Merged What's happening in the Middle East?

In other news, el Baradei shows what a useful idiot he can be for the Muslim Brotherhood:
ZAKARIA: Mohamed, one of the visions that haunts Americans is of the Iranian revolution, where a dictator, pro-American dictator, was replaced by an even worse regime that was even more anti-American and more threatening to the region. People worry about the Muslim Brotherhood. Are you confident that a post-Mubarak Egypt will not give rise to some kind of Islamic fundamentalist force that will undermine the democracy of Egypt?

ELBARADEI: I'm quite confident of that, Fareed. This is a myth that was sold by the Mubarak regime, that it's either us, the ruthless dictators, or above (ph) them the al Qaida types.You know, the Muslim Brotherhood has nothing to do with the Iranian model, has nothing to do with extremism, as we have seen it in Afghanistan and other places. The Muslim Brotherhood is a religiously conservative group. They are a minority in Egypt. They are not a majority of the Egyptian people, but they have a lot of credibility because all the other liberal parties have been smothered for 30 years.
No, nothing extremist about the Muslim Brotherhood, where Khalid Sheikh Mohammed got his start.

Nothing to see here, just move along...
 
Last edited:
No, the reporter said they were Muslim militants. You have evidence they weren't?

The three jails that were broken into were all general population jails. They had their share of criminals rapists murders as any typical jails.

But tell me was the blogger beaten to death a year ago by the police a militant for calling for democratic elections?
 
The three jails that were broken into were all general population jails. They had their share of criminals rapists murders as any typical jails.
There were at least 4 prisons broken into, and one in particular held the hundreds of Islamic militants.

But tell me was the blogger beaten to death a year ago by the police a militant for calling for democratic elections?
Relevance?
 
So what Stalin got his start in a Russian Orthodox seminary

Keep clutching
Keep denying.

The Muslim Brotherhood spawned nearly all of the Islamist groups in recent times. They are very closely tied to Hamas, which is basically the Muslim Brotherhood in Gaza. There is nothing moderate about them.
 
you are asking someone to provide evidence to counter your evidence?

why should he have to do that?
He made the claim, he should provide the evidence. That's the way it works here. I already provided the evidence for my claim.
 
He made the claim, he should provide the evidence. That's the way it works here. I already provided the evidence for my claim.

So when someone makes a claim that counters your claim, that person has to provide EVIDENCE to back up their counter-claim?

ok, I just wanted to make sure I fully understood what you were saying.

:)
 
In other news, el Baradei shows what a useful idiot he can be for the Muslim Brotherhood:

ELBARADEI: I'm quite confident of that, Fareed. This is a myth that was sold by the Mubarak regime, that it's either us, the ruthless dictators, or above (ph) them the al Qaida types.You know, the Muslim Brotherhood has nothing to do with the Iranian model, has nothing to do with extremism, as we have seen it in Afghanistan and other places. The Muslim Brotherhood is a religiously conservative group. They are a minority in Egypt. They are not a majority of the Egyptian people, but they have a lot of credibility because all the other liberal parties have been smothered for 30 years.

Why did you not talk about this part?
 
So when someone makes a claim that counters your claim, that person has to provide EVIDENCE to back up their counter-claim?

ok, I just wanted to make sure I fully understood what you were saying.

:)

He just has to say I-S-L-A-M-I-C

Works the same as playing the joker in 500 - trumps everything, even if you happen to be playing 'go fish'
 
Last edited:
In other news, el Baradei shows what a useful idiot he can be for the Muslim Brotherhood:

No, nothing extremist about the Muslim Brotherhood, where Khalid Sheikh Mohammed got his start.

Doesn't seem to have done much with them, though. He joined when he was 16 and returned to Pakistan soon after:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khalid_Sheikh_Mohammed

In fact, he did so little that the Muslim Brotherhood didn't even notice he had joined:
http://www.ikhwanweb.com/article.php?id=17601


On the Muslim Brotherhood...
Here's an article from the Nixon Centre: (pdf)
http://www.nixoncenter.org/publications/LeikenBrookeMB.pdf
non-pdf intro:
http://www.foreignaffairs.com/artic...steven-brooke/the-moderate-muslim-brotherhood



There's also this article:
http://harpers.org/archive/2007/03/0081425

Which makes a good point:

Ken Silverstein said:
“People say that talking to them [Islamists] gives them legitimacy, but they already have legitimacy,” says Alastair Crooke, formerly of MI6 and the head of Conflicts Forum. “They say you are empowering them, but they already have power. These are the people that run the streets.” In his view, American and British analysts see a “clash of civilizations” between the West and Islam while missing a fundamental struggle within Islam itself, between “revivalists” who see electoral politics as a path to gain a stake in society and “revolutionaries” like Al Qaeda who reject that path. Political dialogue with the revivalists is urgent, since anti-Western sentiment, inflamed by the Iraq war, is pushing the pendulum toward Osama bin Laden, Crooke believes.

[...] by scorning politically active Islamic movements and denying their legitimacy, the United States is essentially signaling to the Middle Eastern public that electoral politics are a meaningless dead end—precisely the same message that this public hears from Al Qaeda.
 
how trustworthy are Egyptian convictions? as trustworthy as their elections?
 
I wish everybody on this planet all the things listed (except for cars). But it is not going to happen. There is not enough for everybody. The muslims will never attain western standards and with every year we Westerners will experience a declining standard of living as well.

Fine. Let it all come into balance then. Everyone doesn't need fast cars, champagne and chateaubriand. Nor do they want them. Clean water, a stable food supply, and basic health care would be a good start for vast numbers of people.

I'm saying there's enough for our needs, but not our greed. I admit it's an optimistic view, but your view is no more likely to be true than mine. I think it's a matter of attitude and political will. If you look at history, the poor and oppressed have always been with us, but more people partake of a higher material standard of living in modern times than ever before. (Not that it makes us any happier...but that's another story.) The tide of history indicates a trajectory. These people in the streets of Egypt are riding it.

The likelihood, of course, is that they will fail to make the most of the opportunity by failing to articulate specific demands. As others have pointed out, the vacuum will be filled by whoever has their act together first. I have a feeling equilibrium will be restored pretty quickly, both locally and globally.
 
Why did you not talk about this part?
What about that part?

The outlawed Muslim Brotherhood, which wants to establish an Islamist state in Egypt, has made some statements that it was willing to let ElBaradei act as pointman for the movement. But it also appeared to be moving for a more prominent role after lying low when the protests first erupted. Sunday evening, the presence of overtly pious Muslims in the square was conspicuous, suggesting a significant Brotherhood representation. Hundreds performed the sunset prayers. Veiled women prayed separately.

A senior Brotherhood leader, Essam el-Erian, told The Associated Press he was heading to Tahrir Square to meet with other opposition leaders. El-Erian told one Egyptian TV station that the Brotherhood is ready to contact the army for a dialogue, calling the military "the protector of the nation."

Clinton suggested American concerns over the possibility of the Brotherhood seizing direction of the movement. She warned against a takeover resembling the one in Iran, with a "small group that doesn't represent the full diversity of Egyptian society" seizing control and imposing its ideological beliefs.
http://my.earthlink.net/article/top?guid=20110130/c1ded1c2-4181-41d3-9078-9082043f2837

Looks like the MB is already mobilizing.
 
so we are OK with governments banning woman from driving cars, so we are able to drive our cars?


Yea, it cuts the Egyptian traffic fatalities in half......well, OK, more than half. :)....and think about all the expensive gasoline it saves their country.
 
Last edited:
He just has to say I-S-L-A-M-I-C

Works the same as playing the joker in 500 - trumps everything, even if you happen to be playing 'go fish'
Oh, cut the crap. I said they were Islamic militants because they were Islamic militants.

They weren't western-style trust fund anarchists, or labor union communists, or Marxists of any stripe.

I'm sure you would rather wish them away by pretending they don't exist, but this is the situation as it is, not as you wish it to be.
 
Last edited:
How about driving a prius instead of a hummer.

Hey; I'm not giving up my Hummer for anybody, especially for a bunch o' Muslim fanatics. In fact, I'm thinkin' of buying two more Hummers just to give Al Gore a heart attack. :)
JW
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom