Merged What's happening in the Middle East?

A few interesting facts about Egypt:

- more than 40% illiteracy
- 75% support stoning of women in case of adultry

Nice conditions for a western style liberal democracy. Is not going to happen.
Actually, its:

-82% support for stoning for adultery
-77% support for whipping/cutting of limbs for theft/robbery
-84% support for apostasy (leaving Islam)
-30%/49% favorable views towards Hezbollah/Hamas

and under the same breath

-59% support some form of democracy over other forms of government
-59% identify themselves with fundamentalists, 27% with modernizers
-54% supprt for gender segregation in the workplace
-Show concern for the spread of extremism???

http://pewglobal.org/files/2010/12/Pew-Global-Attitudes-Muslim-Report-FINAL-December-2-2010.pdf

Bit of a contradiction.
 
Europe (including me) does not support the death penalty in vast majority, unlike the US where the general level of trust is far lower than in Europe thanks to the Jew-promoted immigration insanity. I want to make an exception though for high treason, like actively promoting giving your land and future away towards hostile civilisations.

Same story. The American Euro's are for nearly 100% literate. The Jews for the full 100%. So guess where the illiteracy is to be found? Exactly: in the multicultural 'enrichment'.
Protocols CT section is that way -->
 
In Holland we have an interesting daily radio program called standpuntnl, named after this url:

http://www.stand.nl/

Every day a different 'standpoint' is discussed. Today's 'standpoint':

'The EU should support Egyptian demonstrators'.

72% is in favor.

A lot of 'Dutch'/Egyptians called and all were in favor. The Christian-democrat foreign policy expert Henk Jan Ormel, who was guest to the program, came with the startling revelation that not 10% but 30% of the Egyptians are (crypto-) Christian!. He used this figure to support the idea that a plural democracy was in the cards. Have heard noises myself in the past few days that the Muslim Brotherhood might be willing to support a real representative democracy.

I am sceptical: democracy means one-man-one-vote, and these 40% illiterates are likely in vast majority Muslims and will vote very conservative (MB).
 
Last edited:
'The Egyptian revolution threatens an American-imposed order of Arabophobia and false choices':

"I'm thrilled by what I see in the Cairo streets, but when I turn on American television I see only grim faces.
...

So racism against Arabs is shutting down the American mind once again.
...

Why is America so afraid?
"

Those 'grim faces' are just being careful.

There have been a great many revolutions in history that I personally would have supported.

Notably the French revolution. Which was all for human rights and republicanism, led by a guy who'd given up his job as prosecutor because he didn't want to carry out death sentences.

A few months later that same guy had guillotined 16.000 people, including that nice mr Guillotine.

These things are unpredictable, to say the least.

Also: If Obama threw his weight behind the protesters, and we'd end up with the Muslim Brotherhood taking power and carrying mass executions in football stadiums, Obama might have a hard time explaining his initial support.
 
Of course not. I was reasoning from the interests of the Wests dinosaurs: the multiculties, who soon will land on the scrap heap of history.

How do you suggest we desplice our genes?

Europe (including me) does not support the death penalty in vast majority, unlike the US where the general level of trust is far lower than in Europe thanks to the Jew-promoted immigration insanity. I want to make an exception though for high treason, like actively promoting giving your land and future away towards hostile civilisations.

I was illustrating the irrelevance of your figures.

Same story. The American Euro's are for nearly 100% literate. The Jews for the full 100%. So guess where the illiteracy is to be found? Exactly: in the multicultural 'enrichment'.

Nothing to do with class then...
 
Last edited:
Also: If Obama threw his weight behind the protesters, and we'd end up with the Muslim Brotherhood taking power and carrying mass executions in football stadiums, Obama might have a hard time explaining his initial support.

I noticed the the same grim Muslim Brotherhood obsession amongst establishment figures on BBC Radio 4 Question Time. Not a single one celebrated the power and resistance of the ordinary Egyptian people taking to the streets and defying dictatorial state violence.

How many mass executions in football stadiums have the Muslim Brotherhood organized in the past?
 
Last edited:
I noticed the the same grim Muslim Brotherhood obsession amongst establishment figures on BBC Radio 4 Question Time. Not a single one celebrated the power and resistance of the ordinary Egyptian people taking to the streets and defying dictatorial state violence.

How many mass executions in football stadiums have the Muslim Brotherhood organized in the past?

*sigh*
 
What's the matter?

Nothing.

It's just that my 'mass executions in stadiums' was in the context of the French Revolution example.

Back then you could have said:
'How many people have been guillotined by secular democracy advocates?'
And the answer would have been; None.

For the record:
I hope the Egyptians get their democracy.
If I lived there, I'd be on the streets.

But politicians and even newscasters cannot speak out in support for unrest/revolution. If things turn ugly -and they could turn very ugly- one cannot be seen as complicit.
 
OMG!

The chaos in Egypt has put thousands of valuable pieces of history in the line of fire.

Looters tore the heads off two ancient mummies and destroyed other artifacts at Cairo's Egyptian Museum, and other museums, warehouse and archeological sites around the country have been reportedly raided.

link


WTF is that all about?
It happened in Iraq also.

Kudos for the people defending the musems.
 
Last edited:
http://www.spiegel.de/politik/ausland/0,1518,742614,00.html

Tomorrow will be 'Super Tuesday' in Egypt. Mohamed ElBaradei calls for general strike. 1,000,000 people expected to be on the street. March towards the presidential palast (my free advice: remove all these nice pieces of art and furniture from the palace).

Hollywood sends a representative as well:

Prominente Unterstützung bekommt die Opposition jetzt von einem Filmstar: Der Schauspieler Omar Scharif ("Dr. Schiwago") unterstützt die Bewegung. Nach 30 Jahren an der Macht sei es für Mubarak an der Zeit, diese zu übergeben, zitierte der arabische Nachrichtensender Al-Arabija den Hollywood-Schauspieler.

Omar opines that it is time for Mubarak to go.
 
Last edited:
http://hoeiboei.blogspot.com/2011/01/een-sprong-in-het-duister-met-de.html#more

Dutch review of this book about the Muslim Brotherhood:

- founded as early as 1928
- although originating in Egypt the movement is now transnational
- core message: "Islam is the solution"
- large diversity in opinions within MB, between conservatives and 'reformers'; younger people are radicals
- even reformers advocate sharia
- democracy is under debate; reformers accept minority rights but insist on dominant character of Islam (Germans would say 'Leitkultur'). MB did indeed sharply condemn attacks on Coptic church recently. Even a Christian president is acceptable
 
Last edited:
Nothing.

It's just that my 'mass executions in stadiums' was in the context of the French Revolution example.

Back then you could have said:
'How many people have been guillotined by secular democracy advocates?'
And the answer would have been; None.

Did they have football stadiums back then? I'm not sure a pre-revolutionary French prosecutor can fairly be compared to the Muslim Brotherhood.

For the record:
I hope the Egyptians get their democracy.
If I lived there, I'd be on the streets.

But politicians and even newscasters cannot speak out in support for unrest/revolution. If things turn ugly -and they could turn very ugly- one cannot be seen as complicit.

Whether or not politicians and newscasters speak out in favor of protestors depends on their (or their masters') political beliefs and courage.

Newscasters on Al Jazeera haven't been looking grim, nor have they ignored possible ugly outcomes.

Politician George Galloway had no problem encouraging the Egyptian people and army to rise up against the Mubarak regime:

 
Last edited:
Did they have football stadiums back then? I'm not sure a pre-revolutionary French prosecutor can fairly be compared to the Muslim Brotherhood.



Whether or not politicians and newscasters speak out in favor of protestors depends on their (or their masters') political beliefs and courage.

Newscasters on Al Jazeera haven't been looking grim, nor have they ignored possible ugly outcomes.

Politician George Galloway had no problem encouraging the Egyptian people and army to rise up against the Mubarak regime:


On the off-chance that you are not being deliberately obtuse:
My point is that revolutions have historically been extremely unpredictable events.

I've been sitting in front of my TV, watching the protests with a smile on my face. People getting rid of that autocratic git, is a sight to behold
But if I was in politics, I'd smile in private and hedge my bets in public.

Mind you, when the first wave of protest is over and things start to normalise again, the west might still find a certain Mr Mubarak at the other end of the negotiating table.
Being old, autocratic and bad for the population doesn't make leaders magically disappear. See Mugabe.
 
Last edited:
On the off-chance that you are not being deliberately obtuse:
My point is that revolutions have historically been extremely unpredictable events.

I understand your point, though it is a bit like saying water is wet.

I've been sitting in front of my TV, watching the protests with a smile on my face. People getting rid of that autocratic git, is a sight to behold
But if I was in politics, I'd smile in private and hedge my bets in public.

It would depend on your politics. You could say that Robert Gibbs, Obama et al hedged their bets by supporting Mubarak and their bet has failed. Now, because they chose defending American "interests" over the welfare of real human beings, they find themselves between the proverbial rock and a hard place. No wonder they look grim!

Mind you, when the first wave of protest is over and things start to normalise again, the west might still find a certain Mr Mubarak at the other end of the negotiating table.
Being old, autocratic and bad for the population doesn't make leaders magically disappear. See Mugabe.

It looks like Mubarak could be hedging his bets on encouraging chaos and misery (people are already having to queue for bread and organize their own security) but the protestors have burnt their metaphorical bridges by coming out onto the streets and showing their faces. Their lives now depend on not allowing Mubarak's Security State to survive.
 
This report on Stratfor indicated that the Egyptian blockade of Gaza has collapsed because of the nation-wide retreat of police and security forces in the face of the protesters.

Stratfor has, in their overall analysis of the situation in Egypt, said the following regarding the Muslim Brotherhood:

The consensus of most observers is that the Muslim Brotherhood at this point is no longer a radical movement and is too weak to influence the revolution. This may be possible, but it is not obvious. The Muslim Brotherhood has many strands, many of which have been quiet under Mubarak’s repression. It is not clear who will emerge if Mubarak falls. It is certainly not clear that they are weaker than the democratic demonstrators. It is a mistake to confuse the Muslim Brotherhood’s caution with weakness. Another way to look at them is that they have bided their time and toned down their real views, waiting for the kind of moment provided by Mubarak’s succession. I would suspect that the Muslim Brotherhood has more potential influence among the Egyptian masses than the Western-oriented demonstrators or Mohamed ElBaradei, the former head of the International Atomic Energy Agency, who is emerging as their leader.

The situation regarding the Gaza border is worrying, since it reports that Hamas is crossing into Egypt to assist the Brotherhood. The report also notes that security forces are masquerading as protesters and are causing more chaos and destruction in an effort to drum up a pretext for a stronger crackdown on the "violent troublemakers". In response, the Brotherhood is organizing protection for people and property, and organizing demonstrations and supporting them with food, drinks, and first aid.

This is pretty much the worst thing possible for Egypt, since it simultaneously inflames the protests against the existing government even MORE, while positioning the Brotherhood as nice happy helpers for the protests. The ultimate outcome of the revolution in Egypt is still up in the air, and the exact amount of influence the above will have on that outcome is unknown, but it sure as hell is a bad indicator.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom