Where am I ?

Those three sentences are different, please be careful with the terms:

First) Feelings, thought, and consciousness are tied to brain activity;
Second) Feelings, thought, and consciousness are generated by brain activity;
Third) Feelings, thought, and consciousness are brain activity;

I agree that feelings and thought and maybe even consciousness are tied to brain activity, each one of us can see it on himself/herself that when he/she feels pain his/her brain is giving this or that electric signal.
However, at least feelings and thought, but maybe even to a certain degree consciousness are related to other things as well, your environment, your friends, the rest of your body, ..
When you see your wife you feel well, when you do not see her you feel sad ( or is it the other way around ?? ).

The second one " feelings, thought, and consciousness are generated by brain activity " is not provable and has no scientific ground.
This what I contest to Correa Neto when he says " the "feeling" IS nothing but the result of brain activity ".
If you want to say that since " without a brain, feelings, thought, and consciousness do not exist " then the brain generates conciousness, this is plain wrong.
Even without my blood my consciousness does not exist, because I would be dead ( do not try the experiment on me, though !! ).
So, is blood generating conciousness ??
If you say that, in the future, we will have artificial blood, so that we can live without our " original " blood, I can say, maybe in the future we could have artificial brain, or artificial parts of the brain, so our " original " brain is not needed for consciousness any more.

The third one " Feelings, thought, and consciousness are brain activity " is just saying that apples are oranges.
 
Actually, there are plasma-based products that can be used as blood supplements - but even without that, consider this: that of all the parts of a human that are systematically replaced throughout life, the brain (parts of it) is never replaced, more than a few molecules here and there. So, consciousness cannot be connected to any part of the body except the brain. Further, dependancy of the brain on blood does not mean that consciousness exists within blood; only that the organ responsible for consciousness requires blood (at the moment) to survive.

I'm not familiar with debate terms, but doesn't Occam's Razor suggest that the explanation for consciousness that best fits what we know is that consciousness is tied to the brain? Whether generated by the brain, or simply the subjective observation of brain activity, or whatever, there is plenty of evidence that alterations in the brain can also alter consciousness; yet no evidence of consciousness being connected to anything OTHER THAN the brain. You say there is no evidence or reason to suppose consciousness is generated by brain activity; yet, in fact, there is. Meanwhile, there is no evidence whatsoever of any other scenario. So evidence of the brain-consciousness link is all we have - denial of the evidence (not proof, mind you) is unreasonable, since no alternative is available.
 
Zaayrdragon and Matteo,

The key points are:

(i) As zaayrdragon pointed, Matteo does not accepts brain activity as an evidence that toughts "feelings", "counsience", "self-counsience" and "self", are created by the brain. He also does not accept the influence of the satus of the brain and the body in the "feelings", "counsience", "self-counsience" and "self". The way I understood, they, in his concept are somehow independent from the brain status and most likely immutable, an absolute referential (this last idea is something I specially disagree). It´s more a matter of belief or faith than reason. So, I (better write the people who work with this issue) based on the avaliable evidence (brain activity and status can be tied up with counsience), think that is a cause-and-effect relationship, where brain activity and status cause counsience.

(ii) Matteo is using very ellusive and maleable definitions for "feelings", "counsience", "self-counsience" and "self". It precludes, the way he uses it, causative links with brain activity. Brain activity could be a consequence, but not the cause. His positions are coming quite close to the "homuncle" idea. The way I think about them, they are thoughts or groups of thoughts. created by interactions between the brain (stored data included), the body and its environment.

(iii) Matteo also uses arguments that can be summarized as the impossibility of proving anything about anything ("you can´t prove someone feels something"). Such solipsism-inspired arguments, if taken seriously, render every discussions about everything futile. I doubt a serious productive discussion can exist when such argument is raised. Doubts? Check any thread by Lifegazer...

And Matteo, when you write:
"The second one " feelings, thought, and consciousness are generated by brain activity " is not provable and has no scientific ground.
This what I contest to Correa Neto when he says " the "feeling" IS nothing but the result of brain activity . "

You have to prove it is not provable and has no scientific ground. So far, you have not managed to do so. It seems your background is mostly in the humane sciences and philosophy, and this seems to be causing some bias on where you are searching for information as well as in the relative weight of it. And before you say anything, sure, my background might as well quite likely introduce bias in my position.
 
I think that the problem is the se called "QUALIA", the redness of the red, the sensation of pain and not the physical (external observed) reaction.

There are several approachs. Some deny the very existence of this qualia, some other mantain that there are two kind of entities in the world (dualism) and then try to explain the coexistence of the material manifestations (brain and measurements) with the "inmaterial", the I who experience this qualia. For example, supervenience is a theory which tries to reconciliate this dualism.

There is a good argument which tells us that a blind person and a sighted one are talking about the nature of light. Both agree in that it is both particles and waves, its physical properties, wavelenghts, colors, etc. YET, no matter how well the description works, one of them completly LACKS any "true" experience (or knowledge??) regarding the nature of light: he cant see it.

This shows that one thing is what we think, and another different what we experience. Now, I think there are obvious correlates between brain activity and the act of seeing (from the "I" point of view), but Im also aware of some problems with the pretended reduction of experience to brain activity.

There are some studies on "blindsight" when people report they are blind, yet they avoid some objects in their path as if they could see them. This simple fact would illustrate that it is not an easy task to merely "reduce" a sensation to some specific brain activity.

On the other hand, I do think that the self,somehow, is produced by the brain. Well, more exactly, by the brain-world interaction. I would not say that the brain "contains" the self, but rather than this last one is between the world and the brain, its THE FRONTIER so to speak.

But more than that, in a sense, its the source of everything. I believe that the world (yes the familiar world of objects, lights, sounds, gravity, electromagnetism, planets, life forms, etc) is just a construct. This would mean that it is just an interpretation (of several possible) to try to explain both the self and the world, but that it is unnecessary (in terms of casual explanation) if we can hold another point of view.

Oh well, complex subject!
 
Actually, there are plasma-based products that can be used as blood supplements - but even without that, consider this: that of all the parts of a human that are systematically replaced throughout life, the brain (parts of it) is never replaced, more than a few molecules here and there
Well, how can you say that it will never be possible to replace brain ?? You have no proofs about that !!
2000 years ago they thought that the hearth could never be replaced and now we can replace it.
So, maybe in other 200 years, they will build a quantum mechanical or DNA-based supercomputer that may replace one or more parts of the brain.
If:
1) brain is nothing more than neurons, synapses and electric signals;
2) we can already built some prototype of neural-network computer that simulates the brain;
3) tomorrow we could built a microprocessor that replaces the memory of the brain.
Conclusion: if you say that brain generates consciousness because it is the only part of the body that can not be replaced I say that:
1) Also eyes can not be replaced ( never heard of )
2) Hands can not be replaced, you can built something similar to hands with robotics, but nothing similar to the real thing;
3) If you say that in the future eyes, hands and every other parts of the body might be replaced by artificial parts, I say that even the brain will be, there is no obstacle in doing this
It is just modern microprocessor technology that it is not up to the task, but we are getting there ..
However, I read somewhere, that they were starting implanting microchips in the head of people with damages to their arms to improve their movements

Further, dependancy of the brain on blood does not mean that consciousness exists within blood
I could say, dependency of conciousness on brain does not mean that consciuosness exist within the brain

Whether generated by the brain, or simply the subjective observation of brain activity, or whatever, there is plenty of evidence that alterations in the brain can also alter consciousness; yet no evidence of consciousness being connected to anything OTHER THAN the brain
There are wide proofs that feelings ( and I would say consciousness ) are connected with many things other than the brain:
- friends: if you see frineds your feelings change ( alterations in the friends -> alterations in the feelings );
- wife/husband/mother, .., when they die you feel very bad, when they are happy you feel happy ( alterations in family -> alterations in the feelings );
- environment: when you are in a tropical beach or skiing in the montains probably you feel better that when you are in the fog ( ( change in the environment -> alterations in the feelings )
......
The whole world is connected with your feelings, not only your brain and it would be difficult to find something that is not

You say there is no evidence or reason to suppose consciousness is generated by brain activity; yet, in fact, there is
You say that there is evidence or reason to suppose consciousness is generated by brain activity ??
If so, can you provide any piece of evidence ??
Til now nodoby did ..

So evidence of the brain-consciousness link is all we have - denial of the evidence (not proof, mind you) is unreasonable, since no alternative is available
We saw that speaking about " consciousness " is not easy, I would speak about feelings.
So, I provided evidence that there is not only the brain-feelings connection, but also the friend-feeling connection, the mother/wife/father-feeling connection, ..

Matteo does not accepts brain activity as an evidence that toughts "feelings", "counsience", "self-counsience" and "self", are created by the brain
Yes, exactly, there is no evidence that " feelings " are created by the brain.

He also does not accept the influence of the satus of the brain and the body in the "feelings", "counsience", "self-counsience" and "self".
No, that is not correct.
If you look at my previos post, I stated clearly that there is a connection between the brain ( how the status of the brain is ) and the feelings you have.
I deny that the brain creates those feelings !!

The way I understood, they, in his concept are somehow independent from the brain status and most likely immutable
No, feelings are not immutable, maybe the self is not immutable.
And feelings are not independent from the brain.
But if you say that the patterns inside the brain create this or that feeling, I could say that it is the feelings ( generated not by the brain, but by what happens around you ) that create that pattern in your brain.
So, in my opinion, it is like that: what happens around you gives you this or that feeling, and this or that feeling generates this or that pattern in your brain.
It is the other way around, it is not brain activity that generates feelings, it is feeling who generated this or that brain activity.

Matteo is using very ellusive and maleable definitions for "feelings", "counsience", "self-counsience" and "self". It precludes, the way he uses it, causative links with brain activity
I am not elusive, this concepts are difficult to explain !!
This is why I try now to stick to " feelings ", because we all know what it is a feeling.

Brain activity could be a consequence, but not the cause. His positions are coming quite close to the "homuncle" idea
Absolutely yes !!
I do not know what an " homuncle " is, however ..

Matteo also uses arguments that can be summarized as the impossibility of proving anything about anything ("you can´t prove someone feels something"). Such solipsism-inspired arguments, if taken seriously, render every discussions about everything futile
Again, I do not really believe that I am the only conscious being in the Universe !!
I used this argument to disprove you when you said that you could prove " scientifically " that feelings and consciousness are generated from the brain and its activity.

You have to prove it is not provable and has no scientific ground So far, you have not managed to do so
No, here I do not agree.
I already said this in many posts before.
We have feelings, we have brain activity.
I agree that they are related, but I do not agree that brain activity generates feelings.
I believe nothing.
If you say that brain activity generates feelings, it is up to you to back this claim, because it is you who did the claim.
I never stated that I know where feelings come from.
If you say that they come from brain activity, it is up to you to prove this, not up to me to disprove it.
It is the one who makes the claim that has to prove the claim, not the one who contests it that has to prove that the claim is not true.

When you see your wife you feel well, when you do not see her you feel sad ( or is it the other way around ?? ).
I quote myself, now
I just realized that this joke may be intended as a small insult to somebody here.
Of course it was a joke and I was speaking as " you ", not speaking to anybody in particular, but to a general " someone ".
If you prefer, I can change this sentence as " When I see my wife I feel well, when I do not see her I feel sad ( or is it the other way around ?? ). "
So nobody gets offended because of this ..
 
Matteo Martini said:
Well, how can you say that it will never be possible to replace brain ?? You have no proofs about that !!

No, I did not sy it will never be possible. I said that, of all the parts of the human body systematically replaced by natural biological function (I may not have written clearly), the brain is not replaced - only small parts of it are ever replaced. I wasn't speaking of technological replacement of brain.

2000 years ago they thought that the hearth could never be replaced and now we can replace it.

And the entire fireplace, too! :D (just funnin' ya...)

So, maybe in other 200 years, they will build a quantum mechanical or DNA-based supercomputer that may replace one or more parts of the brain.
If:
1) brain is nothing more than neurons, synapses and electric signals;
2) we can already built some prototype of neural-network computer that simulates the brain;
3) tomorrow we could built a microprocessor that replaces the memory of the brain.

And we will, therefore, be able to create a device that generates consciousness. Now - the real trick will be - can we transfer consciousness from the biological brain into the artificial one? (And this begins the argument about whether the 'self' would, in fact, be moved from one to the other, or only copied! A complex issue, indeed...)

Conclusion: if you say that brain generates consciousness because it is the only part of the body that can not be replaced

No, I'm saying that consciousness continues so long as the brain is not affected/influenced/damaged. I'm saying that it is evidence (not proof!) that consciousness must be connected to the brain - whether generated or an intrinsic feature or what remains to be seen.

I say that:
1) Also eyes can not be replaced ( never heard of )
2) Hands can not be replaced, you can built something similar to hands with robotics, but nothing similar to the real thing;
3) If you say that in the future eyes, hands and every other parts of the body might be replaced by artificial parts, I say that even the brain will be, there is no obstacle in doing this
It is just modern microprocessor technology that it is not up to the task, but we are getting there ..
However, I read somewhere, that they were starting implanting microchips in the head of people with damages to their arms to improve their movements

As I explained, you misunderstood me. I agree that every part of human anatomy can and will eventually be replaced. However, I contend that the consciousness is necessarily connected to the brain. If we have the technology to replace 100% of a human, then we have the technology to create androids. Meaning we could then make a fully artificial being. We would then have to assume that being to be conscious, wouldn't we?

Now, let's say that a person suffers massive brain damage. Doctors go in and replace his brain with an artificial brain. Assuming we somehow had all of the victim's memories, brain patterns, etc. we may well be restoring 'self' to this person - or we may be simply replacing this person with a copy.

Whatever the case, the body, alive (artificially) without the brain has no self, no consciousness. So such attributes must be a part of the brain!

I could say, dependency of conciousness on brain does not mean that consciuosness exist within the brain

That is treating consciousness as if it were a physical thing. If, instead, it is a property or product, then it must necessarily exist within or as a part of some physical thing. So the question must become: what is consciousness? Materialism says it must be a property or product (as in, the net combined effect of neural activity, etc.) of a physical object or process. Dualism suggests that there may be non-physical things that are not properties or products of physical things - but as no proof of this has been offered, I tend to reject dualism (on an intellectual level).

So dependency of a property of the brain on that brain is logically necessary.

There are wide proofs that feelings ( and I would say consciousness ) are connected with many things other than the brain:

Yes, and I'm not suggesting that such things exist within a vacuum - rather, without the brain, feelings, etc. are not possible at all. Each example you provide engenders changes within the brain that alters the state of feeling/thought/emotion/consciousness within the brain (and also, the body, as emotions are also tied to bodily processes, as well).

The whole world is connected with your feelings, not only your brain and it would be difficult to find something that is not

Yet remove the brain, and you have no capacity to have feelings, etc. Remove these outer influences, and your feelings, etc. would still exist, though in different states due to lack of influences.

Think of sensory deprivation tanks. Do you think the person in those tanks has no thoughts, no feelings, no consciousness, no self?

You say that there is evidence or reason to suppose consciousness is generated by brain activity ??
If so, can you provide any piece of evidence ??
Til now nodoby did ..

I could google up some evidence - but then, we can google up 'evidence' for anything we like.

But I consider the following to be evidence:
1) Chemicals affecting the brain can alter the state of consciousness artificially
2) Surgery and brain trauma can alter consciousness considerably. Possibly even remove the 'sense of self'.
3) Off all the parts of the body that can be artificially replaced, whether by integrated parts or external apparatus, consciousness continues - this would imply that consciousness cannot be tied to any body system which can be replaced with artificial process. This leaves very few organs capable of housing or having the property of consciousness - of those, only the brain is responsible for thought, memory, decision, sensory processing, awareness, etc. and therefore is the only organ available for consciousness processing.
4) Nothing without a brain has any form of consciousness (that we are aware of). Nor has 'disembodied consciousness' ever been proven to exist.

Taken as a whole, these factors are clear evidence that consciousness is inherently tied to the brain activity (saying, 'To the brain' might imply that dead brains have consciousness, which they do not). Semantical arguments would exist as to whether consciousness is a 'property of brain activity' or a 'product of brain activity'... I say that the brain 'generates' consciousness because I say that consciousness is brain activity, interactions between neurons, etc. Another bit of evidence - a brain whose neurons are prevented from interacting chemically also has no consciousness.

So I'd say, yes, some evidence does exist that the brain generates 'consciousness'.

We saw that speaking about " consciousness " is not easy, I would speak about feelings.
So, I provided evidence that there is not only the brain-feelings connection, but also the friend-feeling connection, the mother/wife/father-feeling connection, ..

I addressed 'consciousness' because feelings are resultant upon interaction with environment and/or memory and/or bodily process. Consider: it is possible to chemically suppress fear by inhibiting certain bodily processes. So feelings are a combination brain-body effect. But without a 'brain', feelings become impossible.

Yes, exactly, there is no evidence that " feelings " are created by the brain.

The rest of your post I leave to others... there's my thoughts, for the moment.
 
Matteo Martini said:
...snip...
I could say, dependency of conciousness on brain does not mean that consciuosness exist within the brain


There are wide proofs that feelings ( and I would say consciousness ) are connected with many things other than the brain:
- friends: if you see frineds your feelings change ( alterations in the friends -> alterations in the feelings );
- wife/husband/mother, .., when they die you feel very bad, when they are happy you feel happy ( alterations in family -> alterations in the feelings );
- environment: when you are in a tropical beach or skiing in the montains probably you feel better that when you are in the fog ( ( change in the environment -> alterations in the feelings )
......
The whole world is connected with your feelings, not only your brain and it would be difficult to find something that is not

What if the "feelings", the "counsience", the "self-counsience" and the "self" are nothing but reactions of the brain to the inputs generated by the external world, the body and the data stored in the brain. Note that this can also be used as a very non-elusive definition for these features...

Actually, that´s exactly what you described- a response provided by the brain, triggered by stimulae, based in previous experiences (stored data). Nothing that you wrote is an evidence that brain/body/environment interaction is the sourcec of counsience, self-counsience, the sefl and feelings. Many immaterialists deny such possibility, since it would preclude (depending on the definition used ) free will and deny the existence of anything else composing the self other than brain activity, and turn us in to mere zombies (according to their views, that I think are too much anthropocentric).

Matteo Martini said:
...You say that there is evidence or reason to suppose consciousness is generated by brain activity ??
If so, can you provide any piece of evidence ??
Til now nodoby did ..

See above and below. There are evidences that consciousness is generated by brain activity (see other posts for listing). There is no way you can deny it unless you want to stick to arguments that render any discussions about anything improductive and useless.

Matteo Martini said:
We saw that speaking about " consciousness " is not easy, I would speak about feelings.

It does not matter if you are talking about "feelings", "counsiossness", "self-counsiousness or self. the reasoning is the same.

So, I provided evidence that there is not only the brain-feelings connection, but also the friend-feeling connection, the mother/wife/father-feeling connection, ..


Matteo Martini said:
...Yes, exactly, there is no evidence that " feelings " are created by the brain.

Are there any evidences that they aren´t? Please, There are evidences that they are.

Matteo Martini said:
No, that is not correct.
If you look at my previos post, I stated clearly that there is a connection between the brain ( how the status of the brain is ) and the feelings you have.
I deny that the brain creates those feelings !!

Based on what? There are no solid basis for your denial. You are presenting a faith-based argument.

Matteo Martini said:
No, feelings are not immutable, maybe the self is not immutable.
And feelings are not independent from the brain.
But if you say that the patterns inside the brain create this or that feeling, I could say that it is the feelings ( generated not by the brain, but by what happens around you ) that create that pattern in your brain.
So, in my opinion, it is like that: what happens around you gives you this or that feeling, and this or that feeling generates this or that pattern in your brain.

What you described is nothing more than a reaction triggered by external stimulae. No need for nothing else than brain activity. And note that the self IS mutable, since it changes according to new experiences and your brain status (too much damage, or too little brain activity = no self).

Matteo Martini said:
It is the other way around, it is not brain activity that generates feelings, it is feeling who generated this or that brain activity.

And what generates the feeling? And why there is no self when there´s no brain activity? Your claim is an act of faith. Do you have any evidence backing it?

Matteo Martini said:
Again, I do not really believe that I am the only conscious being in the Universe !!
I used this argument to disprove you when you said that you could prove " scientifically " that feelings and consciousness are generated from the brain and its activity.

But you are using an argument that is invoked by solipsists, that is useless since it precludes any discussion about anthing if assumed as correct. It may sound correct from some phylosophical points of view, but is one of the most (if not the most) futile arguments that can be used. Forgive the rude analogy, but its effect in a discussion can be the same as farting when talking at close quarters with other people...


Matteo Martini said:

I believe nothing.
If you say that brain activity generates feelings, it is up to you to back this claim, because it is you who did the claim.
I never stated that I know where feelings come from.
If you say that they come from brain activity, it is up to you to prove this, not up to me to disprove it.
It is the one who makes the claim that has to prove the claim, not the one who contests it that has to prove that the claim is not true.

Sorry, but you´ve just caught yourself in a contradiction. A few lines above you claimed that " it is feeling who generated this or that brain activity. ". Now show evidence for it.

Oh, and the evidence has already been shown. You don´t accept it, and you are free to do so. But don´t forget that actually your "freedom" or "free will" is limited by the choices avaliable to you;) .
 
OK,
I will try to sum up our conclusions in a schematic way:

1) We have feelings, we have consciousness and we have the brain;
2) We all agree that feelings, consciousness and brain are somehow related;
3) Correa Neto states that the kind of relation between brain and feelings is the relation that the brain creates the feelings, when asked for evidence in his posts he always says " see other posts for listing ", " see other posts for evidence ", however, I looked at all the other posts and there is no evidence fot that. If you have a proof that " the brain creates the feelings " is something you can prove, please do not tell me to look at other posts, do me a favour and do " cut and paste " and provide me the arguments; if you give me evidence that " the brain creates the feelings " I will declare that you are right and I will quit this discussion;
4) If you say that the fact that " brain and feelings are related " implies that " the brain generates the feeling " I say that there are other explanations possible ( see point no. 5 )
5) Why do we feel good when we see a friend?
Explanation of Correa Neto: you see a friend, the image of the friend gets into your eyes, then to your brain, the brain recognizes the image of the friend as " pleasurable ", the brain creates the pattern " joy " in the brain, you feel joy.
Alternative explanation of Matteo: it is not the brain which creates the feelings, but are the feelings which create this or that pattern in the brain:
Example, you see a friend, the image of the freind goes to your eye, then to the brain, the brain decodes this image as the image of the friend you like, you feel happy and, because you felt happy, your brain gets a certain pattern of activity
So in this case the feeling that you have generates the pattern of " joy " in your brain and not the other way around;
6) Do not say that I have no proof that the " feelings " create the pattern of pain and other feelings in the brain, because I know it !! I have no proof of this alternative explanation;
7) Therefore we have two explanation possible to how feelings ( and consciousness ) are related to the brain; Correa Neto says that it is the brain which creates the feelings and Matteo who says that are the " feelings " who create this or that pattern in the activity of the brain; in Neto's view the brain is the cause and the feeling the effect, in Matteo's view when a person get this or that feeling, it is the feeling which creates this or that pattern of activity in the brain, therefore it is the feeling the cause and this of that pattern of " joy " or " sadness " in the brain the effect;
8) Since both this explanations have no proof we can not say which is right and which is wrong ( if Correa Neto has any proof that it is the brain that creates the feeling, please do not tell me " go look " but provide me with the argument to back your claims )
9) A third explanation could be possible, it is the " soul " that creates both the feelings and the brain activity;

Matteo
 
Just for the record... (as I seem to be ignored in present discussion:p )

The brain causes all feelings. One can make someone to feel scared or that he/she loves someone else with the right amount of neurochemicals. There is nothing misterious about this.

Every sensation or feeling is chemical, not in the sense of the sensation itself (I concede that) but yes if we are talking about causality.
 
Bodhi Dharma Zen,
yes, sorry.
The problem is that, since I am engaged in a very interesting but very difficult discussion with Correa Neto, I ( and maybe Correa as well, even if I do not want to speak for others ) tend to focus only in answering to him :)

The brain causes all feelings. One can make someone to feel scared or that he/she loves someone else with the right amount of neurochemicals. There is nothing misterious about this
Seems that I am left alone here.
No, Bodhi Dharma Zen, I disagree that the brain causes feelings.
Can you make me fall in love, injecting in me some neurochemicals ??
If I do not like opera, can you make me appreciate opera injecting in me neurochemicals ??
No.

Every sensation or feeling is chemical, not in the sense of the sensation itself (I concede that) but yes if we are talking about causality
It is the other way around.
Let' suppose that, under a brain scan, every time you feel well, the area "b1" of your brain becomes blue.
Now, you and Correa Neto and others say that it is the area " b1 " of the brain that generates that specific feeling while I say it is that feeling that makes the area " b1 " of the brain become blue.

It is the feeling which creates a pattern in the brain and not a pattern in the brain which creates the feeling.
 
Lets not discuss for now in what you believe or what I believe. How can you explain this experiment. Mouses are known to form life long relationships between specific couples, they are monogamus.

If a male encounters a female without his mate (lets suppose its dead) it will kill the progeny of the other mouse and stay with its new couple to procreate.

Now, here comes the tricky part, if you restrict the production of certain chemical in the female the male will kill its own progeny and leave the female.

If, on the other hand, you artificialy produce the same chemical in the female, any male that it is arround will protect her progeny, even when its not his, in case there are no progeny, it will remain with the female.

They are chemically attached.

Now, the really "strange" thing comes when dealing with humans, because the same happens to them! A mother will produce the very same substance and the father will be completly lost in love and incredible attached to her, if this substance is not present... Well, I guess you can guess what I am going to tell.

Of course things are not oversimplified as in my little example, but for me seems an obvious confirmation. Sensations of love and attachment are chemical. Of course its not an isolated example, there are more for other emotions.

When you ascribe causal agency to feelings, you automatically believe that those feelings are independant from the body. But then you face the need to explain the nature of those feelings, how can they be independent of the body, and with luck, demonstrate a case in which the body does not change and the feeling are still there.

Now, maybe we need to go back to what you are trying to express with "feelings". Did you read, at all, my post regarding "QUALIA"??
 
Bodhi Dharma,
what you have just said is that, putting some chemicals in your body ( brain ) you affect the behaviour of mice ( and even people ).
This is because the brain and the self ( or the " feelings " ) are related.
I agree that the brain and the self are related and that if you put a chemical in your brain ( LSD, other drugs ), this affects your " feelings ".
But this only proves that the brain and the " feelings " are related one with the other, not that the brain produces the feelings !!

Now, if you say that you can drive other people' s behaviour using chemicals please tell me how to do it !!
If you say that, putting some chemicals in a beautiful blonde's beer, this blonde will completely fall in love with me, please tell me the name of this chemical, I can pay you a huge amount of money !!

When you ascribe causal agency to feelings, you automatically believe that those feelings are independant from the body
I never said that the feelings are indipendent from the body and the brain, feelings are dependent from the body, the brain, the environment, the persons around you, .. and not just the brain.

Did you read, at all, my post regarding "QUALIA"??
I am sorry, did not have the time, busy to answer to Correa Neto. :)
But I am going to read it right now.
 
OK, I will now try to post the way I see the relationship between brain, the self, the feelings, etc.
It will be a methaphysical explanation, so I can provide no " proofs ", but I think it is an explanation which could be interesting for some.
So, let' s look at the world, we see cars, trees, etc.
However, as science teaches us, what we see it seems to be out there is not what it actually is out there.
When I look at a red brick, it seems to me " red " and " full inside ", that is without empty spaces in the inside.
However, science that that brick is not " full inside ", but it is made up by molecules and atoms, and the atoms are more " empty " than " full ", that is, the space occupied by an atom ( protons and neutrons ) is little if compared with the space between an atom and the closest atom.
Also, science teaches that there is no colour " red " in that brick, just a property of the surface of that brick that does not reflects some wavelengths of the light that hits the brick.
Same way, now we now that the stars in the sky are not drops of milk, that the moon is not a piece of cheese, ..
In the world there are not " two " objects, each object is different from the other
Calling a car as a " car " is our mental construction.
Even more, in the world as it is there are no objects at all ( each object is made up by matter and there is no border between one object and the outstanding world )
Just to tell that the world how it is is different from the world as how we see it.
Science is the tentative of the men to move from the " world-as-we-see-it " to the "world as-it-is"
Progress of science gives us an insight of the "world as-it-is" and the higher our scientific knowledge the more we can know about this "world as-it-is"
We already know that we will not be able to know "world as-it-is" completely, science is a never-ending process, we know that matter is not " full ", but it is made up of atoms, atoms are made up by protons, neutrons and electrons, all the protons are made up by quarks, ..
At each progress we make in scientific knowledge, we get closer to understand "world as-it-is", but the complete knowledge of "world as-it-is" is outside the reach of scientific knowledge; even if we found an " ultimate truth " about the world we would never know that this is an ultimate truth.
Now let' s look at the subject, " us ".
The problem here is " where are we ?? ", or " where am I ?? "
In other words, where is my " self " ??
Some people here say that the " self is or is created by the brain.
Again, there is a discussion going on about this, but in my opinion the self ( and the feelings ) are not created by the brain.
So, where is the " self " ??
Let me ask you a question: what can you look at with your left eye ??
You can look ath this chair, at the sky, at another person, but can you look with your left eye at your left eye ??
No.
You can look with your left eye to a photo of your left eye, to a mirror, but not really look at your left eye.
Second question: with a finger you can touch everything, but you can not touch the same finger !!
So, the self exists, can " look " and " understand " many things, but can not see itself !!
This is why we can understand something of our mind ( our " self " ) but we can not see our mind anywhere.
So the " self " can not see the self, therefore the deep nature of the self is not the brain, is not the body, it is outside the reach of scientific exploration.
So, both the " world as-it-is " and the self are outside the reach of human knowledge.

The selves of the people ( and of the animals ) are in the "world as-it-is" and the "world as-it-is" is around all the selves.
Now, I do not think that the borderline between the " self " and the "world as-it-is" is straight.
Let' s think as the self as a white dot on a black surface ( the "world as-it-is" )
On this black surface ( the "world as-it-is" ) there are many white dots ( all the " selves " ), however, the bordeline between the white dots and the black surface is not straight, there is a gray zone between the self and the "world as-it-is".
The body, the brain and the " world-as-we-see-it " belong to this gray zone, between the " self " and "world as-it-is": they are not 100 % subject ( " self " ) and not 100 % object ( "world as-it-is" ), they are a mix of subject and object.
The body is the part of the gray zone closer to the " self ", it is more white than black, it is light gray; the body and the brain are close to the self because the self can interact directly with the body; however the body and the brain are not 100 % pure subject because they are also part of the world, the body and the brain work in the physical world, they respond to gravity.
The body and the brain are very close to the self, because the self can " interact " with the world using the body and using the brain, so the body and the brain are " between " the " self " and the "world as-it-is".
Also in the gray area there is the " world-as-we-see-it ", that is, the world we look at every day.
The " world-as-we-see-it " is not 100 % subject and not 100 % object, still is closer to the object ( "world as-it-is" ) than the body and the brain.
This is because, while with the body we have a direct contact, we do not have the same direct contact with the world outside, we can not move a fork with our mind ( even if Uri Geller thinks so ), but we can move our arm with our mind.
This is why our body is closer to the self than the outside environment ( " world-as-we-see-it " ).
I said that the pure object ( the " world-as-it-is " ) it outside the reach of knowledge, so what is the " world-as-we-see-it " ??
The " world-as-we-see-it " is the world that we look at every minute, the world as we know it.
If I look at a red brick, at the blue sky, at that tree, that' s the " world-as-we-see-it ".
Of course, this is not the "world as-it-is", because we know that, in " reality " that brick is not red, we " see " it red, but this is just because some wavelenght of light are reflected by the brick surface and others do not.
However, when we look at that brick we do not see " wavelenghts ", we see the colour " red ".
So, if the colour " red " is not part of the pure object ( the " world as-it-is" ), where does it come from ??
There is no other answer than this: we " give " the colour red to that object, we give the colour " blue " to the sky, etc.
Similiarly, we give that portion of matter the name " brick ", but there is no " brick " there, just a bunch of molecules.
So, the " world-as-we-see-it " is not 100% object, but it is also subject, so it is partly object partly subject.

I hope this I have written is more or less clear.
 
Reply to Bodhi Dharma

Reply to Bodhi Dharma ( post about the " qualia " )

Third post in a row, getting boring ??

Hope not.

There are several approachs. Some deny the very existence of this qualia, some other mantain that there are two kind of entities in the world (dualism) and then try to explain the coexistence of the material manifestations (brain and measurements) with the "inmaterial", the I who experience this qualia. For example, supervenience is a theory which tries to reconciliate this dualism.

Read this over and over but still can not understand it ..

There are some studies on "blindsight" when people report they are blind, yet they avoid some objects in their path as if they could see them

Mm..
Do not get me wrong, but I do not really believe this ..

Well, more exactly, by the brain-world interaction. I would not say that the brain "contains" the self, but rather than this last one is between the world and the brain, its THE FRONTIER so to speak.
Yes !!
I do believe this as well.
Please, if you can read my last post ..

But more than that, in a sense, its the source of everything
You are speaking about the self ??
The self is the source of everything ??
This might be possible, but do not you believe that the world outside can exist even without the " self " ( i. e. if all the people die ?? )

I believe that the world (yes the familiar world of objects, lights, sounds, gravity, electromagnetism, planets, life forms, etc) is just a construct
No, I believe that the world exists even without the self, so it is not created by the self
 
Matteo Martini said:

... Calling a car as a " car " is our mental construction.
Even more, in the world as it is there are no objects at all ( each object is made up by matter and there is no border between one object and the outstanding world )...

... So, both the " world as-it-is " and the self are outside the reach of human knowledge...

... So, the " world-as-we-see-it " is not 100% object, but it is also subject, so it is partly object partly subject.

I fully agree with those statements. :D If you can read spanish I think you will find this text very interesting:

http://www.redcientifica.com/doc/doc200105030001.html

EDIT:

I just read your last post, essentially, I think we have reached the same conclusions, a word more or a word less. ;)
 
Matteo Martini said:
...snip...
Correa Neto states that the kind of relation between brain and feelings is the relation that the brain creates the feelings, when asked for evidence in his posts he always says " see other posts for listing ", " see other posts for evidence ", however, I looked at all the other posts and there is no evidence fot that. If you have a proof that " the brain creates the feelings " is something you can prove, please do not tell me to look at other posts, do me a favour and do " cut and paste " and provide me the arguments; if you give me evidence that " the brain creates the feelings " I will declare that you are right and I will quit this discussion; ...snip...

Here they go, summarized. But I doubt you will change your mind for two reasons: (i) your main argument is that nothing can be proved about anything (what in my opinion is a worthless assumptiom) and (ii) you interpretate that the following are just symptoms, and not the cause. Note that if you do not agree with much of what´s written below, you should reffer your questioning not to me, but to specialists in the propper fields.

(a) Brain activity, as acessed by instruments, can be linked to counsiousness states, toughts, and feelings. The results are reproductible;
(b) Brain damage alters the self, counsiousness, feelings, etc. reproductible patterns of brain activity can be derived;
(c) Counsioussness, self, feelings, thoughts, all of them can be influentiated by chemical substances injected in the body. Actually they are affected by substances produced by the very body;
(d) The self, self-counsioussness and cousience are mutable, and there is a reproductive relationship between brain activity and their states. Example- at a dreamless sleep or at a deep coma, there are no self, no self-counsience, no feelings, and just traces of brain activity.

Untill now I´ve displayed avaliable data on the relationships between brain activity and counsioussness, self, self-counsiousness, toughts, etc...

Now, at least two major hypothesis can be created (lets skip middle-terms and note that the soul is a mere variant of the second hypothesis).

(1) Counsioussness, self, self-counsiousness, toughts, etc. are product of brain activity
(2) Brain activity is created by counsioussness, self, self-counsiousness, toughts, etc.

Now, what´s more likely? Don´t say both are, because they are not! Occam´s razor will slash option (2). Why?

Because it creates much more problems than (1). Examples:
(a) What then causes counsiousness, self, self-counsiousness, toughts, etc.?
(b) What happens with the counsiousness, self, self-counsiousness, toughts, etc., while there is no brain activity? Where they are? Why can´t they be detected?
... I could go on, but these are enough for now.

And where are your evidences that brain activity is a product of toughts and feelings? You don´t have them, right? And so, how can you ask me evidence and keep yourself from displaying them? Why must I present evidence? Specially because your single and only answer is "you can´t prove it". Why should you be spared from the trouble, specially because you also made a claim?

What backs your position? Nothing but intuition and faith. The "you can´t prove" argument is, again, useless. If you continue with this line all further discussion about anything, including if its rainy or sunny, is useless.

What´s more likely- a claim based on evidence and logic or an unsubstantiated one, based in nothing but intuition and faith?

Matteo Martini said:
...snip...but can you look with your left eye at your left eye ??...snip...

Yes -and without using a mirror. All I need to do is bend space-time so the ligth will make a circle.

Matteo Martini said:
...snip...with a finger you can touch everything, but you can not touch the same finger !...snip...

Yes one can. By coming back in time and meeting with him/herself ...

All your reasoning, even tough I agree with a couple of things, still does not backs your claim that "the " world as-it-is " and the self are outside the reach of human knowledge." But that´s another discussion. And the "you can´t prove" argument is, again, useless. I shall no longer discuss anything else if you insist on using it, for it´ll render any discussion about anything, pointless.
;)
 
Correa Neto,
until now I did change my mind in soame points and your arguments have been very interesting to me, and made me think critically about my own assumptions and therefore have been useful.
I do not think the only goal of this discussion is to convince the other that he is wrong, even if we stay on our positions, still the discussion is becoming useful to me and we can understand better each other positions.

And I do not think that my " theory " ( if you had the time to read it all ) solves all the problems, in particular, it has two major flaws:

1) it is true that with my left eye I can not see my left eye, but I can look at another person' s left eye. How comes that I can not see his/her self, however ??

2) If there is a " subject ", a pure " self " that we can not see but it exists, there is the problem to understand who are these subjects: humans are subjects, dogs probably, but amoebas ?? And viruses ?? And trees ??

Those two flaws could be solved assuming the " solipsistic " hypothesis but we both agree that we do not want that ..

Now, you did a good job summarizing each other's positions in your scheme, so I will reply to you in the same order:

a) " Brain activity, as acessed by instruments, can be linked to counsiousness states, toughts, and feelings. The results are reproductible ", we do agree that brain acitivity can be related ( I do not know if in full or partially ) to feelings;
b) " Brain damage alters the self, counsiousness, feelings, etc. reproductible patterns of brain activity can be derived "; not only brainactivity alters your consciousness, feelings, but also all the world around you alters your consciousness and feelings; it is true that if someone inhales cocaine he/she will feel excited, he/she will make gorgeus plans for his/her future, become maybe megalomaniac, but the same thing can happen to him/her if he/she wins the lottery; it is true that, after having used heroine you get into big depression and maybe you statr to think about suicide, but the same happens to you maybe if somebody you love dies; it is true that injecting chemicals into your brain you alter your perceptions with the external enviroinment, but also wearing a glove alters your tactile perceptions with the environment, wearing glasses alters your visual perceptions with the environment; in conclusion, not only brain damages alters the self, consciousness, feelings but all your world does this ( your body, your friends, your family, etc. ), your self is not connected only with your brain, but with the whole world. I do agree, however, that the brain is the part of the outstanding world that is closer to the self ( or the part of the self which is farther from the outstanding world ).

c) Counsioussness, self, feelings, thoughts, all of them can be influentiated by chemical substances injected in the body. Actually they are affected by substances produced by the very body; I talked about this in point b)

(d) " The self, self-counsioussness and cousience are mutable, and there is a reproductive relationship between brain activity and their states. Example- at a dreamless sleep or at a deep coma, there are no self, no self-counsience, no feelings, and just traces of brain activity. ", yes but there is always the hypothesis that is because the self is not-existing that the brain activity is low and not the other way around.

Now, at least two major hypothesis can be created (lets skip middle-terms and note that the soul is a mere variant of the second hypothesis).

(1) Counsioussness, self, self-counsiousness, toughts, etc. are product of brain activity
(2) Brain activity is created by counsioussness, self, self-counsiousness, toughts, etc.

Now, what´s more likely? Don´t say both are, because they are not! Occam´s razor will slash option (2). Why?

Because it creates much more problems than (1). Examples:
(a) What then causes counsiousness, self, self-counsiousness, toughts, etc.?
(b) What happens with the counsiousness, self, self-counsiousness, toughts, etc., while there is no brain activity? Where they are? Why can´t they be detected?
... I could go on, but these are enough for now.

Well, Occam' s razor says that, when comparing theories you should prefer simpler theories that ecplain the same phenomenon/phenomena equally well

It seems to me that you fail to mention that even the theory number 1 which you support has problems which I underlined in the previous posts:

1) You say that brain activity generates the " self ", consciousness and the feelings, but how is this possible ?? Brain activity is nothing more than electric signals inside the brain and nothing more, how is it possible that electric signals inside the brain create a " feelings " ?? In nature eletric signals do not create anything like that, only magnetic fields but not feelings.
My alarm clock has " electric signals " inside, but I do no think it has " feelings " as well !! Yes, brian activity is something more than electric signals, it is also neurons moving, synapses moving etc. but how do you explain that a cell moving creates a " feeling " ??
2) Yes, you say that it is not " one " neuron that creates the " self ", not even electric signals alone, but it is the " whole " thing together. However, the " whole thing " does not mean much to me. If electric signals and cells moving creates a " self " or a " feeling ", we should see " selfs " coming out from microwave heaters ( they have electric signals ) or from the skin of our legs ( they have " cells moving ). Nothing like that happens, so why is it only our brain where this strange phenomenon that electric signals create consciousness happens ?? And please do not tell me that it is a question of " quantity ", that only if you have 1 billion electric signals you have consciousness while if you have only 1 million or one hundred you do not have, this does not make much sense in my opinion, or you would have to agree that our microwave heater has a consciousness and a self, only that this is " very little ".

Yes -and without using a mirror. All I need to do is bend space-time so the ligth will make a circle
Yes one can. By coming back in time and meeting with him/herself
You are having fun of me, I assume, or are you serious ??

All your reasoning, even tough I agree with a couple of things, still does not backs your claim that "the " world as-it-is " and the self are outside the reach of human knowledge
Well, at least I hope that you agree that " the-world-as-it-is " is outside the reach of human knowledge. How do you prove that you have the " final truth " about anything in this world ?? The history of scientific discovery is a history of ideas that are areated, discussed, analyzed and then proved wrong in some cases, which leads to a better theory which is created, discussed, analyzed, etc.
 
Matteo Martini said:
Correa Neto,
until now I did change my mind in soame points and your arguments have been very interesting to me, and made me think critically about my own assumptions and therefore have been useful.
I do not think the only goal of this discussion is to convince the other that he is wrong, even if we stay on our positions, still the discussion is becoming useful to me and we can understand better each other positions.

And I do not think that my " theory " ( if you had the time to read it all ) solves all the problems, in particular, it has two major flaws:

1) it is true that with my left eye I can not see my left eye, but I can look at another person' s left eye. How comes that I can not see his/her self, however ??

2) If there is a " subject ", a pure " self " that we can not see but it exists, there is the problem to understand who are these subjects: humans are subjects, dogs probably, but amoebas ?? And viruses ?? And trees ??

First of all, you must define what exactly would you mean by "seeing the self". These are not problems at all, either in the case of brain activitygenerates the self or the self generates brain activity. Of course, both are quite easier to solve if one considers that brain activity generates the self.

You would not be able to experience someone else´s self if its a product of brain activity, and/or depends on each individual´s particularities.

As for the second, its a matter not only of definition, but also of sophistication and complexity when it comes to data processing and interaction with the environment. Viruses, many biologist say, may be at the border between living beings and non-living things. An analogy can be applied. Ask yourself when can you e considered counsient? Since when (in terms of age) can you consider yourself a counsient being? Rather than a sharp boundary, you will most likely end up with a transition, a blurred zone.

Matteo Martini said:
Now, you did a good job summarizing each other's positions in your scheme, so I will reply to you in the same order:

a) " Brain activity, as acessed by instruments, can be linked to counsiousness states, toughts, and feelings. The results are reproductible ", we do agree that brain acitivity can be related ( I do not know if in full or partially ) to feelings;
b) " Brain damage alters the self, counsiousness, feelings, etc. reproductible patterns of brain activity can be derived "; not only brainactivity alters your consciousness, feelings, but also all the world around you alters your consciousness and feelings; it is true that if someone inhales cocaine he/she will feel excited, he/she will make gorgeus plans for his/her future, become maybe megalomaniac, but the same thing can happen to him/her if he/she wins the lottery; it is true that, after having used heroine you get into big depression and maybe you statr to think about suicide, but the same happens to you maybe if somebody you love dies; it is true that injecting chemicals into your brain you alter your perceptions with the external enviroinment, but also wearing a glove alters your tactile perceptions with the environment, wearing glasses alters your visual perceptions with the environment; in conclusion, not only brain damages alters the self, consciousness, feelings but all your world does this ( your body, your friends, your family, etc. ), your self is not connected only with your brain, but with the whole world. I do agree, however, that the brain is the part of the outstanding world that is closer to the self ( or the part of the self which is farther from the outstanding world ).

c) Counsioussness, self, feelings, thoughts, all of them can be influentiated by chemical substances injected in the body. Actually they are affected by substances produced by the very body; I talked about this in point b)

(d) " The self, self-counsioussness and cousience are mutable, and there is a reproductive relationship between brain activity and their states. Example- at a dreamless sleep or at a deep coma, there are no self, no self-counsience, no feelings, and just traces of brain activity. ", yes but there is always the hypothesis that is because the self is not-existing that the brain activity is low and not the other way around.

So, if the self "shuts down" when brain activity is low, then is quite likely that brain activity generates the self. Specially because when you are very tired, its your body who "orders" you to sleep untill its rested. Sure, sleep can be induced, but the way I think, its a two-way path: the brain generates the self, but the self can, up to a certain point, influentiate the boy and the brain. Not unlike softwares that block bad sectors at a HD.

And as you pointed, maybe there´s no self, but just an illusion built by a group of thoughts and sensations. Thoughts and sensations built within the brain.

Matteo Martini said:
It seems to me that you fail to mention that even the theory number 1 which you support has problems which I underlined in the previous posts:

1) You say that brain activity generates the " self ", consciousness and the feelings, but how is this possible ?? Brain activity is nothing more than electric signals inside the brain and nothing more, how is it possible that electric signals inside the brain create a " feelings " ?? In nature eletric signals do not create anything like that, only magnetic fields but not feelings.
My alarm clock has " electric signals " inside, but I do no think it has " feelings " as well !! Yes, brian activity is something more than electric signals, it is also neurons moving, synapses moving etc. but how do you explain that a cell moving creates a " feeling " ??


No, I haven´t ignored them. I have even acessed them already, even in this post there are refferences to it. Its not only a matter of number or cells, but also of sophistication and data processing capacity.

And in nature, eletric signals do create feelings- it happens all the times in our brains.

Note that if a feeling is nothing but data processing, then there´s no problem at all in it being produced by brain activity.

Once again- "feelings" are created by interactions between our brain, body, environment and stored data. Example:
-external stimulae received (say, the smell of apple pie)
-external stimulae is processed by the brain (compared with a database including other smells and pies, previous experiences related, etc.)
-brain sends messages to several organs, triggering a number of responses that include liberation of substances that not only will make you salivate, but maybe also some that sgive you some "feel good sensation"- endorphines.
-overall result-> "I like apple pie" sensation.


Matteo Martini said:
2) Yes, you say that it is not " one " neuron that creates the " self ", not even electric signals alone, but it is the " whole " thing together. However, the " whole thing " does not mean much to me. If electric signals and cells moving creates a " self " or a " feeling ", we should see " selfs " coming out from microwave heaters ( they have electric signals ) or from the skin of our legs ( they have " cells moving ). Nothing like that happens, so why is it only our brain where this strange phenomenon that electric signals create consciousness happens ?? And please do not tell me that it is a question of " quantity ", that only if you have 1 billion electric signals you have consciousness while if you have only 1 million or one hundred you do not have, this does not make much sense in my opinion, or you would have to agree that our microwave heater has a consciousness and a self, only that this is " very little ".

Your microwave owen and your alarm clocks are dumber than a cricket, and quite possibly dumber than a virus, since they can not proceed with its functions by itself - you must turn it on, provide power sources and apply commands to it. We´ve discussed this already. Its the same line of reasoning that can be applied to living creatures. Its not a problem, specially from the materialist POV. For non-materialists, however, its hard to explain.

Matteo Martini said:
You are having fun of me, I assume, or are you serious ??

I am serious! Those are theoretical possibilities, according to our current knoweledge. Bending space-time with a large mass (say a black hole) will curve the trajectory of light. Thus one can possibly see his/hers left eye with his/hers own left eye without the aid of reflections...

What´s my point? Simple. We must be very carefull before saying something is unreachable, specially when it comes to science. Think of how many things were taken as impossible - or were never dreamt of! Many of them nowdays are routine or seen as technological possibilites. The symbolic analogies you used may be interesting and compelling images, but they are not really hard to beat.

Note the above examples are theoretical possibilities. If they are (or will ever be) technically possible, its another discussion.


Matteo Martini said:
Well, at least I hope that you agree that " the-world-as-it-is " is outside the reach of human knowledge. How do you prove that you have the " final truth " about anything in this world ?? The history of scientific discovery is a history of ideas that are areated, discussed, analyzed and then proved wrong in some cases, which leads to a better theory which is created, discussed, analyzed, etc.

That´s science gratest strenght. It is being constantly perfected. Some people see as a weakness, but its not. Science does not proves it has final word about anything, its a common misconception. It is a tool, a methodology, that we use to know the world. And, in my humble opinion, the best one.

Using science, we can say that, based on the avaliable data, theory X is the most likely explanation. Will this position change? Maybe so, maybe no. In many cases it will, but in many others, future alterations will most likely will not change the core of the theory. In other cases, new perspectives are added, as in the case of Newtonian mechanics, Relativity and Quantum mechanics.

Still, I can´t help but disagree that " the-world-as-it-is " is outside the reach of human (scientific) knowledge and will always remain so. That would be to ignore the history of science and its potential. Our knoweledge about " the-world-as-it-is " is constantly changing, increasing. Some time ago we were not aware of quasars, pentaquarks, black smokers, neurons, etc. If we are not able to directly perceive something, we create instruments that can, thus expanding our perceptions, and this is not unlike creating additional senses. Would it be wrong to say that we use these new informations to build new qualia?

But perhaps the question (Will " the-world-as-it-is " be always outside the reach of human knowledge?) should be left open, since mankind as we know it can be extincted before this happens. Or maybe, who knows, mankind will reach the conclusion that its not just worth the effort, even if feasible... Potentially and theoretically, I think its quite possible that mankind may, at some distant future, be able to eventually gather enough information to declare that the world-as-it-is is fully known, but maybe it will not happen.

The bottomline is- currently, one of the few things I have faith in, is science. Contradictory, isn´t it? But humans are contradictory...
 
Correa Neto,
sorry if I did not post a reply in this thread sooner, I had some things to do I could not postpone.

I think we have understood each other's opinion in this thread, even if we did not convince each other, I still think the discussion has been useful to me and, hopefully, maybe to you as well.

But the debate has proved to be difficult, and it is difficult for me to keep on going debate the assumptons, even if, I must admit I would still be interested in doing this.

So, I hope you do not feel robbed if I quit this discussion, at least for the moment.

The matter we are investigating is really difficult and I need to think about it more and take a break from this thread.

And sorry again for that stupid comment I made earlier in this thread, it has been like a ghost that haunted me for days.

Matteo
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom