Merged What's happening in the Middle East?

Hey; I'm not giving up my Hummer for anybody, especially for a bunch o' Muslim fanatics. In fact, I'm thinkin' of buying two more Hummers just to give Al Gore a heart attack. :)
JW

alternatively you could give up your hummer to reduce your C0² production :rolleyes:
or convert it to a E-Hummer
 
Take it up with MG1962, he's the one claiming the MB don't have any power and hardly anyone supports them.

They have power and support, all right.

But they don't have enough of either to make an Egypt dominated by the Brotherhood an inevitability. They probably don't have enough to make it a strong possibility.

They do have enough to make it a distinct possibility, should things fall a certain way (and should the army throw in with them, rather than any of the other opposition movements).

But while Egypt is in a very precarious position right now, it's not Iran in 1979. Two of the biggest things working against the establishment of an Iran-style Islamist state are the fact that there's no Khomeini figure to take control of and direct the flow of the revolution, and the fact that Egypt has (and has had for a while) a complete structure in place to allow for a post-Mubarak government - an elected presidency (however fraudulent the elections, the precedent of everyone voting on the leader was still there), a vice presidency, a cabinet and elected parliament. Iran under the hereditary Shah had nothing like that. The revolution in Egypt has a lot more in common with the revolts that led to the fall of communist governments in Eastern Europe than it does with the fall of the Shah.

In short, while the Brotherhood will undoubtedly do their best to take advantage of the situation, things aren't going to be easy for them. Things aren't going to be easy for a prospective full democratic government, either, though. Depending on what the army does, I'd guess that Egypt's new government will probably end up being a similar form of dictatorship, only under some other general, who will manage to take control and consolidate power while everyone is focused on the Mubarak-hate, and then run things as usual. At least, until the people get pissed at him too, and they do this all over again.
 
Last edited:
Depending on what the army does, I'd guess that Egypt's new government will probably end up being a similar form of dictatorship, only under some other general, who will manage to take control and consolidate power while everyone is focused on the Mubarak-hate, and then run things as usual. At least, until the people get pissed at him too, and they do this all over again.

Won't they ever tire of doing this all over again? Do they prefer doing it this way?

Looks like lion sex to me. Momentary, unfriendly, and unsatifying.
 
Take it up with MG1962, he's the one claiming the MB don't have any power and hardly anyone supports them.

Sigh if you are going to quote me...try and get it right. I habe made no comment about their level of support or power

I have however made coment that they are not a militant organisation - a statement you are yet to refute beyond a single individual
 
I have however made coment that they are not a militant organisation - a statement you are yet to refute beyond a single individual
Is this why you dismiss them? They understand the reins of power are easier to gain control ofthrough the political system, not through militancy and terrorism. That said, they would certainly not give up power once gained, and would impose a conservative Muslim theocracy. Strict Sharia law, the works. And an Egypt ruled by the MB has great consequence for the region. I expect Israel, for example, would have no choice but to occupy the border area between Gaza and Egypt to prevent arms smuggling to Hamas.

The problem with groups like the MB is you can vote them in, but once in you can't vote them out. You can't have a democratic theocracy.
 
They have power and support, all right.

But they don't have enough of either to make an Egypt dominated by the Brotherhood an inevitability. They probably don't have enough to make it a strong possibility.

They do have enough to make it a distinct possibility, should things fall a certain way (and should the army throw in with them, rather than any of the other opposition movements).

But while Egypt is in a very precarious position right now, it's not Iran in 1979. Two of the biggest things working against the establishment of an Iran-style Islamist state are the fact that there's no Khomeini figure to take control of and direct the flow of the revolution, and the fact that Egypt has (and has had for a while) a complete structure in place to allow for a post-Mubarak government - an elected presidency (however fraudulent the elections, the precedent of everyone voting on the leader was still there), a vice presidency, a cabinet and elected parliament. Iran under the hereditary Shah had nothing like that. The revolution in Egypt has a lot more in common with the revolts that led to the fall of communist governments in Eastern Europe than it does with the fall of the Shah.

In short, while the Brotherhood will undoubtedly do their best to take advantage of the situation, things aren't going to be easy for them. Things aren't going to be easy for a prospective full democratic government, either, though. Depending on what the army does, I'd guess that Egypt's new government will probably end up being a similar form of dictatorship, only under some other general, who will manage to take control and consolidate power while everyone is focused on the Mubarak-hate, and then run things as usual. At least, until the people get pissed at him too, and they do this all over again.

Did you see my post where I quoted a poll showing overwhelming support for Sharia and Islamists, and Hamas? That alone makes the situation completely different to the fall of Communism in Eastern Europe.
 
But while Egypt is in a very precarious position right now, it's not Iran in 1979. Two of the biggest things working against the establishment of an Iran-style Islamist state are the fact that there's no Khomeini figure to take control of and direct the flow of the revolution, and the fact that Egypt has (and has had for a while) a complete structure in place to allow for a post-Mubarak government - an elected presidency (however fraudulent the elections, the precedent of everyone voting on the leader was still there), a vice presidency, a cabinet and elected parliament. Iran under the hereditary Shah had nothing like that. The revolution in Egypt has a lot more in common with the revolts that led to the fall of communist governments in Eastern Europe than it does with the fall of the Shah.
Good point about the elections. But how much street cred do the other (secular) opposition parties have? Let's suppose for a minute that power now is handed to a democratically-minded set of people that intends to organize truly free elections. What would then be the outcome?

Let's make the comparison with Iran again. There, it was not only Khomeini's personal authority that made the difference, but also that there still was a well-organized religious opposition, which operated under the protection of the mosques. The Shah had successfully cracked down on the secular opposition and broken their organization, but he couldn't do that with the religious opposition - it's so messy to have police invade mosques and do searches and arrests and so on. So they had the infrastructure in place to take over power, while the secular opposition didn't have the same means to challenge Khomeini.

I have the impression that the same phenomenon has taken place in Egypt. The secular opposition parties that exist, exist by the grace of Mubarak, and their leaders are routinely jailed for some charge or another. The Muslim Brotherhood, on the other hand, has over the years built up and maintained an organization which gives them a head start in any competition for the hearts and minds of the people. And they're certainly not seen as collaborators with the regime.

It makes you wonder, doesn't anyone secular there study Lenin nowadays? Mind, I'm not holding up Lenin as a paragon of democratic thought - he definitely wasn't - but he knew how to maintain a party structure in face of an autocratic regime that cracked down on all opposition - and when that regime fell down, the small size of his party was more than offset by the high level of organization.
 
I have the impression that the same phenomenon has taken place in Egypt. The secular opposition parties that exist, exist by the grace of Mubarak, and their leaders are routinely jailed for some charge or another. The Muslim Brotherhood, on the other hand, has over the years built up and maintained an organization which gives them a head start in any competition for the hearts and minds of the people. And they're certainly not seen as collaborators with the regime.

Your impression isn't correct. The Muslim Brotherhood is outlawed and plenty were jailed and hung by Nasser and plenty were imprisoned by Mubarak. Mubarak also beat an Islamist insurgency into submission during the 80's and 90's. He has no qualms about busting the God-boys chops and any Imam that preaches revolution.

It makes you wonder, doesn't anyone secular there study Lenin nowadays? Mind, I'm not holding up Lenin as a paragon of democratic thought - he definitely wasn't - but he knew how to maintain a party structure in face of an autocratic regime that cracked down on all opposition - and when that regime fell down, the small size of his party was more than offset by the high level of organization.

Well if they're liberal democrats they probably don't study totalitarians like Lenin. Sayeed Qutb was formerly a socialist and the Muslim Brotherhood have been known to take a leaf out of Lenin's book. The bit about revolutionary vanguards appealed to them.
 
Last edited:
BBC:

But there were signs of disagreement within the opposition, with the largest group, the Muslim Brotherhood, appearing to go back on its endorsement of leading figure Mohamed ElBaradei as a negotiator with Mr Mubarak.

Link
 
Fom BBC radio:

Mubarak has chosen an interesting tactic by pulling back the (much hated) police force.

The Egyptians are dealing with looting of stores and homes.
They have to set up makeshift checkpoints and form guards to protect their property.

This keeps people busy and might lead to the people wanting the police to return.
 
http://www.elsevier.nl/web/Opinie/Commentaren/288018/Egyptische-revolutie-geen-reden-tot-juichen.htm

A few interesting facts about Egypt:

- more than 40% illiteracy
- 75% support stoning of women in vase of adultry

Nice conditions for a western style liberal democracy. Is not going to happen.

Have you seen many placards demanding "We want a nice western style liberal democracy" ?

A 2010 gallup poll in the US showed 65% support the death penalty for murder.

In 1994 80% supported it.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_in_the_United_States


20% of US Americans are functionally illiterate.

http://education-portal.com/articles/Illiteracy:_The_Downfall_of_American_Society.html
 
Last edited:
Have you seen many placards demanding "We want a nice western style liberal democracy" ?

Of course not. I was reasoning from the interests of the Wests dinosaurs: the multiculties, who soon will land on the scrap heap of history.

A 2010 gallup poll in the US showed 65% support the death penalty for murder.

In 1994 80% supported it.

Europe (including me) does not support the death penalty in vast majority, unlike the US where the general level of trust is far lower than in Europe thanks to the Jew-promoted immigration insanity. I want to make an exception though for high treason, like actively promoting giving your land and future away towards hostile civilisations.

20% of US Americans are functionally illiterate.

Same story. The American Euro's are for nearly 100% literate. The Jews for the full 100%. So guess where the illiteracy is to be found? Exactly: in the multicultural 'enrichment'.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom