Where am I ?

Re: Dragonrock

Matteo Martini said:
The main point of this thread is to know where self-consciousness comes from. While cars, families, computers are greater than what they are made of but are not self-conscious, the person is. Why ?

The brain is not, and could not, be conscious. It's just a piece of meat.

Less flippantly it's just a physical object like all other physical objects in the Universe; just vastly more complex. But complexity cannot produce the miraculous.

The reason why people believe it must do this miraculous thing is because brain and mind states are inevitably correlated. Moreover mind states often follow brain states suggesting that brain states produce mind states (our mind apparently effecting the brain is simply ignored). Of course this conclusion is not forced as I explain in that other thread that I supplied a link to.
 
" I don't know if you don't understand or if you are being deliberately obtuse "

Please do not start to insult

" I never said car were self-conscious "

I never said you said that, I just pointed out that the analogy does not work because cars are not self-conscious while men are.

" My analogy simply pointed out that many things, including our brains, are greater than what they are made of "

I agree with that.
The main point of this thread is to know where self-consciousness comes from. While cars, families, computers are greater than what they are made of but are not self-conscious, the person
 
Matteo Martini said:
Please do not start to insult

I was not insulting.

Matteo Martini said:
I never said you said that, I just pointed out that the analogy does not work because cars are not self-conscious while men are.

You are just think of the car analogy incorrectly. I was using the car as analogious to the brain and the ability for the car to move as analogious to consciousness

Matteo Martini said:
The main point of this thread is to know where self-consciousness comes from. While cars, families, computers are greater than what they are made of but are not self-conscious, the person is. Why ?

Who knows? The exact mechanism hasn't been discovered.

Matteo Martini said:
This hypothesis of the " soul " is an unproven hypothesis among other unproven hypothesis.

But, what does the soul hypothesis bring to the table that can't be explained by other processes?

It appears as though you have taken the concept of consciousness and lifted it to religious significance. To me it is simply a result of my complex brain, I can accept that, even if I don't know how it works. If someone were to discover that consciousness is part of some previously unknown "soul" then I'll change my opinions as needed.
 
2) Now, let' s imagine to take two healthy neurons linked with some synapses, let' s suppose that we can recreate the condition of the body in this lab so that the two neurons can live, transmit signals and operate like if they were in the brain. I do not know if this is technically feasible at the moment, but not too difficult to imagine, right ?

3) Now the two neurons would operate together, all the two single neurons would be living and healthy, but will there be any conscious entity generating from the two neurons ? No. There would be no "very-little-conscious-person-with-a-two-neuron-brain". There would be only two neurons operating, no other self-conscious entity, right ?
If somebody claims that two neurons linked together generate even an exterenely low conscious self-consciousness, then please tell me where this conciousness should be coming from, from the electrical charges ? From what ?

4) Let's start adding neurons, firstly another one, then another one, we will get a bunch of one hundred, one thousand neurons linked together and operating. Will there be generated any kind of self-consciousness here ? Will this very little brain know that he/she is existing ? If you answer yes, please tell me when exactly this brain start to become conscious. If you say that consciousness grows from zero ( no neurons ) to human consciouness ( 100 billion neurons, if I remember well ) then even two or three neurons should generate a little, little, little, little bit of consciouness, right ? Then answer to point 3)

5) Continuing this process we have somehow built a human brain. Do not tell me that we do not know how to do this process, we do not know yet, but there is no conceptual obstacle to overcome, right ?
So, will this brain be conscious or not ?
Well, you do have a situation like this that happens everyday. When a person is developing from single cell to fetus. it stars out with no neuron, then one then two, then four, so on and so on. At which point would say it becomes concious?

Those you are quoting ( indiivdual drive, personality ) are all attibutes of the individual, they are not the individual.
I am not the sum of my memory, my individual drives, my personality, I am all this plus I know that I am here ( self-consciousness )
Well, everything that you are or ever will be is right there in the brain. Also what is the "plus"? If you can define it, then you might be closer to finding when a group of neurons becomes sentient.
 
The brain is not, and could not, be conscious. It's just a piece of meat.
It's a piece of meat with a purpose. Like a hunk of muscle will contract when electricity is applied. or how a kidney or liver will filter certain compounds. taken in it's entirety it produces something.

Less flippantly it's just a physical object like all other physical objects in the Universe; just vastly more complex. But complexity cannot produce the miraculous.
What's so miraculous about intelligence or sentients? It happens everyday. it does what it supposed to do. It's amazing and wonderous yes but miraculous?
 
Answers to uruk

" I was not insulting "
OK No problem.

" I was using the car as analogious to the brain and the ability for the car to move as analogious to consciousness "
Well, the ability of the car to move can be explained by the functionalities of the various parts of the car itself, as memory, character, personality, sight can be explained by the functionalities of the various parts of the brain and the body.
But not consciousness, I would not know how to explain that I feel I am here by the functionality of my neurons.

" Well, you do have a situation like this that happens everyday. When a person is developing from single cell to fetus. it stars out with no neuron, then one then two, then four, so on and so on. At which point would say it becomes concious? "
This is the big question. I do not know.

" Also what is the "plus"? If you can define it, then you might be closer to finding when a group of neurons becomes sentient. "
The "plus " is the fact that I know I am here in this moment, something that cars, computers and even neurons do not have.
Where this plus come from ?

Maybe I am becoming a little bit boring ?

Matteo
 
This is the big question. I do not know.
Man, that is so refreshing. An honest answer.

Truth is I don't know either. I don't think anyone realy does. This probably because we have such a hard time trying to define what sentience is. All we can come up with is, "you know it when you see it". But this doesn't answer the question.

But I would say that at some point in the development there is a sufficent number of neurons which begin to process a sufficient amount of sensory input which makes a sufficient amount of connections, and at that point it becomes sufficiently self-aware that we begin to call it sentience. But since it is such a gradual and debateable process, we can not say exactly where and when this happens. It a matter of degree I suppose. Some people will call one level sentience while other will not. Heck, some people even claim that we are not really self-aware or sentience. Don't ask who, I'm sure you'll get to his thread soon enough.
The "plus " is the fact that I know I am here in this moment, something that cars, computers and even neurons do not have.
But from where and how do you proceess the information that leads you to this conclusion? It's a combination of many different processes. The big one is, what gives it meaning? or evaluation? or assesment? These are also some of the things that are lost when desease and damage occurs to the brain. Some people with mental retardation have no concept of, or know the meaning of money. Would we call them non-sentient? non-human? They have lost the ability to make that assesment or evaluation. Again where and how do we draw the line or limit?
The only thing that we do know for sure is that there is a correlation of mind and brain. But people will debate about what came first or which affect what.
 
Man, that is so refreshing. An honest answer
Well, I never said I knew the answer, I was looking after someone to enlighten me.

This probably because we have such a hard time trying to define what sentience is. All we can come up with is, "you know it when you see it". But this doesn't answer the question
This is also true.
You can not define self-consciousness, because there is not an higher concept to relate to.

Truth is I don't know either. I don't think anyone realy does
That is a possibility.
There are other theories about this problem, however, that have not been discussed so far.

But since it is such a gradual and debateable process, we can not say exactly where and when this happens

I have tried to explain why it is hard for me to believe that consciousness comes from neurons or their interaction

Heck, some people even claim that we are not really self-aware or sentience. Don't ask who, I'm sure you'll get to his thread soon enough
I am waiting for them to come.
If someone comes up saying that maybe he is not self-conscious, then I will ask him to put and hand in the fire.
If he is not self-copnscious, there would be nobody to feel the pain.

But from where and how do you proceess the information that leads you to this conclusion? It's a combination of many different processes. The big one is, what gives it meaning? or evaluation? or assesment? These are also some of the things that are lost when desease and damage occurs to the brain. Some people with mental retardation have no concept of, or know the meaning of money. Would we call them non-sentient? non-human? They have lost the ability to make that assesment or evaluation. Again where and how do we draw the line or limit?

I do not understand all your answers but I can not draw a line between self-consciousness and non-self-consciousness.
The only thing I am pretty sure is that I have it while objects do not.
Do not ask me how I know it, I am unable to answer.

The only thing that we do know for sure is that there is a correlation of mind and brain. But people will debate about what came first or which affect what
Yes, I think so as well.
Let' s see if anybody comes up with any good idea.
 
Well, I never said I knew the answer, I was looking after someone to enlighten me.
There are a few people on this forum in which it would kill them to admit this. I'm refering to the "preachers".

I have tried to explain why it is hard for me to believe that consciousness comes from neurons or their interaction
I think the point that dragonrock was trying to make was that it is not so much the neural activity but the concert of all the activity of all the parts is from which it derives sentience.
Surely some parts are more vital than other parts, which is why I mentioned lobotomies, alzhimers, and mental retardation. All these affects and aflictions to the brain affect the "plus" or self. The study of how those things affect the brain may lead to an answer of how and where the "self" is.
So far, the consensus is that a large part of the "self" is centered in the frontal lobe. Check out this site for more info:
http://www.neuroskills.com/index.shtml?main=/tbi/bfrontal.shtml
The only thing I am pretty sure is that I have it while objects do not.
Do not ask me how I know it, I am unable to answer.
That is the crux of the delima. We don't yet understand it well enough to even begin to establish definitive critera in which to test it.

Anyhoo, I'm of the belief that it all happens in the brain and at some point we will know for sure. at least compared to what we know now.
 
Re: Re: Dragonrock

Interesting Ian said:
The brain is not, and could not, be conscious. It's just a piece of meat.
Ah, the false dichotomy.
Less flippantly it's just a physical object like all other physical objects in the Universe; just vastly more complex. But complexity cannot produce the miraculous.
Assuming the thing to be proved.
The reason why people believe it must do this miraculous thing is because brain and mind states are inevitably correlated.
And... the Miracle Of The Bleeding Obvious! It always looks exactly as though the brain produces the mind, but in fact it's being done by magic mind pixes or something.

occam_razor.gif
 
" I think the point that dragonrock was trying to make was that it is not so much the neural activity but the concert of all the activity of all the parts is from which it derives sentience "
Well, let' s go a little bit in detalis ?
The " parts " are the neurons and the synapses I assume.
And the " activity ", what could that be ?
Biological activity, i. e. moving molecules around the brain, can provoke consciousness ?
Electrical activity can provoke consciousness ?
Both of them ?
In which ratio and how do biological activity and electrical activity generate consciousness ?
Other activity ?
Which ?

" All these affects and aflictions to the brain affect the "plus" or self "
I agree, but those afflictions to the brain because the brains affects the mind but they are not the mind.
Where is the mind, the " self " is the problem.
And how it relates to the brain.

" We don't yet understand it well enough to even begin to establish definitive critera in which to test it "
I think I understand that the " self " ( that is, me ) is, I just am unable to define it in words.

" Anyhoo, I'm of the belief that it all happens in the brain and at some point we will know for sure. at least compared to what we know now "
I am skeptic about this.
At the moment, we have no clue about this.
 
Well, let' s go a little bit in detalis ?
The " parts " are the neurons and the synapses I assume.
And the " activity ", what could that be ?
Biological activity, i. e. moving molecules around the brain, can provoke consciousness ?
Electrical activity can provoke consciousness ?
Both of them ?
In which ratio and how do biological activity and electrical activity generate consciousness ?
Other activity ?
Which ?
It is probably all of the above. No one part or activity is responsible, but rather the whole is. but if you remove too many of the parts or activity there is no conciousness. There are many descriptions and conditions for sentience. Neurons, electro/chemical activity, specialized areas of activity which processes sensory stimulus that generates more activity which stimulates other areas with specified functions which stimulates further and so on. The "mind" has to be somewhere in there. But I don't think it is as simple as a dividing line. It may also have to do with our inability to clearly define what sentience is. It will probably become easier once we get that definition.
I agree, but those afflictions to the brain because the brains affects the mind but they are not the mind.
Studies in brain damage and desease to certain areas of the brain gives us some insight. Some area can be damaged and we wil still say the self is there, but damage to other areas cause us to say the the person has changed or that the person is no longer there. (i.e. vedgitative states.)
Please do read about brain damage and trauma, it really is facinating as to what is tells us about the brain and mind.
I think I understand that the " self " ( that is, me ) is, I just am unable to define it in words.
Well this might be indication that there may be yet more to understand about what the self is.
I am not really to sure as to what the self really is.
 
" It is probably all of the above. No one part or activity is responsible, but rather the whole is "
In my opinion, this does mean much.
What does it mean that the electrical activity of the neurons or the biological activity are not responsible, but the combination of the two is ?
How the combination of electrical activity and biological activity can be responsible of something ?
They are just electric charges and molecules moving.
How can this generate consciousness ?

" Some area can be damaged and we wil still say the self is there, but damage to other areas cause us to say the the person has changed or that the person is no longer there. (i.e. vedgitative states.)
Please do read about brain damage and trauma, it really is facinating as to what is tells us about the brain and mind. "
I do agree about this.
All this proves us that mind ( that is, the " self " ) and brain are correlated somehow.
But does not prove nor hint that brain can be the self and the self can be the brain

" I am not really to sure as to what the self really is "
The best definition I can give is " self [ consciousness ] is the fact that you feel that you exist in this very moment "
This is the best definition I could find
 
ERRATA CORRIGE

" In my opinion, this does mean much "
To be changed as
" In my opinion, this does not mean much"
 
How does the moving of electrons and a particular filament encased in a particular gas generate light? Surely electrons by themselves do not generate light, nor does the filament, nor the gas.

An engine alone won't cause a car to move; neither will a transmission, nor axles, wheels, etc. But combine them, and you have powered locomotion.

We have many, MANY examples of functions and processes which are more than the sums of their parts - that's the way complex systems work. In nature, we have to reverse-engineer everything - the trick is, sometimes we get it right, off the cuff, and other times we have to stumble around until we get it right. With consciousness, we're dealing with what is possible the single most complex system we've ever encountered in nature - we've got to expect it to be relatively complex as well.
 
What does it mean that the electrical activity of the neurons or the biological activity are not responsible, but the combination of the two is ?
How the combination of electrical activity and biological activity can be responsible of something ?
They are just electric charges and molecules moving.
How can this generate consciousness ?
A bunch of 1's and 0's on a hard drive and fluctuating voltages in circutry do not a program make, but when the 1's and 0's and electronic circuits are arranged in proper order, you have a program that can manage your taxes. It is not the neurons and electro/chemical activity itself alone from which sentience arises. but the pattern, and arrangment of the parts and activity from which sentience arises.
It is all part of a whole organizim. If we look at organizims we can see a increase in magnitude of response and intereaction with the environment as the complexity of the organizim increases. At the very lowest end of organizim complexity you see viruses and single cell orgaizims. they respond to and interact with their environment by chemical stimulus alone. the presence of a certain chemical triggers a sepcific response. With that they can reproduce, which is about all they can do. I don't think there is a person who would agree that viruses and bacteria have sentience, yet there is purpose in their actions (to reproduce which is an extention of what DNA does). They respond and interact with their environment according to their make up. This becomes important when self-preservation comes into play. The viruses and other more simple forms of life are completelat the mercy ofthier present location. But they do not have the abilty to remove themselves or protect themselves if the conditions become unfavorable for their continued existance. If the organizim has sufficient complexity, it stands a better chance of survival. But this increased complexity requires specialzed parts for locomotion, manipulation, reproduction and sustainance. And the specialized parts (especially the parts that are used for locomotion and interaction with the environment need to be coordinated. We are, by the way, still in the realm of stimulus/ response, but a more complex response to stimulus. The stimulus are still there, hunger (to sustain the organizim), reproduction (so that the DNA can contiune to reproduce) and self preservation. But now the response is more complex. If the imidiate conditions become unsafe or hazardous for the organizim it now has the abilty to defend itself or remove itself from the area. It can go searching for food rather than wait for food to come to it. it has the sensory organs to detect sustinance, amd more importantly, mates fro reproduction.
Now notice how chemicals are still responsible for the whole process. It is responsible for smell, taste, nerve signals, muscles contractions, converting light to neural signals, neuro transmitters in the brain which processe the incoming sensory signals and trigger responses for environmental interactions.

At some yet unkown point the whole organisim developed something in its neuro activity which took in account for itself. There is something in the brain in which the organizim becomes aware of it's own existance in the abstract sense. I personaly believe that it is just one of the many complex patterns inwhich the organizim uses to relate to the environment taken to a different level of complexity. There is probably a pattern of activity in which the brain uses as a variable to represent itself when responding to stimulus.

All this proves us that mind ( that is, the " self " ) and brain are correlated somehow.
But does not prove nor hint that brain can be the self and the self can be the brain
But if you affect the brain you affect the self (the brain desease and damage studies have shown this). What else could it mean? (at this point some people will throw in the "radio reciever" argument, but it does not answer any questions. It just gives another possibilty, but with no evidence or proof.)
The best definition I can give is " self [ consciousness ] is the fact that you feel that you exist in this very moment "
But couldn't that just be another response to environment? The "I" in the stimulus/response equation. "I" am hungry. "I" am in danger, "I" need to reproduce. But just a more complex response?
 
When you look at the parts, there's nothing in a brain that suggests consciousness. There's nothing that really explains thought, or reason, or much else. It's a lump of fat laden with neurons. Only our awareness and some really sick experiments have led us to understand what little we do about the brain.

This got me to thinking: if Man kills itself off, and an alien race a hundred years later finds a bunch of CDs, what would they make of them? Would the idea that these simple plastic discs contain knowledge ever occur to them??

Years ago, I read a series called 'The Heechee Saga' by.. um... I think Pohl, but not sure. One of the things mentioned were what they called 'prayer fans' - crystalline fan-shaped things found all over the relics left by aliens. They had no particular value to humans except as souvenirs, and were believed to play some role in the Heechee religious life - until someone accidentally found a 'reader niche' to insert it into, and discovered that these were the Heechee means of information storage.

Of course, technology can be reverse-engineered fairly simply - biology not so simply at all.
 
" How does the moving of electrons and a particular filament encased in a particular gas generate light? Surely electrons by themselves do not generate light, nor does the filament, nor the gas.

An engine alone won't cause a car to move; neither will a transmission, nor axles, wheels, etc. But combine them, and you have powered locomotion. "

There are well know laws of thermodynamics, physics, etc. that describe all this phenomena in detail.
Where are the laws that describe how consciousness generates from neurons, synapses, etc.
Not even a hint ?

" We have many, MANY examples of functions and processes which are more than the sums of their parts - that's the way complex systems work. "
There is a major difference between cars, lamps, computers and people: cars, lamps, computers are not self-conscious, people are
 
Matteo Martini said:
" How does the moving of electrons and a particular filament encased in a particular gas generate light? Surely electrons by themselves do not generate light, nor does the filament, nor the gas.

An engine alone won't cause a car to move; neither will a transmission, nor axles, wheels, etc. But combine them, and you have powered locomotion. "

There are well know laws of thermodynamics, physics, etc. that describe all this phenomena in detail.
Where are the laws that describe how consciousness generates from neurons, synapses, etc.
Not even a hint ?

" We have many, MANY examples of functions and processes which are more than the sums of their parts - that's the way complex systems work. "
There is a major difference between cars, lamps, computers and people: cars, lamps, computers are not self-conscious, people are

So are you suggesting that, because we don't YET understand, scientifically, how consciousness is generated, that we should embrace a mystical explanation instead, which also has no proof whatsoever?

At this point in human knowledge, consciousness is a mystery. We can either confront that mystery scientifically, analyzing the brain and neural interaction until we can pinpoint it, or we can confront it mystically, rationalizing all sorts of possible solutions and never proving anything.

One thing that would help everyone here - define 'self-conscious'. Accurately. What is the defining point of self-consciousness? We say a computer is not self-conscious - but there are computers with internal monitors for temperature and condition, running programs that monitor other programs, the overall state of memory, etc. Self-consciousness could be defined in such a way that sufficiently complex computers could be considered self-conscious. Some researchers have created programs allowing computers to 'understand' the nature of their own existance as machines, though as of yet, these programs generally suck.

Does self-consciousness require 'free-will'? Does it require an awareness of mortality? Needs? Desires? Is a person who lacks wants 'self-conscious'? What about a person who, due to brain damage, has no sense of self?

So a clear definition of self-consciousness could push this along quite a bit.

For the record: I consider most invertebrate life to be self-conscious, and less so for some insects, arachnids, and several other animals, I am undecided on plant life, and believe microbial and viral life to be not-conscious at all. (I say some insects because I have my doubts when it comes to hive insects, who seem to display a group-consciousness instead of a self-consciousness.)

However, the exact criteria escapes me.

Back to my point: just because we cannot understand something today does NOT mean we need to grasp for mystical reasons instead of logical, scientific ones.
 
So a clear definition of self-consciousness could push this along quite a bit.
So far we have no clear definition of what is selfconciousness is. This could be due to species predjudice or egotisim. We are accustomed to thinking (mostly due to religion) that we are superior over all life on this planet. So when we come up with a definition of self-conciouseness and see that criteria exhibited in an "animal" we throw it out and say "naw that wasn't it, it has to be something different". So I think it really comes down to what separates us from the other animals on our planet. And the only thing I could come up with is art and religion. Insects and animals build things and use tools, so there has to some level of self-conciousness and abstract forethought / planning present.

But I haven't an animal paint or sculpt a representative object. (like the mona monkey lisa, or a dog painting a picture of people playing poker). Nor have I seen the church of latter day elephants.

But then there is the repeating whale song (and the praying mantis:D)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom