when have you changed your mind on a matter?

Then either you are suffering from some terrible form of amnesia or you simply haven't been reading people's posts.

This is because the bits of your "evidence" which aren't outright lies have failed to prove your point.

Let me quote Drummer's question to you, which was a good one:

"And I still like to see which skeptics/ scientist still don't believe in aircraft, turbine engines, the light bulb etc. Whatever the objections and ridicule at the time, it looks very much to me that everyone was swayed by the evidence. Which is not very rigidly, kneejerkingly orthodox, is it now?"

Which whacky Biblical Creationists, Islamic fundamentalists, 8 year old children and Popes don't now believe in aircraft, light bulbs etc?
None.
It's a bit of a nonsensical question, to be honest, and doesn't prove anything one way or another
 
lol.. sorry, but I'm afraid that's very naive of you to believe that. Maybe YOU as an individual would have the intellectual integrity to look at all evidence evenly, but in the real world a whole host of other considerations are taken into account determining how evidence is treated

You misunderstood me. Maybe I wasn't clear enough...

If a skeptic (critical thinker) dismisses some evidence, it will be because THEY believe there to be a flaw in that evidence. That doesn't stop them accepting flawed evidence erroneously of course.

My point was that by definition, a critical thinker does examine (or attempts to examine) evidence evenly. What you seem to be talking about is someone who purposefully disregards evidence if it is contrary to their point of view, and that certainly doesn't relate to skeptics. It does, however, commonly relate to proponents of the paranormal (religious or whatever).
 
Drummer - Nice write up. Though the short of it all is, yes – generally speaking skeptics simply do not “believe” things until scientifically proven.

Take the Wright Brothers example; lets say the article is 100% right, the USN and JH ridiculed the whole idea. So? When shown irrefutable scientific proof (such as a working model that could make repeatable flights) I dare say that they changed their mind about the concept of powered flight.

Golly….a skeptic, changing their mind based on scientific evidence – will wonders never cease? :)

Plumjam simply wants to argue that skeptics can be wrong; well duh! Generally speaking when presented with, with credible, repeatable evidence, skeptics are more then willing to admit being proven wrong…that is part of the scientific process.
 
Last edited:
Was the reason for everyone starting to believe in airplanes a paradigm shift, or something as simple as better evidence being provided?
 
You misunderstood me. Maybe I wasn't clear enough...

If a skeptic (critical thinker) dismisses some evidence, it will be because THEY believe there to be a flaw in that evidence. That doesn't stop them accepting flawed evidence erroneously of course.

My point was that by definition, a critical thinker does examine (or attempts to examine) evidence evenly. What you seem to be talking about is someone who purposefully disregards evidence if it is contrary to their point of view, and that certainly doesn't relate to skeptics. It does, however, commonly relate to proponents of the paranormal (religious or whatever).

yes,
unfortunately, contrary to how they prefer to see themselves, history shows that Skeptics are just as vulnerable as anyone else (e.g. paranormalists, religionists) of allowing their over-arching world-view to affect how they treat evidence.
It is my contention in this whole thread that Skeptics seem as incapable of seeing this as may be paranormalists and religionists or anyone else with their own particular set of beliefs about reality.
 
Which whacky Biblical Creationists, Islamic fundamentalists, 8 year old children and Popes don't now believe in aircraft, light bulbs etc?
None.

So? whats that got to do with anything?
It's a bit of a nonsensical question, to be honest, and doesn't prove anything one way or another

You were arguing that skeptics don't change their position if presented with evidence, so It was a perfectly valid question.
 
yes,
unfortunately, contrary to how they prefer to see themselves, history shows that Skeptics are just as vulnerable as anyone else (e.g. paranormalists, religionists) of allowing their over-arching world-view to affect how they treat evidence.
.

Here we go again....

Show a situation where a self confessed critical thinker (such as the types on this board) have done that. Go on....

If you are just going to pluck names from history where so-and-so said something couldn't be done and tried to cover up evidence to the contrary then what makes you think they are a skeptic by definition? I'd say they certainly weren't. So once again, I think you are completely misdirecting this entire thread
 
Part of the explanation is in the Max Planck quote on my signature
Ah yes, I was going to mention him. This would be the same Max Planck who was awarded the Nobel Prize for his revolutionary ideas about energy quanta, yes?

What happened --- all the other scientists died?
 
Was the reason for everyone starting to believe in airplanes a paradigm shift, or something as simple as better evidence being provided?

I would imagine that in the case of airplanes nothing as radical as a paradigm shift was needed, just the experience of seeing it fly. That is more a technological area too.
Other, scientific, areas are much more subtle and elusive in their evidencing than simply seeing a plane fly in front of you.
I would say that in these more subtle areas Skeptics use the subtelty of evidence to allow themselves to remain in their current world-view.
Just a guess ;)
 
Ah yes, I was going to mention him. This would be the same Max Planck who was awarded the Nobel Prize for his revolutionary ideas about energy quanta, yes?

What happened --- all the other scientists died?

If Max was here we could ask him. He obviously had some justification for what he said, perhaps through a lifetime of working in science and observing how it worked in practice as opposed to theory. As a Nobel Prize Winner I tend to give some credit to what he says.
 

well I'd imagine that an area as subtle as parapsychology would probably qualify. Much more difficult to get people to agree on the value of evidence here than the evidence of a plane flying past you.
 
Which whacky Biblical Creationists, Islamic fundamentalists, 8 year old children and Popes don't now believe in aircraft, light bulbs etc?
None.
Right. Not even the religious whackos are as "orthodox" in their beliefs about science as you pretend that skeptics are.

I can, however, show you fundie nutjobs who reject Galileo, Newton, Darwin and Einstein ...

Hey, look, here's a guy who denies the evolution of antibiotic resistance. And, what do you know, it's on one of the sites that you linked to as "evidence" for your views.
 
If Max was here we could ask him. He obviously had some justification for what he said, perhaps through a lifetime of working in science and observing how it worked in practice as opposed to theory. As a Nobel Prize Winner I tend to give some credit to what he says.
As did his scientific peers, who gave him a Nobel Prize.
 
well I'd imagine that an area as subtle as parapsychology would probably qualify. Much more difficult to get people to agree on the value of evidence here than the evidence of a plane flying past you.

Well...exactly what credible, scientific evidence do you have that supports parapsychology being valid, or dare say "proven real"?
 
I would imagine that in the case of airplanes nothing as radical as a paradigm shift was needed, just the experience of seeing it fly. That is more a technological area too.
Other, scientific, areas are much more subtle and elusive in their evidencing than simply seeing a plane fly in front of you.
Evolution, the motion of the Earth, the Big Bang, that sort of thing?

As rejected by sundry religious fanatics, but not by skeptics.

I would say that in these more subtle areas Skeptics use the subtelty of evidence to allow themselves to remain in their current world-view.
Just a guess ;)
There's nothing subtle about spoonbending, nor, indeed, evidential about cold reading --- what did you have in mind?
 
Right. Not even the religious whackos are as "orthodox" in their beliefs about science as you pretend that skeptics are.

I can, however, show you fundie nutjobs who reject Galileo, Newton, Darwin and Einstein ...

Hey, look, here's a guy who denies the evolution of antibiotic resistance. And, what do you know, it's on one of the sites that you linked to as "evidence" for your views.

I get the feeling that at the time Darwin brought out his book you would have been one of those ridiculing him, perhaps (if forums had existed then) coming here and calling him a "fundie nutjob" as you seem to so enjoy calling others.

But according to your current beliefs, you would have been completely wrong to do so, and may even, looking back, felt yourself to have been acting arrogantly and rather foolishly, with little intellectual humility.
Can you see this?

Regarding the antibiotic resistance thing, I know little about the topic, but Milton seems to refute it.
Basically I go back to what I said last night.. that in thousands of generations of intelligence-driven human selective breeding of dogs and horses we've never managed to get anything that isn't just a plain old dog and a plain old horse. I would say that this evidence strongly suggests that Darwinian natural selection is impotent to explain the presence of millions of variegated and incredibly complex species, that are supposedly (according to your ideology) meant to have descended from a single celled organism :)

Face it, it's a belief without evidence
 
Well...exactly what credible, scientific evidence do you have that supports parapsychology being valid, or dare say "proven real"?

I don't know much about parapsychology, but looking at the history of science it wouldn't surprise me that, not being part of the accepted mainstream, its evidence may not be treated as fairly as other more mainstream areas of inquiry, like chemistry, for example
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom