Matteo Martini
Banned
- Joined
- Dec 6, 2004
- Messages
- 4,561
" So are you suggesting that, because we don't YET understand, scientifically, how consciousness is generated, that we should embrace a mystical explanation instead, which also has no proof whatsoever? "
Did I ever suggest that ?
No.
However, I noticed in this forum when people think you MIGHT be suggesting any methaphysical explanation of facts, they " attack " you a little bit.
But that' s an impression and I am going out of topic too.
" One thing that would help everyone here - define 'self-conscious'. Accurately. "
Sorry I can not do that, already said that I can not.
However, the fact that I can not provide a clear definition of " self-consiousness " does not mean that I am not sure that, right now, I am self-conscious and therefore " self-consciousness " exists.
" We can either confront that mystery scientifically, analyzing the brain and neural interaction until we can pinpoint it, .. "
And, after all the researches in neurology, I think there's still no clue about where self-consciousness comes from
" Self-consciousness could be defined in such a way that sufficiently complex computers could be considered self-conscious. Some researchers have created programs allowing computers to 'understand' the nature of their own existance as machines, though as of yet, these programs generally suck. "
OK, but I refuse the idea of a self-conscious computer.
I admit howvever, that I can not prove that a computer of the future may not look as " self-conscious ".
" However, the exact criteria escapes me. "
To me as well.
" just because we cannot understand something today does NOT mean we need to grasp for mystical reasons instead of logical, scientific ones. "
Again, I never said that.
However, I doubt we will EVER scientifically understand how self-consciousness generates.
" Insects and animals build things and use tools, so there has to some level of self-conciousness and abstract forethought / planning present. "
I think animals are self-conscious
At least, my dog is ( was, she is dead )
Did I ever suggest that ?
No.
However, I noticed in this forum when people think you MIGHT be suggesting any methaphysical explanation of facts, they " attack " you a little bit.
But that' s an impression and I am going out of topic too.
" One thing that would help everyone here - define 'self-conscious'. Accurately. "
Sorry I can not do that, already said that I can not.
However, the fact that I can not provide a clear definition of " self-consiousness " does not mean that I am not sure that, right now, I am self-conscious and therefore " self-consciousness " exists.
" We can either confront that mystery scientifically, analyzing the brain and neural interaction until we can pinpoint it, .. "
And, after all the researches in neurology, I think there's still no clue about where self-consciousness comes from
" Self-consciousness could be defined in such a way that sufficiently complex computers could be considered self-conscious. Some researchers have created programs allowing computers to 'understand' the nature of their own existance as machines, though as of yet, these programs generally suck. "
OK, but I refuse the idea of a self-conscious computer.
I admit howvever, that I can not prove that a computer of the future may not look as " self-conscious ".
" However, the exact criteria escapes me. "
To me as well.
" just because we cannot understand something today does NOT mean we need to grasp for mystical reasons instead of logical, scientific ones. "
Again, I never said that.
However, I doubt we will EVER scientifically understand how self-consciousness generates.
" Insects and animals build things and use tools, so there has to some level of self-conciousness and abstract forethought / planning present. "
I think animals are self-conscious
At least, my dog is ( was, she is dead )
