when have you changed your mind on a matter?

plumjam

Banned
Joined
Aug 13, 2007
Messages
7,819
It seems to me that Skepticism is very similar to a religion/ideology. I say this because it's my experience that "Skeptics", although they pay lip service to the importance of the unbiased evaluation of evidence, rarely apply this principle evenly in the real world.

Very often any evidence presented which goes against the general ideology and philosophy held by Skepticism is ignored, discounted out of hand, ridiculed, or the ad hominem approach is taken.

With this in mind I'd be interested to hear examples from you of when new evidence has prompted you to honestly change your mind on a particular subject.
And why did it do so?

Thanks :)
 
Depends what you mean by changed your mind I suppose. If you mean in general e.g. opinions on politics, people, mucic, movies etc. I've changed my mind about loads of things.

If you mean things like ghosts, UFOs etc. well I've changed my mind once on these things which was from believing in them in a not very well thought out way, to not believing after looking at the evidence and finding it lacking (if however new evidence came a long I'd be happy to look at and see if it was convincing.) I suppose I should mention that since coming here I've changed my mind on the evidence on hypnotism from thiking it was really to being generally confused about it.
 
Since I've become someone very skeptical of the paranormal, never because since then no one has come up with any convincing evidence of anything paranormal. If they had, it would be accepted science by now.

But, skepticism works both ways. When I was a lot younger, I used to be skeptical of many explanations given as to how Uri Geller bends spoons, but changed my mind, and I used to be skeptical of the official position that the Mars Face was just a rock, but changed my mind when better, clearer photographic evidence came along proving me wrong. I was a bit of a woo way back then, though.

If we're not talking about paranormal subjects, then I've changed my mind many, many times based on new evidence. These vary from political beliefs (The war on terror, for example), to things like the power of hypnosis.
 
That's interesting, Mid. I hadn't read your post before writing mine (we were writing them at the same time), but they're almost identical!
 
It seems to me that Skepticism is very similar to a religion/ideology. I say this because it's my experience that "Skeptics", although they pay lip service to the importance of the unbiased evaluation of evidence, rarely apply this principle evenly in the real world.

Very often any evidence presented which goes against the general ideology and philosophy held by Skepticism is ignored, discounted out of hand, ridiculed, or the ad hominem approach is taken.

With this in mind I'd be interested to hear examples from you of when new evidence has prompted you to honestly change your mind on a particular subject.
And why did it do so?

Thanks :)

Welcome to the forum!

Here's a thread on pretty much this identical topic: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=88664
 
Very often any evidence presented which goes against the general ideology and philosophy held by Skepticism is ignored, discounted out of hand, ridiculed, or the ad hominem approach is taken.

This is the second time you've posted this assertion with only four posts so far, and while I am sure that some would take this approach, it's a bit of a stretch applying it to skeptics in general. What axe do you have to grind? ;) And you do have any concrete examples that this is true for the skeptical society in general?

It also helps to clarify the issue that we are presenting evidence for. Is it paranormal? Scientific? Societal? Etc? Because this is going to make a big difference. I change my mind often, depending on the subject. I change my opinions on people, governments, organizations, as I learn more about them. I used to believe in ghosts, and then I changed my mind after two years of being on a hauntings investigation team and finding not a shred of evidence.

How is skepticism similar to a religion? I'd like to hear your thoughts on this.

Have a good morning,

Chris
 
It seems to me that Skepticism is very similar to a religion/ideology. I say this because it's my experience that "Skeptics", although they pay lip service to the importance of the unbiased evaluation of evidence, rarely apply this principle evenly in the real world.

Very often any evidence presented which goes against the general ideology and philosophy held by Skepticism is ignored, discounted out of hand, ridiculed, or the ad hominem approach is taken.

With this in mind I'd be interested to hear examples from you of when new evidence has prompted you to honestly change your mind on a particular subject.
And why did it do so?

Thanks :)
1) Have you done any research on the topic yourself?

2) Will you take any heed of the answers supplied to you?
 
Sounds like baiting to me. The initial premise, that there is a "general ideology and philosophy held by Skepticism" that will exclude evidence for consideration, is illogical and strikes me as being dishonest as well.

plumjam, what DOES happen is that people believe in something without evidence, and skeptics reject it BECAUSE THERE IS NO EVIDENCE, OR THE EVIDENCE POINTS AWAY FROM THAT BELIEF. Usually, the believer then presents something that is not considered to be good evidence, like unconfirmed anecdotes, and has a little temper tantrum when wiser folks reject that as insufficient.

What axe do you have to grind?
 
Plumjam is just aggravated because he wants everyone to accept his paranormal beliefs without sufficient evidence, and when they refuse to, he likes to fool himself into believing it's some fundamental defect with the skeptics themselves.

Like the evidence never mattered, the skeptic was never going to believe no matter what, because once a skeptic chooses a position, they never change it, no matter what.

He's wrong on all counts.
 
Plumjam is just aggravated because he wants everyone to accept his paranormal beliefs without sufficient evidence, and when they refuse to, he likes to fool himself into believing it's some fundamental defect with the skeptics themselves.

Like the evidence never mattered, the skeptic was never going to believe no matter what, because once a skeptic chooses a position, they never change it, no matter what.

He's wrong on all counts.
That's what they all do, isn't it? They have no evidence, they know they look foolish, so they pretend that there is no evidence good enough to change our minds... neatly absolving themselves of the need to actually present any evidence in the first place.
 
thanks for all your replies :)

yes, in my original post I should have been more specific. My question was mainly directed at whether examination of new evidence has led you to move away from what might be called Skeptical Orthodoxy.

Unfortunately so far no-one has been able to give an example of this. All the examples offered describe moving towards orthodoxy rather than away from it.
And, although the post hasn't been up for very long this is precisely what supports my broader point i.e. that Skepticism, as it manifests itself on forums such as this one, is an over-arching belief system that is more akin to ideology and religion than that which it prefers to purport itself to be.

In my experience Skepticism takes great pains to appear to be purely scientific in that it claims to view evidence on both sides of an argument equally and without bias.
Yet this effort is disingenuous to say the least.
Judging from what I have read on here most Skeptics adhere to a quite narrow branch of philosophy that might be characterised as reductionist materialism.
Most reductionst materialists do not fully face the fact that if their philosophy were to be true then reality SHOULD be chaotic, devoid of organisation, devoid of life, devoid of intelligence, consciousness, meaning, purpose, emotion, music, humour, selflessness...etc...etc..

To put this in another way, what is either logical or rational about reality having even the most basic of physical laws?

The fact that the laws of physics exist is neither logical nor rational. On the contrary, using a principle which Skeptics often invoke - that of Occam's Razor, it would surely be more reasonable to expect the universe to be completely devoid of the laws of physics, and thus be completely chaotic.

A couple of you asked whether I have an axe to grind. Well, being a thinking, feeling human being like the rest of you, of course I have an axe to grind.
An implication in my original post is that a lot of people on this forum have axes to grind, but prefer to deny the fact, or perhaps they just haven't yet realised that due to their educational upbringing they have been channelled into one particular school of philosophy among a whole range of possible options.

I would say that the axe I have to grind is that my basic position is that of my old mate Bill who used to pipe up with "There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy."

One of the main reasons I think like this is an examination of the history of science and technology and the myriad instances when the Skeptical establishment has been proven spectacularly wrong (e.g. Marconi and the existence of electromagnetism, Maxwell and the existence of electricity, Galileo, the Wright Bros and the possibility of powered flight, science's belief in phlogiston and ether, etc etc.. )

My point is that most of the people on this forum would (as did the establishment figures of those times) have heartily enjoyed ridiculing such notions, and condemning people like Maxwell, Marconi and the Wright Bros as what are pretty distastefully referred to here as "woos".

Yet most of our current society is founded on the work of these woos.
Go figure, huh? ;)
 
thanks for all your replies :)

yes, in my original post I should have been more specific. My question was mainly directed at whether examination of new evidence has led you to move away from what might be called Skeptical Orthodoxy.

Unfortunately so far no-one has been able to give an example of this. All the examples offered describe moving towards orthodoxy rather than away from it.
And, although the post hasn't been up for very long this is precisely what supports my broader point i.e. that Skepticism, as it manifests itself on forums such as this one, is an over-arching belief system that is more akin to ideology and religion than that which it prefers to purport itself to be.

In my experience Skepticism takes great pains to appear to be purely scientific in that it claims to view evidence on both sides of an argument equally and without bias.
Yet this effort is disingenuous to say the least.
Judging from what I have read on here most Skeptics adhere to a quite narrow branch of philosophy that might be characterised as reductionist materialism.
Most reductionst materialists do not fully face the fact that if their philosophy were to be true then reality SHOULD be chaotic, devoid of organisation, devoid of life, devoid of intelligence, consciousness, meaning, purpose, emotion, music, humour, selflessness...etc...etc..

To put this in another way, what is either logical or rational about reality having even the most basic of physical laws?

The fact that the laws of physics exist is neither logical nor rational. On the contrary, using a principle which Skeptics often invoke - that of Occam's Razor, it would surely be more reasonable to expect the universe to be completely devoid of the laws of physics, and thus be completely chaotic.

A couple of you asked whether I have an axe to grind. Well, being a thinking, feeling human being like the rest of you, of course I have an axe to grind.
An implication in my original post is that a lot of people on this forum have axes to grind, but prefer to deny the fact, or perhaps they just haven't yet realised that due to their educational upbringing they have been channelled into one particular school of philosophy among a whole range of possible options.

I would say that the axe I have to grind is that my basic position is that of my old mate Bill who used to pipe up with "There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy."

One of the main reasons I think like this is an examination of the history of science and technology and the myriad instances when the Skeptical establishment has been proven spectacularly wrong (e.g. Marconi and the existence of electromagnetism, Maxwell and the existence of electricity, Galileo, the Wright Bros and the possibility of powered flight, science's belief in phlogiston and ether, etc etc.. )

My point is that most of the people on this forum would (as did the establishment figures of those times) have heartily enjoyed ridiculing such notions, and condemning people like Maxwell, Marconi and the Wright Bros as what are pretty distastefully referred to here as "woos".

Yet most of our current society is founded on the work of these woos.
Go figure, huh? ;)
So, in other words, your intent was to be dishonest, attack strawmen, and to push an anti-rational agenda. Nice work.
 
yes, in my original post I should have been more specific. My question was mainly directed at whether examination of new evidence has led you to move away from what might be called Skeptical Orthodoxy.

There is no "Skeptical Orthodoxy". This is your own invention, and exists only in your mind. In other words, you're creating a strawman argument, and then attempting to ridicule it.

Unfortunately so far no-one has been able to give an example of this. All the examples offered describe moving towards orthodoxy rather than away from it.

There is no "Orthodoxy". If we agree that skeptics like to believe only in the existence of things that have sufficient supporting evidence, then you are asking us whether we have stopped believing in something that has sufficient evidence, and started believing in something else without sufficient evidence instead.

Absurd.

And, although the post hasn't been up for very long this is precisely what supports my broader point i.e. that Skepticism, as it manifests itself on forums such as this one, is an over-arching belief system that is more akin to ideology and religion than that which it prefers to purport itself to be.

That's your claim, and one you have completely failed to support.

In my experience Skepticism takes great pains to appear to be purely scientific in that it claims to view evidence on both sides of an argument equally and without bias.
Yet this effort is disingenuous to say the least.
Judging from what I have read on here most Skeptics adhere to a quite narrow branch of philosophy that might be characterised as reductionist materialism.
Most reductionst materialists do not fully face the fact that if their philosophy were to be true then reality SHOULD be chaotic, devoid of organisation, devoid of life, devoid of intelligence, consciousness, meaning, purpose, emotion, music, humour, selflessness...etc...etc..

No, this is ridiculous. Clearly no Universe of this kind would contain rational beings able to question their own existence, and therefore our very existence as thinking beings necessitates an organized Universe.

Rationality itself mandates a Universe that makes "sense".

To put this in another way, what is either logical or rational about reality having even the most basic of physical laws?

The fact that we would not be here to ask this question unless such laws existed, and that rationality itself would not exist unless this was the case.

The fact that the laws of physics exist is neither logical nor rational. On the contrary, using a principle which Skeptics often invoke - that of Occam's Razor, it would surely be more reasonable to expect the universe to be completely devoid of the laws of physics, and thus be completely chaotic.

Nonsense. Who says there must only be one Universe? Who says there must be only one set of laws? Who says no physical laws is more "rational" than physical laws, and why?

One of the main reasons I think like this is an examination of the history of science and technology and the myriad instances when the Skeptical establishment has been proven spectacularly wrong (e.g. Marconi and the existence of electromagnetism, Maxwell and the existence of electricity, Galileo, the Wright Bros and the possibility of powered flight, science's belief in phlogiston and ether, etc etc.. )

My point is that most of the people on this forum would (as did the establishment figures of those times) have heartily enjoyed ridiculing such notions, and condemning people like Maxwell, Marconi and the Wright Bros as what are pretty distastefully referred to here as "woos".

Ridicule has nothing to do with skepticism itself, that is a personal choice of every individual. However, believing with caution, accepting that you may be wrong, and changing your position when better evidence is available would have been something common to all real skeptics in your scenarios above, and rightfully so.
 
My question was mainly directed at whether examination of new evidence has led you to move away from what might be called Skeptical Orthodoxy.

Hehe. That's funny. Skeptical Orthodoxy. You made that up all by yourself, didn't you? You still haven't answered how skepticism is a religion.


And, although the post hasn't been up for very long this is precisely what supports my broader point i.e. that Skepticism, as it manifests itself on forums such as this one, is an over-arching belief system that is more akin to ideology and religion than that which it prefers to purport itself to be.

Please do explain. We have already asked you to explain in detail and you have just restated what you've already said.

In my experience Skepticism takes great pains to appear to be purely scientific in that it claims to view evidence on both sides of an argument equally and without bias.
Yet this effort is disingenuous to say the least.

Evidence? Specific examples? And I don't mean flap your gums with more vague accusations, and I don't mean re-stating in a different way. Give me something to chew on.

To put this in another way, what is either logical or rational about reality having even the most basic of physical laws?

The fact that the laws of physics exist is neither logical nor rational. On the contrary, using a principle which Skeptics often invoke - that of Occam's Razor, it would surely be more reasonable to expect the universe to be completely devoid of the laws of physics, and thus be completely chaotic.

This is just nonsense.

One of the main reasons I think like this is an examination of the history of science and technology and the myriad instances when the Skeptical establishment has been proven spectacularly wrong (e.g. Marconi and the existence of electromagnetism, Maxwell and the existence of electricity, Galileo, the Wright Bros and the possibility of powered flight, science's belief in phlogiston and ether, etc etc.. )

My point is that most of the people on this forum would (as did the establishment figures of those times) have heartily enjoyed ridiculing such notions, and condemning people like Maxwell, Marconi and the Wright Bros as what are pretty distastefully referred to here as "woos".

Yet most of our current society is founded on the work of these woos.
Go figure, huh?

Your understanding of the difference between woo and skepticism is fundementally flawed. Skeptics (credible ones) of such people as Marconi and the Wright Brothers, once confronted with the evidence, would change positions. Woos have no credible position to begin with do not change ther positions no matter how much evidence is presented. The people you mentioned above are not "woos" and to call them so is laughable.

You also seem to think that over the ages "skeptics" are some sort of card carrying cohesive group that have a clearly defined label. This is simply not true. Someone can be a skeptic of one thing and a woo in another regards. People could be skeptical of the Wright Brothers, without being card-carrying skeptics. Does this make sense to you?

So, tell me, what is your belief(s) that clash(es) with skepticism?
 
One of the main reasons I think like this is an examination of the history of science and technology and the myriad instances when the Skeptical establishment has been proven spectacularly wrong (e.g. Marconi and the existence of electromagnetism, Maxwell and the existence of electricity, Galileo, the Wright Bros and the possibility of powered flight, science's belief in phlogiston and ether, etc etc.. )

My point is that most of the people on this forum would (as did the establishment figures of those times) have heartily enjoyed ridiculing such notions, and condemning people like Maxwell, Marconi and the Wright Bros as what are pretty distastefully referred to here as "woos".

Yet most of our current society is founded on the work of these woos.


I seem to post variations on this post on a regular basis. The cases you mention above are all prime examples of how the scientific method works and knowledge evolves. Yes, for any given discovery or hypothesis there may be individual scientists or authority figures who sneer, for any number of reasons. But there are also large numbers of other scientists who try to reproduce the effect and then play with the equipment until it breaks. All that is ever asked is that the effects can be reproduced independently and reliably - in the cases of electricity, radioactivity, heavier-than-air flight, say, this was done and science leapt ahead. The problems arise with things such as cold fusion, for example, where with the best will in the world no progress could be made because there was no replication.
 
Snippty-snip

I decided not to get involved in another one of these unfortunate agenda threads.
 
Last edited:
My point is that most of the people on this forum would (as did the establishment figures of those times) have heartily enjoyed ridiculing such notions, and condemning people like Maxwell, Marconi and the Wright Bros as what are pretty distastefully referred to here as "woos".

Yet most of our current society is founded on the work of these woos.
Go figure, huh? ;)

Other have already pointed out some of your errors so I will concentrate only on the last one. We do not use the term "woo" to refer to anyone who makes a hard-to-believe claim. If someone were to claim that man will be walking on Mars in four years, no one on this board would claim that to be woo. Several posters would point out that an amazing amount of work would have to be done in a very short period of time and they would therefore conclude that the rational position would be to doubt the claim.

On the other hand, if someone were to say that mankind will learn very much about the Martian landscape by astrally projecting, then most of us would use the "woo" term. Woo is generally used to describe claims that not only lack evidence but also go against everything we know about how the world works. Others might have a different definition of woo: beliefs based on anecdotal claims that always disappear when studied under controlled conditions.

No, today's society is not based on the work of woos. James VanPraag, Sylvia Browne, Samuel Hahnemann, levitating monks, telepaths, and clairvoyants have not produced any significant support to any aspect of today's society. In fact, some woos, psychic surgeons, for instance, are a drain on society's resources.
 
Last edited:
Hi chaps,

thanks for your responses. I must say I'm just getting used to this new concept of a "straw man", I HAD heard of it before, but never inquired as to its meaning. So I hope you'll understand that I wasn't deliberately employing a rather fiendish straw man strategy. Rather I was just talking honestly from my mind and heart as I hope we all do :)

Humphreys and Normal Dude, I really do appreciate the fact that you answer me in such detail and so quickly (not meant sarcastically)
You know the last forum I posted on? It was Big Brother 8 UK.. and the quality of the responses there was a lot lower than yours :)

Well, if I had a spare 3 or 4 hours I maybe could reply with full detail, but despite the fact that I orginally replied to your first answers with moderate language I'll just show you here the words you used to my response:


"your own invention" "you're creating a strawman" "Absurd" "No, this is ridiculous" "Nonsense" "Hehe. That's funny" "This is just nonsense"

I do believe you are very intelligent people. I also believe you have your own strong belief systems (that seem very similar). I just believe that because the probability is that you have been trained in scientific subjects rather than philosophy then your outlook has been somewhat limited. When I first studied philosophy it was a real eye-opener to me that there might me completely other ways of viewing reality to the predominant view promoted by current society/politics/education

Thanks my friends :)
 
thanks for all your replies :)

-snip-

One of the main reasons I think like this is an examination of the history of science and technology and the myriad instances when the Skeptical establishment has been proven spectacularly wrong (e.g. Marconi and the existence of electromagnetism, Maxwell and the existence of electricity, Galileo, the Wright Bros and the possibility of powered flight, science's belief in phlogiston and ether, etc etc.. )

My point is that most of the people on this forum would (as did the establishment figures of those times) have heartily enjoyed ridiculing such notions, and condemning people like Maxwell, Marconi and the Wright Bros as what are pretty distastefully referred to here as "woos".

Yet most of our current society is founded on the work of these woos.
Go figure, huh? ;)

Ah, the good old "science/scepticism has been wrong in the past, therefor it's useless".
And the old 'levelling the playing field" by stating that science/ scepticism is as much a matter of faith/ orthodoxy etc as the irrational beliefs you have.
And do tell, which sceptics still believe in phlogiston? Or which do not believe in electromagnetism? Anyone who believe that heavier than air aircraft are impossible? Who think radio is myth? Come on, you claim they are all so orthodox and rigid, they should be easy to find.
 
I actually do struggle sometimes with this from the other side of the argument. Whatever evidence a believer offers, I'm 99.9% sure I'll reject it, because it will be the same anecdotal or otherwise weak offering that's always offered. From a pragmatic point of view, for all intents and purposes, I am the closed-minded cynic that the believer might see me as.

The difference of course, is that I absolutely would re-assess my position given some decent evidence, and would change my mind given enough of that. Because we're never likely to see such evidence, I'll never be able to demonstrate my open-mindedness in the way the OP desires. He/she will just have to trust me on that, and also when I tell them I would be over the moon if any of it were shown to have a basis in reality. I don't reject it out of fear or misunderstanding, I reject it because there's just no reason to believe it exists. Nothing but faith and belief. Not good enough.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom