What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

What's exactly, specifically wrong with my definition of God?
as maker of heaven and earth and everything.​
The exact, specifi problem with this definition of God is that it accurately describes any one of a host of mutally exclusive God concepts.

It describes Yahweh of the Bible.
It describes Brahmin
It describes Ymir
It describes Ptah
It describes the Flying Spaghetti Monster
It describes the Great Green Arkleseizure.

If you want to define the God of the Bible, you will have to be a lot more specific.
 
Maker: Means what? Normally if I am faced with the word maker I will assume that if refers to a human being. But I doubt that this is the case here. So, if what I would perceive as the literal meaning does not apply, I would have to opt for understanding it as a metaphor. There is nothing wrong with that per se, it is only that there are software packages, like File Maker, which use the word "maker" as well.

So, without further specification I have no clue how to imagine that "maker" in question, let alone imagining how what the making is like.

Heaven: Not sure what this refers to. Might be a reference to the various magical, mystical places of various believers. Might also be a reference to the sky, or to the rest of the universe as seen from earth.

Earth: That one is fairly clear cut.

Everything: This is used to refer to all that exists, or further specified to all that exhibits certain characteristics.


The biggest problem is that "maker" does not compel a specific meaning, and could refer to anything ranging from human beings to software packages. "Maker of everything" is even contradictory, because "everything" by definition asserts that the maker is part of everything, while the meaning of "maker" asserts that the maker is not part of everything. Saying "maker of everything apart from the maker" would solve the problem, and is probably what is intended, though.

If the latter here is intended this would amount to the assertion that there are certain things which exist just so, while other things are contigent up upon them for their existence. This may even be true, and we may even refer to the necessary things as "God." However, it might mean that your "maker" is something that exhibits an exceptional naturalistic uglyness and is utterly boring.

IOW, you take a label with "God" written on it, and then have to slap it onto ANYTHING that fulfills a certain criterion. Even is that something is called, say, quantum chaos, or brane, or whatever, by other people.



Me, I reject this kind of God. It makes me feel betrayed. Nowhere in there is something that talks, that listens, that has family, that sits around on thrones, that lives ^^^^^ up there, that has emotions, that is subject to some sort of time etc pp. Nowhere in there is any of the childish crap that people utter when they don't watch their words carefully enough. Nowhere in there is anything that justifies the hidden borderline anthropocentric premise of the fine tuning argument ("Look, isn't this set of universal constants special, it allows (human)life!"). Nowhere in there is there is the assertion of intentionality. And so on and so forth.

The only exception is maybe "maker of ... heaven...". What is your version of "heaven?" Some magic, mystical place, or just the boring rest of the universe as seen from earth?
 
To be fair, he didn't say he was defining the God of the Bible.

And there is no way that this definition does describe the GoB because it leaves out His constant interfering in our reality and the affairs of man. Together with the lack of responsiveness (unless it's by not responding in any useful way) to whining prayers sent His way by his billions of accolades. :boggled:
 
What's exactly, specifically wrong with my definition of God?
as maker of heaven and earth and everything.
​
Yrreg
There is absolutely nothing wrong with your definition of God, Yrreg. Heck, I've used it myself. It is the favorite definition that was used by Kurt Vonnegut Jr. It is simple and clear.

In the same way, the definition of a unicorn as "A horse with a single horn growing out of it's forehead" is a wonderful definition of a mythological creature. It is simple and clear. Anyone can picture it.

So I am fine with your definition, Yrreg, totally happy. If you ever reach the part where you show that this definition is anything other than the description of a mythological creature, then I'll be even more pleased.
 
Having a word for something means the word exists. It doesn't mean that the thing supposedly defined or described by the word exists.
 
Yrreg, the biggest problem with your definition is that it is gratuitously redundant, and by being so it introduces possibilities for nitpicking disputes that deflect the discussion from what I presume you intend, since there is potential disagreement about the meaning of the word "heaven," and a question about why some parts of creation are made specific while others are not.

If all of the criteria of your definition are correct, then it can be simplified to this:

God is the creator of everything.

Of course that's still open to argument, but perhaps at least the argument would be about the existence or nature of God, rather than the language of Yrreg.
 
yrreg, would you be happy with an equivalent definition of god as "maker of hell, Jupiter, and everything?" It's got your requisite fictional place, your requisite planet from our solar system, and the ever-vague "everything" so that your list could be exactly three items long.

What does "everything" include anyway? The two items it follows are completely different, what with one being fictional and the other based in reality. I get that they're both places. Is your god the maker of all places, fictional and non? Did he create Hogwarts, for instance?

I don't know what this "everything" is supposed to include, but if god created my car, maybe you can ask him why it's breaking down every two months. Thanks.
 
How about this Yrreg? Since you asked what's wrong with your definition of God, why don't you enlighten us on how the definition would be correct.
 
Last edited:
I see nothing wrong with yreggs definition. I just wish we could move on to the evidence of existence part of the course...
I'm all ears here.
The prevaricating is intense. ( Is prevaricating still the latest word of the moment? Im keeping notes)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom