when have you changed your mind on a matter?

the sources I quoted said one thing, the sources you quoted said another thing.. who's to know which is right? which is why I have pointed you to dozens of similar examples through history
"Similar" in that you profess yourself unable to know whether they're true or false?
 
One example of how Skeptics attachment to their particular philosophy turns them into being anti-scientific

http://www.discord.org/~lippard/kammann.html

A good article. Have you read it?

I draw your attention to the author's conclusion to part 1, and notably to this sentence:

"In the long-run, the skeptics' worthy battle against superstition and pseudoscience must rely on trustworthy evidence, rational self-correcting debate, and their ability to supply normal explanations for paranormal claims"
 
My point all along is that due to ideological considerations many Skeptics hold regarding the nature of reality they pick and choose their evidence while pretending not to.
History bears this out.
"My point all along is that due to ideological considerations many Vegetarians hold regarding the nature of reality they eat meat while pretending not to. History bears this out."
 
"Similar" in that you profess yourself unable to know whether they're true or false?

well neither you nor I were omnipresent throughout the whole of human history, so of course, if we want to be able to build up some kind of picture of what happened in the past we ultimately have to take other peoples (historians etc) words for it
either that or be completely agnostic about the past
 
Well I agree with you that ideas should be determined by the evidence, obviously I have never argued against that. My point all along is that due to ideological considerations many Skeptics hold regarding the nature of reality they pick and choose their evidence while pretending not to.
History bears this out.

No, history bears out that religious people pick and choose their evidence while pretending not to, due to ideological consideration.

That's the whole point of the Galileo issue, or evolution.
 
Well I agree with you that ideas should be determined by the evidence, obviously I have never argued against that. My point all along is that due to ideological considerations many Skeptics hold regarding the nature of reality they pick and choose their evidence while pretending not to.
History bears this out.

Well you would be completely and utterly wrong.

Evidence is evidence. If people choose to ignore certain pieces of evidence, its because the evidence is flawed.

What you seem to be talking about has nothing whatsoever to do with skepticism, but rather it is to do with close-mindedness, which - in my experience - does not reflect the skeptical community, but DOES represent a lot of the woo community.

Quite frankly, I think you are at cross-purposes with yourself. There is no orthodoxy and the examples you are giving (whether real or not) are nothing at all to do with critical thinking. This whole conversation is pretty pointless really, although I'm looking forward to see how you manage to keep it going....
 
No, history bears out that religious people pick and choose their evidence while pretending not to, due to ideological consideration.

That's the whole point of the Galileo issue, or evolution.

yes, some religious people do that, and so do some Skeptics. If you look at the historical examples I've provided, plus the info on how current science works you will see that.
Religious people deny that they do it, and so do Skeptics.
Skeptics can't seem to realise that they propagate a very particular world-view, which is one among many available.
 
Evidence is evidence. If people choose to ignore certain pieces of evidence, its because the evidence is flawed.

lol.. sorry, but I'm afraid that's very naive of you to believe that. Maybe YOU as an individual would have the intellectual integrity to look at all evidence evenly, but in the real world a whole host of other considerations are taken into account determining how evidence is treated
 
another interesting paper here

http://www.amasci.com/supress1.html

it details the costs to society of the usual reflexive knee-jerk skepticism which is exhibited on this forum

Well well, what an interesting link. The basic claim is that some great ideas and inventions got suppressed by 'the conventional scientific community'. Ok, let's look at the claims then:
1) Galileo: uhm, didn't he get in trouble with the church and not with scientists? That's one down.

2) Lavoisier and meteorites: again, it's religion here that claimed rocks didn't fall from the sky, not science (and not skeptics). After all, God's creation is perfect and therefor there can be no debris flying around. That's two down.

3) The Wright brothers: it's claimed that experts from the US Navy and John Hopkins ridiculed the whole idea. When would that have been? 300 years earlier? I've seen several documentaries on the Wright brothers and the invention of aircraft, and all of them mentioned there was lots of competition for the Wright brothers, including from the US Navy. Now, they may have ridiculed the idea that two bicycle mechanics could build an aircraft, but I don't believe for a minute that they ridiculed the principle idea of aircraft. I'd like to see evidence for that, not just some guy making that claim.

4) the inventors of the turbine ship engine, the mechanical naval gunnery control, the electric ships telegraph, and the steel ship hull all initially met with disinterest, disbelief and derision by the British Navy of the nineteenth century: I'd like to see exactly what was said by the British navy. Based on the previous claims and what I know of how the armed forces usually treat 'inventions', I think that they told the inventors to come back when they had something more than just an idea. Something like a prototype for instance.

5) The light bulb:
"Such startling announcements as these should be deprecated as being unworthy of science and mischievous to its true progress." -Sir William Siemens, England's most distinguished engineer"
I'd like to see the context of that. He may have been commenting on Edison going directly to the popular press with his invention in stead of going through the normal scientific process, something that is still considered bad form (at the least) today.
Then there is a guy reminding us of the hoaxes in the fields, possibly also because Edison did not go the scientific route and a competitor saying it can't work! Go figure, a competitor, who knows his arc-light business is doomed if Edison is right, saying that it can't be so!

6) Tesla is mentioned: while Tesla was a genius, he was also one of those geniusses who border on the edge of sanity. Some of his ideas where just whacky and he was rightly criticised for that. And especially skeptics don't accept a claim just because some famous person makes it, even when it's a genius. I don't think that is a bad thing.

7) One more gem: Thomas Edison saying that alternating current is no good. But no mention of the fact that it competed with Edison's own technology, so that was not exactly an unbiased objective opinion.

I'll leave at that, but it's a pretty sad collection of half truths and quotemines.
And I still like to see which skeptics/ scientist still don't believe in aircraft, turbine engines, the light bulb etc. Whatever the objections and ridicule at the time, it looks very much to me that everyone was swayed by the evidence. Which is not very rigidly, kneejerkingly orthodox, is it now?
 
I see only one person in this entire thread stubbornly sticking to the same beliefs despite a wealth of evidence to the contrary, plumjam.
 
yes, some religious people do that, and so do some Skeptics. If you look at the historical examples I've provided, plus the info on how current science works you will see that.
Religious people deny that they do it, and so do Skeptics.
Skeptics can't seem to realise that they propagate a very particular world-view, which is one among many available.


Perhaps it's your definition of skepticism that needs refining.

Providing evidence of people acting contrary to skepticism is evidence of the fact that they are not skeptics.
 
yes, some religious people do that, and so do some Skeptics.
Then in what sense are they "skeptics"?

If you look at the historical examples I've provided, plus the info on how current science works you will see that.
Actually, you've given lots of examples of unorthodox ideas, which, being supported by the evidence, were rapidly adopted by the mainstream.

Religious people deny that they do it, and so do Skeptics.
And one group is still scoffing at Galileo, and the other is not. What does that tell you?

Skeptics can't seem to realise that they propagate a very particular world-view, which is one among many available.
We do realise that. This "world-view" is known as, wait for it --- "skepticism".
 
yes, some religious people do that, and so do some Skeptics. If you look at the historical examples I've provided, plus the info on how current science works you will see that.
Religious people deny that they do it, and so do Skeptics.
Skeptics can't seem to realise that they propagate a very particular world-view, which is one among many available.

One has to wonder, what color is the sky in your world?

Explain “Skeptics can't seem to realise [sic] that they propagate a very particular world-view, which is one among many available.” Facts are facts; as with anything else in science, information is evaluated based on the creditability and repeatability.

Randi has said, and I think most here would agree…it would be great if ESP, astrology, fortune telling, etc. (ie. paranormal) were true, that is to say these abilities be scientifically proven to exist. But simply stated, this has not happened.

Rather, the proof that “paranormal” abilities are true is hearsay, largely undocumented, unproven, non-repeatable…or just flat out hoax (such as Sylvia Browne).
 
I see only one person in this entire thread stubbornly sticking to the same beliefs despite a wealth of evidence to the contrary, plumjam.

hmm.. as far as I remember throughout today it's been ME providing the evidence (lots of it) and not one Skeptic that I have heard from accepting any of it.

Just proves my point all over again.
 
lol.. sorry, but I'm afraid that's very naive of you to believe that. Maybe YOU as an individual would have the intellectual integrity to look at all evidence evenly, but in the real world a whole host of other considerations are taken into account determining how evidence is treated
I think he means skeptical people.
 
hmm.. as far as I remember throughout today it's been ME providing the evidence (lots of it) and not one Skeptic that I have heard from accepting any of it.

Just proves my point all over again.

Yes, but it is being rejected for good reason, and you are ignoring those reasons, or rejecting them without explanation.

And I struggle to call what you have provided "evidence".

And you still insist there is a "skeptical orthodoxy".

And it just proves my point all over again that your only issue with skeptics is their justified rejection of your beliefs.
 
It seems to me that Skepticism is very similar to a religion/ideology. I say this because it's my experience that "Skeptics", although they pay lip service to the importance of the unbiased evaluation of evidence, rarely apply this principle evenly in the real world.

Very often any evidence presented which goes against the general ideology and philosophy held by Skepticism is ignored, discounted out of hand, ridiculed, or the ad hominem approach is taken.

With this in mind I'd be interested to hear examples from you of when new evidence has prompted you to honestly change your mind on a particular subject.
And why did it do so?

Thanks :)

Depends what you mean by changed your mind I suppose. If you mean in general e.g. opinions on politics, people, mucic, movies etc. I've changed my mind about loads of things.

If you mean things like ghosts, UFOs etc. well I've changed my mind once on these things which was from believing in them in a not very well thought out way, to not believing after looking at the evidence and finding it lacking (if however new evidence came a long I'd be happy to look at and see if it was convincing.) I suppose I should mention that since coming here I've changed my mind on the evidence on hypnotism from thiking it was really to being generally confused about it.

Since I've become someone very skeptical of the paranormal, never because since then no one has come up with any convincing evidence of anything paranormal. If they had, it would be accepted science by now.

But, skepticism works both ways. When I was a lot younger, I used to be skeptical of many explanations given as to how Uri Geller bends spoons, but changed my mind, and I used to be skeptical of the official position that the Mars Face was just a rock, but changed my mind when better, clearer photographic evidence came along proving me wrong. I was a bit of a woo way back then, though.

If we're not talking about paranormal subjects, then I've changed my mind many, many times based on new evidence. These vary from political beliefs (The war on terror, for example), to things like the power of hypnosis.

Just as a small example of how plumjam has lied and ignored posters in this thread. Opening post:
With this in mind I'd be interested to hear examples from you of when new evidence has prompted you to honestly change your mind on a particular subject.
And why did it do so?

Followed by people describing (on the very same page) what beliefs they've changed in light of acquiring evidence.
 
hmm.. as far as I remember throughout today it's been ME providing the evidence (lots of it) and not one Skeptic that I have heard from accepting any of it.

Just proves my point all over again.

No, you've been providing links to other people making the claims you've made. We've pointed out that since they just make the claims without proving them, they're not evidence. And we've pointed out why this is.

Again, I offer you a lesson in learning what evidence really means, and how to acquire it. Because you need to learn this if you want a proper debate here.

And the fact that you're outright ignoring the evidence we've shown you both yesterday and today only goes to show how intellectually dishonest you are.
 
Then in what sense are they "skeptics"?

Actually, you've given lots of examples of unorthodox ideas, which, being supported by the evidence, were rapidly adopted by the mainstream.

And one group is still scoffing at Galileo, and the other is not. What does that tell you?

We do realise that. This "world-view" is known as, wait for it --- "skepticism".

If you look at the examples quite a few of them weren't adopted into the mainstream for 30, ..50 years, occasionally only after the original researcher is in his grave. If the scientific establishment was being purely motivated by the quality of evidence why did it take them so long?
Part of the explanation is in the Max Planck quote on my signature
 
hmm.. as far as I remember throughout today it's been ME providing the evidence p
Then either you are suffering from some terrible form of amnesia or you simply haven't been reading people's posts.

(lots of it) and not one Skeptic that I have heard from accepting any of it.
This is because the bits of your "evidence" which aren't outright lies have failed to prove your point.

Let me quote Drummer's question to you, which was a good one:

"And I still like to see which skeptics/ scientist still don't believe in aircraft, turbine engines, the light bulb etc. Whatever the objections and ridicule at the time, it looks very much to me that everyone was swayed by the evidence. Which is not very rigidly, kneejerkingly orthodox, is it now?"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom