when have you changed your mind on a matter?

Earlier in this thread, and in other threads, he started reciting the creationist orthodoxy about "no new species" and "stasis in the fossil record", and of course I proved him wrong with masses of scientific evidence, which of course he ignored because it conflicted with his indoctrination.

No he didn't; I'll have no more of your lies! I'm a skeptic, I refuse to be wrong, corrected, or accept proof.....

Sorry, I could not help that....obviously I should have read the entire thread; had I, I would have seen that - Thanks.
 
the difference between you and me is that I don't try to dismiss people by calling them "trolls"

Thats because we are not trolling, and you are (and you know full well you are too)

Off home shortly. I'm sure more and more of our American 'flock' will come online soon and provide you with plenty of action for round 3
 
If we were alive when Darwin first published his great works, I think that many people on this forum would have been interested about what they heard, read the books at their first opportunity, read them again with greater care and interest, thought about what he proposed and the evidence that he layed out in support, raised questions and sought answers.

I certainly would have done this. I would have read his works and thought about them in the scientific context of the time. Given my understanding of the world, I would have been open to his ideas, subject, of course, to a healthy dose of skepticism that they would have to weather while they were being considered, examined, and appreciated.

The theory of evolution is beautiful and, according to all evidence, it is also true.

By the way, skepticism is a challenging and inquisitive way of looking at the world; in particular, it is how we try to approach and examine assertions about reality.

Every idea that we encounter or originate should be subject to the same level of questioning and examination. As some ideas continue to survive skeptical examination, our confidence in them increases. No idea gains our perfect confidence and no idea is immune to reconsideration.

Our goal is to obtain the best understanding of reality that we can.

That, by the way, is also the goal of science.

It is nice to have reality on our side.
 
nice, some photos and diagrams

you could draw all kinds of different conclusions from them.. and in practice the conclusions will tend to be predetermined by your over-arching belief system.

I don't see anything in them that finds strongly in favour of or against the Darwinian hypothesis.
 
If we were alive when Darwin first published his great works, I think that many people on this forum would have been interested about what they heard, read the books at their first opportunity, read them again with greater care and interest, thought about what he proposed and the evidence that he layed out in support, raised questions and sought answers.

I certainly would have done this. I would have read his works and thought about them in the scientific context of the time. Given my understanding of the world, I would have been open to his ideas, subject, of course, to a healthy dose of skepticism that they would have to weather while they were being considered, examined, and appreciated.

The theory of evolution is beautiful and, according to all evidence, it is also true.

By the way, skepticism is a challenging and inquisitive way of looking at the world; in particular, it is how we try to approach and examine assertions about reality.

Every idea that we encounter or originate should be subject to the same level of questioning and examination. As some ideas continue to survive skeptical examination, our confidence in them increases. No idea gains our perfect confidence and no idea is immune to reconsideration.

Our goal is to obtain the best understanding of reality that we can.

That, by the way, is also the goal of science.

It is nice to have reality on our side.



well that's good on you, my friend

in the same vein then I would expect that you now read a lot about currently heretical theories and experiments, and you do so with an open mind and treat the evidence fairly :)
 
One thing plumjam keeps saying is that we refuse to allow our ideas to be demolished and that skeptics are scared to be proven wrong. This is wrong of course. As a skeptic I am not proven wrong, I am enlightened. Many scientific ideas and principles that I believe, are not my ideas. I'm not married to them and I am happy to accept that an idea is wrong and move on.

This contrasts heavily to some who believe they have absolute truth and take being shown wrong personally. A skeptic always has some doubt.

If I read between the lines plumjam's problem stems from science's default rejection of the paranormal as an explanation (I believe this is his "Skeptical Orthodoxy"). This, to me, is one of science's tools. It simply insists that we look for natural explanations. I have no fear that this default position will ever keep us from finding the truth.

The Wright Brothers may have been ridiculed and whatever but airplanes still actually fly.

We know what Galileo went through but the earth did and still orbits the sun.

Some people still laugh and criticize Darwin but living things still keep evolving.

Science has a default position to reject the paranormal but if the paranormal is real it will be shown as fact regardless of our positions.

In the end our beliefs have no effect on facts. Skeptics understand this.

Science is a tool but science is done by humans. Humans can lie, cheat, cover up, be political, have agendas and all those other human weaknesses. Fortunately, scientific method eventually filters this out.
 
well that's good on you, my friend

in the same vein then I would expect that you now read a lot about currently heretical theories and experiments, and you do so with an open mind and treat the evidence fairly :)
You mean, like you'll read about all the evidence for the theory of evolution (starting with a biology textbook) with an open mind and treat the evidence fairly?

After all, you wouldn't demand from others to do something that you have no intention of doing yourself, right?
 
nice, some photos and diagrams

you could draw all kinds of different conclusions from them.. and in practice the conclusions will tend to be predetermined by your over-arching belief system.

I don't see anything in them that finds strongly in favour of or against the Darwinian hypothesis.

OK, then, mr. open minded plumjam: what evidence WOULD change your mind with respect to any of YOUR deeply held beliefs? So far, many posters have offered heaps of evidence which you have ignored. So, since you claim to be open minded, please tell us what sort of evidence could possibly show that you are wrong.
 
first post

First post and I don't like to get my toes wet so I'll just jump in head first.

PlumJam - Look at what you did with an open mind. First you asked -

"With this in mind I'd be interested to hear examples from you of when new evidence has prompted you to honestly change your mind on a particular subject. And why did it do so?" post # 1

When the responses you got were not the answers you were looking for you added in the following conditional statement so that you could disallow the answers you received.

"My question was mainly directed at whether examination of new evidence has led you to move away from what might be called Skeptical Orthodoxy." post #11

You actually went one step further and invented "skeptical orthodoxy" in order to attack/insult the very people you are asking. You may as well say,

"Using the bible as your only reference material describe how you think life came to be on planet earth?"

Rephrasing a question to ensure one gets the answer they want is the most extreme example of close minded behavior I can think of.

In closing -
Science is not a belief system. Understanding the physical world around us does not require a leap of faith. I do not believe in the theory of evolution - I understand it and agree with it's conlusions. If more evidence comes to light and the theory evolves I will not ignore that evidence I will examine it and the conclusion drawn from it. If it causes me to change my mind then so be it. I am not so close minded as to ask only those questions that give me the answers I already know.

Adios
 
I am a bit ashamed to admit that I was a JFK conspiracy believer... well a 'Oswald was set up' believer anyway. Until I saw the director's cut of JFK and listened to Stone's ravings. (around 2003)

I still love the movie though. :D
 
Last edited:
I am a bit ashamed to admit that I was a JFK conspiracy believer... well a 'Oswald was set up' believer anyway. Until I saw the director's cut of JFK and listened to Stone's ravings. (around 2003)

I still love the movie though. :D

did you hear about the recent deathbed confession of E. Howard Hunt?

you can hear a recording of it here
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=fHZl91gN63g

there was also a Rolling Stone article about it
 
nice, some photos and diagrams

you could draw all kinds of different conclusions from them.. and in practice the conclusions will tend to be predetermined by your over-arching belief system.

I don't see anything in them that finds strongly in favour of or against the Darwinian hypothesis.

Well, if your overarching belief system is one that involves rejecting evidence in favour of fundamentalist religious belief, then you could indeed come to the conclusions that you draw. At least be honest about it though - don't try and pretend you've got the evidence on your side, just admit that you're acting on faith and wishful thinking.
 
Perhaps plumjam should be asking when has the preponderance of evidence shown the "skeptical orthodoxy" position to be wrong? It can't happen because the skeptical position changes with the evidence.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom