another interesting paper here
http://www.amasci.com/supress1.html
it details the
costs to society of the usual reflexive knee-jerk skepticism which is exhibited on this forum
Well well, what an interesting link. The basic claim is that some great ideas and inventions got suppressed by 'the conventional scientific community'. Ok, let's look at the claims then:
1) Galileo: uhm, didn't he get in trouble with the church and not with scientists? That's one down.
2) Lavoisier and meteorites: again, it's religion here that claimed rocks didn't fall from the sky, not science (and not skeptics). After all, God's creation is perfect and therefor there can be no debris flying around. That's two down.
3) The Wright brothers: it's claimed that experts from the US Navy and John Hopkins ridiculed the whole idea. When would that have been? 300 years earlier? I've seen several documentaries on the Wright brothers and the invention of aircraft, and all of them mentioned there was lots of competition for the Wright brothers, including from the US Navy. Now, they may have ridiculed the idea that two bicycle mechanics could build an aircraft, but I don't believe for a minute that they ridiculed the principle idea of aircraft. I'd like to see evidence for that, not just some guy making that claim.
4) the inventors of the turbine ship engine, the mechanical naval gunnery control, the electric ships telegraph, and the steel ship hull all initially met with disinterest, disbelief and derision by the British Navy of the nineteenth century: I'd like to see exactly what was said by the British navy. Based on the previous claims and what I know of how the armed forces usually treat 'inventions', I think that they told the inventors to come back when they had something more than just an idea. Something like a prototype for instance.
5) The light bulb:
"Such startling announcements as these should be deprecated as being unworthy of science and mischievous to its true progress." -Sir William Siemens, England's most distinguished engineer"
I'd like to see the context of that. He may have been commenting on Edison going directly to the popular press with his invention in stead of going through the normal scientific process, something that is still considered bad form (at the least) today.
Then there is a guy reminding us of the hoaxes in the fields, possibly also because Edison did not go the scientific route and a competitor saying it can't work! Go figure, a competitor, who knows his arc-light business is doomed if Edison is right, saying that it can't be so!
6) Tesla is mentioned: while Tesla was a genius, he was also one of those geniusses who border on the edge of sanity. Some of his ideas where just whacky and he was rightly criticised for that. And especially skeptics don't accept a claim just because some famous person makes it, even when it's a genius. I don't think that is a bad thing.
7) One more gem: Thomas Edison saying that alternating current is no good. But no mention of the fact that it competed with Edison's own technology, so that was not exactly an unbiased objective opinion.
I'll leave at that, but it's a pretty sad collection of half truths and quotemines.
And I still like to see which skeptics/ scientist still don't believe in aircraft, turbine engines, the light bulb etc. Whatever the objections and ridicule at the time, it looks very much to me that everyone was swayed by the evidence. Which is not very rigidly, kneejerkingly orthodox, is it now?