What the Palestinians Really Want

Given the history of the place, I guess I don't see the need for justification that you do. As far as I'm concerned, it is what it is.

You appear to be agreeing that there is no way to justify the illegal israeli expansion into palestinian territory. Good.
 
for most sophisticated and rational individuals in this world, "Palestine" today only refers to the West Bank, Gaza, and East Jerusalem.

That's not what I'm talking about, and what I was responding to. Try to follow, or don't talk.

Look it up on Wikipedia. The State of Palestine is only the WB and Gaza.
Firegarden was talking about a one state Palestine. Try to follow or don't talk.
 
Taking seriously the views of a communist anarchist about political solutions to real-world problems is about as reasonable as taking the views of a flat-earther about real-world problems in radio astronomy.

In both cases the person is question is a priori committed to such an absurd view that their claims can, at best, be used to mean "whatever they say, do the opposite", but more likely will turn out to be sheer gibberish.

no more absurd that taking seriously the thoughts of a rabid zionist on the palestianian issues.
 
That's not what I'm talking about, and what I was responding to. Try to follow, or don't talk.

if all of historic Palestine becomes one state, they can always change the name.

And its not like "Israeli" is a real nationality.
 
Depends what the state is called. Palesreal, Israstine both sound a bit naff.

See? Right there is another source of conflict. It'll be decades before they can agree on a name to give their state.

Imagine what it will be for the important stuff.
 
How so? They have been at each others throats for 60 years, why would they suddenly be considerate of one another?

When did something like this ever happen in the history of mankind?

Actually, just recently we had a thread on the PA sending fire fighters over to help Israel out. It didn't go well, but that doesn't change that the event happened:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=193820

Uh?

My point was that the animosity between the French and the English in Canada can still be felt even 200 years after the last real conflict, do you think the Palestinians and Israelis won't be resentful of each other?

The Sunni and the Shia are killing eachother in Irak, and they're both Muslims. You think the Palestinians will erase and forget decades of antisemitic indoctrination and propaganda? You think Iranian ifnluence will end full-stop?

I wonder what propaganda there was in that 200-year old conflict you spoke about. Canadians managed to stay together. So did the Americans after a civil war. And Britain and Germany are friendly enough -- except when it comes to football.

And who will make that constitution?

The elves.
Or you could easily guess a more sensible answer.
 
And its not like "Israeli" is a real nationality.

facepalm2ly3.jpg
 
I wonder what propaganda there was in that 200-year old conflict you spoke about.

I'm talking about the propaganda the Palestinians are and have been feeding their children about the Israelis. Will all this go away magically?

Canadians managed to stay together.
Some of us want to seperate.

So did the Americans after a civil war.
Yes, after a civil war. Don't you think that's what's waiting the new single "Palestinian" state, civil war?

And Britain and Germany are friendly enough -- except when it comes to football.
They don't have to live together, and form a single government.
 
face-palm is a great non-response.

:)

sure, Israeli is a political nationlity. But it bears no ethnic, cultural, or even religious meaning. Unlike most other nationalities on Earth.

Yeah? What is the ethnic, cultural or religious makeup of Australia? The US? The UK? China? I can go on and on.
 
sure, Israeli is a political nationlity. But it bears no ethnic, cultural, or even religious meaning. Unlike most other nationalities on Earth.

Please, tell me how being a citizen of Israel differs from being, say, a citizen of the Republic of China (both nations being of roughly equal age and both composed of postwar refugees)?

Or, really, how it even differs from being an American. I'm a US citizen, and have been since birth. What ethnicity and religion am I, Thunder? What's my culture?
 
Or, really, how it even differs from being an American. I'm a US citizen, and have been since birth. What ethnicity and religion am I, Thunder? What's my culture?

American is also only a political nationality. It has no religious, ethnic, or racial meaning.

Unlike most nations of Europe and Asia, which are nation-states.
 
I'm talking about the propaganda the Palestinians are and have been feeding their children about the Israelis. Will all this go away magically?

There's no propaganda in the other direction?
How did the Canadians of old overcome these obstacles?

Some of us want to seperate.

Is that all?

Yes, after a civil war. Don't you think that's what's waiting the new single "Palestinian" state, civil war?

On a scale of 1 to 10, how optimistic are you generally?

They don't have to live together, and form a single government.

But we sometimes discuss a federal Europe. So it's not beyond the pale.
 
American is also only a political nationality. It has no religious, ethnic, or racial meaning.

So, you also think that America can be dismantled on a whim, and merged (even if unwillingly) into another nation, because we're not a "'real' nationality", to use your term?

EDIT: In other words, if being an Israeli is just as valid as being an American, what the hell does that have to do with the discussion of a two-state vs. one-state discussion? What's your point in saying that Israeli isn't a "real" nationality?
 
Last edited:
face-palm is a great non-response.

:)

sure, Israeli is a political nationlity. But it bears no ethnic, cultural, or even religious meaning. Unlike most other nationalities on Earth.

For someone from the US that is a pretty stupid statement.
 
Can't you answer a single of my questions seriously, Firegarden?

I try.
The points you raise are things which have been faced before. That's pretty much what I wanted to point out in my previous answers.

So Canada might vote to split up, even though there's been no real hostility for quite a long while. What if it splits? Do you think this will lead to war? If it does, will that justify how silly it was to have a single Canadian state?

You may not think those are serious answers, but I think they are.

If, after 10 years of a single state, 'Palesraelis' vote on splitting into 2 states, then that's up to them. Hell, it might even be a quicker path to a 2 state solution. I seriously can't see a 2 state solution being negotiated right now. The Palestinian unilateral declaration might well be the 2 state solution's last gasp. If it fails, why shouldn't the Palestinians demand equal rights from the government which pretty much controlls their lives? ie: demand Israeli citizenship.
 
Last edited:
For someone from the US that is a pretty stupid statement.


you are somewhat right, as most nations in Africa are not nation-states.

though, most nations of Latin America do focus on the Ibero-American peoples.
 
you are somewhat right, as most nations in Africa are not nation-states.

though, most nations of Latin America do focus on the Ibero-American peoples.

Again, so what?

Even if your odd concept of "real" nationalities were true, what do you think this means for Israel vis-a-vis the one-state or two-state solutions?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom