You're still trying to pull the "Argument by MySpace" crap? This is a truly, truly, pathetic attempt at guilt-by-association. Par for the course with you, of course.
But still...Get a new shtick already.
I do, and as Skeptic's OP showed, the Palestinians have more than once been proposed a state of their own, they are the ones who keep not taking it.
You missed my point.
The only reason I gave Belgium and Canada as an example was to show you that even after hundreds of years, animosity between two peoples can persist, and cause troubles. The Palestinians and the Israelis have a much more recent history, and a much more bloody one, and their hatred of each other is much more virulent, so how do you expect them to live peacefully under the same roof?
My comparison wasn't literal, it was meant to show you contrast. If we can't agree with each other after 200 years, imagine them!
I do, and as Skeptic's OP showed, the Palestinians have more than once been proposed a state of their own, they are the ones who keep not taking it.
But you have agreed with each other, many times and on many things. Eventually, you might even agree on going seperate ways. So, clearly, the problems you hold to be so large have been handled, and can be handled by others.
Do they want a state or not?Maybe you can explain why the Palestinians should give up things they are entitled to.
Incredible, you missed the point again. Canada is not the Middle East. Again, I'm not making a comparison, I'm making a contrast.
Do they want a state or not?
Do they want a state or not?
As opposed to all the legal wars waged against Israel by the Arab League and the Palestinians, with even Iran getting in on the act?You appear to be agreeing that there is no way to justify the illegal israeli expansion into palestinian territory. Good.
Quoted because that's this thread in a nut shell.
huh?As opposed to all the legal wars waged against Israel by the Arab League and the Palestinians, with even Iran getting in on the act?
.
So they should accept less than they are entitled to?
As opposed to all the legal wars waged against Israel by the Arab League and the Palestinians, with even Iran getting in on the act?
Legality means squat in such a scenario.
Again, so what?
Even if your odd concept of "real" nationalities were true, what do you think this means for Israel vis-a-vis the one-state or two-state solutions?
You are being asked to support your claim and you refuse to. You also failed to support your claim that most nations have unified cultures, races or religions. Put up, or.......
So they should accept less than they are entitled to?
Well, I thank you for being civil, but I completely disagree with your analysis. You appear to believe that if palestine exists under hamas, they will always be trying to destroy israel.
Of course it seems legit to you. However, outside of your ideological convenience, "guilt by association" is called a fallacy for a reason. And guilt by association based on "friends of friends" on MySpace gets you laughed at.
In diplomacy, nobody gets 100% of what they're entitled to. That's the whole idea.
Democracy Now said:[Shlomo ben Ami] The very fact that, as Dr. Finkelstein rightly says, the Palestinians were ready to make this or that concession is the reflection of them understanding that there is no viability, there is no possibility really to reach an agreement that says let us apply automatically and rigidly the requirements of international law.
The "why should the Palestinians get less than what they're entitled to?" has two problems.
1). The largest, and obvious one, is that for the PLO, Hamas, and many others, what the Palestinians are "entitled to" is all of Israel, which means what they are "entitled to" is Israel's destruction.
"If we freeze [construction] for three months, the pressure on us to decide our permanent borders will be unbearable," Shalom told Israel Radio after the meeting. "Unfortunately, if that happens, it will be a huge mistake."
Skeptic said:2). Every single nation on earth believes it is "entitled to" more than it has.
What is it you think they are entitled to, and who is it that did the entitling?