Matteo Martini
Banned
- Joined
- Dec 6, 2004
- Messages
- 4,561
Those three sentences are different, please be careful with the terms:
First) Feelings, thought, and consciousness are tied to brain activity;
Second) Feelings, thought, and consciousness are generated by brain activity;
Third) Feelings, thought, and consciousness are brain activity;
I agree that feelings and thought and maybe even consciousness are tied to brain activity, each one of us can see it on himself/herself that when he/she feels pain his/her brain is giving this or that electric signal.
However, at least feelings and thought, but maybe even to a certain degree consciousness are related to other things as well, your environment, your friends, the rest of your body, ..
When you see your wife you feel well, when you do not see her you feel sad ( or is it the other way around ?? ).
The second one " feelings, thought, and consciousness are generated by brain activity " is not provable and has no scientific ground.
This what I contest to Correa Neto when he says " the "feeling" IS nothing but the result of brain activity ".
If you want to say that since " without a brain, feelings, thought, and consciousness do not exist " then the brain generates conciousness, this is plain wrong.
Even without my blood my consciousness does not exist, because I would be dead ( do not try the experiment on me, though !! ).
So, is blood generating conciousness ??
If you say that, in the future, we will have artificial blood, so that we can live without our " original " blood, I can say, maybe in the future we could have artificial brain, or artificial parts of the brain, so our " original " brain is not needed for consciousness any more.
The third one " Feelings, thought, and consciousness are brain activity " is just saying that apples are oranges.
First) Feelings, thought, and consciousness are tied to brain activity;
Second) Feelings, thought, and consciousness are generated by brain activity;
Third) Feelings, thought, and consciousness are brain activity;
I agree that feelings and thought and maybe even consciousness are tied to brain activity, each one of us can see it on himself/herself that when he/she feels pain his/her brain is giving this or that electric signal.
However, at least feelings and thought, but maybe even to a certain degree consciousness are related to other things as well, your environment, your friends, the rest of your body, ..
When you see your wife you feel well, when you do not see her you feel sad ( or is it the other way around ?? ).
The second one " feelings, thought, and consciousness are generated by brain activity " is not provable and has no scientific ground.
This what I contest to Correa Neto when he says " the "feeling" IS nothing but the result of brain activity ".
If you want to say that since " without a brain, feelings, thought, and consciousness do not exist " then the brain generates conciousness, this is plain wrong.
Even without my blood my consciousness does not exist, because I would be dead ( do not try the experiment on me, though !! ).
So, is blood generating conciousness ??
If you say that, in the future, we will have artificial blood, so that we can live without our " original " blood, I can say, maybe in the future we could have artificial brain, or artificial parts of the brain, so our " original " brain is not needed for consciousness any more.
The third one " Feelings, thought, and consciousness are brain activity " is just saying that apples are oranges.