A'isha
Miss Schoolteacher
About this being a MySpace account that people no longer log onto: that would be an objection if there is any reason to believe the group when more active was different in its composition than the group now. But somehow I doubt that when Cleon was an active member the percentage of death-to-the-Jews folks in it was any lower, as such folks usually dominate any "free Palestine" internet group.
You know, if I were going to smear someone by accusing them of freely and knowingly associating with genocide-promoters, I'd want a bit more evidence than that.
But maybe that's just me.
Anyway I am not saying Cleon is in any way worse than the average far-left "free Palestine" guy. The point is precisely that this sort of not caring about the other guy's genocidal intentions as long as he is for "Palestinian rights", the deliberate closing of one's eyes and ears to the fact that what they are standing shoulder to shoulder with folks who consider "Palestinian rights" as simply the annihilation of Israel, and repeatedly declare this, is quite typical of the useful idiots of this sort.
You're begging the question here. You take it as a given that Cleon doesn't care about the genocidal intentions of his fellow group members (as long as all of those members are pro-Palestinian rights), without first proving that Cleon actually and knowingly did associate with people who did hold such views, at the time he was active in the group.
Again, take the "Marmara" incident. Naturally all the usual gang smeared Israel's "murderous over-reaction". Well, surprise, surprise, surprise -- it turns out that the IHH folks are terrorists whose open goal is genocide and Israel's elimination, for reasons I noted above; but all that didn't matter. They useful idiots are on the IHH's and Hamas' side anyway, simply because it lets them pontificate about "Israel's human rights abuses".
The PLO's "staged plan", the IHH's declarations and actions, the MySpace group member's support of Hamas, the Jihadi mentality -- all that is ignored by the useful idiots who support any anti-Israeli action or group as a matter of reflex. Once more: they are being used as useful idiots by folks whose real goal is genocide, and openly state it too.
And this is another issue entirely, and not nearly as clear-cut as you seem to think it is. While I (as a nominal "leftist" myself) agree with much shame that far too many on my "side" are motivated purely by anti-Israeli sentiment (which is, in most cases, merely a proxy for anti-US sentiment), the issue of Israel vs. Palestine isn't a zero-sum thing.
Or, at least, if it is, then we might as well all agree that peace in the Mideast is impossible, and go ahead and let one side completely wipe out the other.