Interesting Ian
Banned
- Joined
- Feb 9, 2004
- Messages
- 7,675
Re: Dragonrock
The brain is not, and could not, be conscious. It's just a piece of meat.
Less flippantly it's just a physical object like all other physical objects in the Universe; just vastly more complex. But complexity cannot produce the miraculous.
The reason why people believe it must do this miraculous thing is because brain and mind states are inevitably correlated. Moreover mind states often follow brain states suggesting that brain states produce mind states (our mind apparently effecting the brain is simply ignored). Of course this conclusion is not forced as I explain in that other thread that I supplied a link to.
Matteo Martini said:The main point of this thread is to know where self-consciousness comes from. While cars, families, computers are greater than what they are made of but are not self-conscious, the person is. Why ?
The brain is not, and could not, be conscious. It's just a piece of meat.
Less flippantly it's just a physical object like all other physical objects in the Universe; just vastly more complex. But complexity cannot produce the miraculous.
The reason why people believe it must do this miraculous thing is because brain and mind states are inevitably correlated. Moreover mind states often follow brain states suggesting that brain states produce mind states (our mind apparently effecting the brain is simply ignored). Of course this conclusion is not forced as I explain in that other thread that I supplied a link to.