Lord Emsworth
Je ne suis pas une de vos élèves
- Joined
- Apr 22, 2003
- Messages
- 3,181
Thanks for your reactions, in particular I find the following posts: 11, 20, 23, 39, 42, 53, 57 to be conducive to the learning of people who read this thread in the hope of getting something useful into their brain:
Do you count yourself amongst these people?
The title of the thread is:
What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?
First, we have to agree on what is a definition of a word good for.
It is good or useful for people to know what actual or at least possible entity outside your brain or even inside your brain the word you use refers to.
Does my definition of God serve that purpose for people to know what entity outside their brain and/or inside their brain the word God refers to?
No.
Does it tell people what atheists and what theists are talking about with the word God?
Hardly. It could strictly speaking refer to things that conform to materialistic/naturalistic or some such philosophies.
If they know what is a maker, what is heaven, what is earth, and what is everything, then they should find nothing wrong with the word God defined as the maker of heaven and hearth and everything.
If.
If you find something wrong with that definition of God, then it is because for you: you can't know what people are talking about with the word God, whereas they know what they are talking about,
Indeed. Do you know what this one people (me is people as well) is talking about with the word God? I do know. A logical impossiblility. And whatever does not conform to my definition of God, does not pass muster as God. Sure, I am aware that there are a bunch of people who hold to different definitions, deists and pantheists for example, but to me that is hardly worth debate, it would just boil down to a semantic argument.
As for some of the remaining people, I indeed "can't know what people are talking about with the word God" because they assert that God is beyond our understanding, that finite minds cannot grasp the infinite, or that you can merely apprehend yet not comprehend the divine, that our conceptions will always be faulty or some such.
even kids in nursery school have no trouble with the word God and its meaning.
A man in the sky up there. I speak from experience here.
The cause could be some kind of peculiar brain configuration on your part, not found in people who do know what is being talked about with the word God.
Or perhaps you have some kind of dread with the word itself of God, what is that dread all about?
Would it make you happy if I took that word "God" and slapped it onto the totality of all existence and called myself a pantheist instead of strong atheist/ignostic instead? It would be a trivial, definitional thing for me to do.
