Where am I ?

Yaotl wrote:
" So your definition of being self-conscious is to feel physical pain and pleasure? If that capacity is damaged in someone, are they no longer self-conscious? "
No, being able is to feel physical pain and pleasure is one property that only self-conscious entities have ( men, women, cats, dogs, not tocks ).
My definition of self-conscious individual is a individual who knows that he/she is there, that is existing in that very moment.

Dragonrock, the analogy with the car does not work, in my opinion.
A car is not different from the sum of its parts, actually " car " is a name we give to wheels, engine, axles, etc.
I am not the sum of all my neurons !!
At least, we could discuss sbout it and I can try to prove you that I am not.
I am something different from all the neurons that are in my brain and none of the neurons of my brain is me.

Dragonrock wrote:
Perhaps if we were able to slowly remove little pieces of the brain then we would eventually be able to find where the conciousness originates. However, that would be VERY unethical, so all we have is what we learn from people who end up brain damaged from other sources.
Neurologists have already mapped the human brain, where there is the part devoted for language skills, sight, memory.
No part devoted for " self-consciousness " found
 
Nex said:
Good question. I didn't know cats and dogs were self-conscious. If they are, hey, my mistake, I just didn't think we had verified that yet.

No they are not self conscious, they are simply conscious. To be self-conscious is to recognise yourself as a distinct enduring entity.
 
Nex said:
Your argument rests upon the unfalsifiable, which unfortunately makes it very, very weak.

What is this person's argument?

Your opinion is that consciouness stems from a soul.


How do you know this is that person's opinion?

Souls are unfalsifiable. There is no way to prove or disprove your hypothesis.

Are non-souls unfalsifiable too?
 
Interesting Ian said:
No they are not self conscious, they are simply conscious. To be self-conscious is to recognise yourself as a distinct enduring entity.

Proof, please?
 
Interesting Ian said:
Why? You wouldn't understand it. You never understand anything else after all.

Who says I want it for my own benefit? "Mind-numbingly extraordinary claims require mind-numbingly extraordinary evidence."

Now, you are claiming that ONLY humans are self-aware, are you not? Back up the claim.

However, chances are, you either a) have no evidence or b) have once again completely failed to understand scientific evidence, or c) are simply calling scientific facts 'wrong' in light of your own opinion.

Now, are you going to continue this childish cop-out, or will you provide your proof that only Humans are self-aware, as a responsible adult would?
 
Interesting Ian said:
No they are not self conscious, they are simply conscious. To be self-conscious is to recognise yourself as a distinct enduring entity.
My cat rather likes to look at himself in the mirror.
 
Interesting Ian said:
No they are not self conscious, they are simply conscious. To be self-conscious is to recognise yourself as a distinct enduring entity.

OK, but where to draw the line? How (perhaps better ask when and/or in wich species) such trait evolved?

Actually I would like to add that the "enduring" can be disputed, since you can not deny the possibility that what we actually experience is an illusion of consience continuity.


Matteo Martini said:
...snip...
I am not the sum of all my neurons !!
...snip...

No. You are the result of interactions between the activities of all your neurons as well as all your body.

Matteo Martini said:
Neurologists have already mapped the human brain, where there is the part devoted for language skills, sight, memory.
No part devoted for " self-consciousness " found

Note that damaging the brain surely causes negative efects on the consiousness. In some cases, there are personality changes. In others, more dramatic, the person can hardly be called rational or even self-consient.
 
I am not the sum of all my neurons !!
At least, we could discuss sbout it and I can try to prove you that I am not.
I am something different from all the neurons that are in my brain and none of the neurons of my brain is me.

The sum total of all the neurons in your brain contain all your memories, experiances and mental faculties. It is in the brain where all sensory input is processed and evaluated by the individual parts and a thought stream is generated.
Your brain IS you. "You" go wherever your brain goes.

Google lobotomy and the frontal lobe. Most of what we would consider "our personality" and "individual drive" appears to stem from this particular area. So maybe that is where "you" are.

Also google alzhimers, people with that desease undergo a significant personality change.
Yaotl wrote:
" So your definition of being self-conscious is to feel physical pain and pleasure? If that capacity is damaged in someone, are they no longer self-conscious? "
No, being able is to feel physical pain and pleasure is one property that only self-conscious entities have ( men, women, cats, dogs, not tocks ).
Google Kulver-Bucy syndrome.
Also, what level of conciouseness do people with mental retardation posses?
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by Nex
Good question. I didn't know cats and dogs were self-conscious. If they are, hey, my mistake, I just didn't think we had verified that yet.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



No they are not self conscious, they are simply conscious. To be self-conscious is to recognise yourself as a distinct enduring entity.
I have had many dogs and cats and I do believe that they have some level of self-awareness. they give the physical apearance of the experiance of jealousy, happiness, anger, fear, etc. All these behaiviours would seem to mean that the the animal has a sense of individual self. (i.e. that IT is in danger, or not recieving the attention that another is recieving, spitefull or angry that the other animal is recieving attention and not IT...etc..)

My experinace has led to believe that self-awareness and conciousness is not black and white. There are many levels of conciousness.
 
I've said it in another thread:

Show me a human with no electrical impulses in their brain who can still hold a conversation THEN I will consider dualism.
 
Matteo Martini said:
Dragonrock, the analogy with the car does not work, in my opinion.
A car is not different from the sum of its parts, actually " car " is a name we give to wheels, engine, axles, etc.

A car is more than the sum of it's parts. Most of the parts would have no value outside of their use in cars. If there were no cars what good would 500 brake pads do you? Or 250 radiator hoses? How about 100 mufflers? By taking a pile of independently useless parts were are able to create a usefull machine.

Matteo Martini said:
I am not the sum of all my neurons !!
At least, we could discuss sbout it and I can try to prove you that I am not.

No, you aren't the sum of your neurons, but you are the square of your neurons. Neurons interact in a very complex manner making the number of connections many times higher than the number of neurons.

Matteo Martini said:
I am something different from all the neurons that are in my brain and none of the neurons of my brain is me.

Yes, and WindowsXP is different from one line of code and one line of is not WindowsXP. If you are something outside of your neurons then how come hunger makes most people aggresive? Why do low levels of neurotransmitters cause depression? Why did my brother-in-law completely change his taste in food after having a stroke? Physical changes in the brain affect mood and personality.
 
KingMerv00 said:
I've said it in another thread:

Show me a human with no electrical impulses in their brain who can still hold a conversation THEN I will consider dualism.

Go to this thread I just started last night. First post is an entire chapter from a book. Scroll down in that first post until you see the heading:
"Does the Brain Produce or Transmit Consciousness?"

Read it.

Then go to the 3rd post in the thread by me. I reproduce an extract from my forthcoming website. Read that also.
 
Ian, this referenced post in NO way answers his question. And that excerpt you posted, along with your own excerpt, are really ridiculous. But others have already explained this to you repeatedly.
 
Interesting Ian said:
Go to this thread I just started last night. First post is an entire chapter from a book. Scroll down in that first post until you see the heading:
"Does the Brain Produce or Transmit Consciousness?"

Read it.

Then go to the 3rd post in the thread by me. I reproduce an extract from my forthcoming website. Read that also.

I read everything you suggested.

The Brain-Dead Woman:

The author points out the problems in his own theory (that's a good skeptical mind at work) so I won't bother.



The Changing Mind:

You suggest that the mind must always be changing and therefore we could never have a sense of self that is consistant, that you are the same person you were yesterday.

I say this fits just fine with the material mind theory. The brain stores memories as specific configurations of neurons. All the brain must do is maintain these cells in that configuration and the memories will still be there. The idea of being the "same person" is an illusion created by our brain structure and memories.

(On a side note, I am a VERY different person than I was when I was younger.)



Correlation/Causation

The article suggests that just because electrochemical reactions occur at the same time as consciousness does not mean they CAUSE consciousness. Fair enough. However this is not positive evidence for a soul, just wiggle room for a possibility. For the record, I see no evidence for a soul therefore I don't believe in one.

However, the study of brain damage does in fact suggest that the brain causes consciousness.

Take this part of my brain out and I forget stuff. Take that part out and I loose the boundry between myself and the rest of the world etc. etc.


In the end, my statement holds true:

"Show me a human with no electrical impulses in their brain who can still hold a conversation THEN I will consider dualism. "

I remain agnostic on the existance of a soul. The onus is on the person making the positive claim so for now...I don't believe.
 
Answers

Correa Neto wrote:
" You are the result of interactions between the activities of all your neurons as well as all your body "

Dragonrock wrote:
" No, you aren't the sum of your neurons, but you are the square of your neurons. Neurons interact in a very complex manner making the number of connections many times higher than the number of neurons "

uruk wrote:
" Your brain IS you. "You" go wherever your brain goes "

The main opinion on self-consciousness the people on this thread have is that self-consciousness somehow originates from interactions between neurons and synapses in the brain. Even if a person is none of his neurons/synapses, still he is the sum ( squared sum ) of all of them and of their mutual interactions. Is that correct ?

I will try now to disprove this point.

1) I hope it is accepted by everyone that a person is none of its neurons taken singularly. I do not know if neurons are self-conscious or not ( I would rather doubt this, but this is not the point ), but certainly I am not any of my neurons, right ?

2) Now, let' s imagine to take two healthy neurons linked with some synapses, let' s suppose that we can recreate the condition of the body in this lab so that the two neurons can live, transmit signals and operate like if they were in the brain. I do not know if this is technically feasible at the moment, but not too difficult to imagine, right ?

3) Now the two neurons would operate together, all the two single neurons would be living and healthy, but will there be any conscious entity generating from the two neurons ? No. There would be no "very-little-conscious-person-with-a-two-neuron-brain". There would be only two neurons operating, no other self-conscious entity, right ?
If somebody claims that two neurons linked together generate even an exterenely low conscious self-consciousness, then please tell me where this conciousness should be coming from, from the electrical charges ? From what ?

4) Let's start adding neurons, firstly another one, then another one, we will get a bunch of one hundred, one thousand neurons linked together and operating. Will there be generated any kind of self-consciousness here ? Will this very little brain know that he/she is existing ? If you answer yes, please tell me when exactly this brain start to become conscious. If you say that consciousness grows from zero ( no neurons ) to human consciouness ( 100 billion neurons, if I remember well ) then even two or three neurons should generate a little, little, little, little bit of consciouness, right ? Then answer to point 3)

5) Continuing this process we have somehow built a human brain. Do not tell me that we do not know how to do this process, we do not know yet, but there is no conceptual obstacle to overcome, right ?
So, will this brain be conscious or not ?

Dragonrock: your analogy with the car does not work.
The whole point is about self-consciousness.
Human are self-conscious, cars are not ( as far as I know, at least ).

uruk:
" Google lobotomy and the frontal lobe. Most of what we would consider "our personality" and "individual drive" appears to stem from this particular area. So maybe that is where "you" are "
Those you are quoting ( indiivdual drive, personality ) are all attibutes of the individual, they are not the individual.
I am not the sum of my memory, my individual drives, my personality, I am all this plus I know that I am here ( self-consciousness )
I would rather doubt that there is just one part of the brain dedicated to personality ( there is no clear definition of personality agreed to all dictionaries ).
However, even if there would be a part of the brain that explicates why I behave in this way, another one that explicates why I remember things, etc. where is the part of the brain that explicates that I, in this very moment, feel that I am existing ( again, self-consciousness )
 
Re: Answers

Matteo Martini said:
Dragonrock: your analogy with the car does not work.
The whole point is about self-consciousness.
Human are self-conscious, cars are not ( as far as I know, at least ).

Matteo,

I don't know if you don't understand or if you are being deliberately obtuse, but I never said car were self-conscious. My analogy simply pointed out that many things, including our brains, are greater than what they are made of. The brain is a complex organ that we don't have complete understanding of. However, just because we don't understand it doesn't mean that some supernatural force controls it.
 
Dragonrock

" I don't know if you don't understand or if you are being deliberately obtuse "

Please do not start to insult

" I never said car were self-conscious "

I never said you said that, I just pointed out that the analogy does not work.

" My analogy simply pointed out that many things, including our brains, are greater than what they are made of "

I agree with that.
The main point of this thread is to know where self-consciousness comes from. While cars, families, computers are greater than what they are made of but are not self-conscious, the person is. Why ?

" just because we don't understand it doesn't mean that some supernatural force controls it. "
This hypothesis of the " soul " is just an unproven hypothesis among other unproven hypothesis.
 
Re: Answers

Matteo Martini said:
...snip...
I am not the sum of my memory, my individual drives, my personality, I am all this plus I know that I am here ( self-consciousness )
I would rather doubt that there is just one part of the brain dedicated to personality ( there is no clear definition of personality agreed to all dictionaries ).

However, even if there would be a part of the brain that explicates why I behave in this way, another one that explicates why I remember things, etc. where is the part of the brain that explicates that I, in this very moment, feel that I am existing ( again, self-consciousness )


The brain is adaptable. When a give "center" is damaged, other areas may, in a given time, assume their tasks.

Please, don´t jump in to the conclusion that this is proof of an agent external to the brain. An analogy (perhaps a poor one, but I wanted to avoid HD analogies) would be someone who lost the right hand and started to write with the left one (assuming he/she was not left-handed).

The personality of a person will be affected not only if his/her brain is damaged, but also by chemical substances, like hormones. Large electrical shocks may also affect an individual´s personality.

Note that no one here claimed that a particular area of the brain is responsible by self-awareness. The "self", if you want to call the"self-awareness sensation" like this, is generated by the interactions between neurons, body, chemicals, etc. It is dependent of these interactions. Change one of these and you will change the self, eventually terminating it.

As for your brain experiment, well, I think that it would gain counsioussness, if provided with enough stimulae. Note that one could ask when consioussness starts in "naturally-born" humans. Are 6-months old babies consient? Where to draw the line?

And one can ask when it ends. Where to draw the line for people with severe brain damage?
 
" I don't know if you don't understand or if you are being deliberately obtuse "

Please do not start to insult

" I never said car were self-conscious "

I never said you said that, I just pointed out that the analogy does not work because cars are not self-conscious while men are.

" My analogy simply pointed out that many things, including our brains, are greater than what they are made of "

I agree with that.
The main point of this thread is to know where self-consciousness comes from. While cars, families, computers are greater than what they are made of but are not self-conscious, the person is. Why ?

" just because we don't understand it doesn't mean that some supernatural force controls it. "
This hypothesis of the " soul " is an unproven hypothesis among other unproven hypothesis.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom