What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

As an additional comment to my earlier post ...

Yrreg, there is nothing wrong as such with your defintion of God, as long as you realize that there are people with different conceptions (like me) who will simply not see your definition as sufficient. In a similar vein there is nothing wrong as such with Deism; it is only that I, as an atheist, will not necessarily feel contradicted by it.
 
Can I volunteer for part-time devil in the Church of Slingblade? Say... on every other Saturday?
 
"Does it tell people what atheists and what theists are talking about with the word God?"

Now you see, Yrreg, here is your problem. Atheists and theists aren't talking about the same thing when they use the word "god".

Some theists may be satisfied with a definition such as "the maker of everything and the reason why my son was born with a cleft palate".

But atheists define god as "the name superstitious people use for whatever they can't understand."
 
Last edited:
More about this

And also don't nitpick on redundancy, what to you is redundant is to others, greater connoisseurs of definitions, more explicit.
Yrreg

As I'm a bit of a connoisseur of definitions myself, perhaps we could pop upstairs later, and you might view my collections in a more salubrious and studious atmosphere?

Potential mutual definitional studies might be certainly more explicit, but are nonetheless guaranteed guilt-free.
 
How about a (not very good) TrioletWP?

Yrreg has tried to define God,
but it turned out rather wooly
and his language went a bit odd.
Yrreg has tried to define God;
but, challenged. he acts like a clod,
becoming a frothing bully.
Yrreg has tried to define God
but it turned out rather wooly.

Anyone fancy trying a VillanelleWP?
 
Please, let us keep to definition at this point in time, not bringing in existence.

Read this post again, giving utmost attention and concentration and thus compliance to the lines in bold.


Title of Post: First, we have to agree on what is a definition of a word good for.


Thanks for your reactions, in particular I find the following posts: 11, 20, 23, 39, 42, 53, 57 to be conducive to the learning of people who read this thread in the hope of getting something useful into their brain:


The title of the thread is:

What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?​


First, we have to agree on what is a definition of a word good for.

It is good or useful for people to know what actual or at least possible entity outside your brain or even inside your brain the word you use refers to.


Does my definition of God serve that purpose for people to know what entity outside their brain and/or inside their brain the word God refers to?

Does it tell people what atheists and what theists are talking about with the word God?

If they know what is a maker, what is heaven, what is earth, and what is everything, then they should find nothing wrong with the word God defined as the maker of heaven and hearth and everything.


If you find something wrong with that definition of God, then it is because for you: you can't know what people are talking about with the word God, whereas they know what they are talking about, even kids in nursery school have no trouble with the word God and its meaning.

The cause could be some kind of peculiar brain configuration on your part, not found in people who do know what is being talked about with the word God.

Or perhaps you have some kind of dread with the word itself of God, what is that dread all about?





Yrreg


So, judge the definition whether at least it gives the possible object in your brain or brains of people except in yours of the concept of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything.






Yrreg
 
Sorry to butt in so late, but as Russell proved a century ago, "everything" does not exist. because it would have to contain "everything" within it, so it would be a member of itself ad infinitum. Therefore, since "everything" does not exist, the creator of "everything" does not exist either. QED.
 
Read this post again, giving utmost attention and concentration and thus compliance to the lines in bold.

[LOAD_OF_BS][...][/LOAD_OF_BS]

So, judge the definition whether at least it gives the possible object in your brain or brains of people except in yours of the concept of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything.


No.
 
So, judge the definition whether at least it gives the possible object in your brain or brains of people except in yours of the concept of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything.

I have no clue whether it gives me or other people that "possible object". Really, how should I?
 
Last edited:
Read this post again, giving utmost attention and concentration and thus compliance to the lines in bold.
Yrreg, you really ought to break that spamming habit of yours.
So, judge the definition whether at least it gives the possible object in your brain or brains of people except in yours of the concept of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything.
That is a convoluted and confusing sentence. I challenge you to parse it into clear English, but since one can more or less guess what is meant, I will answer it anyway:

In a word,NO.

It conveys no concept of God beyond an action imputed to something with no other named attributes. The definition you provide is applicable to all gods and all creative processes, real or imaginary, without either distinguishing or excluding any.

We know what sort of God you refer to only because we guess from your other writings, and from the cultural context of Christianity, what sort of God you likely mean. If we did not, your definition would be like meeting an explorer from another planet, providing the definition "a guy who kicks a ball" and expecting him to know you're speaking of David Beckham.

It's a poor definition, Yrreg. If you don't like the answer, don't ask the question.
 
Sorry to butt in so late, but as Russell proved a century ago, "everything" does not exist. because it would have to contain "everything" within it, so it would be a member of itself ad infinitum. Therefore, since "everything" does not exist, the creator of "everything" does not exist either. QED.
I must confess I have not read enough Russell to have found this, but wonder about the statement. Is this an ontological paradox, or are we dealing with Russell's and others' thoughts on sets? Granted that a set of specific objects cannot be a member of itself, if it is not the object in the set, and the set of all sets not members of themselves provides an amusing paradox, but not all sets are so compromised. The set of all sets does include itself. What prevents the set of everything from being a member of itself?
 
I must confess I have not read enough Russell to have found this, but wonder about the statement. Is this an ontological paradox, or are we dealing with Russell's and others' thoughts on sets? Granted that a set of specific objects cannot be a member of itself, if it is not the object in the set, and the set of all sets not members of themselves provides an amusing paradox, but not all sets are so compromised. The set of all sets does include itself. What prevents the set of everything from being a member of itself?

Oh, it was just a joke. But anyway, the set of everything seems to me an ill-defined idea. What would its cardinality be, for instance?
 
I must confess I have not read enough Russell to have found this, but wonder about the statement. Is this an ontological paradox, or are we dealing with Russell's and others' thoughts on sets? Granted that a set of specific objects cannot be a member of itself, if it is not the object in the set, and the set of all sets not members of themselves provides an amusing paradox, but not all sets are so compromised. The set of all sets does include itself. What prevents the set of everything from being a member of itself?

cf the ending of The Farnsworth ParaboxWP - in which the universe contains the box that contains the universe...
 
Just wanted to say that I'm up for joining the Church of Slingblade ... and Fiona - you are so nominated ;)
 
It is good or useful for people to know what actual or at least possible entity outside your brain or even inside your brain the word you use refers to.
Surely I'm the best judge of what the word I use refers to? I am, after all, the one using the word. Presumably I chose that particular word for a reason, hmm?
 
cf the ending of The Farnsworth ParaboxWP - in which the universe contains the box that contains the universe...
I suppose, but does that really say anything more than that the box is not a possible construct in a universe that is defined to exclude nothing? I don't see why we need to abandon the idea of "everything" if we simply acknowledge that the a box which "contains" everything is a paradox and thus impossible. If we found the box, we'd be in trouble, of course, but have we?
 
So does that mean we have arrived at:

"If god made everything then he made himself" which, as the Scholastics would have said, is absurd?
 
So, judge the definition whether at least it gives the possible object in your brain or brains of people except in yours of the concept of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything.

At the risk of my coming off crass
I must now head you off at the pass
The ontology's bunk
So your argument's sunk
Then again, it was pulled from your-- butt



(I'd have spent more than 10 seconds on this, but I still have to finish a much longer piece for an assignment this weekend.)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom