What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Just the same, I will ask you [again]: What is the default situation of being, existence or non-existence?
'being' and 'existence' are synonymous, so (surprise, surprise) your question is nonsensical.
You are asking:
' what is the default situation of being: being or non-being?'
or
'what is the default situation of existence: existence or non-existence?'
(I have no idea what 'situation' means in this context, but that's the least of your worries.)
 
Yrreg, here's some bedtime reading, which I invite you to consider with the utmost diligence. This will require some serious thinking, thinking being what sets Homo sapiens apart from our non-Homo sapiens brethren, and all that:

JHendrix said:
Thanks for the willingness to look at this monster. I'd appreciate any feedback, rip it to shreds if I've made a mistake in here! I would ask that this not be reposted elsewhere without my permission.

Mild updates were made since the posting, the changes are in RED.

Science and the Kalam - By JHendrix of http://www.rationalskepticism.org (still leary of putting my real name online atm)

The Kalam cosmological argument is a philosophical argument for the existence of god, with the twist that it is usually presented as having substantial scientific evidence supporting its conclusion. This is problematic because it perverts the science in misleading ways to justify a conclusion that the evidence in no way supports.

The purpose of this paper is to show that the two pieces of scientific evidence usually cited in support of the Kalam absolutely do not support its premises in the way the argument requires. It will then be shown that the Kalam has substantial problems with modern science, and requires its defenders to take unscientific, non falsifiable positions on fundamental aspects of physics in order to maintain the argument.

Since this paper will cover a large amount of complex topics of science and philosophy, I have tried to include references to various topics so that the reader will better be able to educate themselves on any given topic. I highly recommend any confused readers look into each of these topics to confirm for themselves the validity of what I am saying.

[SNIP]


Due credit should be given to JHendrix, who originally posted this paper here: http://www.rationalskepticism.org/g...smological-argument-t21224-1360.html#p1425614.

Thank you for giving this your undivided attention, Yrreg! :)

Edited by kmortis: 
Snipped to comply with Rule 4
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Okay, to be brief, think and answer: Has there always (always here is both a logical always and a chronological always) been something instead of nothing.


Yes, but remember that "always" started at the Big Bang. There was no "before".
 
Evidence is anything which makes a proposition more or less true. We already did this months ago.

Hey, did you read that from somewhere, I want your own thinking from your experience if you have any, when you search for evidence in your own lifetime so far -- or you never did any search for evidence at all?
I read it earlier in the thread; it was the pared-down definition that everybody (except you) agreed was the most succinct explanation, and the one least likely to lead to misunderstanding. It is a much better definition than yours, which is needlessly verbose and unwieldy, and which contains an assumption that evidence necessarily has a direction.

But we will talk about that when you are through with our present issue, the default status of being, existence or non-existence, and explain.
I don't think I can state it any clearer than I have done; being and existence are synonyms in the way you are using them. Thus, the default status of being is existence purely by definition. There isn't anything to explain: being is equivalent to existence.

However, very few objects have one single default status. In the simplest terms, during a person's lifetime, their default status is to be alive, after their lifetime their default status is dead. Their body will exist a while longer (how long depends on the way it is treated after death).

But that is a very simplistic way of looking at things, as a living person's default status in a broad sense could be many different states depending on their activities, the time of day, their upbringing, their stage of life, and so on.

I don't think the term 'default status' is really helping you explain what you mean. Perhaps you could move on from the long-agreed "being is equivalent to existence" and move to the next step, so that we can work out what you are attempting to show.
 
You are not connecting with me, ask yourself has there always been something?

[...]

Quote:
So, what is the default status of being: existence or non-existence, and explain.
​
Again? OK, as being and existence (sorry it's tiresome putting in UBB code on my phone, or would have italicised those) are synonymous, so if something is in a state of being it is by definition in a state of existence. What is there to explain? It's just two words which mean the same.

[...]



You are not connecting with me, ask yourself has there always been something?

Tell me whether you can understand these words from me:
  • In the status in logical anteriority of the universe and in the logical exteriority of that universe the same that is studied by atheist scientists has there always been something instead of nothing?


If you cannot understand some words or some phrases above let me know.



You see, Agatha, you do not see things in the big big big big big picture of existence or non-existence.

And it is because for you (and you don't realize it) existence is self-pre-delimited already in your heart and mind to exclusively matter in time and space.



Yrreg
 
Existence has been encrusted by atheists with a lot of distractions, but press the reset button and it will come up clearly that there is always something.

Now, I ask you, is it to your thinking that there is always something and that is the default status, or are you subscribing to the desperate tack of atheists today who now go into the default status of existence as nothing?

Because they are now into telling mankind that there was nothing then something came forth and that is the universe.


...
Yrreg
And yet again Yrreg you lie and misrepresent the position of science which is not atheism.

The universe did no come from 'nothing', it came from 'we don't know', I say you lie because this has been explained to you many many times and you have in other threads responded to this fact, that science does not say the universe came from nothing.

So once again you drag out the same theology encrusted strawman and yet again send the same encrusted strawman around the same old course.

Knowing that you are telling a falsehood, isn't that a sin?

Edited by Gaspode: 
Edited for moderated thread.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You are not connecting with me, ask yourself has there always been something?

Tell me whether you can understand these words from me:
[/list]In the status in logical anteriority of the universe and in the logical exteriority of that universe the same that is studied by atheist scientists has there always been something instead of nothing?[/list]


If you cannot understand some words or some phrases above let me know.
I understand but as I attempted to explain to you by PM, neither anteriority nor exteriority are words, and the concepts are much better expressed by 'before' and 'outside'.

Further, your question is meaningless; firstly there is no 'before' the universe, as time started at the moment the universe came into being. Since it is not possible for there to be a time which was before time, there was never a 'before' the universe.

Secondly, as the definition of the word 'universe' is 'everything that exists', it is equally not possible for there to be anything which exists outside the universe. If something exists, it is by definition within the universe.

You see, Agatha, you do not see things in the big big big big big picture of existence or non-existence.
I'm surprised this got approved for a moderated thread, it seems to be clearly addressing the arguer rather than the argument. However, I refute your allegation and would suggest that I am more than capable of seeing the big picture, and further, to understand the essential difference between existence and non-existence.

And it is because for you (and you don't realize it) existence is self-pre-delimited already in your heart and mind to exclusively matter in time and space.
More addressing the arguer? However, yes, as a rational person and sceptic, I do not believe that anything which is not "matter in time and space" exists outside the realm of imagination.

If it is your contention that something exists outside time and space, then you will need to provide evidence that this is possible as well as evidence for the existence of whatever it is. Belief and faith, however strong they might be, are not evidence.

Edited by Gaspode: 
Edited for moderated thread.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Better you put up a Russell's calling card, to save people's time and trouble.

I am going to talk with Agatha, so sorry guys if I don't reply to your posts, and I hope this is no violation of the rules.




Dear Agatha, I am saying that atheists have pre-self-delimited their heart and mind as to see nothing in the universe except matter in time and in space, or in short what they think that scientists advocate, or folks they claim for themselves to be into science.

Tell me frankly, you don't subscribe to anything outside the universe of guys like Krauss, Hawking, Stenger and their fellow club-members?

And then these guys also go into semantics so that nothing is in effect something, even though they keep insisting that they are talking about nothing, and also they tend to multiply things so that universe is not already everything that exists, but there are other universes, an infinitude of universes which they call multiverse.

If you are like them, I can't see how we can ever get connected.


Better you take up the card of B. Russell:

See or google:
  • The Copleston / Russell Debate on the Existence of God (1948) A transcript of the famous BBC radio broadcast.


[...]


R: Well, the word "gratuitous" suggests that it might be something else; I should say that the universe is just there, and that's all.

C: Well, I can't see how you can rule out the legitimacy of asking the question how the total, or anything at all comes to be there. Why something rather than nothing, that is the question? The fact that we gain our knowledge of causality empirically, from particular causes, does not rule out the possibility of asking what the cause of the series is. If the word "cause" were meaningless or if it could be shown that Kant's view of the matter were correct, the question would be illegitimate I agree; but you don't seem to hold that the word "cause" is meaningless, and I do not suppose you are a Kantian.


[…]


R: I don't think he'd [the scientist] say so. If there's a world in which most events, but not all, have causes, he will then be able to depict the probabilities and uncertainties by assuming that this particular event you're interested in probably has a cause. And since in any case you won't get more than probability that's good enough.

C: It may be that the scientist doesn't hope to obtain more than probability, but in raising the question he assumes that the question of explanation has a meaning.

But your general point then, Lord Russell, is that it's illegitimate even to ask the question of the cause of the world?

R: Yes, that's my position.

C: Well, if it's a question that for you has no meaning, it's of course very difficult to discuss it, isn't it?

R: Yes, it is very difficult. What do you say -- shall we pass on to some other issue?


[ They passed on to Religious Experience. ]


[...]


Edited by Gaspode: 
Edited for moderated thread.





Yrreg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I am going to talk with Agatha, so sorry guys if I don't reply to your posts, and I hope this is no violation of the rules.

Dear Agatha, I am saying that atheists have pre-self-delimited their heart and mind as to see nothing in the universe except matter in time and in space, or in short what they think that scientists advocate, or folks they claim for themselves to be into science.

<snip derail into multiverse theories>

Edited by Gaspode: 
Edited for moderated thread.
The definition of "the universe" is everything that exists. By definition, them nothing can be 'outside' it. If it is your contention that anything exists outside the universe, despite the glaring contradiction in terms, then you need to show evidence.

No matter how many times you accuse sceptics of "delimiting their...mind", it remains the case that you have yet to show evidence of anything existing other than what is in the universe. Without evidence, all you have is faith and belief. Critical thinkers and sceptics will never find mere faith persuasive, the only thing which would persuade an atheist to change his or her position on the existence of gods is evidence.

The burden is on you to provide such evidence. For the avoidance of doubt, evidence in this context means something which is repeatable and testable.

It is past midnight here as I write this, so I will not be replying further tonight.
 
Tell me whether you can understand these words from me:
  • In the status in logical anteriority of the universe and in the logical exteriority of that universe the same that is studied by atheist scientists has there always been something instead of nothing?

We know the individual meanings of the words you've typed. However their composition makes them rather challenging to parse. The latter part of the sentence seems to distill your question into something accessible, so let's concentrate on that.

...has there always been something instead of nothing?
As far as we know, yes. You see, there is no time before space and time. You still seem to be imagining time as something that goes on and on forever into the past, that we could time travel back to the moment of the Big Bang and then continue on into the past to see what came before it, and that this means that there has to be a discreet moment in time that marks a transition from nothing to something. But this is not the case.

So in a sense, the answer to your question is, "Yes, the universe has always existed". But don't mistake this to mean that space/time is eternal. The universe seems very likely to be unbounded, yet finite.

Do you understand?
 
What's exactly, specifically wrong with my definition of God?
as maker of heaven and earth and everything.​





Yrreg

Zero point singularity
that is non-spacial and of infinite mass
that is consciously aware of itself and has purpose and intent

THAT THAN WHICH NOTHING GREATER CAN BE CONCIEVED OF

THE ULTIMATE ABSOLUTNESS

a coherent and unified body body of power intrinsic to which is the potential for all possibilities to occur. This body of power consists of three aspects; the known, the unknown and the unknowable.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom