when have you changed your mind on a matter?

I get the feeling that at the time Darwin brought out his book you would have been one of those ridiculing him, perhaps (if forums had existed then) coming here and calling him a "fundie nutjob" as you seem to so enjoy calling others.

I certainly doubt I personally would have done anything of the kind.

Regarding the antibiotic resistance thing, I know little about the topic, but Milton seems to refute it.
Basically I go back to what I said last night.. that in thousands of generations of intelligence-driven human selective breeding of dogs and horses we've never managed to get anything that isn't just a plain old dog and a plain old horse. I would say that this evidence strongly suggests that Darwinian natural selection is impotent to explain the presence of millions of variegated and incredibly complex species, that are supposedly (according to your ideology) meant to have descended from a single celled organism :)

Face it, it's a belief without evidence

You know absolutely nothing about evolution or the evidence for/against it, face it. Antibiotic resistance has nothing to do with supposed selective breeding limitations whatsoever, and you're really starting to show your ignorance.

What would you expect to get when you breed two dogs? A giraffe?

How would you decide when a dog has become a non-dog, anyway? By sight? That's the usual creationist answer, but of course, it's a ridiculous one.

You've been given lots of examples of speciation, and you rejected them all without good reason.

ETA: Evolution is more than just natural selection. That's what mutations are for.
 
I get the feeling that at the time Darwin brought out his book you would have been one of those ridiculing him, perhaps (if forums had existed then) coming here and calling him a "fundie nutjob" as you seem to so enjoy calling others.
I should certainly have had grave doubts about his views at the time that they were first published. I have said, in so many words, that his views should have been subjected to criticism, just like those of every other scientist.

As you may recall, unless you've been stuck down by one of your bouts of amnesia, I wrote:
Should no-one have criticised Darwin? I should be interested to hear your views.

I'm a skeptic, and so I think that his ideas should have been open to criticism just like those of every other scientist...

I should not, of course, have called him a "fundie nutjob", since he was obviously neither.

But according to your current beliefs, you would have been completely wrong to do so, and may even, looking back, felt yourself to have been acting arrogantly and rather foolishly, with little intellectual humility.
Can you see this?
No, I have explicitly said that those who criticised were right to do so.

Whereas you feel free to ignore the past 150 years of accumulated knowledge, while linking me to sites which suggest that he should have been above criticism.

Regarding the antibiotic resistance thing, I know little about the topic ...
I'm sure you do, yes.

Basically I go back to what I said last night..
You're going to go back to reciting a lie which I demonstrated to be false by extensive citation of the scientific literature?

Your mind would appear to be closed for business.
 
Last edited:
lol

pretty sensitive on that one, aren't you chaps? ;-)

speaks to me of some kind of emotional attachment to the theory. Not, strictly speaking, something a skeptic should be indulging in, is it
 
lol

pretty sensitive on that one, aren't you chaps? ;-)

speaks to me of some kind of emotional attachment to the theory. Not, strictly speaking, something a skeptic should be indulging in, is it
What are you babbling about now?
 
I don't know much about parapsychology, but looking at the history of science it wouldn't surprise me that, not being part of the accepted mainstream, its evidence may not be treated as fairly as other more mainstream areas of inquiry, like chemistry, for example

You were the one that suggested that skeptics are ignoring factual information in the area of parapsychology in a previous post - why did you even mention it then?

So basically, you want to slam or otherwise condem all skpetics for ignoring factual evidence supporting parapsychology - but offer no proof of this happening. I see...well, I'm convinced.
 
You were the one that suggested that skeptics are ignoring factual information in the area of parapsychology in a previous post - why did you even mention it then?

So basically, you want to slam or otherwise condem all skpetics for ignoring factual evidence supporting parapsychology - but offer no proof of this happening. I see...well, I'm convinced.

good, hoped you would be
 
lol

pretty sensitive on that one, aren't you chaps? ;-)

speaks to me of some kind of emotional attachment to the theory. Not, strictly speaking, something a skeptic should be indulging in, is it

No, I think most are just tired of ignorant nitwits spouting of about ToE without knowing the first thing about it...
 
your and others on heres apparent emotional attachment to Darwinian theory... why else jump down the throat of anyone who raises questions about it?
Translated into English --- you wonder why I correct people who get science utterly wrong.

I'm a skeptic. It's one of the things we do.

I guess you could say I'm emotionally attached to factual accuracy. It's a skeptical thing, you wouldn't understand.
 
your and others on heres apparent emotional attachment to Darwinian theory... why else jump down the throat of anyone who raises questions about it?

What exactly have you questioned about it? You questioned weather or not scientist/skeptics would have accepted it right off the bat…that is not questioning the theory itself, simply its acceptance
 
lol

pretty sensitive on that one, aren't you chaps? ;-)

speaks to me of some kind of emotional attachment to the theory. Not, strictly speaking, something a skeptic should be indulging in, is it

I do get emotional when people who know absolutely nothing about something I believe in attack that thing erroneously, and spread those same lies and nonsense until it becomes common "knowledge" amongst the uninformed.
 
your and others on heres apparent emotional attachment to Darwinian theory... why else jump down the throat of anyone who raises questions about it?

But you haven't raised any questions now, have you? Just done the usual "LoL! Ev1lution is a religious belief! lol! no new kinds! Lol!".
 
your and others on heres apparent emotional attachment to Darwinian theory... why else jump down the throat of anyone who raises questions about it?

We don't like being told falsehoods, that's true. But then again, do you know anyone who likes being told blatant falsehoods, especially when repeated in the face of actual evidence?

The only attachhement we have to the theory of evolution itself is one based on evidence. Some of which we've shown to you, but which you've blatantly refused to read. Whereas we have read the links you've shown us, and found them lacking because they were pretty much only claims (and wrong ones at that.)

And hey, isn't someone who refuses to read something that goes against his already made-up mind the one who's emotionally attached to his ideas? Sure sounds logical to me.
 
You're a troll thats why. Not someone genuinely wanting to intelligently debate

the difference between you and me is that I don't try to dismiss people by calling them "trolls"

right chaps, i'm off to have my tea. thanks for your input
 
But you're trying to dismiss people by calling them "orthodox skeptics" instead. A term which is internally self-contradictal, by the way. Just in case you've forgotten that. Which seems likely, considering how easily you forget anything that you don't agree with.

Are you going to read some of the evidence we've presented to you one of these days?
 
thanks for your input
Why thank me? You evidently have no use for facts.

You recited the silly lie about speciation with which you've been indoctrinated, and I went to the trouble of finding the evidence, and I showed you the evidence, and you couldn't refute the evidence, but your sealed-off mind couldn't accept the evidence because it would shatter your rigid world-view.

And, may I add, people with closed minds really tick me off. If everyone was like you, and refused to recognise advances in science, we'd all still be living in caves.
 
Last edited:
What exactly have you questioned about it? You questioned weather or not scientist/skeptics would have accepted it right off the bat…that is not questioning the theory itself, simply its acceptance
Earlier in this thread, and in other threads, he started reciting the creationist orthodoxy about "no new species" and "stasis in the fossil record", and of course I proved him wrong with masses of scientific evidence, which of course he ignored because it conflicted with his indoctrination.
 
As he seems to have dropped the Dawkins thread, I think I'll cross-post.

Does he ever say anything about the species barrier or the stasis nature of the fossill record?
No, and neither do the "Skeptics"
I imagine that, like us, he says that these are lies which creationists tell as a substitute for having any actual evidence for their views.

I've shown up your nonsense about the "species barrier" ... Now, about that "stasis nature of the fossill record" ...

foram_work.gif


238px-Ceratopia.jpg


575px-Dinosaur-to-Bird.jpg


jaws1.gif


hominids2_big.jpg


fossil_hominin_cranial_capacity_lg.png
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom