Matteo Martini
Banned
- Joined
- Dec 6, 2004
- Messages
- 4,561
Yaotl wrote:
" So your definition of being self-conscious is to feel physical pain and pleasure? If that capacity is damaged in someone, are they no longer self-conscious? "
No, being able is to feel physical pain and pleasure is one property that only self-conscious entities have ( men, women, cats, dogs, not tocks ).
My definition of self-conscious individual is a individual who knows that he/she is there, that is existing in that very moment.
Dragonrock, the analogy with the car does not work, in my opinion.
A car is not different from the sum of its parts, actually " car " is a name we give to wheels, engine, axles, etc.
I am not the sum of all my neurons !!
At least, we could discuss sbout it and I can try to prove you that I am not.
I am something different from all the neurons that are in my brain and none of the neurons of my brain is me.
Dragonrock wrote:
No part devoted for " self-consciousness " found
" So your definition of being self-conscious is to feel physical pain and pleasure? If that capacity is damaged in someone, are they no longer self-conscious? "
No, being able is to feel physical pain and pleasure is one property that only self-conscious entities have ( men, women, cats, dogs, not tocks ).
My definition of self-conscious individual is a individual who knows that he/she is there, that is existing in that very moment.
Dragonrock, the analogy with the car does not work, in my opinion.
A car is not different from the sum of its parts, actually " car " is a name we give to wheels, engine, axles, etc.
I am not the sum of all my neurons !!
At least, we could discuss sbout it and I can try to prove you that I am not.
I am something different from all the neurons that are in my brain and none of the neurons of my brain is me.
Dragonrock wrote:
Neurologists have already mapped the human brain, where there is the part devoted for language skills, sight, memory.Perhaps if we were able to slowly remove little pieces of the brain then we would eventually be able to find where the conciousness originates. However, that would be VERY unethical, so all we have is what we learn from people who end up brain damaged from other sources.
No part devoted for " self-consciousness " found