Merged What's happening in the Middle East?

Just because it's not inevitable that the Egyptian revolution will end badly, that doesn't mean it still won't end badly.

It's interesting to see which people prefer to discuss how it might end badly rather than how it might end well.
 
It's interesting to see which people prefer to discuss how it might end badly rather than how it might end well.
I note that for you, who regularly fantasizes about the collapse of western civilization, "ending well" is what most people would consider "ending badly".
 
Reza Aslan has some interesting (and informed) comments about the role of the MB in the uprising:

First of all, it should be noted that the Muslim Brotherhood neither launched the revolt against Mubarak (on the contrary, it was quite late in joining it), nor is it now leading it. Although the Brotherhood remains the largest and most organized opposition movement in Egypt, the demonstrations that have caught the world's attention were instigated by tens of thousands of mostly unemployed Egyptian youths who, in providing the most significant challenge to Mubarak's regime in decades, have utterly displaced the more traditional opposition groups in Egypt, including the Muslim Brotherhood. As the Egyptian scholar Emad Shahin told the New York Times,
"The Brotherhood is no longer the most effective player in the political arena... [This is] a youth uprising. It is the youth that knows how to use the media, Internet, Facebook, so there are other players now."​
At the very least, the youth in Egypt have demonstrated that they do not need the assistance of the Brotherhood and its somewhat ossified institutions to turn the masses onto the streets.
Aslan's Twitter feed has been a great source of information over the last week or so.
 
I'm getting the impression that the army has decided (or accepted) Mubarak is going to go. They haven't decided what happens after.
 
Mubarak is still Commander-in-Chief, isn't he?

ETA: Have now actually read the link!

Political analyst Diaa Rashwan said: "...This means the army has now taken control."
 
Last edited:
The army doesn't want to take over. They know whoever takes over will be just as powerless to fix Egypt's economic problems as Mubarak currently is.
 
In these difficult hours Mubarak has at least the support of one party: the Israeli government. That is just what he needs. With the timing and diplomatic skills of a rhinoceros Peres expressed his support for Mubarak:

Alluding to the riots in Egypt and the current regime in Iran, Peres declared that “a fanatic religious oligarch is not better than a lack of democracy.”

Translation: "If the population wants a cleric but we want a dictator, than we should prevail."

The usual double standards: democracy in the former Russian satellites (with the aim of weakening Russia) and dictatorship in Arabia. All for the glory of the Washington lead West.
 
Last edited:
The world according to Al Jazeera:

Breaking: Al Jazeera Reports Mubarak’s planning exile to Tel Aviv—The Writing on the Wall

... after Saudi-Arabia rejected him.

This is an older story from Januari 29. But I have to admit it would be the shortest route into safety.
 
Last edited:
The army doesn't want to take over. They know whoever takes over will be just as powerless to fix Egypt's economic problems as Mubarak currently is.

I've been thinking about this.

I suspect that a major driver behind the protests is rising food and energy prices in a country where a lot of people live on $2 a day.

Democracy might open Egypt up for investment, but it will still be corrupt, arid, underdeveloped, overpopulated, lacking natural resources with a 40% illiteracy rate.

What are Egypt's main sources of income?
If the answer is tourism and US aid, they are royally screwed in the event of an Islamist government.
 
What are Egypt's main sources of income?
If the answer is tourism and US aid, they are royally screwed in the event of an Islamist government.

Yep. Once Mubarak is gone, Egypt is at a crossroads. In one direction lies a Turkish-style open(ish) democracy, with all of its problems and prosperity (but no Kurds). In the other direction lies Libya, an isolationist, hostile and ridiculously impoverished nation. (And in the worst of all worlds lies Gaza, but I think that the least likely and worst-case scenario.) One direction faces outward towards liberalization and a market-based economy. The other direction faces inward, towards isolation, more poverty, and eventually, back to repression. Egypt doesn't have the natural resources that allows Iran and Venezuela to thumb their noses at the West. The problem is that reaching out will mean forgiving a lot of people who supported Mubarak -- America, Europe, and Israel -- that the Egyptian public probably isn't all that fond of right now. That's a tough pill to swallow for an already bruised national ego. Here's hoping the Egyptians will do it.
 
According to reports I read, there was hope in Egypt that the US government would support them and reach out to them. They have not got that.

I think the USA has been doing exactly what we should do. Call for peace, reform, and harmony while not totally taking sides.

Though, if you read into Clinton's statements, clearly she was slightly on the side of the reformers and protestors.
 
Let Mubarak leave by say, March. a peaceful and orderly transition is good for everyone.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom