Because the "feeling" IS is nothing but the result of brain activity
The problem is that this is only your assumption.
Brain activity = brain activity and nothing else.
In detail, brain activity = electric signals in our brains and nothing more.
If you say that " the "feeling" IS is nothing but the result of brain activity " it is up to you to prove this.
I say that there is no evidence that the " feeling " is generated from brain activity.
I do not know where this " feeling " is generated from, but we have no proof that it is generated from brain activity.
If you say that is generated from brain activity it is up to you to prove this claim, not to me to disprove it.
No one has so far managed to prove there´s something else
I do not want to prove that there is something else.
I never spoke about " soul " or other things like that.
And if I spoke about philosophical theories about the nature of the " self ", I meant them just as suppositions, not as facts or evidence.
You are trying to attribute a dimension to "feeling" that is not real
I do not know where " feeling " comes from.
I do not know where " conciousness " comes from.
All the discussion I made about Zen monks etc. where just philosophycal discussions.
Your assumption is that consciousness is generated from brain activity, but this is just an assumption like many others.
I would like to point out that brain activity is just brain activity, it is NOT feeling
Or that if you state that brain activity generates feelings it is up to you to prove it.
And if you say no one can prove that consiousness is a product of brain activity, its your call
I think that no one can prove it, but if you say that you can I would be happy to know how.
If you think that someone can, I would like to know how.
If somebody wants to prove that brain activity generates consciousness it is up to him to prove it, not up to me to disprove it.
I have no proofs that brain activity does not generate consciousness, but if you want to back the claim that it does, it is up to you to prove this.
You started the thread with the intention of discussing counsience and to use the discussion to imply that we are more than products of interactions between our brain, body and environment. I have presented evidence that it is, even if the burden to present evidence for anything was yours, since you started the discussion, and to prove your point you mut present evidence to back your claims
I started this thread asking " where am I ? " because, scientifically, we can not prove that my " self " is anywhere, there is no proof that my " feelings " come from my brain.
Therefore, do my feelings, my consciousness really come from my brain ??
I say that we have no proof for this !!
I say that we have no proofs that our " consiousness " comes from our " soul ", our " karma ", our brain, our nervous system, etc.
I do not know and I could not find any evidence that our " consciousness " comes from any of these things.
I understood that you are convinced that our " conciousness " comes from our brain activity.
I would doubt it is like this.
So, can you provide any proofs for this ??
I say, I do not know where our consciousness comes from, if you say it comes from brain activity, it is up to you to back this claims, not to me to disprove it
To say that one can´t prove that another people feels something is not proof of anything. Its an evasion
It is not an evasion, in my opinion.
It is a very important limitation to what we can prove scientifically.
It means that scientifically, you can not prove the feelings of another person.
You can look at his/her brain activity but you can not prove that he/she feels well, bad or anything else.
This is a very important difference.
By acessing the symptoms, the evidence, the paterns of brain activity related to each state of consiousness. Because consusionness, self-counsioussness, and self are defined as toughts or groups of toughts, and the act of thinking creates patterns that can be assyaed, measured, studied. And lets make clear that that consciousness is most likely not related to a single part of the brain, but to the interaction of the brain
Sorry, Correa Neto, you are making the same mistake over and over.
Brain activity = brain activity and nothing more
Patterns of the brain = patterns of the brain and nothing more
Electric activity of the neurons = electric activity of the neurons and nothing more
Interaction of the brain = interaction of the brain and nothing more
A hat is a hat, it is not anything else.
If you say that brain activity, or the patterns of the brain or the electric activity of the neurons or interaction of the brain generates consciousness and the feelings all the persons have, it is up to you to prove this claim, not to me to disprove it.
And if you say that physical reactions to pain ( like crying, shouting, tears ) and patterns of the brain are " pain ", I repeat that physical reactions to pain ( like crying, shouting, tears ) and patterns of the brain are physical reactions to pain ( like crying, shouting, tears ) and patterns of the brain and nothing more.
Again, a hat is a hat, it is not anything else.
Again the dead end. Deny it if you want, but if you continue with this line, all further discussion is useless. You are giving to the word "feeling" an esoteric unreachable meaning
I do not know if the discussion is useless, I do not think so.
But, if you say that " feelings " are unreachable, this is what I wanted to point out from the beginning.
Feelings and consciousness are unreachable from scientific explorations.
And, it is not me who gives " feelings " an esoteric meaning, we all know what feelings are.
The mistake you are making is that you say that " the "feeling" IS is nothing but the result of brain activity ".
This is a methaphysical assertion, the same as the " feeling " come from the soul or the " feeling " come from your stellar-consciousness.
All these assertions, good or bad, are not scientific assertions.
And it is not me who has to prove anything, I just do not know where my " feelings ", where my consciousness come from ( where am I ? ).
If anybody wants to prove that it comes from my brain, my soul or anything else, it is up to him to provide evidence.
The "proofs" you provided are nothing but an elusive definition and a philosophic dead end.
Again, I never provided any proof.
I am not making any claim, at least any " scientific " claim about where " consciousness " comes from.
I tried to give evidence that your claim that " the "feeling" IS is nothing but the result of brain activity " is not backed by anything.
Like the claim that " the "feeling" IS is nothing but the result of soul "