What the Palestinians Really Want

Defending your Home is perfectly fine, as long you do it in your home. You cant build a fence in your neighbors home.
And who gets to define where your neighbors property begins and ends?

Can you link to the official PA stance on Israel's sovereign borders? The Arab League's? No? Didn't think so.
 
I've still never had it explained to me, satisfactorily, how "expanding your borders into another countries' borders" is a form of self-defence.
See my post above, then link to the PA and Arab League's officially recognized Israeli border.

Can you do that?
 
And who gets to define where your neighbors property begins and ends?

Can you link to the official PA stance on Israel's sovereign borders? The Arab League's? No? Didn't think so.

So while you, your neighbor and the authorities are in negotiation about the borders, you believe its ok for you to build a fence where you want it?
 
So while you, your neighbor and the authorities are in negotiation about the borders, you believe its ok for you to build a fence where you want it?
If my neighbor was constantly shooting at me from his house? Damn right I'd build a fence, wherever necessary and as high as possible.
 
Cleon -- you, personally, are a "Friend" of the Myspace "Atlanta Palestine Solidarity Movement", right?

Did you note that your "friends" includes people whose online icon is Hamas' seal? (You, yourself, are only a few "friends" below him). The same Hamas which openly and repeatedly declares its genocidal antisemitic goals are precisely that?

Numerous others who openly express their desire for Israel to disappear are there, too -- such as the "Al Adwa" friend (the one right below you on the friends list), who advocates the so-called "right of return", that is, destroying Israel by demographic means. And that's just from a cursory look on the first page of "friends". God knows who else is on the other 27 pages of "friends" there.

Now, you remain to this day a "friend" in that group. You would never, I am certain, remain a "friend" in a group which had members whose online avatar was, say, a Swastika or a KKK symbol. Nor would you tolerate having only a few such people in a larger group of your friends. But when it is all about "freeing Palestine", you overlook such genocidal antisemitism, all for the chummy internet togetherness of feeling you are "working for justice in Palestine" or something.

So, yes, as your own personal history proves, those you hang out with do support Israel's destruction, and you know it, and still hang out with them.

You're still trying to pull the "Argument by MySpace" crap? This is a truly, truly, pathetic attempt at guilt-by-association. Par for the course with you, of course.

But still...Get a new shtick already.
 
Here is another example, from yesterday's paper. Remember the IHH and the Mavi Marmara flotilla incident? And how the useful idiots on this forum were full of rage about Israel's action?

Well, surprise surpise: the IHH and thousand of other Islamic supporters arrange a big carnaval today in Turkey as the Mavi Marmara returned home. In it the IHH's preaches told the adoring crowd that -- surprise! -- Israel's destruction is their goal, and they will not rest until it is achieved.

http://www.jpost.com/Headlines/Article.aspx?id=201006
http://www.vpr.net/npr/132358552/

vpr said:
Chants of "Israel be damned!" rang out from the crowd as the ship was eased into dock.

And, as has been said before, Israel's destruction is not genocide. The destruction of the USSR was not genocide. Nor was the destruction of apartheid South Africa. But you know this:

Numerous others who openly express their desire for Israel to disappear are there, too -- such as the "Al Adwa" friend (the one right below you on the friends list), who advocates the so-called "right of return", that is, destroying Israel by demographic means. And that's just from a cursory look on the first page of "friends". God knows who else is on the other 27 pages of "friends" there.

"demographic means"

Of course, the IHH being on the European terrorist list, it telling the Israelies who asked the ship to stop to "go back to Auschwitz", and its 'peace' activists singing the Islamists' death-to-the-Jews song ("Khayabar, Kahybar, oh Jews! Muhammad's army will return!" -- Khaybar being the Jewish tribe Muhammad slaughtered when he had a spare moment), should have been a dead giveaway.

Except the tribe wasn't slaughtered. They lost in battle, having allied themselves with enemies of the Muslims: the Banu Nadir. Some captives were executed at the end of the battle. It's not stated why, except in a few cases.


They weren't expelled by Mohammed, that happened under Umar:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khaybar

During the reign of Caliph Umar (634-644), the Jewish community of Khaybar were transported alongside the Christian community of Najran to the newly conquered regions of Syria and Iraq. As a settlement, Umar issued orders that these Christians and Jews should be treated well and allotted them land in their new settlements equivalent to they land they initially owned.




As for 'taking sides'....
Having an overlap in opinion doesn't mean agreeing on everything. Why do you find this confusing?

The blockade of Gaza is wrong. The IHH and others were correct in trying to break that blockade. I remember when the Free Gaza movement sent their first boat. Some dismissed it as nothing but a gesture. Even Israel left them alone to sail into Gaza. But the blockade runners have made a difference: People followed the first ones; after Mavi Marmara, Egypt opened up the Rafah border; even Israel has had to ease the blockade somewhat.

Good on all those that ran the bloackade. And here's hoping they finish the job and end the blockade completely!
 
Last edited:
You're still trying to pull the "Argument by MySpace" crap? This is a truly, truly, pathetic attempt at guilt-by-association. Par for the course with you, of course.

But still...Get a new shtick already.

Seems pretty legit to me.

That's the problem with these far leftist organizations, they're made up of and associated with some pretty disgusting and wacko people.
 
Yes, it's hilarious when Jews have to defend themselves against genocidal religious nutcases who consider all of Israel proper "occupied land".

why do Nazis, anti-Semites, Arab nationalists, and Islamic extremists, love to say Israeli=Jew?
 
Seems pretty legit to me.

Of course it seems legit to you. However, outside of your ideological convenience, "guilt by association" is called a fallacy for a reason. And guilt by association based on "friends of friends" on MySpace gets you laughed at.
 
Last edited:
You're still trying to pull the "Argument by MySpace" crap? This is a truly, truly, pathetic attempt at guilt-by-association.

Of course it's "guilt by association". It shows the kind of people you find no problem associating with, and proves my point -- namely, that you knowingly associate with people who explicitly support genocide of the Jews. This is, indeed, precisely my point about the far left.
 
Of course it's "guilt by association".

Well, at least you admit that your argument is fallacious.

It shows the kind of people you find no problem associating with,
Yeah, see, except that it's MySpace. It really doesn't show that as much as you really, really, really want it to show that.

and proves my point -- namely, that you knowingly associate with people who explicitly support genocide of the Jews.
And your evidence of this "knowing association" is that we both appear on the page of a defunct activist group on an all-but-defunct networking website together. Yeah...Totally flawless, your logic. :rolleyes:

Can you show that I've ever even met the individual you're talking about? Or that the person was, in any way, actually involved in anything I was part of? Or that we were ever in the same room together? Can you even show that I know his (I'm assuming it's a "his") name?

No, you can't. Why? Because I never have met this person, much less "knowingly associated" with him. It's *********** Myspace. It's a means of communication, nothing more. You assign importance to it because it's convenient for your pathetic attempt at character assassination - but in reality, it's meaningless.
 
Last edited:
Of course it seems legit to you. However, outside of your ideological convenience, "guilt by association" is called a fallacy for a reason.

"Guilt by association" is only a fallacy when it is wrongly that you associate with someone when in reality there is merely an accidental agreement in opinions about something, as in "Hitler was a vegetarian!" as evidence that the vegetarian down the street is wrong.

Here we have something quite different. Here, you knowingly, voluntarily, socially and publicly associate yourself with those who openly support genocidal murder -- it is not something your opponents falsely claim you do. That is like opening a vegetarian restaurant and decorating it with pictures of Der Fuhrer.
 
That is like opening a vegetarian restaurant and decorating it with pictures of Der Fuhrer, or joining the neo-nazi party and claiming it's all because Hitler was a vegetarian.

Hitler was not a vegetarian. This is a common and pathetic Conservative lie.
 
Here, you knowingly, voluntarily, socially and publicly associate yourself with those who openly support genocidal murder -- it is not something your opponents falsely claim you do.

Actually, you are indeed falsely claiming this very thing. Sorry to ruin the fantasy.

I mean, FFS, you're talking like I go around waving Hamas flags at political rallies; in reality, you found my name and some random person with a Hamas avatar on MySpace. I'm literally laughing at you over the importance you're desperately trying to assign to this.
 
Last edited:
And, as has been said before, Israel's destruction is not genocide. The destruction of the USSR was not genocide. Nor was the destruction of apartheid South Africa.
Nor would the destruction of Germany, Liberia, Taiwan, Canda or the US of A. Do you have a point:confused:?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom