What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Thanks for your reactions, in particular I find the following posts: 11, 20, 23, 39, 42, 53, 57 to be conducive to the learning of people who read this thread in the hope of getting something useful into their brain:

Do you count yourself amongst these people?

The title of the thread is:

What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?​


First, we have to agree on what is a definition of a word good for.

It is good or useful for people to know what actual or at least possible entity outside your brain or even inside your brain the word you use refers to.


Does my definition of God serve that purpose for people to know what entity outside their brain and/or inside their brain the word God refers to?

No.

Does it tell people what atheists and what theists are talking about with the word God?

Hardly. It could strictly speaking refer to things that conform to materialistic/naturalistic or some such philosophies.

If they know what is a maker, what is heaven, what is earth, and what is everything, then they should find nothing wrong with the word God defined as the maker of heaven and hearth and everything.

If.

If you find something wrong with that definition of God, then it is because for you: you can't know what people are talking about with the word God, whereas they know what they are talking about,

Indeed. Do you know what this one people (me is people as well) is talking about with the word God? I do know. A logical impossiblility. And whatever does not conform to my definition of God, does not pass muster as God. Sure, I am aware that there are a bunch of people who hold to different definitions, deists and pantheists for example, but to me that is hardly worth debate, it would just boil down to a semantic argument.

As for some of the remaining people, I indeed "can't know what people are talking about with the word God" because they assert that God is beyond our understanding, that finite minds cannot grasp the infinite, or that you can merely apprehend yet not comprehend the divine, that our conceptions will always be faulty or some such.


even kids in nursery school have no trouble with the word God and its meaning.

A man in the sky up there. I speak from experience here.

The cause could be some kind of peculiar brain configuration on your part, not found in people who do know what is being talked about with the word God.

Or perhaps you have some kind of dread with the word itself of God, what is that dread all about?

Would it make you happy if I took that word "God" and slapped it onto the totality of all existence and called myself a pantheist instead of strong atheist/ignostic instead? It would be a trivial, definitional thing for me to do.
 
Yrreg, I accept that your definition of "God" is:

maker of heaven and earth and everything

Now, I would ask that you consider the following. This is (one of) the dictionary definition(s) of "God". I chose this portion out of the 9 available listed definitions, because I think that it is the most clear and relevant.

"1. God
a. A being conceived as the perfect, omnipotent, omniscient originator and ruler of the universe, the principal object of faith and worship in monotheistic religions.
b. The force, effect, or a manifestation or aspect of this being.

2. A being of supernatural powers or attributes, believed in and worshiped by a people, especially a male deity thought to control some part of nature or reality."

Would you accept this as an acceptable definition for "God"? Please explain why or why not.
 
Thanks for your reactions, in particular I find the following posts: 11, 20, 23, 39, 42, 53, 57 to be conducive to the learning of people who read this thread in the hope of getting something useful into their brain:


The title of the thread is:

What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?​


First, we have to agree on what is a definition of a word good for.

It is good or useful for people to know what actual or at least possible entity outside your brain or even inside your brain the word you use refers to.


Does my definition of God serve that purpose for people to know what entity outside their brain and/or inside their brain the word God refers to?

Does it tell people what atheists and what theists are talking about with the word God?

If they know what is a maker, what is heaven, what is earth, and what is everything, then they should find nothing wrong with the word God defined as the maker of heaven and hearth and everything.


If you find something wrong with that definition of God, then it is because for you: you can't know what people are talking about with the word God, whereas they know what they are talking about, even kids in nursery school have no trouble with the word God and its meaning.

The cause could be some kind of peculiar brain configuration on your part, not found in people who do know what is being talked about with the word God.

Or perhaps you have some kind of dread with the word itself of God, what is that dread all about?





Yrreg

There is a difference between a definition and a label. If you are intending a designation of what sort of god you believe in, your so-called definition is certainly adequate as a working definition (or more properly, perhaps as a label for what definition you are working from), and when we argue about God we know more or less what we are arguing about when you use it. But the understanding of what we are arguing about depends largely on an understanding of ideas that are not contained in the definition. If you were to provide that definition to someone with no cultural, religious or historical context by which to understand what you consider to be the properties of the God you believe in, the definition would be of little use in conveying an understanding of what sort of God you're talking about, since it includes no idea of the actual properties of that God, only the statement that something or other engaged once in an act of creation. All else, including even the current existence of the god in question, is inferred from a cultural context, and is not found in your definition.

In any case, you asked for opinions on what is wrong with the definition, and people have pointed out problems. It has nothing to do with one's attitude toward God, toward you, or anything else, except the quality of the definition.

I pointed out, and I continue to maintain, that the definition is needlessly redundant. "Heaven and earth" are part of everything. Your definition is as silly as defining God as the creator of butterflies, twist drills and stuff.

Others have pointed out that if one wishes to go any deeper into the implications of the definition, beyond its function as a label for more comprehensive definitions that are implied, "everything" is problematic. Even though one can pretty easily understand in the loose, conversational sense what you mean by "everything," it's obvious that if one were interested in theological or ontological accuracy, God did not create "everything" unless you are an idealist of the most radical sort, believing that the entire universe exists only in the mind of God. Otherwise, it is pretty safe to assume that He is not the author of my current post, and not, in a direct sense, at least, the creator of mortgage-backed securities, dildoes, Barbie dolls, locomotives, the Australian brush fires or the dust bunnies under my computer desk (well, I'll give him that last one).

So, if you ask for what is wrong with your definition, don't crab and start casting aspersions on people's religion, character, motivation or mental capacity when they flat out tell you what is so painfully obvious to nearly everyone but yourself: it's a poor definition, and even to call it a definition is a kindness.

edited to add: I see that Frankiak7 has provided a definition which I suspect is closer to what you mean when you speak of God," and if so, makes it clear what essential properties or attributes are missing from yours.
 
Last edited:
First, does the definition serve the purpose a definition is supposed to serve?

Please do not bother with labels.

What's in a name? that which we call a rose
By any other name would smell as sweet.​


And also don't nitpick on redundancy, what to you is redundant is to others, greater connoisseurs of definitions, more explicit.




That is why the readers here are my witnesses, it is to my very serious and dismaying impression that exchanging thoughts with atheists here is so exasperating: because they either are playing naive or are really born naive.

The effect is the just the same though that you can't have any productive exchange of ideas with them.


Conclusion is that they really don't want to be relevant; which is a good topic for dissertation candidates in psychology of human behavior to work on for their doctorates.





About my definition of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything, if that is not what atheists are writing against about...

Then tell me what they are writing about and selling books for people like their fellow atheists to buy, in order to feel so smart for having swallowed a lot of code phrases, which they repeat without ever knowing anything really solid about the semblance of reasoning, semblance only just to be kind, behind the code phrases.






Yrreg
 
Please do not bother with labels.

What's in a name? that which we call a rose
By any other name would smell as sweet.​


And also don't nitpick on redundancy, what to you is redundant is to others, greater connoisseurs of definitions, more explicit.




That is why the readers here are my witnesses, it is to my very serious and dismaying impression that exchanging thoughts with atheists here is so exasperating: because they either are playing naive or are really born naive.

The effect is the just the same though that you can't have any productive exchange of ideas with them.


Conclusion is that they really don't want to be relevant; which is a good topic for dissertation candidates in psychology of human behavior to work on for their doctorates.





About my definition of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything, if that is not what atheists are writing against about...

Then tell me what they are writing about and selling books for people like their fellow atheists to buy, in order to feel so smart for having swallowed a lot of code phrases, which they repeat without ever knowing anything really solid about the semblance of reasoning, semblance only just to be kind, behind the code phrases.






Yrreg

That's more than twenty words, and you did not use E-prime. Stop tergiversating. Try again, only this time you must use eighteen words exactly, and two of them must be "ficus".
 
Behold, one atheist not playing naive and not born naive.

I must apologize to the author of the following post, for not mentioning it as one which is of useful contribution to the brain storage of readers here who do care to learn something useful to their intellectual culture.

I see nothing wrong with yreggs definition. I just wish we could move on to the evidence of existence part of the course...
I'm all ears here.
The prevaricating is intense. ( Is prevaricating still the latest word of the moment? Im keeping notes)




And the two posts, 77 and 82, are also enrichment to the intellectual culture of people who are not playing naive or regrettably born naive.




If anyone want me to react to your post, just pm me, but you have to give me the permission to respond to you in open public forum.




Yes, we will go to the evidence of God's existence as the maker of heaven and earth and everything -- eventually.

But no productively enriching exchange of thoughts can ensue between discussants, unless and until they come to a mutually acceptable definition of the object they are discussing about.





Yrreg
 
About my definition of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything, if that is not what atheists are writing against about...

Then tell me what they are writing about and selling books for people like their fellow atheists to buy,

Those books are about all god beliefs, including belief in the kind of god you describe in your definition as well as the more common beliefs in gods that, in addition to creating the universe, actually interact with it.
 
About my definition of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything, if that is not what atheists are writing against about...

Then tell me what they are writing about and selling books for people like their fellow atheists to buy, in order to feel so smart for having swallowed a lot of code phrases, which they repeat without ever knowing anything really solid about the semblance of reasoning, semblance only just to be kind, behind the code phrases.

So far, all you have pointed out for evidence is the first 2 chapters of Genesis...Where is Genesis, Yrreg? In a book? Is this a book of evidence?
 
Read this carefully...

What's exactly, specifically wrong with my definition of God?
as maker of heaven and earth and everything.​


Yrreg

Yrreg,

What is wrong with this definition is that it assumes a lot, and informs us of nothing useful. Let me break this down a little more:

It assumes that something made "heaven and earth and everything"; it further assumes that all of those had the same maker. That is, it ignores the possibility that, once Heaven and Earth existed, everything else developed from them; or, perhaps, that Heaven was created by Entity One, but Earth was created by Entity Two, and everything else by Entity Three.
There's also the possibility that Earth was created, but that everthing but Earth did not require intervention.

The other issue is that it tells us nothing about God's nature. It simply describes something(s) he has done. This is equivalent to a DA saying in a press conference, "We know who the killer is!" and then adding, "It's the person who murdered Mr. Jensen, Mrs. Jensen, and stole Mrs. Jensen's jewelry." An attorney who made that statement would be laughed at, and rightly so; it's a useless statement.

To identify the suspect, there would have to be some characteristics or attributes, such as: "A tall, dark-haired male, with a heavy build; quite strong; not a native English speaker; intelligent, patient, and not likely to draw attention to himself--pretty average looking." These are things that the police likely derived from information about what was done, and how it was done, but from that evidence they have concluded how the perpetrator is.

Further, they have described it in terms that make sense. Based, perhaps, on witness testimony, they have come up with a tall, dark, strong male with an accent and/or grammar errors in spoken English. Anyone who is short, female, blonde and erudite can be eliminated from the discussion.

By contrast, your description of your Supreme Being lacks even the specification that it is a being! It doesn't say if God is conscious, aware or self-aware; it doesn't say if God is living or dead--hey, creating Everything is a big job, may it gave Him heart attack--or if She has any physicality. It doesn't say if She's interested in what She created, or if it was the divine equivalent of excrement.

It's a big bag of words that can't be used to define anything, or eliminate anything from the discussion.

That's "what's wrong with" the definition you used. It doesn't serve any useful purpose for discussion God's nature, attributes, or likely existance/ non-existance.

Resepectfully, Miss Kitt
 
About my definition of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything, if that is not what atheists are writing against about...

Then tell me what they are writing about and selling books for people like their fellow atheists to buy, in order to feel so smart for having swallowed a lot of code phrases, which they repeat without ever knowing anything really solid about the semblance of reasoning, semblance only just to be kind, behind the code phrases.

What is the point of asking a question in which the answer is already contained? Or asking a question that is tied to so much baggage that you will have a hard time finding anybody to agree to all of that baggage?

Asking what the heck atheist authors are writing about is entirely sufficient. (You even sort of have a point) Somehow stuffing things into that sentence about swallowing, feeling smart, or not knowing anything solid is unnecessary.

Then tell me what yrreg is writing about and selling stuff to his own mind to buy into, in order to feel so smart for having swallowed a lot of code phrases, which he repeat without ever knowing anything really solid about the semblance of reasoning, semblance only just to be kind, behind the code phrases.​

Well, well, that was easy. But seriously, what exactly do you understand by "maker" in your definition? What is below the 'code phrase'? Any source, referred to in a metaphorical way?
 
So far, all you have pointed out for evidence is the first 2 chapters of Genesis...Where is Genesis, Yrreg? In a book? Is this a book of evidence?

Is this true?

In the first creation story in the Bible, God does not create everything, at least not in the sense everything would be understood nowadays. The waters of the deep, though they may embody unordered chaos, are not created, rather that which is given order. So, 'maker of ... everything' would not mesh with the first creation story in Genesis. (I am far less familiar with the second, but if I am not misunderstood, this is not a creation of everything either.)

What is more, is that God talks, produces speech. If that is to be understood at face value it has several extremely unpalatable consequences for the God concept. If it is not to be taken at face value, but rather is a metaphor, is seriously needs to be cleared up.
 
My definition of God:

God is a Jellyroll with tofu and creamcorn.


I will justify my definition as soon as we move to that phase of the thread.
 
Please do not bother with labels.

What's in a name? that which we call a rose
By any other name would smell as sweet.​


And also don't nitpick on redundancy, what to you is redundant is to others, greater connoisseurs of definitions, more explicit.




That is why the readers here are my witnesses, it is to my very serious and dismaying impression that exchanging thoughts with atheists here is so exasperating: because they either are playing naive or are really born naive.

The effect is the just the same though that you can't have any productive exchange of ideas with them.


Conclusion is that they really don't want to be relevant; which is a good topic for dissertation candidates in psychology of human behavior to work on for their doctorates.





About my definition of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything, if that is not what atheists are writing against about...

Then tell me what they are writing about and selling books for people like their fellow atheists to buy, in order to feel so smart for having swallowed a lot of code phrases, which they repeat without ever knowing anything really solid about the semblance of reasoning, semblance only just to be kind, behind the code phrases.






Yrreg

I see the answere is in your usual combination of bad faith and gratuitious insult. You ask what is wrong with your definition but you no actual interest in hearing opinions, only in dismissing them as signs of inferior thought or what you choose to think of as naiveté, for some odd reason, perhaps an unawareness of the proper definition of the term.

Your definition is a bad one. Any definition which depends for full understanding of its subject on sources other than itself is a bad definition. It matters not whether, in ordinary discourse, we rely on that dependency and manage to understand each other. That does not make the definition a good one. If you think that it does, you're an idiot.
 
And also don't nitpick on redundancy, what to you is redundant is to others, greater connoisseurs of definitions, more explicit.

The term "everything" can't be made more explicit in the context you've applied it. Therefore, I think even the greatest "connoisseur of definitions" would consider your definition of God superfluous and redundant, eliciting more confusion than clarity.
 
Yrreg; Read The Following.

You asked us what we felt was wrong with your definition of god (maker of heaven and earth and everything).

This has been provided, although you dismiss the posts as signs of naivete. Which is insulting, frankly. But then, so is most of what you write.


Here is the issue:

You routinely and reliably get angry whenever somebody brings up the Flying Spaghetti Monster or the Invisible Pink Unicorn or other deity concepts to prove a point.

The trouble is, these deity concepts are perfectly compatible with your definition of god.

Yet you refuse to acknowledge the analogies made, instead insulting the posters by saying people who bring up such concepts are "non-thinkers".

If these concepts are not your god, the fault lies with you.
Your definition, as presented, gives no way of differentiating between many hundreds of deity concepts (many of which are mutually incompatible).

Since you obviously have a specific god-concept in mind (or else you wouldn't reject the others as "non-thinking"), and since your definition fails completely to describe the specific concept you have in mind (or any other specific concept, for that matter), it is not a very good definition. By definition.


That is what is wrong with it. As a definition of a concept, it works, but doesn't really clarify anything. As a definition of a specific deity-concept, as you are using it for, it fails utterly. It is too vague, and it eschews actual description in favour of giving a resume.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom