ah, implicit.
yep, if you happen to be a human being capable of understanding a communication without having everything spelt out to you, then it's clear as day what he's saying
ah, implicit.
Perhaps plumjam should be asking when has the preponderance of evidence shown the "skeptical orthodoxy" position to be wrong? It can't happen because the skeptical position changes with the evidence.
yep, if you happen to be a human being capable of understanding a communication without having everything spelt out to you, then it's clear as day what he's saying
well if you read some of the links I put up you'll see that the Skeptical Orthodoxy of the time has been wrong about most of the important new discoveries and innovations in history
the same, of course, will apply to today's version of Skeptical Orthodoxy
what evidence is that? I don't remember you supplying anyWhy do you keep telling this lie in the face of all the evidence?
what evidence is that? I don't remember you supplying any
well if you read some of the links I put up you'll see that the Skeptical Orthodoxy of the time has been wrong about most of the important new discoveries and innovations in history
the same, of course, will apply to today's version of Skeptical Orthodoxy
You mean the post about Galileo being persecuted by the church where the church represents skepticism? LOL Yeah right. Do you mean they laughed at the Wright brothers where "they" is the ominous "they" that is some how supposed to represent skepticism? What posts are you talking about? You haven't mentioned yet the track record for skepticism being right and instead are trying to fabricate failures. You know skeptics also laughed at Bozo the Clown. It seems you are mistaking laypersons being skeptical about something with scientific skepticism where skeptics are skeptical of people making scientific claims without evidence.
So that means you want me to say something about the other 4 examples?
Further more its the skeptical mind that figured out how it flew! The woos would sit back and say, "Ghosts picked up the plane and ran with it, flight is proof of ghosts!"
well just one of the links had 20 to 30 examples by itself.. so I don't know where you get the number 4 from
Ok so I looked and all I saw was more of the same misrepresentations. Besides your misrepresenting what skepticism as a philosophy is even if those were skeptics they would represent isolated failures out of the humongous number of correct judgments. But still those are all misrepresentations of skepticism. Your just playing word games with us and it's a bit boring. You're obviously smart why don't you astound us with your intelligence instead? How about learning what a straw man is?
here we go again with the old "straw man" accusation.. been on here two days and must have had it levelled at me 10 times or more so far. It seems to be a bit of a mantra used by Skeptics when they can't think of a proper argument.
Misrepresentations you say. There were dozens of historical examples reported by many different sources, many quotes describing contemporary Skeptics views of new findings/innovations. I'd be interested to learn how these are misrepresentations.
The fact that so few current Skeptics are unaware of the damaging effects militant Skepticism has had in the past on research, fresh approaches, rates of discovery, individual careers and wider society is a function of the fact that these instances are more or less swept under the carpet.
If more so called Skeptics were aware of this they might take a bit less glee in scoffing at anyone with something to offer that stands outside of their accepted norms.
here we go again with the old "straw man" accusation.. been on here two days and must have had it levelled at me 10 times or more so far. It seems to be a bit of a mantra used by Skeptics when they can't think of a proper argument.
Misrepresentations you say. There were dozens of historical examples reported by many different sources, many quotes describing contemporary Skeptics views of new findings/innovations. I'd be interested to learn how these are misrepresentations.
The fact that so few current Skeptics are unaware of the damaging effects militant Skepticism has had in the past on research, fresh approaches, rates of discovery, individual careers and wider society is a function of the fact that these instances are more or less swept under the carpet.
If more so called Skeptics were aware of this they might take a bit less glee in scoffing at anyone with something to offer that stands outside of their accepted norms.
Just meandered through this entire ridiculous thread.