If we were alive when Darwin first published his great works, I think that many people on this forum would have been interested about what they heard, read the books at their first opportunity, read them again with greater care and interest, thought about what he proposed and the evidence that he layed out in support, raised questions and sought answers.
I certainly would have done this. I would have read his works and thought about them in the scientific context of the time. Given my understanding of the world, I would have been open to his ideas, subject, of course, to a healthy dose of skepticism that they would have to weather while they were being considered, examined, and appreciated.
The theory of evolution is beautiful and, according to all evidence, it is also true.
By the way, skepticism is a challenging and inquisitive way of looking at the world; in particular, it is how we try to approach and examine assertions about reality.
Every idea that we encounter or originate should be subject to the same level of questioning and examination. As some ideas continue to survive skeptical examination, our confidence in them increases. No idea gains our perfect confidence and no idea is immune to reconsideration.
Our goal is to obtain the best understanding of reality that we can.
That, by the way, is also the goal of science.
It is nice to have reality on our side.