What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Is this true?

In the first creation story in the Bible, God does not create everything, at least not in the sense everything would be understood nowadays. The waters of the deep, though they may embody unordered chaos, are not created, rather that which is given order. So, 'maker of ... everything' would not mesh with the first creation story in Genesis. (I am far less familiar with the second, but if I am not misunderstood, this is not a creation of everything either.)

What is more, is that God talks, produces speech. If that is to be understood at face value it has several extremely unpalatable consequences for the God concept. If it is not to be taken at face value, but rather is a metaphor, is seriously needs to be cleared up.

This is where yrreg's belief is derived from. I certainly would like to see him explain where his "everything" evidence came from and present it here, except Yrreg becomes very selective of what posts he responds to. He avoids specificity and is very evasive when it comes to giving a direct answer.
 
Last edited:
I like to read Yrreg's posts, especially the ones that are really insulting.

It makes me laugh, because he seems to have no idea whatsoever that he's talking only about himself. :D
 
I've decided to change my definition of god.

God is no longer jellyroll with tofu and creamcorn.

God is now defined as being Slingblade.
 
Yrreg, what in your definition distinguishes a personal, or intentional deity from any creative force that could be imagined to be responsible for the creation of the universe? I see none. Your definition is entirely devoid of descriptive content, and can be equally applied to any imagined entity, force or process that can be said to have created the universe, from the Biblical Jehovah to the big bang.

No matter how many times, in how many ways, with how many malapropos dribblings you squeeze out of your thesaurus you insult me, or anyone else, if your definition remains as it is, it is a sloppy and careless definition, redundant and too dependent on ideas inferred from outside itself ever to be considered adequate. If it suits your purpose to use it in your arguments, go right ahead - we can all guess from the cultural context what you mean with or without the definition. But even if you don't respect those who honestly answer the questions you ask, your rude and clumsy manner of responding does you no service.
 
Right on! 2 new Official Worshipers, and the bonus is that I actually exist!

Please see Hokulele for her recipe for macadamia nut brownies, which she has established constitute the only Appropriate Sacrificial Offering.

The Only Commandment is "Don't Steal," and it covers pretty much everything, if you think about it.

The Golden Rule is "Think. Then, Think Some More."

The High Sacrament is exactly what it sounds like, and we recommend you bring a designated driver so you can celebrate properly.

You will be invested as a member in a 12-hour ceremony at The Temple of The Voluptuous Sex-Crazed Priestesses, and that, too, is exactly what it sounds like. You lucky devils.

Oh, and the part of said Devil is a random rotation of Shemp, Tricky, MdC, Tragic Monkey, and Piscivore. Hokulele sometimes takes weekends.

There is no Hell. There are occasional field trips to AAH.

Heaven is here and now. Make the most of it.

The Sacred Texts are too numerous to list, but include such authors as Pratchett, Adams, Sagan, and Randi. Look, if it makes you think and/or laugh, I probably approve.

Our Credo:
Don't Worry, Be Happy.

Welcome aboard! :D :p :D
 
Right on! 2 new Official Worshipers, and the bonus is that I actually exist!

Please see Hokulele for her recipe for macadamia nut brownies, which she has established constitute the only Appropriate Sacrificial Offering.

The Only Commandment is "Don't Steal," and it covers pretty much everything, if you think about it.

The Golden Rule is "Think. Then, Think Some More."

The High Sacrament is exactly what it sounds like, and we recommend you bring a designated driver so you can celebrate properly.

You will be invested as a member in a 12-hour ceremony at The Temple of The Voluptuous Sex-Crazed Priestesses, and that, too, is exactly what it sounds like. You lucky devils.

Oh, and the part of said Devil is a random rotation of Shemp, Tricky, MdC, Tragic Monkey, and Piscivore. Hokulele sometimes takes weekends.

There is no Hell. There are occasional field trips to AAH.

Heaven is here and now. Make the most of it.

The Sacred Texts are too numerous to list, but include such authors as Pratchett, Adams, Sagan, and Randi. Look, if it makes you think and/or laugh, I probably approve.

Our Credo:
Don't Worry, Be Happy.

Welcome aboard! :D :p :D

I'll gladly join, although I'm a bit concerned about that Devil. :eye-poppi
 
A long long long time ago, in another thread far far away, there lived a people who were quite Polite: they were called the Polite People. They went about being polite to each other nearly all the time. The other thing they did was try to Find Things Out, and so they lived: asking each other questions and listening Politely to the answers they got: and then thinking about those answers to see if they had Found Anything Out. And when they had Found Something Out they were all pleased and they had a party. They were a happy people and they hardly ever bothered the neighbours.

The neighbours who lived in different threads were not as they were though: they did not believe that being Polite was so important: and they did not believe in Finding Things Out. They had a different way of doing things and they were sure it was a better way.

One day a person from another thread decided to visit the Polite People in their thread. And so he came on a very long journey. He crossed the big desert called I Don't Much Care to Find Things Out, where a lot of people called the Don't Know, Don't Care lived. He forded a big river called Confusion. He walked over the land of the Politeness Has Limits (a people who lived right next door to the Polite People's thread and occasionally strayed into it) and finally he arrived at the Polite People's thread.

The Person from another thread was called Proselytiser. He did not think it was good to be polite. In fact he thought the best way to go about his business was to be very rude indeed. Now Proselytiser had heard all sorts of stories about the Polite people. And because he came from the thread called What I Tell You Three Times Is True, he believed everything he had been told three times. And he had been told a lot of things about the Polite people. He had been told all of these things three times. Once a person from What I Tell You Three Times Is True has been told something three times, he can never, ever change his mind again. This saves a lot of time and trouble and thinking.

One of the things he had been told about the Polite people was that they liked to Find Things Out. And this was true. So Proselytiser wanted to help the Polite people. Proselytiser knew everything. He knew everything he knew was true. And he wanted the Polite people to know everything too. Then they could stop wasting time Finding Things Out and do something else instead. Like go on journeys to other threads, maybe

So Proselytiser told the Polite people the things that he knew. He told them three times. But do you know what happened, children? Why, the Polite People did not believe what Proselytiser told them. Not even though he told them three times. In VERY BIG WORDS.

Proselytiser could not understand this. He thought about it. This was difficult for him because all the things he had been told three times were obviously true. So what was he to think? Well one of the things he had been told three times was that the Polite People were polite. So maybe, he thought, that was why the polite people did not believe him: maybe they could not hear the things he told them three times because he was very very impolite when he told them. He did not see why that should matter so long as he told them three times: but he had to try something

So Proselytiser pretended to be sorry for being so rude. He said he was sorry and he promised to be polite in future. And the Polite People were very pleased to hear this. And they listened to him again, politely.

But they still didn't believe him. And so Proselytiser, who did not find it easy to be polite anyway, realised that wasn't getting him anywhere. And he became rude all over again.

The Polite people weren't Finding Anything Out either, and this made them sad. Some of the people from Politeness Has Limits, who were visiting the Polite People's thread to try to Find Things Out became annoyed. They were on holiday after all: they only had a little while to Find Things Out and they saw that Proselytiser was wasting their precious vacation. And so they stopped being so Polite:usually they thought "when in Rome": which means they thought they should be polite when they were in the Polite People's thread. And so they were polite when they were there. But they thought if Prosylitser was so rude they should be rude back: and so they were

And it was clear that nobody was Finding Anything Out.

I do not know what happened at the end of the story, children. Some say they are all still there trying to Find Things Out: but they have not had a We Found Something Out party for a very long time: and some say Proselytiser went home. But some say that all the Polite People were driven out of their land and they went to stay with the Politeness has Limits and lived happily ever after.
 
Yrreg,

What is wrong with this definition is that it assumes a lot, and informs us of nothing useful. Let me break this down a little more:

It assumes that something made "heaven and earth and everything"; it further assumes that all of those had the same maker. That is, it ignores the possibility that, once Heaven and Earth existed, everything else developed from them; or, perhaps, that Heaven was created by Entity One, but Earth was created by Entity Two, and everything else by Entity Three.
There's also the possibility that Earth was created, but that everthing but Earth did not require intervention.

The other issue is that it tells us nothing about God's nature. It simply describes something(s) he has done. This is equivalent to a DA saying in a press conference, "We know who the killer is!" and then adding, "It's the person who murdered Mr. Jensen, Mrs. Jensen, and stole Mrs. Jensen's jewelry." An attorney who made that statement would be laughed at, and rightly so; it's a useless statement.

To identify the suspect, there would have to be some characteristics or attributes, such as: "A tall, dark-haired male, with a heavy build; quite strong; not a native English speaker; intelligent, patient, and not likely to draw attention to himself--pretty average looking." These are things that the police likely derived from information about what was done, and how it was done, but from that evidence they have concluded how the perpetrator is.

Further, they have described it in terms that make sense. Based, perhaps, on witness testimony, they have come up with a tall, dark, strong male with an accent and/or grammar errors in spoken English. Anyone who is short, female, blonde and erudite can be eliminated from the discussion.

By contrast, your description of your Supreme Being lacks even the specification that it is a being! It doesn't say if God is conscious, aware or self-aware; it doesn't say if God is living or dead--hey, creating Everything is a big job, may it gave Him heart attack--or if She has any physicality. It doesn't say if She's interested in what She created, or if it was the divine equivalent of excrement.

It's a big bag of words that can't be used to define anything, or eliminate anything from the discussion.

That's "what's wrong with" the definition you used. It doesn't serve any useful purpose for discussion God's nature, attributes, or likely existance/ non-existance.

Resepectfully, Miss Kitt

Well said, Miss Kitt. Too bad it won't be read by the OP. Or at least, comprehended by same.
 
Ah've jist channelled ma great great great great Uncle Rabbie.

Yrreg, tersivigating in word and deed
Wit delusions are in yer hied?
is trolling how ye pass yer time?
wi' lang words and mystic sign
gi'e us yer arguements,in warp and woof
cease this postin' or gi'e us some proof
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom