Where am I ?

Do you agree that self-consiousness can be defined as a product of toughts and perceptions of our own body´s status created by feedback from our nerve system?
No, I can be self-conscious even when I do not have any perception in my body ( when I have eyes closed, total silence, my body is totally anestetyzed but I am not sleeping, etc. ). And self-consciusness ( SC ) can exist even when I am not thinking about anything in particular.

Perhaps something as simple as "I think that I exist"?
I would rather say " I know that I exist ".
SCness does not involve thinking

Check the links on neurology kindly provided by the persons in this and other threads. Measuring brain activity and performing tests on the subject on several status of consience would be a way. And if you agree with the question I started this post with, you´ll see that it can be measured
Measuring brain activity is only measuring brain activity, not SC.
If you say that brain activity creates SCness, you have to support this claim and give evidence for it.
I think brain activity has many things to do with SCness and that our brain works with SCness.
I question the claims in this thread that brain activity creates SCness, a claim that is not and, in my opinion, can not be proved.
When you speak about " performing tests on the subject on several status of consience " you should be more precise about what you mean.
I tried to explain why I do not agree with the question you started your post.

The solipsism line also will not provide any help. Actually solipsism is one of the -if not the most- useless philosophies avaliable. If its true, than discussing anything about the world is utterly futile.
I agree with that, the point was to prove that you can not understand if another being is SC or not by scientific means ( maybe, by all means )

Nothing that you wrote proves anything. Our robots, regardless of being able to walk, crawl, swim, etc. are dumber than an insect when it comes to their autonomy and the variety of functions they can perform. They can´t proccess dat as efficienty (or "think", if you preffer) as an insect can.
Well, that depends on how you define " processing data ". If " processing data " means do some ray-tracing calculations, any old Pentium is far more efficent than any SC being on Earth ( at least, if you do not believe in God )
But this is not my point.
My point is that almost any of the functionalities of a SC being can be duplicated more or less well with a robot now or in a foreseeable future. A robot can move, swim, talk, look like thinking, understand how to move in its environment. This supports my thesis that SCness can not be understood scientifically, you can not understand scientifically ( maybe you can not understand at all ! ) if another being is SC or not.

So, "scientifically speaking", the robot would have a lesser dregree of self-consiousness than a fly
I disagree with that, you can not measure how SC is a fly or a robot.
Those are all unsupported opinions

Would such a magnificient piece of hardware be self-consicent? On a certain level, yes
I disagree with that, how would you know ?
Then, why my Pentium 4 is not SC ?
It performs basically the same functions, even if at a lesser level, that you robot would perform.

The actual level will depend on how adaptable it is to learn solve new problems
Again, this is not, by any means, a definition of SCness

And will it have anything other than its own hardware creating its self-conscience? No
Then my own hardware-based Pentium 4 computer is SC ?
Why your robot is SC and my P4 is not ?

Despite the fact that it may eventually think that it is so special that it must be made of something else than mere materialistic hardware parts...
Are not we ( SC beings ) all made of " materialistic hardware parts " ?
 
Matteo Martini said:
No, I can be self-conscious even when I do not have any perception in my body ( when I have eyes closed, total silence, my body is totally anestetyzed but I am not sleeping, etc. ). And self-consciusness ( SC ) can exist even when I am not thinking about anything in particular.

Please note that I wrote "self-consiousness can be defined as a product of toughts and perceptions of our own body´s status created by feedback from our nerve system". Consiousness of your body, of your physical limits is a part of your self-consiousness, as well as your thoughts are also.

You may be floating silent inside one of those tanks that deprive your body from external stimulae, but you will still have feedback from your body indicating its status ("I´d better get something to eat").

If you are completely sedated, your status will be a bit comparable to be deeply asleep. Still, feedback stimulae from your body is constanly being generated. So, the definition stands still, since it states that selfconsiousness is composed both by toughts and perceptions (internals and externals). The exact importance of each one of these factors will depend on the moment.

Matteo Martini said:
I would rather say " I know that I exist ".
SCness does not involve thinking

No. You can´t say that you exist without thinking about it. You can´t know that you exist without thinking about it. And without receiving some feedback from your body, you can´t know what parts you are composed of. So, "I think that I exist" is a good qualifier.

Matteo Martini said:
Measuring brain activity is only measuring brain activity, not SC.

Brain activity can be correlated with degrees of consiousness. Even of self consiouness. Check the links. Different patterns for different brain damage (or development, or awakeness, or sensory inputs -external and internal) status, being, therefore, a qualitative and quantitative picture of the tought patterns that compose the "self-consiousness picture" at that moment.

Matteo Martini said:
If you say that brain activity creates SCness, you have to support this claim and give evidence for it.

We here have pointed to evidence that supports the idea that brain activity creates self-consiousness. And you have to suppot your claim that it does not and provide evidence for it. So far, you have not.

Matteo Martini said:
I think brain activity has many things to do with SCness and that our brain works with SCness.

Actually I agree that our brain works with self-consience. But I think that it creates the self-consience to work with.

Matteo Martini said:
I question the claims in this thread that brain activity creates SCness, a claim that is not and, in my opinion, can not be proved.

Please provide evidence that it can´t be proved.

Matteo Martini said:
When you speak about " performing tests on the subject on several status of consience " you should be more precise about what you mean.

Ask a neurologist. I am not one, but I can give a try. Place the subjects in several states of consiousness induced by drugs, then apply a series of standard questions while taking brain scans. Self-consiousness is severely influenced by drugs -as well as by sleep. At certain points, even our very identity is forgotten. One can also test wit subjects with diverse types of brain damage. Follow the links and you´ll have more precise answers.

Matteo Martini said:
I tried to explain why I do not agree with the question you started your post.

But the arguments to me seem quite weak. As you can see, its not that hard to obtain a definition. Even if the boundaries are blurred. And that´s nothing that science can not handle. There are many examples of "blurry boundaries" for definitions in science and this does not causes problems.

Matteo Martini said:
I agree with that, the point was to prove that you can not understand if another being is SC or not by scientific means ( maybe, by all means )

Solipsism is a dead-end. Nothing can be proven from it other than its useless. And once again, its use was... Useless. Because if you stick to the idea that one can´t prove anything about anything, than its utterly pointless to discuss something!

And self-consiousness can be defined, indeed. As with many subjects it may be hard to understand and to draw clear boundaries, but it is not a barrier to science.

Matteo Martini said:
Well, that depends on how you define " processing data ". If " processing data " means do some ray-tracing calculations, any old Pentium is far more efficent than any SC being on Earth ( at least, if you do not believe in God )
But this is not my point.

Processing data, in the present case, can be anything from adding 1+1 to thinking about the meaning of life, passing through solving problems like "how can I get that fruit over that tree" or "where can I find sticks to build a nest" or trying to solve a triple integral.

Matteo Martini said:
My point is that almost any of the functionalities of a SC being can be duplicated more or less well with a robot now or in a foreseeable future. A robot can move, swim, talk, look like thinking, understand how to move in its environment.

Here´s the point- "look like thinking". Why not actually think? What are the differences between a dog and a human being trying to figure out how to go from A to B? Does the dog just "looks like it´s thinking"? The human may have more resources when it comes to data processing and finding alternatives, but that does not even means that he/she will be able to reach B!!!! So, a human, a dog and C3P0 are trying to figure out how to reach B from A. How can you tell if any of them is not really thinking -within their limitations- but just "looking like thinking"?

You seem to be of opinion that only humans can truly think. I think that animals can solve problems, therefore they can also think -within their limitations. Advanced machines will also be able to do so - ithin their limitations, so they will be able to think.

The problem comes when one considers "abstract thinking". Animals have, as far as we know, severe limitations in this point. Machines will also have them? I think that sooner or later (possibly later) machines will be constructed that will be able to do so. Still, I bet some people will still claim that they just "look like they are thinking", but there will be no difference.

Matteo Martini said:
This supports my thesis that SCness can not be understood scientifically, you can not understand scientifically ( maybe you can not understand at all ! ) if another being is SC or not.

No, it does not supports any parts of your thesis. It can be understood, it is being understood. Do some googling on artificial intelligence research (better filter using names of institutions, such as MIT or you´ll get millions of craplinks).

Originally posted by Matteo Martini
I disagree with that, you can not measure how SC is a fly or a robot.
Those are all unsupported opinions

A fly has consiousness of its own body. This is as far as its self-consiousness will go. If it does not has, it will not survive. It has to survive predators, eat and breed. It will solve the problems it faces, within its capacities. Ours is more sophisticated, because we evolved big brains and more sophisticated data processing routines, to solve similar problems- survive predators, eat and breed.

Originally posted by Matteo Martini
I disagree with that, how would you know ?
Then, why my Pentium 4 is not SC ?
It performs basically the same functions, even if at a lesser level, that you robot would perform.

By all means it does not. See above and below. Its dumber than a fly, quite possibly dumber than an amoeba.

Originally posted by Matteo Martini
Again, this is not, by any means, a definition of SCness

Who said it is? I wrote "Now integrate all these systems in a single piece of hardware. The piece of hardware, according to some definitions, would be now "alive". Would such a magnificient piece of hardware be self-consicent? On a certain level, yes. The actual level will depend on how adaptable it is to learn solve new problems. It may be as self-conscient as an amoeba, a bug, or as a human being."

I said that such a machine, that seeks its own "food", tries to preserve its own physical integrity and tries to breed could be considered alive. And depending on its sophistication, would be as self-conscient as a fly or as a human being. Nothing more nothing less. Is there any definition of self-cosnciousness in that part of the text?

I was just pointing that even artificial lifeforms may be considered self-conscient. They may be, as weell as dogs and flys, not as sophisticated as we humans are. Back to the definition "self-consiousness can be defined as a product of toughts and perceptions of our own body´s status created by feedback from our nerve system", its easy to see that for flys and fly-like robots, the data processing -the toughts- will be quite limited.

Originally posted by Matteo Martini
Then my own hardware-based Pentium 4 computer is SC ?
Why your robot is SC and my P4 is not ?

Can your P4 solve problems by itself? Can it learn and apply the new knoweledge to solve new problems? Drop your P2 inside a maze. An antivirus that will solve its latest infection is at the end. Will it realize that it needs the antivirus, has to reach it, figure out how to reach it and install it? No.

Why? Because your P4 is dumber than an amoeba... With the propper softwares, perhaps it can. But It may be limited by its hardware. C3P0 is much more advanced. It is self-consient. As the dog is, as you are. The difference is that we have better data processing capacity than the dog.

Originally posted by Matteo Martini
Are not we ( SC beings ) all made of " materialistic hardware parts " ?

Exactly. And that´s all that we are. Nothing more, nothing less.
 
Correa Neto,
thanks for the informative posting !!
I think the discussion is getting more and more interesting, so I hope you will not get bored even if it will take a while until we will be able to reach any conclusion.
Maybe we can even not reach any conclusion, after all, but at least we will both learn something about other people thoughts ( at least, I am learning from you !! )
I would also hope uruk and others join the discussion !!

Since it seems that I misinterpretating your opinions, let me recap what I think your opinions are so I will know that I know what you really think.
So, please correct me if I report any of your opinions incorrectly or if you think I miss any relevant point of your thoughts in my explanation .

So, as far as I have understood, you think that the we humans ( maybe animals as well ) are made of a body and a mind.
According to you the mind is a " product " of our bodies, specifically, of the brain ( or of the central nervous system ).
In other terms, we, at least the core of us, " are " our brains.
Our memory, our capacity to understand other people speeches, our logical abilities, our ability to understand the space around us, our abilities to solve math problems, our ability ( I would say, our " characteristic " ) to feel for other people, to feel cold and hot, can ultimately be related to one or more part of the brain which are dedicated to one or more of the above mentioned tasks ( of course, the body is also involved here, to feel cold, you need a skin ).
Those parts of the brain " produce " our thoughts, our rememberings, our feelings more or less like the body produces sweat, tears and other organic liquids.
Please correct me if I am not interpretating your thought correctly or if I am missing any important part of your thought.
You said that you defined SCness as " I think that I exist ", I hope you agree that, along with SCness, come feelings, that is, if you are SC you " feel " pain or pleasure, if you are not SC you do not feel pain and pleasure.
So, even if SCness is not only " feeling pain or pleasure ", only SC beings can feel pain or pleasure, other can not.
So, having the ability to " feel " is a criteria to know if a being is SC or not.
I agree that you can not prove to others that you have feelings, and others can not prove to you that they have feelings, even if they shout and cry if their hand is bitten by a dog, they can not " prove " scientifically to you that they actually felt pain.
However, each of us can be sure that, at least he/she is SC because he/she knows that he/she has the ability to feel pain.
Now, according to what I think is your opinion, self-consciousness ( I will call it SC ) is a part or the whole sum of our " mind ", so, along with our memory and the other our abilities, may be related to one or more parts of our brain.
Question: do you think our SC is just another part of our mind ( therefore, we have our memory, our ability to undestand other people speaking, our ability to understand difference in colours, etc. and we have SCness ) or it is the sum of all the properties of our mind ( therefore, our SCness is the sum of our memory, our ability to undestand other people speaking, our ability to understand difference in colours, etc. ) ?
Now, along with uruk, I think you agree that SC can and will one day be measured " scientifically ", we will be able to relate SC of the individual to the activity of some parts of his/her brain ( measuring brain activity by a PET scan or other modern instrument used in neurophysiology ).

Now, please tell me if you ( and uruk if he wants to join ) agree that what I stated above is your opinion.
 
uruk said:
The "I" would reside with the brain. If you were able to transplant your brain in a another person's body would you still be you? or would you be that other person? would you experiance what that person experiances as that person? or would you still be having your own experiances but in the other person's body?

You missed the point. The "I" would be at the senses location. If you say that the "I" is a physical process (correct me if this is not what you believe) then how can you explain that the location of the "I" (from the subject point of view) is different from the external observers (you and the evil scientist) point of view?

How about an example like The Matrix? The "I" is inside a computer simulation, not in the body located at the "batteries towers". Another way to say it: the sound occurs in your speakers, not in the radio station.

Lets take your example with a twist. Your brain is in your friends body but radio connected to your body senses, and your friends brain is in your body but connected to his body senses. Where are you both? Do you think that you will answer, to a straight question, that you "are" in your friends body?
 
Bodhi Dharma Zen said:
You missed the point. The "I" would be at the senses location. If you say that the "I" is a physical process (correct me if this is not what you believe) then how can you explain that the location of the "I" (from the subject point of view) is different from the external observers (you and the evil scientist) point of view?

How about an example like The Matrix? The "I" is inside a computer simulation, not in the body located at the "batteries towers". Another way to say it: the sound occurs in your speakers, not in the radio station.

Lets take your example with a twist. Your brain is in your friends body but radio connected to your body senses, and your friends brain is in your body but connected to his body senses. Where are you both? Do you think that you will answer, to a straight question, that you "are" in your friends body?

It's important that you know that The Matrix was a movie. Movies don't have to be based on reality. The proper way to think about it is a remote control. The brain remotely controls the body. You see where the body is, but the brain is still in the lab.
 
The thing to realize is that the 'I' is a variable concept. At any given moment, the 'I' may be you, body and mind; the brain alone; you plus your clothes and belongings; you and your works; anything that you connect to yourself at any moment defines 'I' for you. For my own part, if I were utterly unaware that my brain was in a lab in Wisconsin, I'd say that 'I' was wherever my senses told me I was; but if I knew it were in Wisconsin, I'd say that 'I' was both here and in Wisconsin. And if the radio connection were severed, I'd say that I were in Wisconsin, but my body was in Cincinnati. If I log onto some game server, and take control of an avatar flying through space in a ship, I'd say that I were both in Cincinnati and in virtual space. Of course, I might also say that my character was in virtual space rather than I - it depends on what level of connection I feel with that avatar. And if virtual reality becomes more useful and common, I might very well be flying to Antares aboard a ship with a cargo of platinum.

'I' is not a fixed quantity, not a stagnant situation; it is a dynamic and variable aspect of the self whose definition alters from second to second. This is important to understand. But if you want to know where the 'self' is located, ultimately, you'll have to find it within the brain. The body can be replaced - maybe not entirely, not yet anyway, and even parts of the brain can be replaced. The key discovery that awaits is what part of the brain is essential to self-consciousness. THAT is where the ultimate self will be found.
 
Bodhi Dharma Zen

Bodhi Dharma Zen,
let me join your discussion.

I do not believe that the self is the brain as others ( uruk, correa neto, .. ) believe.
However, if you believe that your self is with your brain, you are with your brain in the lab and not in the train.
In your " Matrix " example, Keanu Reeves ( before meeting with Morpheus ) would be in the brain with his physical body and not in the " Matrix ".

Again, this using the assumption taht your self is with your brain ( which I do not believe )
 
You missed the point. The "I" would be at the senses location. If you say that the "I" is a physical process (correct me if this is not what you believe) then how can you explain that the location of the "I" (from the subject point of view) is different from the external observers (you and the evil scientist) point of view?
I do believe the "I" is a physical process. The body may have the senses but it is your brain that recieves and processes the sensory information into an experiance. My body would simply be under remote control. I would see my brain in lab with the Doc, but I would know that "I" am really with the Doc. If the doctor destroyed body, "I" would still be in the lab. If the doctor destroyed my brain "I" would cease to be.
How about an example like The Matrix? The "I" is inside a computer simulation, not in the body located at the "batteries towers". Another way to say it: the sound occurs in your speakers, not in the radio station.
I think I'm beginning to see what you mean. I think your saying the "I" is where ever the sensory information in telling you where you are. But remember that the sensory information is meaningless unless there is a brain to process the signals. The brain is the focal point and it can be fooled by the information that it is recieving.
You may believe that that the "I" is with the remote body or in a 'matrix'. but when the brain is physicaly affected the "I" is affected. If the remote or matrix body is damaged, the "I" still remains but the sensory information is changed. If the brain is affected the "I" can be changed or affected. Look up lobotomies, alzhimers, and various brain injuries in which the personality of the person has been affected.
Lets take your example with a twist. Your brain is in your friends body but radio connected to your body senses, and your friends brain is in your body but connected to his body senses. Where are you both? Do you think that you will answer, to a straight question, that you "are" in your friends body?
Ok lets look at this example further. What would happen if the body with your brain in it gets destroyed? What about if the body your in control of gets destroyed?
 
uruk said:
I think I'm beginning to see what you mean. I think your saying the "I" is where ever the sensory information in telling you where you are. But remember that the sensory information is meaningless unless there is a brain to process the signals. The brain is the focal point and it can be fooled by the information that it is recieving.

Well, Im not saying, at all, that the brain does not hold the "I". Of course, without a brain-senses combination, there is no "I". Still, from the subjective point of view, this "I" is located at the dream/virtual reality/remote controled senses and body, and what Im trying to say is that, because of this, it is nonsense (again, from HIS subjective point of view) to think that "he" is somewhere else.

This very notion makes the "I" independent of its "source". So, in a way, this "I" is not the brain. Again, from HIS point of view.

English is not my first language, that might be a problem to communicate what Im trying to say.
 
Bodhi Dharma Zen

Bodhi Dharma Zen

May I ask you ..

Are you Japanese ?

Do you practize Zen or is it just your nick name ?

Matteo
 
Matteo Martini said:
...snip...
So, as far as I have understood, you think that the we humans ( maybe animals as well ) are made of a body and a mind.

Those parts of the brain " produce " our thoughts, our rememberings, our feelings more or less like the body produces sweat, tears and other organic liquids.

Yes, something quite like that. I just would add the importance of internal and external stimulae. Without external stimulae, there´s no (or very little) learning.

Matteo Martini said:
...snip...
Please correct me if I am not interpretating your thought correctly or if I am missing any important part of your thought.
You said that you defined SCness as " I think that I exist ", I hope you agree that, along with SCness, come feelings, that is, if you are SC you " feel " pain or pleasure, if you are not SC you do not feel pain and pleasure.
So, even if SCness is not only " feeling pain or pleasure ", only SC beings can feel pain or pleasure, other can not.
So, having the ability to " feel " is a criteria to know if a being is SC or not.

Not exactly. Note that the skill or ability of perceiving external and internal inputs changes from species to species. A plant is alive, and receives external and external inputs, and reacts to them (grows in a certain direction, closes leaves, etc.). A dog can see itself and hitch or lick a given part, and so on. So, to each species, a certain type (I will avoid terms such as level or degree because I don´t want to imply a hyerarchy) of self-consiousness, evolved to fulfill the needs of its survival.

For humans, "I think that I exist" would be the core for a definition. "I think that I exist", plus a lot of other qualifiers, such as "I am composed by a number of organs, with a given status, with a given size, etc..." would be a better definition for what each of us consider self-consiousness.

We question our existence, we try to gauge exactly what it is, why we are here, etc. Flys, most likely, don´t. Because our data processing devices are much more sophisticated and we have free time to do so.

Matteo Martini said:
I agree that you can not prove to others that you have feelings, and others can not prove to you that they have feelings, even if they shout and cry if their hand is bitten by a dog, they can not " prove " scientifically to you that they actually felt pain. However, each of us can be sure that, at least he/she is SC because he/she knows that he/she has the ability to feel pain.

No, it can be proven that the animal or the human felt pain. Measurements of nerve and brain activity would clearly show the electrochemical messages exchanges between neurons that mean "OUCH!". Even an emotion could be detected in such way.

Matteo Martini said:

Now, according to what I think is your opinion, self-consciousness ( I will call it SC ) is a part or the whole sum of our " mind ", so, along with our memory and the other our abilities, may be related to one or more parts of our brain. Question: do you think our SC is just another part of our mind ( therefore, we have our memory, our ability to undestand other people speaking, our ability to understand difference in colours, etc. and we have SCness ) or it is the sum of all the properties of our mind ( therefore, our SCness is the sum of our memory, our ability to undestand other people speaking, our ability to understand difference in colours, etc. ) ?

First answer me if what you are calling "self-consiousness" is not the same concect as the "self". It seems to me that what you call self-consiousness is quite like the self.

There are a lot of processes that are not consient and there are also abstract thoughts that do not need the notion of self-consiousness to be carried on (solving an equation, for example). One just concentrates on the problem and tries to solve it, without having to ponder about anything else. But note that the process may be stopped by inputs from the body (FEED ME!).

So, if you are separating the notions, and calling self-consiousness just the act of "thinking or acknoweledging my own existence " then I would say that its part of our mind, since it´s a tought like many others. But, if you are actually considering the self, then memories and skills are part of the self. And, before you ask, yes, I think the self is also generated by interactions between the brain, the body and the environment.

Matteo Martini said:
Now, along with uruk, I think you agree that SC can and will one day be measured " scientifically ", we will be able to relate SC of the individual to the activity of some parts of his/her brain ( measuring brain activity by a PET scan or other modern instrument used in neurophysiology ).

Now, please tell me if you ( and uruk if he wants to join ) agree that what I stated above is your opinion.

Yes, I think so. I also think that the chances that we will someday build machines advanced enough to be deemed self-consient, even by humans standards, are high.
 
Matteo

Im Mexican, and I practiced regularly. I do not suscribe to any religion/philosophy in particular, but like the way Monks live, and their goals.
 
Self- consciousness

Correa Neto,
first let me clarify one point.
Consciousness = I think ( or I know ) that there is a world outside.
Self- Consciousness = I think ( I know ) that there is a world outside and that I am living in this world.
Do you agree with those definitions ?
Do not you think that consciousness involves SCness ?
If there is a world outside there has to be somebody looking at it and that somebody is me ( self-consciousness ).
I agree that I may have caused some confusion because I used the terms Self- Consciousness and Consciousness indifferently.
So, if you agree, I will talk about consciousness from now on ..

Yes, something quite like that. I just would add the importance of internal and external stimulae. Without external stimulae, there´s no (or very little) learning.
OK, I agree with that

Not exactly. Note that the skill or ability of perceiving external and internal inputs changes from species to species. A plant is alive, and receives external and external inputs, and reacts to them (grows in a certain direction, closes leaves, etc.). A dog can see itself and hitch or lick a given part, and so on. So, to each species, a certain type (I will avoid terms such as level or degree because I don´t want to imply a hyerarchy) of self-consiousness, evolved to fulfill the needs of its survival.
I agree with what you are saying, however, I do not see what this has to do with my argument that you have consciousness if and only if you have the ability to feel pain and pleasure ( along with other feelings ).
But maybe I did not get your point.
Or maybe you are stating that your ability to feel pain or pleasure comes from internal and external inputs ?
If you wanted to say so, I agree, even if I would say that pain and pleasure can also come from thoughts, memories and many other things.

No, it can be proven that the animal or the human felt pain. Measurements of nerve and brain activity would clearly show the electrochemical messages exchanges between neurons that mean "OUCH!". Even an emotion could be detected in such way.
Well, let me try to make an example.
Let' s imagine a person gets a bullet in the head
Now, he/she is brainly dead, but his / her body is still " alive ", his / her hearth is still pulsing, he/she still breaths, of course because he / she is connected with machines that keep him/her alive.
I read about some cases of this kind on newspapers.
Now, I would imagine that, under some circumstances, the body could still respond and give electromechanical answers to stimuli, for example, his /her hearth keeps beating forced with stimuli from mechanical machines, but this is no proof that the person is still alive, if his/her brain is dead ( and you say brain = self ).
Another example: you know that with some animals, those animals which look like crocodiles but are much much smaller and live everywhere, sorry Google does not translate the word " lucertola " in English, after the animal is dead, there is still electrochemical activity in their nerves ?
They move after they are dead.
So, electrochemical activity in the body may not be regarded as a proof that the person feels anything because it may happen also when to person is dead.

So, if you are separating the notions, and calling self-consiousness just the act of "thinking or acknoweledging my own existence " then I would say that its part of our mind, since it´s a tought like many others. But, if you are actually considering the self, then memories and skills are part of the self. And, before you ask, yes, I think the self is also generated by interactions between the brain, the body and the environment
Ok, I understand this.

Now let me ask one final question:
You say that consciousness ( and SCness ), along with memory, facial recognition, etc. are products of the brain so you can link, for example, memory to an area of the brain, facial recognition to another area and consciousness to another area.
I assume to do this you have to do some tests.
For example, you may ask a person to look at five cards and then, while using a PET scan, look at his/her brain when he/she tries to remember the cards.
This way you can link the memory ability to a part of the brain.
Same thing with facial recognition.
You show the person ten different faces and then, while using a PET scan, ask him/her which face is which person.
This way you can link facial recognition ability to another part of the brain.
Now, how would you do the test to understand which area of the brain is linked to consciousness ?
Would you ask the person " Are you conscious now, and are you 100 % conscious or 95 % " ?

Matteo
 
Re: Self- consciousness

Matteo Martini said:
Correa Neto,
first let me clarify one point.
Consciousness = I think ( or I know ) that there is a world outside.
Self- Consciousness = I think ( I know ) that there is a world outside and that I am living in this world.
Do you agree with those definitions ?
Do not you think that consciousness involves SCness ?
If there is a world outside there has to be somebody looking at it and that somebody is me ( self-consciousness ).
I agree that I may have caused some confusion because I used the terms Self- Consciousness and Consciousness indifferently.
So, if you agree, I will talk about consciousness from now on ..

There´s a lot on confusion here. The way I understood it, you seem to be referring to the self sometimes and to self-consiousness other times. These are two different concepts, and one may be part of the other. The self experiences self-consiousness, but it is not self consciousness.

Consiousness is another different thing. Awaken, asleep, stunned, these are consiousness states (and the self experiences it also). So, the concepts are all messed up.

Now, regarding "Consciousness = I think ( or I know ) that there is a world outside."

I agree partialy. We receive inputs from the external world that allow us to interpret it (please let´s leave solipsism and variants aside, otherwise this ain´t going nowhere). But, if you are inside one of those chambers that isolate you from external stimulae (used in the 60s for experiments) -or an hipothetic version that cuts all external inputs- you still would get inputs from your own body. Better define it as a degree of awareness of your body and your surroundings, something as awake, asleep, comatose, half-asleep, stunned, etc.

"Self- Consciousness = I think ( I know ) that there is a world outside and that I am living in this world. "

I do not agree, for self-consiousness includes, as the name says, knoweledge of yourself, your physical limits, your skils, etc. It is not restricted to the external world. So, as I wrote before,

"For humans, "I think that I exist" would be the core for a definition. "I think that I exist", plus a lot of other qualifiers, such as "I am composed by a number of organs, with a given status, with a given size, etc..." would be a better definition for what each of us consider self-consiousness"

Note that in this case, it blends with the concept of self. Actually I think that you are talking, most of the times, about the self. But note that the "I think that I exist and that my limits are..." is felt by the self... Kind like a snake biting its own tail, eh?

Matteo Martini said:
I agree with what you are saying, however, I do not see what this has to do with my argument that you have consciousness if and only if you have the ability to feel pain and pleasure ( along with other feelings ).
But maybe I did not get your point.
Or maybe you are stating that your ability to feel pain or pleasure comes from internal and external inputs ?
If you wanted to say so, I agree, even if I would say that pain and pleasure can also come from thoughts, memories and many other things.

Yes, it comes from external inputs and in some cases internal (both internal to our body, say in the case of a disease, or from our mind as memories and toughts -that I consider that also qualifies as related to the body, but related to data stored and processed in the brain).

Note that "pleasure" in many cases is something that is learned, while pain (even tought we can be consitioned to feel different levels). Pain is a physical sensation -even tought we quite often use it in a figurative way ( to omply sadness, for example "her absence causes me pain"). "Pleasure" is relative to our conditioning, one just have to look at the various individual tastes and cultures to see this.

Matteo Martini said:
Well, let me try to make an example.
Let' s imagine a person gets a bullet in the head
Now, he/she is brainly dead, but his / her body is still " alive ", his / her hearth is still pulsing, he/she still breaths, of course because he / she is connected with machines that keep him/her alive.
I read about some cases of this kind on newspapers.
Now, I would imagine that, under some circumstances, the body could still respond and give electromechanical answers to stimuli, for example, his /her hearth keeps beating forced with stimuli from mechanical machines, but this is no proof that the person is still alive, if his/her brain is dead ( and you say brain = self ).
Another example: you know that with some animals, those animals which look like crocodiles but are much much smaller and live everywhere, sorry Google does not translate the word " lucertola " in English, after the animal is dead, there is still electrochemical activity in their nerves ?
They move after they are dead.
So, electrochemical activity in the body may not be regarded as a proof that the person feels anything because it may happen also when to person is dead.

Lucertola = lizzard. It also happens with frogs.

You are making another confusion here. There are diffrent types of electrochemical reactions/message exchanges in our bodies. Some are involuntary, related to basic functions that keep the body alive (pumping of blood by the heart, stomach/intestine movments, etc. ). These functions may continue for some time after the brain is dead. Scans of electrochemical activity in animals and humans with severe brain damage shows patterns that can be compared to healthy ones, and there are enormous differences in the level of activity. Please read the links posted by the other posters in this and other threads for more detail. You´ll see that in people with cerebral death, only some of these "autonomous functions" are still going on, and restricted to certain areas of the brain. Sure, the exact pattern will depend on the affected areas of the brain.

Matteo Martini said:

Now let me ask one final question:
You say that consciousness ( and SCness ), along with memory, facial recognition, etc. are products of the brain so you can link, for example, memory to an area of the brain, facial recognition to another area and consciousness to another area.
I assume to do this you have to do some tests.
For example, you may ask a person to look at five cards and then, while using a PET scan, look at his/her brain when he/she tries to remember the cards.
This way you can link the memory ability to a part of the brain.
Same thing with facial recognition.
You show the person ten different faces and then, while using a PET scan, ask him/her which face is which person.
This way you can link facial recognition ability to another part of the brain.
Now, how would you do the test to understand which area of the brain is linked to consciousness ?
Would you ask the person " Are you conscious now, and are you 100 % conscious or 95 % " ?

Matteo

The tests you decsribed were already made several times. There are several documentaries on Discovery and similar channels on the subject.

Once again, I am no neurologist, but regarding self-consiousness, I recall reading about experiences where the subjects were under the influence of drugs, at several degress of sleep, deprived of oxigen, etc. A number of standard questions were posed. I think you agree that someone who can´t remember its own name is not in the same state as someone who can...
 
In 1978, Daniel Dennett wrote a sci-fi story which addresses this question in a very interesting way. Titled (appropriately enough): Where Am I?, it is excerpted here.
 
Dymanic
Thanks for the link, I will look at the excerpt

Now, Correa Neto, I think we are getting closer to understand each other.

Just some more posts ??
:)


There´s a lot on confusion here. The way I understood it, you seem to be referring to the self sometimes and to self-consiousness other times. These are two different concepts, and one may be part of the other. The self experiences self-consiousness, but it is not self consciousness
Yes, I may have used self and SCness concepts indifferently. I will try to make a better use of those terms from now on ..

Consiousness is another different thing. Awaken, asleep, stunned, these are consiousness states (and the self experiences it also). So, the concepts are all messed up.
Now, regarding "Consciousness = I think ( or I know ) that there is a world outside."
I agree partialy. We receive inputs from the external world that allow us to interpret it (please let´s leave solipsism and variants aside, otherwise this ain´t going nowhere). But, if you are inside one of those chambers that isolate you from external stimulae (used in the 60s for experiments) -or an hipothetic version that cuts all external inputs- you still would get inputs from your own body. Better define it as a degree of awareness of your body and your surroundings, something as awake, asleep, comatose, half-asleep, stunned, etc.
OK, I agree with your definition thaat consciousness is a " degree of awareness of your body and your surroundings, something as awake, asleep, comatose, half-asleep, stunned "
I would add that counscious beings have the ability to feel ( pain, pleasure, cold, hot, love, hate, or at least some of those, some animals may not feel " hate ", but at least they have the ability to feel pain ) while non-conscious beings do not have the ability to feel anything.
This is important because gives a discrimination between conscious and non-conscious beings

"For humans, "I think that I exist" would be the core for a definition. "I think that I exist", plus a lot of other qualifiers, such as "I am composed by a number of organs, with a given status, with a given size, etc..." would be a better definition for what each of us consider self-consiousness"
Well, I would define self-consciusness as a higher degree of consciousness, where you not only are conscious of " your body and your surroundings, something as awake, asleep, comatose, half-asleep, stunned, etc. ", but also have an image of " yourself " in your mind.
Again, I would stick to the concept of " conciousness " because it seems that it the concept more clear and about which we both agree.

Yes, it comes from external inputs and in some cases internal (both internal to our body, say in the case of a disease, or from our mind as memories and toughts -that I consider that also qualifies as related to the body, but related to data stored and processed in the brain).
I called your internal stimuli as external because coming from externally of the brain.
However, we both agree that counscious beings have the ability to feel ( pain, pleasure, cold, hot, love, hate, or at least some of those ) while non-conscious beings do not have the ability to feel anything and that is the important thing

Note that "pleasure" in many cases is something that is learned, while pain (even tought we can be consitioned to feel different levels). Pain is a physical sensation -even tought we quite often use it in a figurative way ( to omply sadness, for example "her absence causes me pain"). "Pleasure" is relative to our conditioning, one just have to look at the various individual tastes and cultures to see this.
I think you are " finding the hair in the egg " as we say here in Italy.
Let' s call pleasure as " desired " feeling and pain as " non-desired " feeling

You are making another confusion here. There are diffrent types of electrochemical reactions/message exchanges in our bodies. Some are involuntary, related to basic functions that keep the body alive (pumping of blood by the heart, stomach/intestine movments, etc. ). These functions may continue for some time after the brain is dead. Scans of electrochemical activity in animals and humans with severe brain damage shows patterns that can be compared to healthy ones, and there are enormous differences in the level of activity. Please read the links posted by the other posters in this and other threads for more detail. You´ll see that in people with cerebral death, only some of these "autonomous functions" are still going on, and restricted to certain areas of the brain. Sure, the exact pattern will depend on the affected areas of the brain.
OK, but you agree that your sentence " No, it can be proven that the animal or the human felt pain. Measurements of nerve and brain activity would clearly show the electrochemical messages exchanges between neurons that mean "OUCH!". Even an emotion could be detected in such way " is questionable.
If some brain activity ( " electrochemical messages exchanges between neurons " ) can go on even after the person's death, your assumption that, when there is some brain activity in a certain area of the brain the person has actually felt the pain is questionable.
If we keep the body alive after a person death ( with artificial respiration and connecting the hearth to a machine ) and maybe some parts of the brain are still working for some time, you can not rule out that it is possible that a researcher could put a sting in the ( dead ) person hand and you see some kind of response in the brain even if the person is dead.
But I admit I am making many assumptions about this, since I am no neurologist.

The tests you decsribed were already made several times. There are several documentaries on Discovery and similar channels on the subject.
Once again, I am no neurologist, but regarding self-consiousness, I recall reading about experiences where the subjects were under the influence of drugs, at several degress of sleep, deprived of oxigen, etc. A number of standard questions were posed. I think you agree that someone who can´t remember its own name is not in the same state as someone who can...
Well, I do not understand how you can pose question to a subject sleeping. :)
However, this is my main point so I would like to have an answer from you here.
I would like to know how you test if a person is conscious or not ( and to which degree ) in order to " look " at his/her brain and see which are the areas which affect consciousness.
When you say " I think you agree that someone who can´t remember its own name is not in the same state as someone who can... " you are talking about memory, and a test to see if a person has good memory or not, not consciousness.
Remember that someone said in this thread ( I think you agree with this ) that consciousness is a continuos property that goes from zero ( rock ) to higher and higher degrees in the evolution scale ( fishes, birds, dogs, men ).
So, we need a test to find out if a person is conscious or not ( and, important, at which degree of consciousness ) in order to relate a person's consciousness to brain activity in a certain part of the brain, how would you hypothetically design such a test ?
 
I forgot one thing about consciousness.
In my opinion, if you are asleep and you feel hungry, or cold, or you are in a dream and you feel scared, that is consciousness as well.
If you feel something, you have to be conscious in some way in some degree.
I hope you agree with that.
 
Matteo Martini said:

Well, I would define self-consciusness as a higher degree of consciousness, where you not only are conscious of " your body and your surroundings, something as awake, asleep, comatose, half-asleep, stunned, etc. ", but also have an image of " yourself " in your mind.
Again, I would stick to the concept of " conciousness " because it seems that it the concept more clear and about which we both agree.

No! To be consious is one thing (it just means a being receives external impulses and reacts propperly, to a given level). To be self-consicent is another, and the self is a third one! The distinctions are important, and calling blue of red will not help, since it will lead to mistakes. Please state if you are reffering to the self or to sel-counsicence. The definitions may seem blurred but that´s important.

Matteo Martini said:
I called your internal stimuli as external because coming from externally of the brain.
However, we both agree that counscious beings have the ability to feel ( pain, pleasure, cold, hot, love, hate, or at least some of those ) while non-conscious beings do not have the ability to feel anything and that is the important thing

Define non-counsient beings. A rock is not a being. Lets stick to living entities. Peasure is more complex than pain. It is a learned sensation. A given animal may feel pain after being hit, but not pleasure by remembering something. You are mixing different things.

Matteo Martini said:
I think you are " finding the hair in the egg " as we say here in Italy.
Let' s call pleasure as " desired " feeling and pain as " non-desired " feeling

No, I´m not, neither I am finding horns in horse´s heads. The distinctions are important, since you are mixing different things and concepts. Pain requires no or little thinking to be felt, while hate and pleasure does. So, check above to see the importance. Its not a question of desire or not. Its a question of being able to have these feelings or tought patterns or not.

Consiousness is a degree of awareness. Self consiousness its to be able to recognize what you are made of, it also comes in degrees but one must actually do much more data processing to have this "feeling". A plant could be seen as counscient of it surroundings (it reacts to external stimulae) within its limitations, but its rather unlikely its self-counsicent.

Matteo Martini said:

Well, I do not understand how you can pose question to a subject sleeping. :)

These tests he been done more than once. Please check the links, otherwise this ain´t going nowhere. What part of the "the subjects were under the influence of drugs, at several degress of sleep, deprived of oxigen, etc" you have not understood? If the subject is asleep, passed out etc. of course it will not respond. And this does not invalidates the tests, since we already know brain actvity patterns during the sleep, as well as the responses of the subjects to external stimulae at each stage of sleep like REM, stages without dreams, etc. And we can compare them with comatose states, for example.

Please follow the links, and do a bit more reading on the subjects, so the discussion can be a bit more productive...

Matteo Martini said:
However, this is my main point so I would like to have an answer from you here.
I would like to know how you test if a person is conscious or not ( and to which degree ) in order to " look " at his/her brain and see which are the areas which affect consciousness.
When you say " I think you agree that someone who can´t remember its own name is not in the same state as someone who can... " you are talking about memory, and a test to see if a person has good memory or not, not consciousness.
Remember that someone said in this thread ( I think you agree with this ) that consciousness is a continuos property that goes from zero ( rock ) to higher and higher degrees in the evolution scale ( fishes, birds, dogs, men ).
So, we need a test to find out if a person is conscious or not ( and, important, at which degree of consciousness ) in order to relate a person's consciousness to brain activity in a certain part of the brain, how would you hypothetically design such a test ?

It has already been answered. And please state if you are reffering to the self or to sel-counscience.
Note that you experince several levels of counsicence and self-counsience everyday. They are not the absolute referentials you imply they are. Every degree of these will imply a level of say, memory or awareness ot the surroundings and your own body. So, these can be used to gauge your level of self-counsience.
 
Correa Neto,
so consciousness = " it as a degree of awareness of your body and your surroundings, something as awake, asleep, comatose, half-asleep, stunned "
Than you say again that " Consiousness is a degree of awareness "

Now, you said that " brain activity can be correlated with degrees of consiousness ", so I imagine there might be test that correlates consciouness to activity of one or more parts of the brain.
How would we perform such a test ?
We should start speaking about relations between faculties of the person, or if you prefer the " self ", to properties of the " self " ( or call it " mind " ) such as memory, speech recognition, face recognition, logical reasoning and activity of some part of the brain.
For example, if we want to find out which part of the brain is dedicated to memory, we have to do a test which involves memory ability, and when the person is recalling something, look at the brain and see which part is working.
Then we will discover which part of the brain is dedicated to memory.
For example, we can put a woman under PET scan, show her three cards and then, when we put the cards away ask her to remember the cards.
When she is doing this, we can " look " at her brain activity and see which is the part of the brain which works.
Then we will know how to relate memory with a certain part of the brain which involves memory.
Same thing with speech recognition, we can make this woman listen to a difficult dialogue and ask her to report it on paper.
When this woman is listening to the dialogue, we " look " at her brain activity and see which parts are involved.
Then we will know how to relate speech recognition to a certain part of the brain which involves speech recognition.
Same thing for visual recognition, we can ask this woman to look at ten different faces and then to associate at each face his/her name.
When this woman is doing this, we " look " at her brain activity and see which parts are involved.
Then we will know how to relate visual recognition to a certain part of the brain which involves visual recognition.
Now, you said that " Brain activity can be correlated with degrees of consiousness ", so let' s try to imagine a similar test, in which the researcher:
1) performs a test similar to the ones described above in order to find out if a person is conscious or not and at which degree;
2) looks at which areas of the brain are working when he is performing such a test;
3) finds out that those areas of the brain are related to consciousness.
So, let' s think to a test, similar to the one described above, to find out if a person is conscious and at which degree.
Note that we can not say " that person is conscious because this or that part of his/her brain is working " because we have to do the test before looking at his/her brain, we are still at point number one of the list.
Also note that you defined consciousness as " a degree of awareness of your body and your surroundings ".
Note that the test should be " scientifical ", we can not say that the woman " seems " conscious, or seems little bit conscious, we have to have some evidence of what we are saying.
In the example above, the evidence was:
1) in memory, the fact that the woman was remembering which cards she saw;
2) in speech recognition, the fact that the woman was able to report the dialogue che was listening correctly;
3) in facial recognition, tha fact that the woman is associating correctly each face to the name of the person.
Note the woman is in front of you, looking at you and waiting.
She seems to be awake, so you might say " of course she is conscius, she is awake !! "
But I would say that it is not a proof of " being aware of her body and her surroundings "
Then you can put her hand on a little fire and she will scream and you would say " look, she is screaming, she is aware of her body.
No, this is no proof !!
What has happened is:
1) the nervous receptors in her hand have received the input from the hot source of the heat;
2) the signal has moved from her hand to her arm til the part of the brain that recollects the signals of the enviroinment;
3) the part of her brain the recollects the signal of the environment decoded this signal as " excessive heat " and sends a signal to the part of the brain that is dedicated to the movement of her body, with the order of " take off the hand "
4) the signal of " take off the hand " arrives to the spinal chord
5) the spinal chord gives the order to the muscle of thearmto take off the hand
6) the muscle of the arm contracts and the woman takes off the hand
7) in the meantime, the part of her brain the recollects the signal of the environment decoded gives the order to the part of the brain devoted to speech synthesis to say " Ouch ! "
8) the part of the brain devoted to speech synthesis send the signal to the mouth and tongue to say " ouch ! "
9) the woman says " ouch ! "

Beware that, at point number 2) when we say that " the signal arrived to the part of the brain that recollects the signals from the body ", there is no proof that the woman actually felt pain.
It is just a nervous signal that has arrived to a part of the brain and generated other nervous signals, there is no proof that there is " awareness of her body and her surroundings "
So, how do we know that, with all this movement of nervous signals from the hand to the head, then to the arm and to the mouth, the woman actually felt pain ?
We have none.
The fact that she cried ?
This is another nervous signal to the eyes that made tears go out of the eye.
Well, she says that she recollects pain.
After this experiment, a nervous signal goes to the area of the brain dedicated to memory where stores the data " 25 October, felt pain, researcher a** hole " but that' s just a nervous signal which goes to the memory area, that is it.
Only nervous signals that travel around our body, and move the mouth and of the tongue in order to speak, that store data in her memory, that perform logical and operations, that decode signals of the environment.
Where is consciousness = " degree of awareness of your body and your surroundings " ?
There is no proof that the woman was aware of all this !!
It is just movement of neurons.
Of course, you can say, but the woman has seen, listened all this.
What is seeing ?
Just light that goes to the eye, being decoded somehow, travels along the nerves til the brain and stored in memory.
What is hearing ?
Just waves of pression which go to the head, being decoded somehow, travels along the nerves til the brain and stored in memory.
Of course she remembers all this, how can she be unconscious of what has happened ?
But remembering is moving nervous sygnals in the brain in the memory area, no proof that while all this happens the woman is aware of this.
No proof that the woman is aware of the hot in her hand, of her scream of her arm, ..
No proof that the woman is aware " of your her and her surroundings "
You may say, but how is it possible that memory, processing signals of hot/cold, visual and hearing recognition, memory can happen without consciousness ?
This happens today.
I hope you agree that we have no proof that a computer is conscious, but a computer can decode signals ( so point no 2 can happen without consciousness ), can do speech synthesis ( so point no 7 can happen without consciousness ), can do visual and hearing recognition, can store information in memory.
Of course, not as good as the brain of the woman does, but it is a quantitative difference, not qualitative.
So all what happens in point 1 through 9 can happen also without consciosness.

So, why do we " know " inside that the woman really felt pain ?
We use this thought:
1) I am sure at least I am conscious, I do not know how I know it, but I know that if I put an hand on the fire I feel pain and I have the same reactions of that woman in that situation;
2) The woman in that situation had the same reactions I would have has in her situation
3) The woman " really " felt pain

It is easy to see why this assuption is an " act-of-faith ", there is no proof that point three is true, that the woman really felt pain even if she had the same reactions that I would have in the same situation in which I would feel pain.
Point three is not provable " scientifically ".

So, the woman maybe was never aware of her body and her surroindings ( = consciousness ), we can never have a proof that in this or that situation she was aware

So, maybe , she is just a body, living if we can say " living ", but maybe her " self " is not conscious, she is not conscious, maybe the woman's " self " ( even if we have not defined " self " yet ) does not even exist, maybe other people' s selves do not even exist, maybe I am the only " conscious being in the universe.

It is clear to see that this path may lead to solipsism and to the mad-house, so we will discard this option practically, but pleasae remember that solipsism can not be proven wrong " scientifically "

And you can not prove that the woman felt pain " scientifically ".

So, why we can prove that the woman has memory, visual and speech recognition " scientifically " and we can not prove the the woman has consciousness " scientifically " ?
Because with memory we have proofs, the fact that the woman says the name of the same cards that she and the researcher saw it is a proof that she remembers.
Same thing with speech and visual recognition, there is an independent proof, the transcript of the speech and the correct link between faces and names that prove that the woman' s facial and speech recognition are working.
But, as we saw, there is no proof that the woman actually " felt " pain, you can explain her cry, the movement of her hand with nervous signals and encoding / decoding of nervous signals.
No independent proof here.
Of course, the woman might remember what has happened, but that proves memory ability, not consciousness.

You may think at any test possible but you will always find that, when you try to prove that a person is conscious ( = aware of her body and surroundings ) you will only be able to prove that the nervous signals in that body work well, but not consciousness.
That another person really has consciousness is always more or less an act-of-faith.

Remember the the three steps to prove scientifically that consciousness is generates by activity of one or more partd of the brain:
1) performs a test similar to the ones described above in order to find out if a person is conscious or not and at which degree;
2) looks at which areas of the brain are working when he is performing such a test;
3) finds out that those areas of the brain are related to

I hope you now agree that steo number one can not be performed in any way we could design a test.
Therefore, we will never be albe to design a test that proves that a person is conscious or not.
Never, not today nor tomorrow.

So, there is no way we can scientifically relate one person's consciousness to any part of the brain.

I hope I made my points clear now, I do not know if you agree with me, but at least I hope I have expalined my points effectively.

Matteo

P.S.
Happy 2005 !!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom