It must be terrifying for these people to contemplate a universe in which Man is an insigificant speck, a momentary accident in the back corner of the tiniest part of a vast universe.

When one of these philosophies starts on the premise that Man only appeared recently in a vast and ancient universe of wonders, then I'll sit up and take notice. Until then, they may join lifegazer in the corner.
 
" Since I tend to assume that physical things are real things, this position, that the objective requires the subjective to exist, seems ludicrous and extremely egotistical to me. After all, the Universe has existed for billions of years prior to the appearance of any self-conscious entity; why would it suddenly vanish in the absense of any self-conscious entity? "
Well, AFAIK, Schpenhauer said that, when you think at an object, for example, a red carpet, you see it as " red " and as extended in space.
But, according to Schopenhauer, the colour red, and the fact that you see in the space and at a precise time, are not properties of the " red carpet ", but means by which you see the object.
Time, space and multeplicity are not properties of the " object-in-itself ", but means by which you see it, that is, means by which the subject can see the world.

So, since you can not even imagine a world if not in space and in time, it comes that such a world could not exist, that is, could not exist without a " subject ".

I am not convinced by Schopenhauer' s philosophy, we will see .. I am still reading his book.

" But it is quite clear that many philosophers are merely theists or humanicentrists who are desperately seeking a way to place Man back at the center of the universe "
Well, they do not say that the man is at the center of the Universe in a physical sense, but in the sense that many of the properties that we usually think are property of the objects ( such as colour, being cold or hot, being pleasurable or not, .. ) may not be properties of the object but projections of our mind on those objects.
For example, water may be hot or cold, only in relation to a subject, the sun is very hot, because it is hot compared with the temperature of my skin, the carpet is red because I see it as red, science just tells me that some of the light' s wavelenghts are not reflected by the carpet surface and that, because of this, I see the carpet as red.
But the fact that, because of this phenomenon ( some of the light' s wavelenghts are not reflected by the carpet surface ) I see the carpet as red, this is something physic can not explain, it is part of the subject, that is, a mean by which the subject sees the carpet
 
If your brain is in a lab, but your body and senses are in a train watching through the window (an evil scientist is doing some weird experiment with you as the subject)...

Where are you? in the lab? or in the train? :D
 
Bodhi Dharma Zen said:
If your brain is in a lab, but your body and senses are in a train watching through the window (an evil scientist is doing some weird experiment with you as the subject)...

Where are you? in the lab? or in the train? :D

If you have no way to tell the difference then it doesn't matter.
 
[QUOTE" If there is a thouht in our heads, it exists in the physical world "
In my opinion, that's a big mistake.
Do not get angry, I said " in my opinion " !!
As far as I know about philosophy, this should be the position of philosopher Hegel who stated that " what is rational [ i. e. exists in our heads ] is real [ i. e. exists in the physical world ]"
Hegel has been heavily criticized for this assumpt by other philosophers ( Nietzsche among others ) and this claim is not true in my opinion, as we can think about things that do not exist in the physical world ( a pink elephant, a green sky, a dragon, etc. )
[/QUOTE]
Don't worry, I know what you mean.

The point I was making is that the act of thinking is physical. the electro/chemical activity involved in thought is physical. what the thought is of may not exists (i.e. pink elephants and so forth), but the thought itself does physicaly exist via the neural activity.
 
Uruk

Uruk,
remember that you are claiming things you have no evidence for.
Please, do not tell me to prove this, I have already given enough evidence ( I think ) in the past posts of this thread.

As you said in a post " So far we have no clear definition of what is selfconciousness is ", so it is hard to assume that " act of thinking is physical " if you can not even define it.
At least, if you mean act of thinking = self consciousness
 
As you said in a post " So far we have no clear definition of what is selfconciousness is ", so it is hard to assume that " act of thinking is physical " if you can not even define it.
What is involved when you think? Do you think with words, images and sensations? The senses are involved with thinking. Sight, sound, touch, smell. These are all things which involve a physical processes. Eyes, ears, nose, skin. physical things of which we interact with the world. those things generate electro/chemical signals which are directed to the brain. the brain recieves these signals. From those signals, we develop our mental image of the world.
Now think about this. Could we have a thought without sensory input? If we never had hearing, touch or sight, how could we learn or develop a language from which to have an internal dialogue or have symbols or images to use for thought. Or be able to feel anything to interact with something?
How can we have thought without those things?

Using PET scans, scientists have shown that when we are thinking or using our mind there is physical activity in the brain. every emotional state has a neurotransmitter associated with it.

This does not explain what self-conciousness is but the act of thinking is a physical process. It can be detected and measured. Thought does have a physical side to it.
 
Let's recap

Uruk, yes I have been not very precise. Thought has a physical side, even if it is not be proved ( and, in my opinion is not ) that is only physical

Let me recap the conclusions which we all ( hopefully ) agree on:

1) Self-consciousness ( = " that fact that I know I am here " ) exists, at least I have it and I assume other humans ( if not other animals ) have it as well
2) Self-consciousness can not be defined using scientific terms, maybe you can not give a clear definition of self-consciousness at all, it can not be measured, therefore it is out of the area of scientific discussion, it is not a subject of science because science deals only with measurable things while self-consciousness is not. You can also say that self-consciousness does not belong to the physical world ( if you mean as " physical world " the world that can be touched and measured, that is, the world that science deals with )
3) The fact that it is diffucult to talk about self-consciousness ( and impossible to talk about it in scientific terms ), and that self-consciousness is not part of the physical world do not mean that self-consciousness does not exist ( see point 1 )
4) Self- consciouness is not generated from neurons interaction, electric and biological interactions in our brain, the whole brain interacting, etc. I hope I showed it clearly in my last posts; the proof of this is that, while electric charges, molecules, biologic and electric interaction are part of the physical world ( they can be measured ), self-consciousness is not part of the physical world ( see also point 2 )
5) Thoughts are partly generated by our brain, however, I would rather doubt that you see the thoughts as " products " of our brain only. How toughts relate to self-consciousness is difficult to understand ( impossible ? ) since we do not have a clear understanding of self-consciousness in first place
 
Dragonrock said:
If you have no way to tell the difference then it doesn't matter.

But of course it matters. It is an answer of capital importance!

You are where the experience happens, and this is not the brain, but the senses. Now, of course Im answering from the self's point of view. Still, for a external observer (perhaps the evil scientist) the question remains, where is the subject? In the lab where his brain is? or in the train?
 
Re: Let's recap

Matteo Martini said:
Uruk, yes I have been not very precise. Thought has a physical side, even if it is not be proved ( and, in my opinion is not ) that is only physical

Let me recap the conclusions which we all ( hopefully ) agree on:

1) Self-consciousness ( = " that fact that I know I am here " ) exists, at least I have it and I assume other humans ( if not other animals ) have it as well
2) Self-consciousness can not be defined using scientific terms, maybe you can not give a clear definition of self-consciousness at all, it can not be measured, therefore it is out of the area of scientific discussion, it is not a subject of science because science deals only with measurable things while self-consciousness is not. You can also say that self-consciousness does not belong to the physical world ( if you mean as " physical world " the world that can be touched and measured, that is, the world that science deals with )

Why it "can not be defined using scientific terms"? The links presented by many people here -and other threads as well- on neurology and similar disciplines do have their definitions. Self-consiousness IS an area of scientitic study. Several branches of neurology deal with it, not to mention psichiatry.

We (well, at least those with the propper equipments) can mesure the patterns of electrical activities related to the act of tought. It can be measured, therefore it belongs to the physical world. It belongs to the worlds science deals with.

Matteo Martini said:
3) The fact that it is diffucult to talk about self-consciousness ( and impossible to talk about it in scientific terms ), and that self-consciousness is not part of the physical world do not mean that self-consciousness does not exist ( see point 1 )

It IS part od the physical world. See above.

Matteo Martini said:
4) Self- consciouness is not generated from neurons interaction, electric and biological interactions in our brain, the whole brain interacting, etc. I hope I showed it clearly in my last posts; the proof of this is that, while electric charges, molecules, biologic and electric interaction are part of the physical world ( they can be measured ), self-consciousness is not part of the physical world ( see also point 2 )

No you did not. There´s not a single piece of solid evidence that suggests that self-consiousness is not generated by our body.

Matteo Martini said:
5) Thoughts are partly generated by our brain, however, I would rather doubt that you see the thoughts as " products " of our brain only. How toughts relate to self-consciousness is difficult to understand ( impossible ? ) since we do not have a clear understanding of self-consciousness in first place

Can you prove that toughts are only partly generated by our brain?
No.

Can you prove that self-consiousness is created by toughts and constantly updated impulses transmitted by our nerves indicating that our organs are there and with a given status?
No.

The fact that something is not well understood can not can be taken as evidence of anything.
 
Correa Neto,
I disagree.

You say that self-consciousness ( I will use the acronym SC from now on ) is an area of scientific study.

I will try to prove you that it is not:

1) Science deals with measurable things, right ? Power, energy, acceleration, gravitation forces, quantity of red cells in your blood, temperature of your body etc. are all measurable things, if you do not have a measurable quantity you can not build a law over it, you can not write a paper, you can not do a proper experiment. Now how do you measure SC ? Somebody said in this thread that SC grows up in the evolution scale from 0 ( rock or unanimated odject ) to 100 ( man ), with intermediate values of counsiousness or SC of trees, insetcs and mammals. So, what is the degree of SC of a pig ? How do you measure it ?

2) But the biggest problem is that you do not even know if other beings are SC or not. You can only be sure for yourself. Assuming that other people are SC is a kind of act-of-faith. There is a phylosophical school which I think is called " solipsism " that teaches that each one is the only SC entity of the Universe and others are just projection of his mind. I agree that this philosophy is suitable for a mad man, but can not be disproved. Did you read about the Sony new robot called ASIMO ? He can walk, he can move and, in future versions, he will be able to listen, talk and see ( maybe already now, I do not remember ). Now, show me " scientifically " why this robot may not be SC while a two-year-old child is ?
Because a child cries ? We can build a robot that cries.
Because a child thinks ? We can already build a program which simulate the thinking of a child.
Yes, it is a simulation, but how scientifically can you state that the child " really " thinks while the robot only looks like thinking ?
 
Bodhi Dharma Zen said:
But of course it matters. It is an answer of capital importance!

You are where the experience happens, and this is not the brain, but the senses. Now, of course Im answering from the self's point of view. Still, for a external observer (perhaps the evil scientist) the question remains, where is the subject? In the lab where his brain is? or in the train?

As far as the individual is concerned, they are wherever their senses tell them they are. If their brain is being fed false information so that it appears that they are on a train, then as far as they are concerned, they ARE on a train. If the observer sees them lying in a lab with wires feding them sensory information then the observer knows what is really happening and is aware that the subject is in the lab. The subject is just mistaken in his belief that he is on a train. In this case, the subject's opinion about his location has no affect on where he actually is.
 
You missed the whole point. I clearly stated that the subject's brain is in a lab, while HIS BODY is in another place. Not quite what you are answering. ;)

Let me rephrase it: The scientist has made a radio connection between the body and the brain, so they are in different places. Where is the subject?? The "I"??
 
Bodhi Dharma Zen said:
You missed the whole point. I clearly stated that the subject's brain is in a lab, while HIS BODY is in another place. Not quite what you are answering. ;)

Let me rephrase it: The scientist has made a radio connection between the body and the brain, so they are in different places. Where is the subject?? The "I"??

Okay, sorry, I misread it. The answer is:

His brain is in the lab and his body is in the train. The "self" is a part of the function of the entire body. The self is simply spread around but is being maintained by a radio transmitter. There is not an extreme answer like "The 'self' is maintained in the part of the brain called the 'selfabelum'. The "self" is a function of the entire brain and, to a lesser extent, the body also.
 
Matteo Martini said:
Correa Neto,
I disagree.

You say that self-consciousness ( I will use the acronym SC from now on ) is an area of scientific study.

I will try to prove you that it is not:

1) Science deals with measurable things, right ? Power, energy, acceleration, gravitation forces, quantity of red cells in your blood, temperature of your body etc. are all measurable things, if you do not have a measurable quantity you can not build a law over it, you can not write a paper, you can not do a proper experiment. Now how do you measure SC ? Somebody said in this thread that SC grows up in the evolution scale from 0 ( rock or unanimated odject ) to 100 ( man ), with intermediate values of counsiousness or SC of trees, insetcs and mammals. So, what is the degree of SC of a pig ? How do you measure it ?

Do you agree that self-consiousness can be defined as a product of toughts and perceptions of our own body´s status created by feedback from our nerve system? Perhaps something as simple as "I think that I exist"?

Now, how to measure self-consiousness? Check the links on neurology kindly provided by the persons in this and other threads. Measuring brain activity and performing tests on the subject on several status of consience would be a way. And if you agree with the question I started this post with, you´ll see that it can be measured. Its not up to me or you (unless you are a neurologist os a professional involverd in such study) to create a scale. The scale example posted, if I understood correctly, was an analogy, a suggestion. Its purpose was to show that it can be measured.

Matteo Martini said:
2) But the biggest problem is that you do not even know if other beings are SC or not. You can only be sure for yourself. Assuming that other people are SC is a kind of act-of-faith. There is a phylosophical school which I think is called " solipsism " that teaches that each one is the only SC entity of the Universe and others are just projection of his mind. I agree that this philosophy is suitable for a mad man, but can not be disproved.


The solipsism line also will not provide any help. Actually solipsism is one of the -if not the most- useless philosophies avaliable. If its true, than discussing anything about the world is utterly futile.

Matteo Martini said:
Did you read about the Sony new robot called ASIMO ? He can walk, he can move and, in future versions, he will be able to listen, talk and see ( maybe already now, I do not remember ). Now, show me " scientifically " why this robot may not be SC while a two-year-old child is ?
Because a child cries ? We can build a robot that cries.
Because a child thinks ? We can already build a program which simulate the thinking of a child.
Yes, it is a simulation, but how scientifically can you state that the child " really " thinks while the robot only looks like thinking ?

Nothing that you wrote proves anything. Our robots, regardless of being able to walk, crawl, swim, etc. are dumber than an insect when it comes to their autonomy and the variety of functions they can perform. They can´t proccess dat as efficienty (or "think", if you preffer) as an insect can. So, "scientifically speaking", the robot would have a lesser dregree of self-consiousness than a fly.

One can create a system that aknoweledges the status of its parts (there are quite a few right now, some of them working in our computers), another system that moves around, another one that actively seeks for energy supplies to "feed", other that tries to replicate themselves (if you ever read about Von Neumann automats, then you know where it´ll end), systems that avoid being damaged, etc.

Now integrate all these systems in a single piece of hardware. The piece of hardware, according to some definitions, would be now "alive". Would such a magnificient piece of hardware be self-consicent? On a certain level, yes. The actual level will depend on how adaptable it is to learn solve new problems. It may be as self-conscient as an amoeba, a bug, or as a human being.

And will it have anything other than its own hardware creating its self-conscience? No. Despite the fact that it may eventually think that it is so special that it must be made of something else than mere materialistic hardware parts...
 
Well, Matteo Martini, I guess I have to agree to disagree with you. I do believe that, in time, we will eventually discover a physical cause and source of SC. The reason we haven't found a discription for SC could due to species-centrisim or predjudice or perhaps we are not asking the right questions. The SC has physical effects and inhabits a physical world. If it is a part of this world, it is most likely physical as well.

But this is only my opinion.

Let me rephrase it: The scientist has made a radio connection between the body and the brain, so they are in different places. Where is the subject?? The "I"??
The "I" would reside with the brain. If you were able to transplant your brain in a another person's body would you still be you? or would you be that other person? would you experiance what that person experiances as that person? or would you still be having your own experiances but in the other person's body?

The evidence shows (so far) that the "I" travels with the brain.
 
I´m not sure if you could say the brain transplant would merely result in a transfer of the self. Our behavior is influentiated by hormones and other chemicals produced by our body. Also, different organs would result in different sensory feedbacks to the brain.

My guess is that you would get a modified self, that would look like the original, but it would definitly not be the same original self. No big deal here, since naturally the self changes as the body ages.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom