Merged What's happening in the Middle East?

I honestly do not expect some sort of Islamist government to come out of this. Such an outcome does not at all appear to be the goal of the protestors. They want MORE freedom, not less.
 
I honestly do not expect some sort of Islamist government to come out of this. Such an outcome does not at all appear to be the goal of the protestors. They want MORE freedom, not less.

Only fear mongering is pushing the line of an Islamic takeover.
 
I honestly do not expect some sort of Islamist government to come out of this. Such an outcome does not at all appear to be the goal of the protestors. They want MORE freedom, not less.

Only fear mongering is pushing the line of an Islamic takeover.
I don't think it's fearmongering at all. There is a very real chance of militants filling the power vacuum if the government collapses completely.

Already, armed Muslim militants have fought their way into a prison where hundreds of other militants were being held, and freed them. Including leaders of the Muslim Brotherhood.

Egyptian security officials said that overnight armed men fired at guards in gun battles that lasted hours at the four prisons including one northwest of Cairo that held hundreds of militants. The prisoners escaped after starting fires and clashing with guards.

Those who fled included 34 members of the outlawed Muslim Brotherhood, Egypt's largest and best organized opposition group. The Muslim Brotherhood's lawyer, Abdel-Monaem Abdel-Maqsoud, told The Associated Press the 34 were among scores rounded up by authorities ahead of the large anti-government demonstrations on Friday. The escapees included at least seven senior members of the group.
http://my.earthlink.net/article/int?guid=20110130/c1ded1c2-4181-41d3-9078-9082043f2837
 
Already, armed Muslim militants have fought their way into a prison where hundreds of other militants were being held, and freed them. Including leaders of the Muslim Brotherhood.

Sorry 34 militants out of a total of a 1000 escapees is fear mongering
 
I honestly do not expect some sort of Islamist government to come out of this. Such an outcome does not at all appear to be the goal of the protestors. They want MORE freedom, not less.

There is precedent for this fear. After all, Iranian demonstrators in 1979 wanted more freedom, yet the ayatollahs came to power.
 
There was just live pictures of Mohamed ElBaradei walking with protestors in Cairo here:

http://english.aljazeera.net/watch_now/

edit: Guess that house-arrest wasn't very effective.. BTW did you hear about the 3 prison breaks? 1000's of convicts escaped..
 
Last edited:
J, if they were all political prisoners, maybe not such a bad thing.
If they were in prison for crimes against persons -- murder, mayhem, robbery, assault, rape-- maybe not such a good thing.

Most likely a mixed bag.
 
http://www.spiegel.de/politik/ausland/0,1518,742498,00.html

Even Der Spiegel acknowledges that the Egyptian authorities are creating anarchy and violence themselves, which is confirmed by Egyptian establishment members:

Dabei verdichten sich die Hinweise, dass ein Großteil der Gewalt vom Regime selbst initiiert wurde, um die Auseinandersetzungen bewusst eskalieren zu lassen. Was zunächst wie eine Verschwörungstheorie klang, wird mittlerweile nicht nur von Augenzeugen und seriösen Analysten, sondern sogar von Leuten des ägyptischen Establishments bestätigt.
 
Last edited:
Even the Muslim Brotherhood is proposing secular leftwinger Elbaradei as mediator...

http://www.telegraaf.nl/buitenland/8878756/__Steun_voor_ElBaradei__.html?p=2,1

Interesting position to take. After chewing on that for a moment, I think any political faction in Egypt would like things to settle down a bit ... constant upheaval tends to have a degrading influence on civil services, such as Fire Brigade, Police, Trains, trade ...

So, a lot of folks want HM out ... but then who gets to be "the new boss," and how?
 
http://english.aljazeera.net/news/middleeast/2011/01/2011130165636218719.html

al-Jazeera[/quote said:
Mohamed Elbaradei, a leading opposition figure, has joined thousands of protesters in Cairo's Tahrir Square, in continued demonstrations demanding an end to President Hosni Mubarak's 30-year rule.

The former head of the International Atomic Energy Agency told the crowd on Sunday night that "what we have begun cannot go back" referring to days of anti-government protests.

The National Coalition for Change, which groups several opposition movements including the Muslim Brotherhood, wants ElBaradei to negotiate with the Mubarak government.
 
...

The Roman Empire lasted 4 centuries or so. I doubt the American empire will exist in a few years time. We are entering a very instable multipolar world. Enjoy your warm shower, your central heating, your espresso machine, your Beamer... it is not going to last.

On the contrary. All these poor people rising up will need warm showers and espresso too. There's enough for everyone. (Well, maybe not everyone will get a Beamer. Maybe a VW 1L instead...)
 
On the contrary. All these poor people rising up will need warm showers and espresso too. There's enough for everyone. (Well, maybe not everyone will get a Beamer. Maybe a VW 1L instead...)

I wish everybody on this planet all the things listed (except for cars). But it is not going to happen. There is not enough for everybody. The muslims will never attain western standards and with every year we Westerners will experience a declining standard of living as well.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom