What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

The hippopotomonstrosesquipedalian posts of gerry annoys me.
 
What's exactly, specifically wrong with my definition of God?
as maker of heaven and earth and everything.​





Yrreg

If god made everything he must have made himself.

"Q. 163. What is God?

A. God is a spirit infinitely perfect.


Q. 206. What is the difference between making and creating?

A. Making" means bringing forth or forming out of some material already existing, as workmen do. "Creating" means bringing forth out of nothing, as God alone can do."(Baltimore catechism)
 
I like to define God as "The Sum of All Things". What's wrong with this definition?
If the sum is merely a count, it's meaningless without specifying what qualifies as a 'thing'

The sum of all electrons, protons and neutrons?
The sum of all atoms?
The sum of all molecules?
 
A tergiversator named Gerry
Who's grammatic usage was hairy
Offered a proof of God
Quite logically flawed
Was evidence lacking? Yes, very


Next contestant must write a Haiku. If Dr. A or Mercutio join this thread perhaps one will treat us to a sonnet.

I think it odd
Of god
To have a bod
That is of sod
 
First, we have to agree on what is a definition of a word good for.

Thanks for your reactions, in particular I find the following posts: 11, 20, 23, 39, 42, 53, 57 to be conducive to the learning of people who read this thread in the hope of getting something useful into their brain:


The title of the thread is:

What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?​


First, we have to agree on what is a definition of a word good for.

It is good or useful for people to know what actual or at least possible entity outside your brain or even inside your brain the word you use refers to.


Does my definition of God serve that purpose for people to know what entity outside their brain and/or inside their brain the word God refers to?

Does it tell people what atheists and what theists are talking about with the word God?

If they know what is a maker, what is heaven, what is earth, and what is everything, then they should find nothing wrong with the word God defined as the maker of heaven and hearth and everything.


If you find something wrong with that definition of God, then it is because for you: you can't know what people are talking about with the word God, whereas they know what they are talking about, even kids in nursery school have no trouble with the word God and its meaning.

The cause could be some kind of peculiar brain configuration on your part, not found in people who do know what is being talked about with the word God.

Or perhaps you have some kind of dread with the word itself of God, what is that dread all about?





Yrreg
 
Oops, I see there's an entirely new thread on this question. As I'd posted in the original thread, I'll repost my objections over here (even though I see the question has been covered by others).

Your definition of God would cover anything from The Laws of Physics, to Zeus, to the IPU or FSM, the Christian, Muslim, Jewish, Hindu Gods or anything else you could think of. It tells us nothing about your God, just what you claim he has done.
 
yyreg- Human language is an evolved extension of human minds.
It deals adequately with concepts understandable by such minds and for which a vocabulary of description, analogy and metaphor exists. It tends to become unreliable in dealing with concepts outwith our daily experience, such as quantum or relativistic effects, which are , nonetheless, aspects of our universe.

The creator of the universe you postulate must exist outwith that universe.

Define the specific and precise meanings, if you can, of the words in red, as used in that sentence.
I respectfully suggest to you that this is what people mean by "too vague". Your description conveys no useful information. It is hard to see how any desription of such a creature or process actually could.
 
Last edited:
Okay, how about this definition of God:

'Being you can't see who is supposedly responsible for everything that happens.'

Everyone would recognise that, right?
 
I believe in 42. It's a fact. 42 is the answer to life, the universe and everything.

So if Yrreg can make his statement and say it's a fact. I know that in fact, god isn't a fact. 42 is.

:)
 
The creator of the universe you postulate must exist outwith that universe.

Define the specific and precise meanings, if you can, of the words in red, as used in that sentence.

I think that's a little unfair. Yrreg is having enough trouble with English, now you're asking him to deal with Scottish too. (Have we stopped the poetry, or should we have next one in the style of Rabbie Burns?)
 
First, we have to agree on what is a definition of a word good for.
If we discuss anything (From economics to star trek trivia) this is true.

It is good or useful for people to know what actual or at least possible entity outside your brain or even inside your brain the word you use refers to.
For conversation purposes, yes.


Does my definition of God serve that purpose for people to know what entity outside their brain and/or inside their brain the word God refers to?
certainly.

Does it tell people what atheists and what theists are talking about with the word God?
In this conversation, yes. But note, it isn't the sole definition for god.

If they know what is a maker, what is heaven, what is earth, and what is everything, then they should find nothing wrong with the word God defined as the maker of heaven and hearth and everything.
certainly.


If you find something wrong with that definition of God, then it is because for you: you can't know what people are talking about with the word God, whereas they know what they are talking about, even kids in nursery school have no trouble with the word God and its meaning.
This is false. Finding something wrong with that definition simply means that that person has a different Idea for god. There is nothing in your definition that makes it more accurate than other definitions. Simply put, your definition is popular with christians and diests but probably less popular than with pagans.

The cause could be some kind of peculiar brain configuration on your part, not found in people who do know what is being talked about with the word God.
Nope.

Or perhaps you have some kind of dread with the word itself of God, what is that dread all about?
nope.


ETA:
Yrreg, you do realize that in your last two sentences, you basically said, "IF you don't agree with me, you're either afraid of god or mentally ill."
 
Last edited:
Does it tell people what atheists and what theists are talking about with the word God?


No. You've failed. Again. But at least you're consistent.

ETA...

Yrreg, you do realize that in your last two sentences, you basically said, "IF you don't agree with me, you're either afraid of god or mentally ill."


And an interesting accusation his is, because yrreg has provided much evidence that he is afraid of non-belief and/or non-believers, and that he is mentally ill. Perhaps we're seeing a little projection going on there? :)
 
Last edited:
Godspread.jpg


I created a range value of Universe and then did the formula to see if god equalled that range. I'm sorry but Excel says no. :)
 
I think that's a little unfair. Yrreg is having enough trouble with English, now you're asking him to deal with Scottish too. (Have we stopped the poetry, or should we have next one in the style of Rabbie Burns?)

I suspect the style of William Topaz McGonagall would be more fitting/apt/suitable/appropriate/etc (yes, I have access to a thesaurus too!) :rolleyes:
 
I see nothing wrong with yreggs definition. I just wish we could move on to the evidence of existence part of the course...
I'm all ears here.
The prevaricating is intense. ( Is prevaricating still the latest word of the moment? Im keeping notes)


What he/she said.

I have no problem with the definition either, sure it's a little flowery and redundant, Rather Koranish IMO.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom