Matteo Martini
Banned
- Joined
- Dec 6, 2004
- Messages
- 4,561
" If there is a thouht in our heads, it exists in the physical world "
In my opinion, that's a big mistake.
Do not get angry, I said " in my opinion " !!
As far as I know about philosophy, this should be the position of philosopher Hegel who stated that " what is rational [ i. e. exists in our heads ] is real [ i. e. exists in the physical world ]"
Hegel has been heavily criticized for this assumpt by other philosophers ( Nietzsche among others ) and this claim is not true in my opinion, as we can think about things that do not exist in the physical world ( a pink elephant, a green sky, a dragon, etc. )
As a coincidence, I am reading ( well, trying to read as the book is difficult ) the book of German philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer " World as will and idea " which is about the things we are discussing in this forum.
As far as I understood about Schopenhauer' s thought, he claimed that the world ( the " object " ) and the person ( the " subject ", close to what I called " self-consciousness ) exist one because of the other.
That is, if there was no subject ( no self-conscious entity ) the world would disappear !!
Also, if there was no world, there could be no self-conscious entity alone.
Moreover, as the subject ( the self-conscious entity, the " ego " of each of us or the " soul " ) is not a part of the object ( the outstanding world ) anyone of us can not find himself in the world.
According to S., time and space are not properties of the physical world, but means of the subject to get in touch with the outstanding world ( the object ); that is, time and space belong to us and not the the physical world.
This seems like an extreme ideas to me, but I am still in the first chapters of the book.
" I understand that identical twins are quite often intuitive and have been known to read each other's thoughts "
It seems to me that, proving this claim, you could win Randi's challenge.
In my opinion, that's a big mistake.
Do not get angry, I said " in my opinion " !!
As far as I know about philosophy, this should be the position of philosopher Hegel who stated that " what is rational [ i. e. exists in our heads ] is real [ i. e. exists in the physical world ]"
Hegel has been heavily criticized for this assumpt by other philosophers ( Nietzsche among others ) and this claim is not true in my opinion, as we can think about things that do not exist in the physical world ( a pink elephant, a green sky, a dragon, etc. )
As a coincidence, I am reading ( well, trying to read as the book is difficult ) the book of German philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer " World as will and idea " which is about the things we are discussing in this forum.
As far as I understood about Schopenhauer' s thought, he claimed that the world ( the " object " ) and the person ( the " subject ", close to what I called " self-consciousness ) exist one because of the other.
That is, if there was no subject ( no self-conscious entity ) the world would disappear !!
Also, if there was no world, there could be no self-conscious entity alone.
Moreover, as the subject ( the self-conscious entity, the " ego " of each of us or the " soul " ) is not a part of the object ( the outstanding world ) anyone of us can not find himself in the world.
According to S., time and space are not properties of the physical world, but means of the subject to get in touch with the outstanding world ( the object ); that is, time and space belong to us and not the the physical world.
This seems like an extreme ideas to me, but I am still in the first chapters of the book.
" I understand that identical twins are quite often intuitive and have been known to read each other's thoughts "
It seems to me that, proving this claim, you could win Randi's challenge.