Where am I ?

" So are you suggesting that, because we don't YET understand, scientifically, how consciousness is generated, that we should embrace a mystical explanation instead, which also has no proof whatsoever? "
Did I ever suggest that ?
No.
However, I noticed in this forum when people think you MIGHT be suggesting any methaphysical explanation of facts, they " attack " you a little bit.
But that' s an impression and I am going out of topic too.

" One thing that would help everyone here - define 'self-conscious'. Accurately. "
Sorry I can not do that, already said that I can not.
However, the fact that I can not provide a clear definition of " self-consiousness " does not mean that I am not sure that, right now, I am self-conscious and therefore " self-consciousness " exists.

" We can either confront that mystery scientifically, analyzing the brain and neural interaction until we can pinpoint it, .. "
And, after all the researches in neurology, I think there's still no clue about where self-consciousness comes from

" Self-consciousness could be defined in such a way that sufficiently complex computers could be considered self-conscious. Some researchers have created programs allowing computers to 'understand' the nature of their own existance as machines, though as of yet, these programs generally suck. "
OK, but I refuse the idea of a self-conscious computer.
I admit howvever, that I can not prove that a computer of the future may not look as " self-conscious ".

" However, the exact criteria escapes me. "
To me as well.

" just because we cannot understand something today does NOT mean we need to grasp for mystical reasons instead of logical, scientific ones. "
Again, I never said that.
However, I doubt we will EVER scientifically understand how self-consciousness generates.

" Insects and animals build things and use tools, so there has to some level of self-conciousness and abstract forethought / planning present. "
I think animals are self-conscious
At least, my dog is ( was, she is dead )
 
So, without a clear definition of 'self-consciousness', how can we hope to try to find it?

If we have no common definition for self-consciousness, but only arbitrary individual definitions, then there is nothing wrong with saying that self-consciousness is an emergent property of brain activity as a whole. Nor is there anything wrong with saying that self-consciousness is a function of the human soul. In other words, meaningful discussion is pointless without this definition.

For example, it's clear that quite a few people believe that self-consciousness is a function unique to humans. Uruk has pointed this out, even going so far as to narrowing down religion and art as functions of self-consciousness. However, I think religion and art tend to be more the product of creativity, imagination, and idle time than self-consciousness. In point of fact, there are a few examples of what could be called art in the animal world, though we try blowing it all off as one form or another of instinctive behaviour. And what if art and religion are merely human instincts?

The only clear thing is that I (apply to yourselves, obviously) am self conscious. All else is based upon beliefs.

Does that make me any different from animals? From machines? Who knows, since I cannot define it?
 
" In other words, meaningful discussion is pointless without this definition. "
You are ( maybe unintentionally ) quoting Wittengstein: " about the things you can not talk you should be silent "

" And what if art and religion are merely human instincts? "
That can be considered as a valid opinion, even if unsopported.

" The only clear thing is that I (apply to yourselves, obviously) am self conscious. All else is based upon beliefs.
Does that make me any different from animals? From machines? Who knows, since I cannot define it? "
That is the good point that seems to end all the discussions.
Still a question mark stands as the end of the sentence.
We have clarified and agreed a final question, but still the question remains unanswered.
Maybe Wittengstein would say that the question ( " What is self-conmsciousness ? " ) is the problem and when you can see that for this question there is no answer, then the question disappeares.
I do not believe very much in Wittengestein, however.
 
Me neither - I prefer his neighbor, Frankenstein.

:dl:

Sorry - in a bit of a mood tonight.

Of course, you realize the other catch, don't you? That we don't have a precise definition of consciousness in general, nor even, to be honest, 'self'. So to explore what it means to be 'self-conscious' means clearly defining all these ideas first.

I think the best answer would be: "Insufficient data to formulate a response."

(Thank you Asimov...)
 
Hewever

However,
there is another thing related to this topic.
Some years ago I had a talk with a Zen monk who stated that the " ego ", as a separate being from the rest of the environment, does not exist, it is just a delusion.
He made the example that, when you shoot a photo, you actually see the " person " together with the environment and not separated in individual entities.
This experience of " communion with the universe " may be achieved by, guess what, meditation
This witness has somehow been given also by writer Arthur Koestler who, during his time in prison in Malaga during the Spanish war, had this experience of " self- disappearance ".
As far as I know, also Freud may have talked about this calling it " oceanic feeling " saying, however, that he never experienced it himself.
I do not know much more about this and I do not know if this witnesses prove or have anything to do with our question, but they are interesting, however.
 
Correa Neto said:

No. You are the result of interactions between the activities of all your neurons as well as all your body.
What dumb-ass thing to say. That implies no uniqueness whatsoever.


Note that damaging the brain surely causes negative efects on the consiousness. In some cases, there are personality changes. In others, more dramatic, the person can hardly be called rational or even self-consient.
Try blasting a couple of rounds into a radio receiver and tell me if that doesn't impair its reception?
 
I think it's an interesting phenomenon - self-disappearance, becoming 'one' with the universe, whatever you want to call it, is a considerable achievement in most cultures with regards to meditative or religious practice. What I wonder is, are we seeing something truly metaphysical, or merely another physiological brain phenomenon that we have yet to study?

Iacchus: Try tuning in a brain to someone else's 'soul'. :D
 
" What I wonder is, are we seeing something truly metaphysical, or merely another physiological brain phenomenon that we have yet to study? "
I do not understand what you mean with " something truly metaphysical ".
You mean if these people see something " true " or if this is just a big delusion, just like what you feel using LSD or something like that ( never used LSD, just told about the effects ).
AFAIK, there is nothing paranormal here, it is just that they " get " a different understanding on reality ..
Honestly, I do not know, I do not even if you can draw a line between " true " mystical experiences and strange phenomena happening with your neurons.
Very difficult to even speak clearly about this ..
Maybe after a lot of meditation you become a little bit mad ?
 
Hmm... By using 'metaphysical' I think I tend to forget that what we consider today to be metaphysical may well be common science tomorrow. Certainly, this has been the case in the past - perhaps I should say 'something truly spiritual' or 'something beyond the grasp of science'?

But - when you get right down to it, nothing is beyond the grasp of science, so long as it's a)real, b)consistant, and c)logical.

Sorry - poorly worded post.

Losing the 'self' - maybe the part of the brain responsible for self-identity goes momentarily numb.

Oh, if only I had the resources and time to conduct experiments! This would be a fascinating study, I think - what, exactly, happens when one 'becomes one with the univese' or 'loses oneself'?

Of course, if I had the resources and time, I know I'd probably be studying what happens when one becomes 'one' with nubile twenty-something nymphomaniacs... :P
 
" Hmm... By using 'metaphysical' I think I tend to forget that what we consider today to be metaphysical may well be common science tomorrow. Certainly, this has been the case in the past - perhaps I should say 'something truly spiritual' or 'something beyond the grasp of science'? "
I personally do not think science will ever be able to enter the realm of self-consciousness ( Wittengstein said that, even if all the questions about science were answered, still the main questions of human existence would have not be touched ).
Science only deals with measurable quantities while self-consciousness, along with human emotions, questions about meaning of life, does not belong to the physical world. We can not even define it properly, sa someone said in this forum.
However, if I remember it properly, there was a physic ( I think it was Scrhoedinger ) who said that the mystery of self-consciousness can be solved with a short sentence.
If i remember well, he said that, along with the pysical world ( measurable one ), we see another world which is, the world of the emotions which we gather from the physical world ( the pleasure of a bright day, the fear of a spider .. )
We are that world

" But - when you get right down to it, nothing is beyond the grasp of science, so long as it's a)real, b)consistant, and c)logical. "
Science deals with measurable quantities of the physical world, self-consciouness is not something you can measure

" what, exactly, happens when one 'becomes one with the univese' or 'loses oneself'? "
I read a good description of this in A. Koestler " The invisible writing ".

" if I had the resources and time, I know I'd probably be studying what happens when one becomes 'one' with nubile twenty-something nymphomaniacs "
You can not buy love from twenty-something nymphomaniacs, but you can buy sex from twenty Brazilian bitches.
But I am becoming too rude now.
 
Iacchus said:
What dumb-ass thing to say. That implies no uniqueness whatsoever.

That was a dumb-ass answer. Since no two persons neurons are in the same confuguration, since stored sets of data are different and since no twor bodies are identical, there is indeed uniqueness. Or uniqueness, if you feel it has a different meaning written this way...

Iacchus said:
Try blasting a couple of rounds into a radio receiver and tell me if that doesn't impair its reception?

And here one jumps in to conclusions based on wild speculations. To sum things up, in such concept, The Great Radiostation constantly emmits a broad spectrum of "vibrations". Each brain is fine-tuned to ressonate with a narrow"vibration" band of The Great Radiostation broadcast that is actually a soul, that manifest itself as a self... And evidence for that would be?

[OT note-> this is not that different from Lifegazer´s foolish solipsistic god <- end OT note]

Now, try blasting a couple of rounds into a computer and tell me if it doesn´t impair processing?

Try harder next time.

And regarding Mateo´s comments, the self and its continuity may quite well be an illusion. However, that is not an evidence of "something else". Neither epiphanies or LSD (ond similar drug-induced) experiences. They are internal experiences that are built by a combination of external factors (such as stress and/or chemicals modifying brain activity). They are based on our cultural backgrounds, and sometimes can even be a mechanism of self-defense.

I think that one day science will explain the generation of conconsciousness. And it will be by interactions between the activities of neurons as well as the body.

On a personal note, before making comments like that "Brazilian bitches" line of yours, make sure that no one form that country is around. I am from Brazil, and I have not liked your attitude. I could find the place from where you type from and reply at the same level, but I will not lower myself to do so.
 
Correa Neto said:

That was a dumb-ass answer. Since no two persons neurons are in the same confuguration, since stored sets of data are different and since no twor bodies are identical, there is indeed uniqueness. Or uniqueness, if you feel it has a different meaning written this way...
And, might I suggest there's something more to life than that which is strictly mechanical?


And here one jumps in to conclusions based on wild speculations. To sum things up, in such concept, The Great Radiostation constantly emmits a broad spectrum of "vibrations". Each brain is fine-tuned to ressonate with a narrow"vibration" band of The Great Radiostation broadcast that is actually a soul, that manifest itself as a self... And evidence for that would be?
The mind is like a corridor between energy and matter, with an existent reality on either side. Evidence of this? You can remain both awake (conscious) and interact within your dreams. This is the beginning of what we would term, a "spiritual reality." Now, if you wish to pass it off as electro-chemical processes within the brain that's your business. But sooner or later you're going to have to come to terms with the "observer" who has witnessed all of this. Yourself.
 
Iacchus said:
Identical twins.

Non-sequitur. Identical twins are not tuned into the same soul. Some coincidences are likely to occur, given genetic similarity. However, show me where one thinks and the other knows what he's thinking across vast distances. Show me the evidence...

Oh, never mind, I'm talking to Iacchus.

Iacchus, would you go tell your mommy that you need some evidence? She'll know what I'm talking about.

:D
 
zaayrdragon said:

Non-sequitur. Identical twins are not tuned into the same soul. Some coincidences are likely to occur, given genetic similarity. However, show me where one thinks and the other knows what he's thinking across vast distances. Show me the evidence...

Oh, never mind, I'm talking to Iacchus.

Iacchus, would you go tell your mommy that you need some evidence? She'll know what I'm talking about.

:D
I understand that identical twins are quite often intuitive and have been known to read each other's thoughts.
 
As an experienced and practiced dreamworker, Iacchus, I have to say your interpretation of dreams is total bunk. There is no realm within or beyond your dreams. The only unusual phenomena about dreams are a) certain temporal inconsistancies, including apparent predictive ability, which, oddly, is usually of quite a trivial or insignificant nature; and b) dream-linking, a.k.a. shared dreaming, which may have a number of rational explanations. I have myself experienced dream-linking (apparently) numerous times, though I remain sceptical of these incidents, as I cannot fully rule out any number of conflagrating factors.

As a lucid dreamer, the dream is merely putty. Blank stage for the mind. An active mind creates its own dreams at will - whatever I desire to dream, I may. And if I desire, the dream goes away. No reality to this at all. Nothing more than imagination without senses getting in the way.

Iacchus, until you let go of dreams and understand that they only hold significance if you let them, you will never understand anything.
 
Iacchus said:
I understand that identical twins are quite often intuitive and have been known to read each other's thoughts.

Proof? Evidence? (Preferably not of the homeopathic variety)
 
Iacchus said:
And, might I suggest there's something more to life than that which is strictly mechanical?

Strictly organical, you mean.

Yes, you can suggest. But that´s how far you will go.


Iacchus said:
The mind is like a corridor between energy and matter, with an existent reality on either side. Evidence of this? You can remain both awake (conscious) and interact within your dreams. This is the beginning of what we would term, a "spiritual reality."

And that energy would be? Please, how can it be measured, detected, in other words, how can one know for sure it exists? No intuitions and/or wording around. Provide evidence.

Dreams? They are product of the activity of the brain while the person is asleep. If the brain is dead, there are no more dreams. So much for your spiritual reality.

Iacchus said:
Now, if you wish to pass it off as electro-chemical processes within the brain that's your business. But sooner or later you're going to have to come to terms with the "observer" who has witnessed all of this. Yourself.

Yes, just that. And why so many theists, religious persons etc. insist on making this type of threat? They run out of arguments and start with threats of hell, some sort of punishment, kill god, go to oblivion, blah blah blah.

Edited for typos. There are some left still, but I´m feeling to lazy to fix them all right now.
 
Iacchus wrote: " I understand that identical twins are quite often intuitive and have been known to read each other's thoughts "
I do not think that you have much proofs about this, do you ?

Iacchus wrote: " The mind is like a corridor between energy and matter, with an existent reality on either side. Evidence of this? You can remain both awake (conscious) and interact within your dreams. This is the beginning of what we would term, a "spiritual reality."
This seems to me a very methaphysical explanation

Correa Neto wrote: " On a personal note, before making comments like that "Brazilian bitches" line of yours, make sure that no one form that country is around. I am from Brazil, and I have not liked your attitude. I could find the place from where you type from and reply at the same level, but I will not lower myself to do so "

Yes, that was a ( very ) stupid joke and I have showed myself like a stupid.
I say I am sorry for what I have written to you and to anyone who could have felt offended, without replying me the same way you showed me how dumb-ass I have been.
I would like, if you still want, to continue with you the discussion about serious matters.

Correa Neto wrote: " the self and its continuity may quite well be an illusion "
I do not think that the self could be defined as an illusion, otherwise you could put the hand on fire and feel no pain.

Correa Neto wrote: " think that one day science will explain the generation of conconsciousness. And it will be by interactions between the activities of neurons as well as the body. "
How would you science deal with self-consciousness if it can not measure and even define it ?
 
Science only deals with measurable quantities while self-consciousness, along with human emotions, questions about meaning of life, does not belong to the physical world. We can not even define it properly, sa someone said in this forum.
If there is a thouht in our heads, it exists in the physical world. Every thought and emotion has a related neuro-transmitter or electro/chemical activity pattern associated with it. PET scans reveal patterns in the brain when a subject is recalling memories, or seeing a color or hearing music or solving a puzzle. There is a physical process to thoughts in our brains, so emotions and questions about life have some physicality.

And just because we cannot find a proper definition or physical measurement of self-conciousness yet, does not neccessarily mean that we will never find one. But this is a belief I have.
And what if art and religion are merely human instincts?
I do believe that art and religion are human instincts. when you give a crayon to a child he/she will try to draw something representation on paper without prompting or proctering. The lascoux cave paints seem to suggest that representive drawings were humans first form of communicating abstract ideas or fore thought or recollections. I think religion is just intellectual lazyness. This is a personal opinion though. I've never held a high opinion of organized religion.
Try blasting a couple of rounds into a radio receiver and tell me if that doesn't impair its reception?
Didn't I tell you someone would bring up that old argument. It still does not provide any answers at all. It mearly just suggest an alternative with unecesissary and unsupportable baggage.
I understand that identical twins are quite often intuitive and have been known to read each other's thoughts.
Unfortunately, there has never been a test, and all evidence is anecdotal.
You can remain both awake (conscious) and interact within your dreams. This is the beginning of what we would term, a "spiritual reality."
There is no evidence to support the "spiritual" world. Dreams are perfectly explainable in terms of brain activity.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom