Where am I ?

This very notion makes the "I" independent of its "source". So, in a way, this "I" is not the brain. Again, from HIS point of view.
Or a possibility could be that this "I" is an illusion. The "I" could be a derived illusion from all the different systems of the brain. Sort of like an icon in which all the various parts of the brain uses to represent the whole of the system in it's neural "algorithyms" or processing.

A car analogy was brought up earlier: "car" is an icon representing an assembly of parts which all work together to posses a particular purpose or quality. Each individual part is not a "car", but together they become the "car". You can damage or take away some parts of the car and it will still function and be a "car". But at what point of damage or dissassembly would the assembly of parts cease to become a "car"? Does it become a matter of opinion? Bias? Or is there a defined line?

I believe the "I" is somewhat like that. The "I" is an illusion or icon. Something that we call this total, gradient, system. What "it" is becomes a matter of opinion possibly based on predjudice and species-centricisim.
But what ever SC turns out to be, it cannot be denied that the brain is crucial to what "it" is.
 
Uruk,
this is a very interesting post.

Let me reply:

1) " I " is not an illusion. If it was an illusion, I would not feel pain, hate, sorrow, .. In other words " I " would not be conscious. But " I " am conscious and, about this, I am 100% sure. It is true that some Buddhists say that " I " is an illusion ( I met a Zen monk who said that - Bodhi Dharma Zen required here .. ), but I think he meant that the " I " and the Universe exist but are not separated one from the other.
This opinion of mine is confirmed by the fact that even Freud wrote about an " oceanic feeling " as a " of boundlessness and oneness felt between the ego and the outside world ".
First link I found on Google: http://www.gradesaver.com/ClassicNotes/Titles/civilization/summ1.html
Moreover, if " I " is an illusion, the illusion exist and where does it come from ??

2) I always claimed that the car - self analogy does not work !!
Look at the second post here : http://www.internationalskeptics.co...hp?s=&threadid=50001&perpage=40&pagenumber=2, where I said " I just pointed out that the analogy does not work because cars are not self-conscious while men are "

3) The "I" is an illusion or icon.
Absolutely disagree.
I remember to have read a Zen story ( am I getting a little bit boring with all this Buddhism ? ) where a monk said to his teacher:
" The I does not exist, the universe does not exist, nothing really exist "
Hearing that, his teacher slapped his face.
The monk was angry:
" You slaped my face, why did you do that ? "
At which the teacher replied:
" If you do not exist, where does this rage come from ? "
 
Matteo,

Buddhism is VERY appropriate. ;)

The "I" is an illusion in the same sense the "world" is an illusion. This is to say that both come to the existence at the same time, and both can be diluted at the same time. It exactly as you say, they cant be separated.

Now, it is possible to deny the very existence of this "I", but it is impossible to deny consciousness. Those who "deny it" are reading this words, and no matter how much they try to say they are not, they are reading them from "THERE".

I loved the story you quoted. :D All this thing about the existence of the "I" lead, necesarily, to contradictions. But it is important to say that those contradictions are JUST at an intelectual level. The only way to reach some kind of knowledge is "to be there". Its like trying to discuss light and sighting with a blind person. You may believe you are reaching some agreements, but all you are doing is discussing ideas, not reaching anything.
 
Maybe the problem is that mankind tries to neatly wrap everything within language. Maybe some things are better left without a neat lingual wrapping/rapping. Maybe "I" should just be I, screw finding meanings and reasons. After all, isn't it true that the harder you look for "I" the less you find?
 
This is to say that both come to the existence at the same time, and both can be diluted at the same time. It exactly as you say, they cant be separated
I just find a problem in this, if, as Schopenhauer ( and maybe Buddha ) said, world ( object ) and self ( subject ) come to existence together and fade together, how is that, when a person dies, the world does not disappear ?
Maybe because the subject does not disappear, but just reincarnate ?
Or maybe I have not understood Schopenhauer and Buddhism.
Moreover, reincarnation is a kind of act-of-faith, like existence of the soul ..

You may believe you are reaching some agreements, but all you are doing is discussing ideas, not reaching anything
Yes, also that Zen monk I met told me that you can " see " the oneness between you can the Universe when you lose all your attachments with the world.
And he said that is pretty difficult to achieve.
Attachment is pain, was not it Buddha who said that ?

Maybe the problem is that mankind tries to neatly wrap everything within language. Maybe some things are better left without a neat lingual wrapping/rapping
That' s what Wittengstein said, language is a trap.
There are not two chairs, there are not two " anything ", one object is just another thing.
Moreover, there are no even " objects ", a car does not exist, it is wheel+lights+engine+transimssion tree+ ..
But I did not understand Wittengstein's Tractatus well, too difficult !!

Now, I would like to hear Correa Neto and Uruk.
They are the Neopositivists, while me and Bodhi Dharma are the Idealists.
Zaayrdragon as free thinker ?
 
I prefer "Innocent Bystander."
I prefer "Ignorant Bystander" for myself.:p

1) " I " is not an illusion. If it was an illusion, I would not feel pain, hate, sorrow, .. In other words " I " would not be conscious. But " I " am conscious and, about this, I am 100% sure. It is true that some Buddhists say that " I " is an illusion ( I met a Zen monk who said that - Bodhi Dharma Zen required here .. ), but I think he meant that the " I " and the Universe exist but are not separated one from the other.

The "I" would not feel anything without the parts of the brain functioning together. Pain, hate, sorrow all have a neuro-transmitter and an area of the brain associated with it. Damage to certain areas of the brain can remove the "I"'s capability to feel these emotions and sensations. The consciousness could just be another "sensation" or "emotion" that we have not yet isolated a corresponding neuro-transmitter.
Or perhaps, it is a governing or regulating nerual-net that performs the same function that the brain stem does for the body. The brain stem directs the various parts of the body functions and brings them under control of the higher brain.
The higher brain is composed of many different parts and probably needs a similar regulating or governing system.
The "I" has many parts also. Id, ego, sub-concious, and soforth (if you still buy into Freud and Jung, Et al.) All these parts create the whole or the "I". But all are derived from the brain.
Moreover, if " I " is an illusion, the illusion exist and where does it come from ??
The illusion is real in that the illusion has a physicality in what is having the illusion or rather what is facilitating the illusion.
The "I" is real in that it is a physical object that is having the illusion. But the "I" is a derived entity from the many parts that are functioning in union. The "I" feels real because it is the illusion that is considering it's own existance. The illusion is real to the illusion.

I think my head hurts.

I always claimed that the car - self analogy does not work !!
Look at the second post here : http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread....0&pagenumber=2, where I said " I just pointed out that the analogy does not work because cars are not self-conscious while men are "
The fact that a car is not self-concious is irrelevent to the analogy. I am using the concept of a "car" to represent the self-conciousness. That is the purpose of an anology to relate one thing to another in the hopes of understanding.

The conciouseness is similar to a car in that the individual parts of a car, taken alone or in partial assemblies, do not make a "car".
Just as the individual parts of what makes self conciousness, like the ability to feel pain, hunger, sorrow,love (emotions) or the ability to know a clear path from and obstructed path (judgement), do not make up the "I". It is the whole of the system.

The "I" is an illusion or icon.
Absolutely disagree.
I remember to have read a Zen story ( am I getting a little bit boring with all this Buddhism ? ) where a monk said to his teacher:
" The I does not exist, the universe does not exist, nothing really exist "
Hearing that, his teacher slapped his face.
The monk was angry:
" You slaped my face, why did you do that ? "
At which the teacher replied:
" If you do not exist, where does this rage come from ? "

Rage is an emotion and has a physicality in the chemicals and neural systems that are involved.

The "I" exists within the physicality of the system from which it is derived.

I believe the world that is described by our senses is real for two reasons. First, if it is not real it still behaves exactly as if it is "real" so there is no difference. Second, I have no way of knowing one way or the other if it is real or not, so I simply choose to believe.
I guess that separates me from idealists or immaterialists and soforth.
 
After all, isn't it true that the harder you look for "I" the less you find?
It could be a predjudice or species-centricism that blind us to the defintion when we go looking for it. Just like when you start looking really hard at anything. Let's take tree for example, you look at the whole and see something you call a tree. You start breaking it down to it's constituent parts and it starts looking less like a tree. Untill you get to it's fundamental building blocks; subatomic particles. You then would look at the particles and say "how can atoms be a tree?" (sound familiar?)

We begin to look at the constituent parts of the self and it starts to look less like a self. We see these same building blocks in other creatures and say "no that can't be it because we're different". Or we look at the different parts and say "how can these parts be self-conciousness?"
It's as if we have put self-conciouseness on a pedestal that we never try to reach. Everytime we arrive at a defintion we move it just little bit higher........ So we wouln't be dissapointed.
 
Matteo Martini said:
...snip...

I hope you now agree that steo number one can not be performed in any way we could design a test.
Therefore, we will never be albe to design a test that proves that a person is conscious or not.
Never, not today nor tomorrow.

So, there is no way we can scientifically relate one person's consciousness to any part of the brain.

I hope I made my points clear now, I do not know if you agree with me, but at least I hope I have expalined my points effectively.

No, I don´t agree. Now, I admit that my knoweledge in neurology is limited, so anyone reading these posts please feel free to point my mistakes and errors.

To feel pain requires a certain ammount -better write degree- of counsioussnes, to move the affected area from the pain source another, to remember the pain another, and to avoid a new similar unpleasant sensation yet another. Too heavilly asleep or sedated and no pain will be felt.

What´s the difference? The ammount of data processing required. The more counscient the individual is, the more able he/she/it will be able to go to the next level of response.

Whats the importance of it? Note that flys, dogs and humans will try to avoid the pain. They will (i) recognize that something hurts, (ii) move away from the pain sorce. Now, humans and dogs may remember that a certain thing causes pain and later try to avoid it. Humans may be able to recognize it faster and more eficient than dogs. But a sedated human wil not be able to do anything. And one can create an advanced machine that, besides searching for food and reproducts itself (a Von Neuman automat) reacts to damage in similar ways to protect itself. Why can´t this be described as "pain"?

What are my points?
Flys, dogs and humans (as well as the advanced machine) are counsient beings (whithin their limiattions). The level of interaction they have with their surroundings depend on how sophisticated their "data processing devices" are and on their operational status (damages, influence of chemicals, state of counsiousness, etc.).

I hope you agree.

Now the second point - consider the following two different major ways of sedating- (i) by turning the nerves of a given area insensitive to pain (think of a root channel treatment) and (ii) to turning the whole individual uncousnsious (say, general anesthesy). On the first case, no feedback is transmitted to the brain from the affected area. And the person is counsient of its surroundings, who he/she is, etc. A particular area of his/her body is not aknoweledge by his/her brain by regular nerve system feedback. Yet it´s still there but the person may have no counsicence of it unless he/she does something else like say, touching it.

On the second, however, the area may be sending electrochemical signals to the brain, that just does not process them. And the person is not counsient of its surroundings, who he/she is, etc. Its like a dreamless sleep. And at this stage, I think you should agree that there is no counsicence or self-counsience at all. Note that in dreamless sleeps one can be awaken by external stimulae.

Another possibility is to deny activity of the particular brain area responsible for processing the "pain" somehow, by sedating or even removing it. For all practical reasons, it would have the same effects as sedating the area that is sending impulses that mean "something wrong down here" and will be interpretated as pain. Got the differences now and where your mistakes regarding the experiments are?

Do you agree?

And my points regarding this are? Counsioussnes levels depends on the status of your brain and body (damages, influence of chemicals, state of counsiousness, etc.) and all these can be monitored by the propper equipment. So, counsioussness -and self-counsioussness levels- can be gauged.

Another disagreement of mine-

You are talking about self counsioussness or the self as something immutable, an ultimate referential. It is not, they are not. The very act of "thinking that I exist and am composed by..." brings with itself the implication of mutability. "I think that I exist and am composed by..." is a tought. Its data processing. Based on inputs gathered by your body from its surroundings, on its operational status and the data stored in your brain. All these variables changes, therefore the "I think that I exist and am composed by..." changes.

Also, your "feeling" of self-cousiousness is not the same when you are on a REM-state sleep, when you are drunk or when you are perfectly sobber. And when you are in a dreamless sleep state or in a deep coma, it is nothing. There is no self-counsience in this case. And all these states produce different and repeatable results in the propper measuring equipments.

So, we can scientifically relate one person's consciousness level to brain activity. Or you are forgeting all the work that has been done so far in these research fields?

Besides, note that this also causes the self to be mutable. You are not the same as you were when you were 2 years old, and will not be the same in 10 years. Actually, we had a nice discussion on the continuity of the self some time ago. Personally, I think that we have just an illusion of continuity of the self (incidentally, this brings surficial similaties with Buddhism). At comatose states and when sleeping without dreams, the self disappears, and is rebuilt as we regain counsicousness. Not unlike a computer being turned on.

And by the way, the difference between a fly, a plant, a dog and a Von Neuman automat is just in terms of sophistication. The more sophisticated the data processing equipment is, the more efficient and "self-counsiouss" it will be. This should make clear my points regarding the issue.

Matteo Martini said:
...snip...
P.S.
Happy 2005 !!

Thanks, for you too.

Oh, and regarding Schopenhauer, Wittengstein et alii, remember that what matters is if you agree or not with what they say and on which basis. Never mind the importance of the guy. Just focus on the issue if you agree or not with the ideas, and why you stand in this position. Specially the last part. I hate when someone uses "But [add philosopher/scientist/thinker name here] said that ..." as an argument, and usually to intimidate. The really important things are the basis (say, data) over which the idea/theory/philosophy/speculation was built and how logic was the process of its development. That´s what you have to do some unbiased critical thinking over before accepting or not the proposal. And be ready to defend if you decided to stand by it.

I, for myself, don´t feel confortable when labelled as "neopositivist", "nihilist", "[add labell here]". Why? Because that would mean that I accept most if not all the prerrogatives of that current. "Materialist" is as far as I would go on a labell, since it still allows a lot of maneauvering space. Still, not as much as I would like, since I consider myself an agnostic with strong atheistic inclination, and many would say that a materialist can not be agnostic, he/she must be an atheist...
 
Oh, and regarding Schopenhauer, Wittengstein et alii, remember that what matters is if you agree or not with what they say and on which basis. Never mind the importance of the guy. Just focus on the issue if you agree or not with the ideas, and why you stand in this position. Specially the last part. I hate when someone uses "But [add philosopher/scientist/thinker name here] said that ..." as an argument, and usually to intimidate. The really important things are the basis (say, data) over which the idea/theory/philosophy/speculation was built and how logic was the process of its development. That´s what you have to do some unbiased critical thinking over before accepting or not the proposal. And be ready to defend if you decided to stand by it.
Neto, please do not take me wrong. I do not think I can intimidate anybody and I do not want to show that I am a person of culture. I quote all those guys just to show that this interesting discussion we are doing has probably already been done before. And what I am saying here is my opinion ( current opinion )

I, for myself, don´t feel confortable when labelled as "neopositivist", "nihilist", "[add labell here]". Why? Because that would mean that I accept most if not all the prerrogatives of that current. "Materialist" is as far as I would go on a labell, since it still allows a lot of maneauvering space
That labeling was too add a little bit of humour here. Let' call everybody " free thinker ".

OK, now back to the point.
I would like to draw your attention to the main point of my last long post which probably went overlooked or I did not explain so well.

Let' s look at this experiment.
Let' s take a person, take his/her hand and put it on fire.
What does it happen ?
Thia preson cries out loud " ouch ! ", take away his/her hand very quickly from the fire, tears on his/her face, looks at his/her little bit burned hand, says that I am a bastard and then goes to the police to sue me, right ?
Did this person felt pain ?
I would assume everybody says " yes ", he/she had his/her hand half burned, cried, and then was very angry with me.
Can we prove that he/she felt pain ?
No, we can not.
You may say:
" Are you mad ?? Of course he/she felt pain !! He/she was crying with half of his/her hand burned !! And you are saying that he/she did not feel pain "
I can answer:
" Those are just reactions of the body, what did we see ?? A man/woman crying, taking off an arm fron the fire, crying out loud and a hand burned. The cry is just a signal from the brain to the muscles of the tongue and the mouth, taking away the arm from the fire is just a signal from the brain to the muscles of the arm, hand burned are just skin cells getting burned, all what happened can be explained without taking into account actually " feeling pain ". Do you agree ? "
You can say:
" But where all this signals of taking off the hand, of crying loud came from ? The brain right ? So the person has to actually have felt pain, because otherwise his/her brain would not have sent all these signal around "
I would reply:
" Again no need to take account actually having felt pain. It is just the signal of the hand that was on the fire that went to the brain, was processed by the " logical thinking " part of the brain which says: input = "hand on fire" then output = "cry out loud and take off the hand from fire and sue the bastard".
The " logical thinking " part of the brain sends out signals to the muscles of the arm to take off the hand, to the mouth to cry out loud.
As you see, we can explain all the reactions of this poor man/woman without taking into account the fact that he/she actually has felt pain, that is, without taking into account consciousness.
We can explain all his/her reactions with the work of the nerves, the muscles, the parts of the brain which do not include consciousness ( memory, logical thinking, processing signals from the body, etc. ).
I think that the person has felt pain, we just can not prove it !!
 
I would better put it this way:
We recognize that all the behaviour of that person can be explained by electric signals entring the brain, being processed by the brain and going out of the brain to muscles and nerves, right ??
All our behaviour can be explained with electric signals processes and biological processes.
If you want to say that electric signals and biological processes in the brain produce consciousness you have actually to prove it, because all our behaviour ( like the behaviour of that person ) can be explained without taking into account consciousness, without taking into account feeling pain or anything else
 
Matteo Martini said:
If you want to say that electric signals and biological processes in the brain produce consciousness you have actually to prove it, because all our behaviour ( like the behaviour of that person ) can be explained without taking into account consciousness, without taking into account feeling pain or anything else
Hi Matteo,

I'm personally a fan of HPC. I also like P-Zombies. I'm in agreement with you, well sort of.

The lack of proof does not invalidate materialism any more than the lack of proof prior to the understanding of aerodynamics invalidated flight.

We who believe in HPC are simply providing a problem for a philosophical debate. A rather significant problem IMHO. But absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.
 
What is HPC, high performance computing ??
And P-Zombies ??

The problem with the fact that there is a lack of proof now that brain activity generates consciousness is that there will always be a lack of proof that brain activity generates consciousness.

You can not even think about how to prove that performing a stimulation on a person' s hand provokes pain.

In my opinion, it is just outside the boundaries of science.
 
Matteo Martini said:
I just find a problem in this, if, as Schopenhauer ( and maybe Buddha ) said, world ( object ) and self ( subject ) come to existence together and fade together, how is that, when a person dies, the world does not disappear ?

Whos world are you talking about? ;)

"The World" is an abstaction, a theoretical construct, no matter how persuasive is the current thinking about a world of objects around us, in which we are just like videocameras, imprinting in our mind a movie of what happens outside...

Matteo Martini said:
Maybe because the subject does not disappear, but just reincarnate ?
Or maybe I have not understood Schopenhauer and Buddhism.
Moreover, reincarnation is a kind of act-of-faith, like existence of the soul ..

Who reincarnate? the self is a product of memories of a body, how can this "body self" reincarnate?? This is another theoretical construct.

Matteo Martini said:
Yes, also that Zen monk I met told me that you can " see " the oneness between you can the Universe when you lose all your attachments with the world.
And he said that is pretty difficult to achieve.
Attachment is pain, was not it Buddha who said that ?

OH YES, you can see it, the naked "thing" that is beyond concepts. But, at that point you are no longer "a human"... maybe this is not the right forum to discuss it.

Matteo Martini said:
That' s what Wittengstein said, language is a trap.
There are not two chairs, there are not two " anything ", one object is just another thing.
Moreover, there are no even " objects ", a car does not exist, it is wheel+lights+engine+transimssion tree+ ..

You are getting close!! Still at an intellectual level, but, as I see you, you could be "there" if you wanted.

Matteo Martini said:
Now, I would like to hear Correa Neto and Uruk.
They are the Neopositivists, while me and Bodhi Dharma are the Idealists.
Zaayrdragon as free thinker ?

Mmm, nope. Not an idealist. If anything, my possition would be an "Advaita Vedantist" :D
 
Matteo Martini said:
Neto, please do not take me wrong. I do not think I can intimidate anybody and I do not want to show that I am a person of culture. I quote all those guys just to show that this interesting discussion we are doing has probably already been done before. And what I am saying here is my opinion ( current opinion )

Uh.. I was just giving some advise. I never felt you wanted to intimidate. I was just pointing out that someone might eventually use this sort of argument in an discussion, pro- or con your position. And yes, this discussion has been made countless times before. I would love to see some statistics on their outcomes, since it seems to me that very few persons really change their minds.

Matteo Martini said:
...snip...
We can explain all his/her reactions with the work of the nerves, the muscles, the parts of the brain which do not include consciousness ( memory, logical thinking, processing signals from the body, etc. ).
I think that the person has felt pain, we just can not prove it !!

Nope. Because what you described (damage is inflicted to a part of the body->electrochemical messages transmitted to the brain by the nerves->data processing within the brain) is what is exactly the whole "phenomena" or "manifestation" or "feeling" or "proccess" called pain is!

Matteo Martini said:
...snip...All our behaviour can be explained with electric signals processes and biological processes.
If you want to say that electric signals and biological processes in the brain produce consciousness you have actually to prove it, because all our behaviour ( like the behaviour of that person ) can be explained without taking into account consciousness, without taking into account feeling pain or anything else

Note that if you want to say that electric signals and biological processes in the brain do not produce consciousness, you would also have to prove it!!! And so far, no evidence for it has been provided. Yet, its a very interesting discussion. Don´t think I am placing the responsability on your shoulders. Countless people tried before, and none managed to provide something other than speculations (most of them, in my opinion, wild and/or baseless).

Matteo Martini said:
[BThe problem with the fact that there is a lack of proof now that brain activity generates consciousness is that there will always be a lack of proof that brain activity generates consciousness.) [/B]

A bold claim! Many top people at their specialization fields would counter that claim, specially with the last part of it. There´s no way you can be certain of that. I don´t inted to be rude, so please don´t interpret as that, but are you a neurologist? How versed are you in science branches that study counsiousness? Do you really have the basis to say that? It not different that I saying that a givern cosmological theory will never be of any use to understanding the universe, for I lack knoweledge to do so... Note that even if you are a top researcher in one of these fields, its stiull very risky to say "there will always be a lack of proof that brain activity generates consciousness". Unless you are basing your claims in a belief, and not in a critical impersonal analysis of the evidence.

Note that what I have tried to show is that there is evidence pointing that counsiousness, self-counsiousness, self, etc. is/are created by the brain. A thought, the way I think about it, taking in to account what I know about it (that again, I acknoweledge is not a huge ammount) is just the product of data processing by the brain. Consiousness, self-consiousness, the self, are/is just a group of thoughts, just data being processed by the brain.

Some persons may say that the evidences actually point to this/these features to be partially created of influentiated by the brain, and that it can not be used to deny the possibility that there is something else. But they fail to provide evidence for this "something else". At least, untill now, I have not been convinced by whats backing their claims (I admit some of the philosophies presented by them are intriguing and interesting, but I always find them very weak in terms of basis, many are abstract supositions). But maybe one day I will, who knows?

Sure, many persons will deny that and try to rationalize my next sentence, but here it goes anyway. The key point is that to think that there´s something other than electric signals and biological processes in the brain producing consciousness, self, self-counsiousness, [add term here] is actually a matter of belief, call it faith if you want.
 
Matteo Martini said:
What is HPC, high performance computing ??
And P-Zombies ??
Oh say it aint so Matteo!

Hard Problem of Consiousness. AKA the The Mind-Brain Problem AKA Dualism are the attempts to explain the very problem you posit.

You said,
...because all our behaviour ( like the behaviour of that person ) can be explained without taking into account consciousness...
Zombies or Polger Zombies are also an attempt to flesh out this notion, so to speak.

The problem with the fact that there is a lack of proof now that brain activity generates consciousness is that there will always be a lack of proof that brain activity generates consciousness.

You can not even think about how to prove that performing a stimulation on a person' s hand provokes pain.

In my opinion, it is just outside the boundaries of science.
Perhaps,

Please find below a very comprehensive list of online papers dealing with the subject at hand. Sit down, buckle up and hold on tight. You are in for a bumpy ride.
 
Nope. Because what you described (damage is inflicted to a part of the body->electrochemical messages transmitted to the brain by the nerves->data processing within the brain) is what is exactly the whole "phenomena" or "manifestation" or "feeling" or "proccess" called pain is!
Maybe we use the same words for different things ..
But ..
All the process: ( damage is inflicted to a part of the body->electrochemical messages transmitted to the brain by the nerves->data processing -> etc. ) is just a mechanical/chemical/electric process similar to other process that happen in nature.
You have electric signals in cars, planes, computers but they are not " feeling " anything when they receive and compute those signals.
You have chemical processes in a battery but the battery is not " feeling " anything when it gets recharged or any other chemical process happens.
So how do you prove that a person is " feeling " anything when all these processes happen in his/her brain ??

Note that if you want to say that electric signals and biological processes in the brain do not produce consciousness, you would also have to prove it!!!
This is a cart-and-horse inversion, in my opinion.
I can explain all the processes that happen in the body and in the brain of the individual without taking into account consciousness.
The process that the person takes off his/her hand from the fire can be explained in chemical/electrical/mechanical grounds, without taking into account consciousness ( that is, feeling pain )
And I say that, if we are to believe that all humans are conscious, that is an act-of-faith.
Now, if you say that you can prove that consciousness is generated from brain activity, it is up to you to prove this claim.

A bold claim! Many top people at their specialization fields would counter that claim, specially with the last part of it. There´s no way you can be certain of that. I don´t inted to be rude, so please don´t interpret as that, but are you a neurologist? How versed are you in science branches that study counsiousness? Do you really have the basis to say that? It not different that I saying that a givern cosmological theory will never be of any use to understanding the universe, for I lack knoweledge to do so... Note that even if you are a top researcher in one of these fields, its stiull very risky to say "there will always be a lack of proof that brain activity generates consciousness". Unless you are basing your claims in a belief, and not in a critical impersonal analysis of the evidence.
Well, we are now in the year 2500.
You have a brain scan that let' s you see the processes of the brain in real time and all the electric signals into the brain and out of the brain.
You would have a 20 Teraflop computer just on your desk.
You would have all your tools that you could imagine.
How could you ever think to imagine a test to prove that consciousness is related to a part of the brain ??

Note that what I have tried to show is that there is evidence pointing that counsiousness, self-counsiousness, self, etc. is/are created by the brain
All you can show is that, if a person is asleep, under drugs, using LSD, in coma or in any altered state of consciousness, his/her brain behave in a certain way and also the person behaves in a certain way.
If the person is in state " asleep ", his/her brain will behave in a certain way and the person will probaly have eyes closed, regular respiration, etc.
If a person is in a state " using drugs ", his/her brain will give other signals, the person will move very much, will talk loudly, etc.
But how would you know how the persons feels ??
You would have to assume it from his/her behaviour, right ??
We always assume how a person feels from his/her behaviour.
If a person cries we assume he/she is sad.
If a person laughs we assume he/she is happy.
But all those are assumptions.
You can never know how another person really feels.
You can not even know if the person really feels anything.
You can just look at how he/she behaves and, if you want, you can look at his/her brain.
But if a person is crying how do you know that the person is really feeling pain.
You can not.
 
Matteo Martini said:
Maybe we use the same words for different things ..
But ..
All the process: ( damage is inflicted to a part of the body->electrochemical messages transmitted to the brain by the nerves->data processing -> etc. ) is just a mechanical/chemical/electric process similar to other process that happen in nature.
You have electric signals in cars, planes, computers but they are not " feeling " anything when they receive and compute those signals.
You have chemical processes in a battery but the battery is not " feeling " anything when it gets recharged or any other chemical process happens.
So how do you prove that a person is " feeling " anything when all these processes happen in his/her brain ??

Because the "feeling" IS is nothing but the result of brain activity, there´s nothing else involved. No one has so far managed to prove there´s something else. You are trying to attribute a dimension to "feeling" that is not real.


Matteo Martini said:
This is a cart-and-horse inversion, in my opinion.
I can explain all the processes that happen in the body and in the brain of the individual without taking into account consciousness.
The process that the person takes off his/her hand from the fire can be explained in chemical/electrical/mechanical grounds, without taking into account consciousness ( that is, feeling pain )
And I say that, if we are to believe that all humans are conscious, that is an act-of-faith.
Now, if you say that you can prove that consciousness is generated from brain activity, it is up to you to prove this claim.

And if you say no one can prove that consiousness is a product of brain activity, its your call. As it is your call to prove that believing that all humans are conscious is an act-of-faith. You started the thread with the intention of discussing counsience and to use the discussion to imply that we are more than products of interactions between our brain, body and environment. I have presented evidence that it is, even if the burden to present evidence for anything was yours, since you started the discussion, and to prove your point you mut present evidence to back your claims.

To say that oine can´t prove that another people feels something is not proof of anything. Its an evasion. "Feeling" the way you use it is a very unsubstantiated definition. And the line that no one can prove anything is a completely useless deead end -even tough it may sounds nice anc cozy for some, specialy some brands of immaterialists. If its true, than discussing anything about anything is utterly futile.

Matteo Martini said:
Well, we are now in the year 2500.
You have a brain scan that let' s you see the processes of the brain in real time and all the electric signals into the brain and out of the brain.
You would have a 20 Teraflop computer just on your desk.
You would have all your tools that you could imagine.
How could you ever think to imagine a test to prove that consciousness is related to a part of the brain ??

By acessing the symptoms, the evidence, the paterns of brain activity related to each state of consiousness. Because consusionness, self-counsioussness, and self are defined as toughts or groups of toughts, and the act of thinking creates patterns that can be assyaed, measured, studied. And lets make clear that that consciousness is most likely not related to a single part of the brain, but to the interaction of a lot of them.

Matteo Martini said:
All you can show is that, if a person is asleep, under drugs, using LSD, in coma or in any altered state of consciousness, his/her brain behave in a certain way and also the person behaves in a certain way.
If the person is in state " asleep ", his/her brain will behave in a certain way and the person will probaly have eyes closed, regular respiration, etc.
If a person is in a state " using drugs ", his/her brain will give other signals, the person will move very much, will talk loudly, etc.
But how would you know how the persons feels ??
You would have to assume it from his/her behaviour, right ??
We always assume how a person feels from his/her behaviour.
If a person cries we assume he/she is sad.
If a person laughs we assume he/she is happy.
But all those are assumptions.
You can never know how another person really feels.
You can not even know if the person really feels anything.
You can just look at how he/she behaves and, if you want, you can look at his/her brain.
But if a person is crying how do you know that the person is really feeling pain.
You can not.

Again the dead end. Deny it if you want, but if you continue with this line, all further discussion is useless. You are giving to the word "feeling" an esoteric unreachable meaning. You "feel" happy because you received inputs that are interpreted by your brain as a feeling of happiness, just like you feel hungry when you receive inputs that indicate you need something to eat. You can´t prove that there´s nothing else than just it. The catch here is that, while one show evidence that brain activity is reponsible by all the we are, no one can prove there´s something else. So, the way I think, its more likely that there is nothing more.

The "proofs" you provided are nothing but an elusive definition and a philosophic dead end.
 
Because the "feeling" IS is nothing but the result of brain activity
The problem is that this is only your assumption.
Brain activity = brain activity and nothing else.
In detail, brain activity = electric signals in our brains and nothing more.
If you say that " the "feeling" IS is nothing but the result of brain activity " it is up to you to prove this.
I say that there is no evidence that the " feeling " is generated from brain activity.
I do not know where this " feeling " is generated from, but we have no proof that it is generated from brain activity.
If you say that is generated from brain activity it is up to you to prove this claim, not to me to disprove it.

No one has so far managed to prove there´s something else
I do not want to prove that there is something else.
I never spoke about " soul " or other things like that.
And if I spoke about philosophical theories about the nature of the " self ", I meant them just as suppositions, not as facts or evidence.

You are trying to attribute a dimension to "feeling" that is not real
I do not know where " feeling " comes from.
I do not know where " conciousness " comes from.
All the discussion I made about Zen monks etc. where just philosophycal discussions.
Your assumption is that consciousness is generated from brain activity, but this is just an assumption like many others.
I would like to point out that brain activity is just brain activity, it is NOT feeling
Or that if you state that brain activity generates feelings it is up to you to prove it.

And if you say no one can prove that consiousness is a product of brain activity, its your call
I think that no one can prove it, but if you say that you can I would be happy to know how.
If you think that someone can, I would like to know how.
If somebody wants to prove that brain activity generates consciousness it is up to him to prove it, not up to me to disprove it.
I have no proofs that brain activity does not generate consciousness, but if you want to back the claim that it does, it is up to you to prove this.

You started the thread with the intention of discussing counsience and to use the discussion to imply that we are more than products of interactions between our brain, body and environment. I have presented evidence that it is, even if the burden to present evidence for anything was yours, since you started the discussion, and to prove your point you mut present evidence to back your claims
I started this thread asking " where am I ? " because, scientifically, we can not prove that my " self " is anywhere, there is no proof that my " feelings " come from my brain.
Therefore, do my feelings, my consciousness really come from my brain ??
I say that we have no proof for this !!
I say that we have no proofs that our " consiousness " comes from our " soul ", our " karma ", our brain, our nervous system, etc.
I do not know and I could not find any evidence that our " consciousness " comes from any of these things.
I understood that you are convinced that our " conciousness " comes from our brain activity.
I would doubt it is like this.
So, can you provide any proofs for this ??
I say, I do not know where our consciousness comes from, if you say it comes from brain activity, it is up to you to back this claims, not to me to disprove it

To say that one can´t prove that another people feels something is not proof of anything. Its an evasion
It is not an evasion, in my opinion.
It is a very important limitation to what we can prove scientifically.
It means that scientifically, you can not prove the feelings of another person.
You can look at his/her brain activity but you can not prove that he/she feels well, bad or anything else.
This is a very important difference.

By acessing the symptoms, the evidence, the paterns of brain activity related to each state of consiousness. Because consusionness, self-counsioussness, and self are defined as toughts or groups of toughts, and the act of thinking creates patterns that can be assyaed, measured, studied. And lets make clear that that consciousness is most likely not related to a single part of the brain, but to the interaction of the brain
Sorry, Correa Neto, you are making the same mistake over and over.
Brain activity = brain activity and nothing more
Patterns of the brain = patterns of the brain and nothing more
Electric activity of the neurons = electric activity of the neurons and nothing more
Interaction of the brain = interaction of the brain and nothing more
A hat is a hat, it is not anything else.
If you say that brain activity, or the patterns of the brain or the electric activity of the neurons or interaction of the brain generates consciousness and the feelings all the persons have, it is up to you to prove this claim, not to me to disprove it.
And if you say that physical reactions to pain ( like crying, shouting, tears ) and patterns of the brain are " pain ", I repeat that physical reactions to pain ( like crying, shouting, tears ) and patterns of the brain are physical reactions to pain ( like crying, shouting, tears ) and patterns of the brain and nothing more.
Again, a hat is a hat, it is not anything else.

Again the dead end. Deny it if you want, but if you continue with this line, all further discussion is useless. You are giving to the word "feeling" an esoteric unreachable meaning
I do not know if the discussion is useless, I do not think so.
But, if you say that " feelings " are unreachable, this is what I wanted to point out from the beginning.
Feelings and consciousness are unreachable from scientific explorations.
And, it is not me who gives " feelings " an esoteric meaning, we all know what feelings are.
The mistake you are making is that you say that " the "feeling" IS is nothing but the result of brain activity ".
This is a methaphysical assertion, the same as the " feeling " come from the soul or the " feeling " come from your stellar-consciousness.
All these assertions, good or bad, are not scientific assertions.
And it is not me who has to prove anything, I just do not know where my " feelings ", where my consciousness come from ( where am I ? ).
If anybody wants to prove that it comes from my brain, my soul or anything else, it is up to him to provide evidence.

The "proofs" you provided are nothing but an elusive definition and a philosophic dead end.
Again, I never provided any proof.
I am not making any claim, at least any " scientific " claim about where " consciousness " comes from.
I tried to give evidence that your claim that " the "feeling" IS is nothing but the result of brain activity " is not backed by anything.
Like the claim that " the "feeling" IS is nothing but the result of soul "
 
Feelings, thought, and consciousness are necessarily tied to brain activity. Proof? Feelings, thought, and consciousness can be suppressed, altered, or removed altogether by various means which influence the brain. Without a brain, feelings, thought, and consciousness do not exist. Yet to determine precisely where feelings, thought, and consciousness resides within the brain would require extensive and probably inethical medical research.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom