What the Palestinians Really Want

Well, whatever you want to call them, how do you justify israel expanding theirs?
Given the history of the place, I guess I don't see the need for justification that you do. As far as I'm concerned, it is what it is.
 
Those are called "facts on the ground", and are a powerful bargaining chip. I expect a future agreement would allow these areas to become part of Israel, and sparsely populated Israeli land swapped in exchange.

would you have a problem with wealthy Muslim Americans funding massive building projects for Palestinians in East Jerusalem?
 
would you have a problem with wealthy Muslim Americans funding massive building projects for Palestinians in East Jerusalem?
If they aren't giving it to terrorists they can do as they wish with their money as far as I'm concerned.
 
If they aren't giving it to terrorists they can do as they wish with their money as far as I'm concerned.

I wonder how Lieberman would feel about a wealthy Muslim American donating $1 billion to build thousands of apartments in EJ. :D
 
Folks -- those who are supporting the Palestinians are simply supporting genocide. Sorry to ruin the fantasies.

...they are standing shoulder to shoulder with folks who consider "Palestinian rights" as simply the annihilation of Israel, and repeatedly declare this, is quite typical of the useful idiots of this sort.

[...] Once more: they are being used as useful idiots by folks whose real goal is genocide, and openly state it too.

And, as has been said before (in this thread), Israel's destruction is not genocide. The destruction of the USSR was not genocide. Nor was the destruction of apartheid South Africa.

There are many plans for the distruction of Israel. The latest is to declare a State of Palestine. This has been accepted by a few countries. But won't be by Israel and possibly not by the USA. If the creation of an independent Palestine fails, the Palestinians will switch to demanding Israeli citizenship. Both Olmert and Barak have already noted this anti-apartheid strategy and how it will destroy Israel.

The status quo is not going to continue. The Fatah leadership seem to have given up on negotiating and negotiating and negotiating. There will be no more peace talks between a stateless people and the state of Israel. There will be negotiations between two states or between a state and its oppressed minority. We know how the latter ends -- we saw it all play out with South Africa.

Personally, I see it as win-win: either there is an independent Palestine or a single state which is a state of its citizens. And it does not support genocide to be satisfied with either of those outcomes.
 
What borders are you talking about? The ones recognized by the Palestinians? Israel?

Those are the players that count. And when they recognize no borders, the conflict and violence will continue. When they agree on a border, there will be peace. Or at least it will be a lot more peaceful.

What do you think this guy meant:
http://www.haaretz.com/news/diploma...he-settlement-freeze-is-a-honey-trap-1.324604

Haaretz said:
"If we freeze [construction] for three months, the pressure on us to decide our permanent borders will be unbearable," Shalom told Israel Radio after the meeting. "Unfortunately, if that happens, it will be a huge mistake."
 
Personally, I see it as win-win: either there is an independent Palestine or a single state which is a state of its citizens. And it does not support genocide to be satisfied with either of those outcomes.

You think Israelis and Palestinians can live together under the same roof peacefully? Even after 60 of violence? French and Flemish Belgians can hardly agree on anything, French and English Canadians are always feuding about everything, and the last conflict was 200 years ago. Forcing two diametrically opposed peoples to live together is a bad, bad idea.

What if the Palestinian majority elects Hamas as their government? Will that be a "win-win" for the Jewish population?
 
Last edited:
What if the Palestinian majority elects Hamas as their government? Will that be a "win-win" for the Jewish population?

don't you mean, Israelis? Certainly you are not suggesting that all Israelis are Jews and all Jews are Israelis.
 
You think Israelis and Palestinians can live together under the same roof peacefully? Even after 60 of violence?

Yes.

French and Flemish Belgians can hardly agree on anything, French and English Canadians are always feuding about everything, and the last conflict was 200 years ago. Forcing two diametrically opposed peoples to live together is a bad, bad idea.

Taking that literally... Then 199 years ago, the last conflict would only have been a year in the past.

What if the Palestinian majority elects Hamas as their government? Will that be a "win-win" for the Jewish population?

A one state solution would have a consitution that sets out what a government can/can't and must do.
 
A one state solution would have a consitution that sets out what a government can/can't and must do.

Even if you set up a constitution that explicitly forbids any kind of amendment process, a constitution is only as good as far as it can be enforced.
 
I should also say, that while I do support the two-state solution, I do also believe that the hundreds of thousands of illegal Israeli settlers and the right-wing mindset in Israel, has made the two-state solution almost impossible. It would take a miracle to get an agreement...and a double-miracle to get it approved by the Knesset.

After maybe a few more years of fruitless negotiations, I expect Israel to:

a. Annex those parts of the West Bank that are within the Seperation Wall, and force those Israelis on the other side to move west of the wall.

b. declare the rest of the West Bank free of Israeli control.

...though, in all honesty, this ain't soo bad for the Palestinians, as it gives them more than 90% of the West Bank. But none of East Jerusalem.

But still...its 90% better than nothing.

For the most part, I completely agree with you, with the exception that you place all the blame on Israel. The PA has shown no willingness to negotiate.
 
Last edited:
Well if "Palestine" becomes one state, the word "Israeli" will become meaningless, won't it?

for most sophisticated and rational individuals in this world, "Palestine" today only refers to the West Bank, Gaza, and East Jerusalem.

Only left-wingers, some Arab nationalists, and Muslim extremists, expect or even hope to recover all of historic Palestine as the new State of Palestine.

Look it up on Wikipedia. The State of Palestine is only the WB and Gaza.

All of the South American countries who recently recognized the State of Palestine, only consider the WB and Gaza to be this new state.

http://www.google.com/search?q=stat...7&rls=com.microsoft:en-US:IE-SearchBox&ie=&oe=
 
Last edited:

How so? They have been at each others throats for 60 years, why would they suddenly be considerate of one another?

When did something like this ever happen in the history of mankind?

Taking that literally... Then 199 years ago, the last conflict would only have been a year in the past.
Uh?

My point was that the animosity between the French and the English in Canada can still be felt even 200 years after the last real conflict, do you think the Palestinians and Israelis won't be resentful of each other?

The Sunni and the Shia are killing eachother in Irak, and they're both Muslims. You think the Palestinians will erase and forget decades of antisemitic indoctrination and propaganda? You think Iranian ifnluence will end full-stop?

A one state solution would have a consitution that sets out what a government can/can't and must do.
And who will make that constitution?
 
Last edited:
Taking seriously the views of a communist anarchist about political solutions to real-world problems is about as reasonable as taking the views of a flat-earther about real-world problems in radio astronomy.

In both cases the person is question is a priori committed to such an absurd view that their claims can, at best, be used to mean "whatever they say, do the opposite", but more likely will turn out to be sheer gibberish.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom