What the Palestinians Really Want

The Jews and Muslims of historic Palistine, have become connected by fate and blood.

I honestly think they will either learn to live together or die in seperation.
 
You're still trying to pull the "Argument by MySpace" crap? This is a truly, truly, pathetic attempt at guilt-by-association. Par for the course with you, of course.

But still...Get a new shtick already.

Is it true though? Do you support Atlanta Palestine Solidarity?
 
I do, and as Skeptic's OP showed, the Palestinians have more than once been proposed a state of their own, they are the ones who keep not taking it.

I expect the next "offer", will simply be in the form of an Israeli pull-back to the Seperation Wall. Which gives them 90% of the WB.

it ain't bad.
 
You missed my point.

The only reason I gave Belgium and Canada as an example was to show you that even after hundreds of years, animosity between two peoples can persist, and cause troubles. The Palestinians and the Israelis have a much more recent history, and a much more bloody one, and their hatred of each other is much more virulent, so how do you expect them to live peacefully under the same roof?

My comparison wasn't literal, it was meant to show you contrast. If we can't agree with each other after 200 years, imagine them!

But you have agreed with each other, many times and on many things. Eventually, you might even agree on going seperate ways. So, clearly, the problems you hold to be so large have been handled, and can be handled by others.

I do, and as Skeptic's OP showed, the Palestinians have more than once been proposed a state of their own, they are the ones who keep not taking it.

I refer you to my first post in this thread:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=6694250&postcount=4

Maybe you can explain why the Palestinians should give up things they are entitled to. And the other points in that post.
 
Last edited:
But you have agreed with each other, many times and on many things. Eventually, you might even agree on going seperate ways. So, clearly, the problems you hold to be so large have been handled, and can be handled by others.

Incredible, you missed the point again. Canada is not the Middle East. Again, I'm not making a comparison, I'm making a contrast.

Maybe you can explain why the Palestinians should give up things they are entitled to.
Do they want a state or not?
 
Incredible, you missed the point again. Canada is not the Middle East. Again, I'm not making a comparison, I'm making a contrast.

I've not missed the point. Maybe I don't think the difference you've pointed out is all that big. People at war, in various parts of the world, have agreed to live in peace. This won't be any different.

Do they want a state or not?

So they should accept less than they are entitled to?
 
You appear to be agreeing that there is no way to justify the illegal israeli expansion into palestinian territory. Good.
As opposed to all the legal wars waged against Israel by the Arab League and the Palestinians, with even Iran getting in on the act?

Legality means squat in such a scenario.
 
facepalm2ly3.jpg
Quoted because that's this thread in a nut shell.
 
As opposed to all the legal wars waged against Israel by the Arab League and the Palestinians, with even Iran getting in on the act?

Legality means squat in such a scenario.

They ended decades ago, and decades-old wars are not justifications for current expansion of borders. While it is interesting that you have no respect for international law, you are yet to provide a satisfactory explanation as to why israels expansion of its borders is a form of self-defence.
 
Again, so what?

Even if your odd concept of "real" nationalities were true, what do you think this means for Israel vis-a-vis the one-state or two-state solutions?

It is a way to quiet those nagging doubts -- as I noted in the first post in this thread -- that one's ceaseless work for "Palestinian rights" is merely being a useful idiot for Israel's destruction, by denying that its destruction would be a bad thing.

Of course this applies ONLY to the Jewish nation, Israel. Only it is "not a real nationality". Only its destruction is no big deal. This is called "holding Israel to a higher standard".
 
The "why should the Palestinians get less than what they're entitled to?" has two problems.

1). The largest, and obvious one, is that for the PLO, Hamas, and many others, what the Palestinians are "entitled to" is all of Israel, which means what they are "entitled to" is Israel's destruction.

2). Every single nation on earth believes it is "entitled to" more than it has. The whole difference between peaceful and aggressive nations is not that the aggressive ones thinks it's "entitled to" more, but that -- like the Palestinians -- they believe war and violence are perfectly legitimate unless one gets everything one is "entitled to"; think Germany or Italy in the 1960s.

"We will fight until we get everything we are entitled to" is not a cry of "liberation"; it is a cry of a fascist dictator, since what it means in practice is "we will react violently whenever we feel like it". In practice if they get everything unconditionally that they are "entitled to" now, all it means -- as they openly say -- would be to demand more and more, with more and more violence, since once they have a Palestinian state they will openly ask -- in fact they already do -- to take the rest of Israel, too, since they're "entitled" to that, too.

The sense of endless grievance, of violence being justified because "we were robbed", is the mark of a fascist state.
 
You are being asked to support your claim and you refuse to. You also failed to support your claim that most nations have unified cultures, races or religions. Put up, or.......

Of course, if Parky were correct, Israel would be perfectly justified in kicking out all Israeli Arabs, foreign workers, etc., etc.

THEN, once it finished the ethnic cleansing a la the Arab world's ethnic cleansing of Jews and Christians, it would finally achieve the coveted status of being a "real" nationality.

So why is Parky so opposed to Kahane, let alone Liberman (if Liberman were what he wrongly says he is)?

By the way, Israel should probably start a war to take over Jordan (15% non-Palestians that rule the place) Syria (Allawite minority controls the place), Lebanon (Muslims vs. Chritians, etc.), Iraq (Shiites vs, Sunnis vs. Kurds).

By his standard, they are not REAL nations, so hey, no big deal. No harm done.
 
Well, I thank you for being civil, but I completely disagree with your analysis. You appear to believe that if palestine exists under hamas, they will always be trying to destroy israel.

Yeah, people believe that because that's what Hamas says.
 
Of course it seems legit to you. However, outside of your ideological convenience, "guilt by association" is called a fallacy for a reason. And guilt by association based on "friends of friends" on MySpace gets you laughed at.

You are so full of it.

The "guilt by association" fallacy has nothing to do with who you literally associate with, but I think you know that and this is deliberate obfuscation.

But let's be honest, the ISM is connected with Palestinian "resistance" in all it's forms. Its connections to Hamas are a lot stronger than just belonging to the same myspace group as another person who used the Hamas logo as his avatar. To try to distance yourself from that after all the effort put into making the connections in the first place is just disingenuous.
 
In diplomacy, nobody gets 100% of what they're entitled to. That's the whole idea.

If you'd read the post I linked,
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=6694250&postcount=4
You'd know that Shlomo ben Ami makes this same argument and agrees that the Palestinians have, indeed, made concessions by giving up things they are entitled to. Why should they go on doing this?
http://www.democracynow.org/2006/2/14/fmr_israeli_foreign_minister_if_i

Democracy Now said:
[Shlomo ben Ami] The very fact that, as Dr. Finkelstein rightly says, the Palestinians were ready to make this or that concession is the reflection of them understanding that there is no viability, there is no possibility really to reach an agreement that says let us apply automatically and rigidly the requirements of international law.

So your argument is not new. It merely fails to explain why one side should give up things it is entitled to. It implies both sides are doing such. What part of the West Bank is Israel entitled to by international law? None. Yet it wants some of it. But it's willing to give up some of what it wants. That is the same kind of concession?



The "why should the Palestinians get less than what they're entitled to?" has two problems.

1). The largest, and obvious one, is that for the PLO, Hamas, and many others, what the Palestinians are "entitled to" is all of Israel, which means what they are "entitled to" is Israel's destruction.

That's rubbish.
The Palestinians have already agreed to the 1967 borders. But that isn't good enough. That doesn't end the discussion of borders -- something some Israeli politicians are loath to even be drawn into.

As linked before, in another post which went without response:
What do you think this guy meant?
http://www.haaretz.com/news/diploma...he-settlement-freeze-is-a-honey-trap-1.324604

"If we freeze [construction] for three months, the pressure on us to decide our permanent borders will be unbearable," Shalom told Israel Radio after the meeting. "Unfortunately, if that happens, it will be a huge mistake."


Skeptic said:
2). Every single nation on earth believes it is "entitled to" more than it has.

If you bothered to read the actual argument in post 4,
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=6694250&postcount=4
you would know that the argument doesn't involve what people believe they are entitled to (difficult to distinguish from what they want), it involves what international law says they are entitled to.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom