Matteo Martini said:
No, I can be self-conscious even when I do not have any perception in my body ( when I have eyes closed, total silence, my body is totally anestetyzed but I am not sleeping, etc. ). And self-consciusness ( SC ) can exist even when I am not thinking about anything in particular.
Please note that I wrote "self-consiousness can be defined as a product of toughts and perceptions of our own body´s status created by feedback from our nerve system". Consiousness of your body, of your physical limits is a part of your self-consiousness, as well as your thoughts are also.
You may be floating silent inside one of those tanks that deprive your body from external stimulae, but you will still have feedback from your body indicating its status ("I´d better get something to eat").
If you are completely sedated, your status will be a bit comparable to be deeply asleep. Still, feedback stimulae from your body is constanly being generated. So, the definition stands still, since it states that selfconsiousness is composed both by toughts and perceptions (internals and externals). The exact importance of each one of these factors will depend on the moment.
Matteo Martini said:
I would rather say " I know that I exist ".
SCness does not involve thinking
No. You can´t say that you exist without thinking about it. You can´t know that you exist without thinking about it. And without receiving some feedback from your body, you can´t know what parts you are composed of. So, "I think that I exist" is a good qualifier.
Matteo Martini said:
Measuring brain activity is only measuring brain activity, not SC.
Brain activity can be correlated with degrees of consiousness. Even of self consiouness. Check the links. Different patterns for different brain damage (or development, or awakeness, or sensory inputs -external and internal) status, being, therefore, a qualitative and quantitative picture of the tought patterns that compose the "self-consiousness picture" at that moment.
Matteo Martini said:
If you say that brain activity creates SCness, you have to support this claim and give evidence for it.
We here have pointed to evidence that supports the idea that brain activity creates self-consiousness. And you have to suppot your claim that it does not and provide evidence for it. So far, you have not.
Matteo Martini said:
I think brain activity has many things to do with SCness and that our brain works with SCness.
Actually I agree that our brain works with self-consience. But I think that it
creates the self-consience to work with.
Matteo Martini said:
I question the claims in this thread that brain activity creates SCness, a claim that is not and, in my opinion, can not be proved.
Please provide evidence that it can´t be proved.
Matteo Martini said:
When you speak about " performing tests on the subject on several status of consience " you should be more precise about what you mean.
Ask a neurologist. I am not one, but I can give a try. Place the subjects in several states of consiousness induced by drugs, then apply a series of standard questions while taking brain scans. Self-consiousness is severely influenced by drugs -as well as by sleep. At certain points, even our very identity is forgotten. One can also test wit subjects with diverse types of brain damage. Follow the links and you´ll have more precise answers.
Matteo Martini said:
I tried to explain why I do not agree with the question you started your post.
But the arguments to me seem quite weak. As you can see, its not that hard to obtain a definition. Even if the boundaries are blurred. And that´s nothing that science can not handle. There are many examples of "blurry boundaries" for definitions in science and this does not causes problems.
Matteo Martini said:
I agree with that, the point was to prove that you can not understand if another being is SC or not by scientific means ( maybe, by all means )
Solipsism is a dead-end. Nothing can be proven from it other than its useless. And once again, its use was... Useless. Because if you stick to the idea that one can´t prove anything about anything, than its utterly pointless to discuss something!
And self-consiousness can be defined, indeed. As with many subjects it may be hard to understand and to draw clear boundaries, but it is not a barrier to science.
Matteo Martini said:
Well, that depends on how you define " processing data ". If " processing data " means do some ray-tracing calculations, any old Pentium is far more efficent than any SC being on Earth ( at least, if you do not believe in God )
But this is not my point.
Processing data, in the present case, can be anything from adding 1+1 to thinking about the meaning of life, passing through solving problems like "how can I get that fruit over that tree" or "where can I find sticks to build a nest" or trying to solve a triple integral.
Matteo Martini said:
My point is that almost any of the functionalities of a SC being can be duplicated more or less well with a robot now or in a foreseeable future. A robot can move, swim, talk, look like thinking, understand how to move in its environment.
Here´s the point-
"look like thinking". Why not
actually think? What are the differences between a dog and a human being trying to figure out how to go from A to B? Does the dog just "looks like it´s thinking"? The human may have more resources when it comes to data processing and finding alternatives, but that does not even means that he/she will be able to reach B!!!! So, a human, a dog and C3P0 are trying to figure out how to reach B from A. How can you tell if any of them is not really thinking -within their limitations- but just "looking like thinking"?
You seem to be of opinion that only humans can truly think. I think that animals can solve problems, therefore they can also think -within their limitations. Advanced machines will also be able to do so - ithin their limitations, so they will be able to think.
The problem comes when one considers "abstract thinking". Animals have, as far as we know, severe limitations in this point. Machines will also have them? I think that sooner or later (possibly later) machines will be constructed that will be able to do so. Still, I bet some people will still claim that they just "look like they are thinking", but there will be no difference.
Matteo Martini said:
This supports my thesis that SCness can not be understood scientifically, you can not understand scientifically ( maybe you can not understand at all ! ) if another being is SC or not.
No, it does not supports any parts of your thesis. It can be understood, it is being understood. Do some googling on artificial intelligence research (better filter using names of institutions, such as MIT or you´ll get millions of craplinks).
Originally posted by Matteo Martini
I disagree with that, you can not measure how SC is a fly or a robot.
Those are all unsupported opinions
A fly has consiousness of its own body. This is as far as its self-consiousness will go. If it does not has, it will not survive. It has to survive predators, eat and breed. It will solve the problems it faces, within its capacities. Ours is more sophisticated, because we evolved big brains and more sophisticated data processing routines, to solve similar problems- survive predators, eat and breed.
Originally posted by Matteo Martini
I disagree with that, how would you know ?
Then, why my Pentium 4 is not SC ?
It performs basically the same functions, even if at a lesser level, that you robot would perform.
By all means it does not. See above and below. Its dumber than a fly, quite possibly dumber than an amoeba.
Originally posted by Matteo Martini
Again, this is not, by any means, a definition of SCness
Who said it is? I wrote "
Now integrate all these systems in a single piece of hardware. The piece of hardware, according to some definitions, would be now "alive". Would such a magnificient piece of hardware be self-consicent? On a certain level, yes. The actual level will depend on how adaptable it is to learn solve new problems. It may be as self-conscient as an amoeba, a bug, or as a human being."
I said that such a machine, that seeks its own "food", tries to preserve its own physical integrity and tries to breed could be considered alive. And depending on its sophistication, would be as self-conscient as a fly or as a human being. Nothing more nothing less. Is there any definition of self-cosnciousness in that part of the text?
I was just pointing that even artificial lifeforms may be considered self-conscient. They may be, as weell as dogs and flys, not as sophisticated as we humans are. Back to the definition
"self-consiousness can be defined as a product of toughts and perceptions of our own body´s status created by feedback from our nerve system", its easy to see that for flys and fly-like robots, the data processing -the toughts- will be quite limited.
Originally posted by Matteo Martini
Then my own hardware-based Pentium 4 computer is SC ?
Why your robot is SC and my P4 is not ?
Can your P4 solve problems by itself? Can it learn and apply the new knoweledge to solve new problems? Drop your P2 inside a maze. An antivirus that will solve its latest infection is at the end. Will it realize that it needs the antivirus, has to reach it, figure out how to reach it and install it? No.
Why? Because your P4 is dumber than an amoeba... With the propper softwares, perhaps it can. But It may be limited by its hardware. C3P0 is much more advanced. It is self-consient. As the dog is, as you are. The difference is that we have better data processing capacity than the dog.
Originally posted by Matteo Martini
Are not we ( SC beings ) all made of " materialistic hardware parts " ?
Exactly. And that´s all that we are. Nothing more, nothing less.