when have you changed your mind on a matter?

Perhaps plumjam should be asking when has the preponderance of evidence shown the "skeptical orthodoxy" position to be wrong? It can't happen because the skeptical position changes with the evidence.

well if you read some of the links I put up you'll see that the Skeptical Orthodoxy of the time has been wrong about most of the important new discoveries and innovations in history
the same, of course, will apply to today's version of Skeptical Orthodoxy
 
yep, if you happen to be a human being capable of understanding a communication without having everything spelt out to you, then it's clear as day what he's saying

So the evolutionary evidence that's been presented to you you're happy to dismiss (either through ignorance or faith-based reasons), but because you want to believe it, vague statements become an obvious confession. And you're complaining that sceptics don't change their mind when presented with evidence.

I've not seen this much projection since I last went to the cinema.
 
well if you read some of the links I put up you'll see that the Skeptical Orthodoxy of the time has been wrong about most of the important new discoveries and innovations in history
the same, of course, will apply to today's version of Skeptical Orthodoxy

Why do you keep telling this lie in the face of all the evidence?
 
So somebody said that someone else said something and that someone else is dead now and can no longer corraborate, and there are no tapes of the actual confession, and a handful of hand written notes that may or may not have been verified, I don't know. Jr. isn't trying to sell a book or capitalize on his dad's name, is he?

See, as a skeptic, I would gladly change my mind with more evidence. This isn't enough for me. That, and I really don't care about the JFK assasination.
 
well if you read some of the links I put up you'll see that the Skeptical Orthodoxy of the time has been wrong about most of the important new discoveries and innovations in history
the same, of course, will apply to today's version of Skeptical Orthodoxy

You mean the post about Galileo being persecuted by the church where the church represents skepticism? LOL Yeah right. Do you mean they laughed at the Wright brothers where "they" is the ominous "they" that is some how supposed to represent skepticism? What posts are you talking about? You haven't mentioned yet the track record for skepticism being right and instead are trying to fabricate failures. You know skeptics also laughed at Bozo the Clown. It seems you are mistaking laypersons being skeptical about something with scientific skepticism where skeptics are skeptical of people making scientific claims without evidence.
 
You mean the post about Galileo being persecuted by the church where the church represents skepticism? LOL Yeah right. Do you mean they laughed at the Wright brothers where "they" is the ominous "they" that is some how supposed to represent skepticism? What posts are you talking about? You haven't mentioned yet the track record for skepticism being right and instead are trying to fabricate failures. You know skeptics also laughed at Bozo the Clown. It seems you are mistaking laypersons being skeptical about something with scientific skepticism where skeptics are skeptical of people making scientific claims without evidence.

go read them. I posted at least half a dozen, which cover scores of examples.
 
Skeptics were not wrong to question the wright brothers! The would only have been wrong if in the face of overwhelming evidence they continued to question their success. However, that is not the case. Further more its the skeptical mind that figured out how it flew! The woos would sit back and say, "Ghosts picked up the plane and ran with it, flight is proof of ghosts!"

Lets say I came to you and said, "I have developed a receipe for cold fusion and I will sell it to you for $1,000.00." Would you whip out your wallet and pay the me or would you like some proof first? This is what happened to the wright brothers, they were asked for proof and when they did provide it they were exhaulted.

There is no conspiracy against new ideas but a burden of proof on those making the claims. Repeat that to yourself or write it down, stick it under your pillow, and learn by osmosis.
 
Further more its the skeptical mind that figured out how it flew! The woos would sit back and say, "Ghosts picked up the plane and ran with it, flight is proof of ghosts!"

I can't imagine you seriously mean this. If you do you must be pretty susceptible
 
well just one of the links had 20 to 30 examples by itself.. so I don't know where you get the number 4 from

Ok so I looked and all I saw was more of the same misrepresentations. Besides your misrepresenting what skepticism as a philosophy is even if those were skeptics they would represent isolated failures out of the humongous number of correct judgments. But still those are all misrepresentations of skepticism. Your just playing word games with us and it's a bit boring. You're obviously smart why don't you astound us with your intelligence instead? How about learning what a straw man is?
 
I mean it

Actually, I mean it.

I am also serious about that cold fusion receipe, I will PM the wire transfer details and I would be happy to accept 1,000 pounds instead of dollars.

Once that business is done I own a very profitable tower in Paris that I am interested in selling.

Adios
 
Ok so I looked and all I saw was more of the same misrepresentations. Besides your misrepresenting what skepticism as a philosophy is even if those were skeptics they would represent isolated failures out of the humongous number of correct judgments. But still those are all misrepresentations of skepticism. Your just playing word games with us and it's a bit boring. You're obviously smart why don't you astound us with your intelligence instead? How about learning what a straw man is?

here we go again with the old "straw man" accusation.. been on here two days and must have had it levelled at me 10 times or more so far. It seems to be a bit of a mantra used by Skeptics when they can't think of a proper argument.
Misrepresentations you say. There were dozens of historical examples reported by many different sources, many quotes describing contemporary Skeptics views of new findings/innovations. I'd be interested to learn how these are misrepresentations.
The fact that so few current Skeptics are unaware of the damaging effects militant Skepticism has had in the past on research, fresh approaches, rates of discovery, individual careers and wider society is a function of the fact that these instances are more or less swept under the carpet.
If more so called Skeptics were aware of this they might take a bit less glee in scoffing at anyone with something to offer that stands outside of their accepted norms.
 
Maybe the reason that accusation keeps coming up is because you keep setting up strawmen.

What you are describing is a carricature. It bears no relation to the reality of skepticism.
 
here we go again with the old "straw man" accusation.. been on here two days and must have had it levelled at me 10 times or more so far. It seems to be a bit of a mantra used by Skeptics when they can't think of a proper argument.
Misrepresentations you say. There were dozens of historical examples reported by many different sources, many quotes describing contemporary Skeptics views of new findings/innovations. I'd be interested to learn how these are misrepresentations.
The fact that so few current Skeptics are unaware of the damaging effects militant Skepticism has had in the past on research, fresh approaches, rates of discovery, individual careers and wider society is a function of the fact that these instances are more or less swept under the carpet.
If more so called Skeptics were aware of this they might take a bit less glee in scoffing at anyone with something to offer that stands outside of their accepted norms.

You really don't have a clue do you?

What you are talking about is NOT skepticism. At least not the sort of skepticism us here are talking about. Just because someone is skeptical of something, doesn't make them a skeptic.

The more you are posting, the more you are appearing to be either a troll (most likely - you are clearly only doing this to get a reaction) or you are a completely misinformed and rather ignorant person. I honestly think its the first, although I'd like to know your motivation for all this. You must have spent best part of a day arguing an argument that has no basis in fact, twisting what people are saying and ignoring anyone trying to spell it out in plain english.

And a strawman isn't a skeptical term. Its a widely used term - we even use it in our office during early project meetings. I suggest that if you really don't understand the concept of a strawman, then thats half the problem.
 
here we go again with the old "straw man" accusation.. been on here two days and must have had it levelled at me 10 times or more so far. It seems to be a bit of a mantra used by Skeptics when they can't think of a proper argument.
Misrepresentations you say. There were dozens of historical examples reported by many different sources, many quotes describing contemporary Skeptics views of new findings/innovations. I'd be interested to learn how these are misrepresentations.
The fact that so few current Skeptics are unaware of the damaging effects militant Skepticism has had in the past on research, fresh approaches, rates of discovery, individual careers and wider society is a function of the fact that these instances are more or less swept under the carpet.
If more so called Skeptics were aware of this they might take a bit less glee in scoffing at anyone with something to offer that stands outside of their accepted norms.

Here we go again your defensive dancing around the answer. Pick one example so that we can discuss this together if you dare. As far as I can see you are just putting up straw men and leaving them there. And it is all besides the point anyway since even if the person doing the laughing would qualify as a skeptic, single skeptics don't speak for the rest. For one skeptic to laugh at some idea would be one skeptics perspective. I am against the militant type skeptics myself but only because they don't create an environment favorable to learning or any other useful outcome that I can see (not because they make rare mistakes in judging phony baloneys).
 
Just meandered through this entire ridiculous thread.

Really? Wow. The woos only read themselves and the words of others if they can distort to support their view. What made you so diligent to keep plowing through page after page--was it like a compulsion... ?

I don't think I've read a long thread from beginning to end unless I've been participating all along. Have others read through entire threads?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom