when have you changed your mind on a matter?

Really? Wow. The woos only read themselves and the words of others if they can distort to support their view. What made you so diligent to keep plowing through page after page--was it like a compulsion... ?

I don't think I've read a long thread from beginning to end unless I've been participating all along. Have others read through entire threads?

I read through this whole one, registered, then waited to be approved so I could put in my two cents.

And now back to plumjam...

Discovery has been held back for short periods of time by stubborn, skepitcal, or just down right ignorant forces. Most of that was done by religious entities and not scientific ones but regardless. I think it sucks that sometimes incredible discoveries have been ignored for short periods of time before being accepted as fact.

What do you think the solution is? Should we accept every claim that is made?

What discovery that is not being currently accepted gets you worked up? Is it telepathy or mediums and why?

What has science done to make you so vitriolic?

Can you name someone from the last 50 years whose discoveries have been denied by a majority of the scientific community only to be vindicated?

I am completely serious with these questions. please answer them. If it helps I apologize for being sarcastic earlier but I am also British and it comes natural to me.
 
lol

pretty sensitive on that one, aren't you chaps? ;-)

speaks to me of some kind of emotional attachment to the theory. Not, strictly speaking, something a skeptic should be indulging in, is it

I do hope you'll be going back to school this fall. Please consider Logic 101.
 
Last edited:
here we go again with the old "straw man" accusation.. been on here two days and must have had it levelled at me 10 times or more so far. It seems to be a bit of a mantra used by Skeptics when they can't think of a proper argument.
Misrepresentations you say. There were dozens of historical examples reported by many different sources, many quotes describing contemporary Skeptics views of new findings/innovations. I'd be interested to learn how these are misrepresentations.
The fact that so few current Skeptics are unaware of the damaging effects militant Skepticism has had in the past on research, fresh approaches, rates of discovery, individual careers and wider society is a function of the fact that these instances are more or less swept under the carpet.
If more so called Skeptics were aware of this they might take a bit less glee in scoffing at anyone with something to offer that stands outside of their accepted norms.

Have you not looked up the definition yet?! Please do so and write us a paragraph on straw men arguments before you post again.
 
... you'll see that the Skeptical Orthodoxy of the time has been wrong about most of the important new discoveries and innovations in history
the same, of course, will apply to today's version of Skeptical Orthodoxy

Although the term 'Skeptical Orthodoxy' is new to me, I think I can accurately guess what it means in this context and, if I'm guessing correctly, it ain't exactly breaking news...

One of the most respected sceptical thinkers of the last 100+ years shared similar views - although I doubt if he resorted to ad hominem trolling in order to share them

Bertrand Russell (1872 - 1970) said:
Do not fear to be eccentric in opinion, for every opinion now accepted was once eccentric

Bertrand Russell (1872 - 1970) said:
In all affairs it's a healthy thing now and then to hang a question mark on the things you have long taken for granted

He is in record as the source of a great many other thoughts, some of which have, I suspect, relevance to the tangent that this thread is on

Bertrand Russell (1872 - 1970) said:
The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, but wiser people so full of doubts

And, on a lighter note, he said "The time you enjoy wasting is not wasted time", something that (partially) explains why I came to this thread in the first place, which was to answer plumjam's questions in the thread title when have you changed your mind on a matter?

Well... prior to (skim) reading this thread, I thought you'd be interested in reading my personal anecdotes about the (multiple) times that I have changed my mind regarding important issues

But... now that I have read all too many of your posts that do nothing to advance thought, I have changed my mind, and think that you're liable to attack me for my sceptical stance on any/all issues you hold dear

Bertrand Russell (1872 - 1970) said:
A stupid man's report of what a clever man says can never be accurate, because he unconsciously translates what he hears into something he can understand

However... perhaps naively, I hope you can calm down long enough to accept the possibility that many of those you attack might well be persuaded to share the insight you lack - if you're polite, humble and open to new ideas

Bertrand Russell (1872 - 1970) said:
The good life, as I conceive it, is a happy life. I do not mean that if you are good you will be happy - I mean that if you are happy you will be good.
 
nice, some photos and diagrams

you could draw all kinds of different conclusions from them.. and in practice the conclusions will tend to be predetermined by your over-arching belief system.

I don't see anything in them that finds strongly in favour of or against the Darwinian hypothesis.
You've done it again.

Choose one of the following options:

(1) Scientists cannot really find out what the fossil record really tells us, you know this, and therefore you were lying when you said that there was "stasis in the fossil record".

(2) Scientists can really find out what the fossil record really tells us, and the bones constitute evidence which proves you wrong.
 
Last edited:
here we go again with the old "straw man" accusation.. been on here two days and must have had it levelled at me 10 times or more so far. It seems to be a bit of a mantra used by Skeptics when ...
... they see a straw man argument.

Misrepresentations you say. There were dozens of historical examples reported by many different sources, many quotes describing contemporary Skeptics views of new findings/innovations. I'd be interested to learn how these are misrepresentations.
Well ... y'know ... all the lies. As demonstrated on this thread, repeatedly.
 
... they see a straw man argument.

Well ... y'know ... all the lies. As demonstrated on this thread, repeatedly.

no no no-- it's only "lies" if the skeptics are saying it... if the woos say it, it's a "higher truth", or "a slight exaggeration" or someone "misspoke"--
 
here we go again with the old "straw man" accusation.. been on here two days and must have had it levelled at me 10 times or more so far.
Whereas I've made thousands of posts, and the accusation hasn't come up that often.

The reason for this striking difference is left as an exercise for the reader.
 
Last edited:
plumjam said:
The fact that so few current Skeptics are unaware of the damaging effects militant Skepticism has had in the past on research, fresh approaches, rates of discovery, individual careers and wider society is a function of the fact that these instances are more or less swept under the carpet.

I wasn't aware such facts were being swept under the rug and I wish to know the facts. Please give me some examples which show Militant Skepticism damaging the following:

-research
-fresh approaches
-rates of discovery
-individual careers
-wider society
 
I've got to chime in. Yes, I once believed in all sort of paranormal phenoma. I believed in astrology, magic, UFOs, Atlantis - you name it. But I grew up. I discovered the worth of scientific exploration -- the value of evidence. I became a skeptic and demanded evidence for incredible claims. OK, this isn't what you want to hear. You only want stories that support your world view - you are dogmatic. You can't admit that some people find the evidence for what you believe in very lacking. You are the poster child of close mindedness. What would it take to make you doubt your beliefs? I believe it's nothing -- because your beliefs have been firmly entrenched in who you are. To question them would be to doubt your identity -- not a comfortable thing, but a thing skeptics do all the time.

Evidence, it's the key thing. We don't believe in fairy tales. Sure, we'd love if psi was true - but we haven't seen any convincing evidence. Instead, we've seen charlatans, sloppy scientific controls, and wishful thinking. Please give us some evidence. We'll analyze it and consider it objectively. If you can't do that, well go back to your sandbox and stop bothering us with your unsubstantiated claims.
 
I've got to chime in. Yes, I once believed in all sort of paranormal phenoma. I believed in astrology, magic, UFOs, Atlantis - you name it. But I grew up. I discovered the worth of scientific exploration -- the value of evidence. I became a skeptic and demanded evidence for incredible claims. OK, this isn't what you want to hear. You only want stories that support your world view - you are dogmatic. You can't admit that some people find the evidence for what you believe in very lacking. You are the poster child of close mindedness. What would it take to make you doubt your beliefs? I believe it's nothing -- because your beliefs have been firmly entrenched in who you are. To question them would be to doubt your identity -- not a comfortable thing, but a thing skeptics do all the time.

Evidence, it's the key thing. We don't believe in fairy tales. Sure, we'd love if psi was true - but we haven't seen any convincing evidence. Instead, we've seen charlatans, sloppy scientific controls, and wishful thinking. Please give us some evidence. We'll analyze it and consider it objectively. If you can't do that, well go back to your sandbox and stop bothering us with your unsubstantiated claims.

Great post! I just finally came to a point in my life that I would rather not know something than to believe a lie. Some prefer the latter. Not me. Truth is important. And if the facts warrant, then what else am I to do but change my mind if I want the truth. Woo can't even frame the questions well. Can there be consciousness outside a brain? Until the evidence shows otherwise, I will presume the answer is no. That eliminates gods, souls, engrams, fairies, demons, etc. until or unless the evidence warrants. And science is great at amassing evidence for useful true info. Look what we've amassed in regards to DNA and evolution. What guru had a clue?
 
Great post! I just finally came to a point in my life that I would rather not know something than to believe a lie. Some prefer the latter. Not me. Truth is important. And if the facts warrant, then what else am I to do but change my mind if I want the truth. Woo can't even frame the questions well. Can there be consciousness outside a brain? Until the evidence shows otherwise, I will presume the answer is no. That eliminates gods, souls, engrams, fairies, demons, etc. until or unless the evidence warrants. And science is great at amassing evidence for useful true info. Look what we've amassed in regards to DNA and evolution. What guru had a clue?

Bad enough to believe a lie rather than admit that you just don't know. How much worse is it to resist knowing, to reject facts and evidence and rationality and reason, in order to continue believing lies? That's what we're facing here. The Internet gives everyone on it access to every bit of knowledge we have... and some people use it to spit on that knowledge.
 
Bad enough to believe a lie rather than admit that you just don't know. How much worse is it to resist knowing, to reject facts and evidence and rationality and reason, in order to continue believing lies? That's what we're facing here. The Internet gives everyone on it access to every bit of knowledge we have... and some people use it to spit on that knowledge.

Yes... I think for the first time in human history, someone has to actively work at remaining ignorant. We humans have figured out so much... I think creationists have got to be doing the denial thing almost every minute to miss the vast amassing data regarding evolution. Do they imagine all the Natural History Museums are in on the conspiracy--and forensic testers--and scientists all over the world... that DNA labs are a "sham" operation run by Satan? Do the fossils constantly on the front pages just not penetrate the cranium?

I think the next big thing in science people will need to start changing their minds about is materialism. Increasing evidence shows there are no ghosts in the brain. Prepare the kids to accept this reality. As consider evolution to be as proven and vindicated as the Wright Brother's flying machine. The public needs to get a bit of a clue that the only controversy as to whether evolution happened exists solely in the mind of theists of the fundamentalist variety (christian, moonies, and muslims...)
 
Last edited:
...creationists have got to be doing the denial thing almost every minute to miss the vast amassing data regarding evolution. Do they imagine all the Natural History Museums are in on the conspiracy--and forensic testers--and scientists all over the world... that DNA labs are a "sham" operation run by Satan? Do the fossils constantly on the front pages just not penetrate the cranium?

During a brief dalliance with the happy-clappy brigade, I was told - by sheep masquerading as 'pastors' - that to be saved, one must live in but not of the world, which is governed by Beelzebub

As far as CT is concerned, the cess pit of fundie propaganda makes the truthers movement look like, well, erm... a movement
 
During a brief dalliance with the happy-clappy brigade, I was told - by sheep masquerading as 'pastors' - that to be saved, one must live in but not of the world, which is governed by Beelzebub

As far as CT is concerned, the cess pit of fundie propaganda makes the truthers movement look like, well, erm... a movement

Yes... and the fundies look like a bowel movement.

I think the Amish have a similarity to the fundies you refer too. And sadly, I bet your happy clappy brigade was imported from the U.S.

That woo is an insidious little bugger-- the skeptics and scientists were going about their business content to be left alone for the most part never realizing how the woo was seeping in the consciousness of the public in a slow brain washing fashion... too slow for the woo infested to detect it in time-- and now we have a whole bunch of plumjams...
 
Can you name someone from the last 50 years whose discoveries have been denied by a majority of the scientific community only to be vindicated?

Plate tectonics would probably be the best example. The idea of continents moving was mostly ignored with a large helping of ridicule from most in the field. Then they found some evidence...
 
Because of the persistent lack of evidence for woo-related stuff, my examples (in the direction in which the OP intended ie away from scepticism) are real-world based.

The Y2K thread reminded me that I was (first cynical, then) sceptical of the Y2K problem until I was pointed to evidence for it online, at which point I changed my mind. I have also in the past been sceptical of anthro global warming, and have changed my mind.

But I doubt examples like that (where evidence actually comes to light and a sceptic changes his/her mind) are what plumjam is looking for.
 
I get the feeling that at the time Darwin brought out his book you would have been one of those ridiculing him, perhaps (if forums had existed then) coming here and calling him a "fundie nutjob" as you seem to so enjoy calling others.

Darwin's idea was rather new. Could you explain how a novel idea can be called 'fundamentalist'? And this is a strawman too. Darwin provided a wealth of evidence in the Origin of Species, which is why 'orthodox conventional science' embraced his ideas rather quickly. The only ones skeptical of Darwin were (and still are) religious fundie nutjobs. It's a funny ol' world, ain't it?

But according to your current beliefs, you would have been completely wrong to do so, and may even, looking back, felt yourself to have been acting arrogantly and rather foolishly, with little intellectual humility.
Can you see this?

A bit of advice, do look up what a strawman argument is please. Wikipedia will do nicely thank you.

Regarding the antibiotic resistance thing, I know little about the topic, but Milton seems to refute it.

So when you have a bacterial infection, you'd be quite happy to use older anti-biotics? You know, the ones that bacteria have evolved restance to? Not the new ones that had to be developed because this evolving of resistance is real. Using those would be intelectually dishonest, don't you think?

Basically I go back to what I said last night.. that in thousands of generations of intelligence-driven human selective breeding of dogs and horses we've never managed to get anything that isn't just a plain old dog and a plain old horse.

Oh boy. Has it ever occured to you that a dogbreeder, who makes a living breeding dogs, would not continue to breed with anything that doesn't look like a dog? The purpose of dogbreeding/ horsebreeding etc. is to breed dogs and horses. The sad thing is that that probably is a revelation for you.

I would say that this evidence strongly suggests that Darwinian natural selection is impotent to explain the presence of millions of variegated and incredibly complex species, that are supposedly (according to your ideology) meant to have descended from a single celled organism :)

Face it, it's a belief without evidence

Plumjam, ignorance can be solved. Please read the alt.talk.origins archive, specifically the FAQ, and then come back to us on evolution. We orthodox skeptics, with our rigid ideology, are always willing to change our opinion based on evidence. Let's see what you do after you have seen the evidence.
 
I read through this whole one, registered, then waited to be approved so I could put in my two cents.

And now back to plumjam...

Discovery has been held back for short periods of time by stubborn, skepitcal, or just down right ignorant forces. Most of that was done by religious entities and not scientific ones but regardless. I think it sucks that sometimes incredible discoveries have been ignored for short periods of time before being accepted as fact.

What do you think the solution is? Should we accept every claim that is made?

What discovery that is not being currently accepted gets you worked up? Is it telepathy or mediums and why?

What has science done to make you so vitriolic?

Can you name someone from the last 50 years whose discoveries have been denied by a majority of the scientific community only to be vindicated?

I am completely serious with these questions. please answer them. If it helps I apologize for being sarcastic earlier but I am also British and it comes natural to me.

Biscuit- I'm afraid you've asked some difficult questions of plumjam. And I worry that you may have scared him away. Pity, as he could have learned something here had he been sufficiently open minded...
 
The context of plumjam’s discussion is not what he/she asked in post #1 (“when have you changed your mind on a matter?”); clearly the intended discussion was more pointed at “science has been wrong in the past” and “skeptics have wrongly interpreted scientific data”. A classic "bait and switch" on his/her part, and somewhat intellectually dishonest.

Regardless, both of these points are intuitively obvious; science is often proven/shown to be wrong, skeptics have wrongly interpreted scientific data.

These two facts do not diminish attempts to define “the world around us” in scientific terms. Rather, I’d argue just the opposite; the fact that science has been shown to be wrong and has incorporated new ideas/concepts/changes over time demonstrates a self correcting nature.

BTW – Biscut, welcome & nice posts.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom