What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Actually, if we were really to argue the definition on a logical level, then you are stating that God created three things:
Heaven
Earth
Everything
​
The way this is stated, "Heaven" and "Earth" are not included in "Everything"; they are somehow separate. But if "Everything" doesn't include "Heaven" and "Earth", then its not "Everything", is it?

You may argue that, obviously, that is not what you intended; and that it should be adjusted to say, "maker of Heaven and Earth and everything else"

But then, we have the problem of God himself. Would not god be included in "Everything"? If "Everything" doesn't include god, then again its not "Everything". So if God really created "Everything", then God created Himself. But that obviously just doesn't make sense.

So, from both logical and linguistic viewpoints, your definition just doesn't make sense.

:D

Well...you asked!

Maybe Gerry is as witty as Douglas Adams? No, you're right. Probably not.
 
What's exactly, specifically wrong with my definition of God?
as maker of heaven and earth and everything.

Yrreg
​
In truth, I see nothing inherently wrong with that definition. In fact, it's practically the exact definition given in the Nicene creed.

So, I say, go ahead and use that definition.

Now, all you need to do next is prove that there is indeed a maker of heaven and earth and everything.

You'll also need to prove there's a heaven, but I'll be happy if you can prove that the earth has a maker.
 
Last edited:
Now you must choose the new form of Gozer the Traveler. And no Torgs, that's been done to death.
Twiler said:
Okay. Someone try expressing these threads in the form of a flow-chart.

Sorry, a sonnet has already been requested.

What can one do with an ideal idea
Which can only be said in very few words
Or tergiversation grows like chia
That evil atheists farm on the boards
And refuse to follow wordcount restraints
Leading to prevarication and hate
It truly would try the patience of saints
While I am left here to dangle my bait
Posting my questions until satisfied
That my definitions are well taken in
While all have agreed that atheists lied
As false evolution left them in sin
But I the believer never once strayed
From my true god the impossibly vague

Please forgive the meter.

Now we can do flowcharts
 
Last edited:
What's exactly, specifically wrong with my definition of God?
as maker of heaven and earth and everything.​

It doesn't define your god, you're just summing up things you claim your god did.
 
It is not a definition, yrreg. It explains nothing about the god you claim it defines.

I've pointed this out to you before. Here, for example.


Suffice to say that "maker of heaven and earth and everything" defines nothing.


It does not tell us if god is powerful, loving, good, evil, female, past, of if any of those terms even apply.

That is what is wrong with your "definition". It does not define anything.


Feel free to use it if you want, but don't go flinging accusations of "Tergiversator!" and "Non-Thinker!" when somebody tells you it fits the concept of the Flying Spaghetti Monster, or the Invisible Pink Unicorn, or the Great Green Arkleseizure.

You failed to provide information on your god that would rule such things out. Thus, with your "definition", you cannot claim those ideas are not your god.
 
Okay. Someone try expressing these threads in the form of a flow-chart.

"Maker of heaven and earth and everything."

Okay..

Flow chart:

God --> makes heaven

God --> makes Earth

God --> makes everything

Everything =/= Heaven

Everything =/= Earth

God =/= Heaven

God =/= Earth

Therefore:

God c Everything (Sorry, that's the best I can do to get the "is a subset of" symbol)

Therefore:

God created God.

....what do I win?



oohh I hope it's Natalie Portman..... alive, please....no dressing... :)
 
Last edited:
Okay..

Flow chart:

God --> makes heaven

God --> makes Earth

God --> makes everything

Everything =/= Heaven

Everything =/= Earth

God =/= Heaven

God =/= Earth

Therefore:

God c Everything (Sorry, that's the best I can do to get the "is a subset of" symbol)

Therefore:

God created God.

....did I get it?

:clap: Not bad!

You just need to pick the new form.
 
What's exactly, specifically wrong with my definition of God?
as maker of heaven and earth and everything.​

I made my own breakfast today. Since I made it and not god, either god isn't god because he didn't make everything, or I am god because I made something that must be included by the term 'everything' even though it isn't everything itself.

Either way, your definition fails.
 
What's exactly, specifically wrong with my definition of God?

as maker of heaven and earth and everything.

If God made everything, then God made the table I'm sitting in front of. However, I made the table I'm sitting in front of. Therefore, it follows from your definition that I am God.

However, I am not God. You know this, because if I was God, I would be infallible, and therefore you can trust me absolutely on this matter.
 
It's a good definition of the deist god. Most of the gods of existent religions have more attributes in addition to the ones you've listed: they intervene in human affairs, they have opinions about human behavior, and they seem to have emotions or something like them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom