What the Palestinians Really Want

About this being a MySpace account that people no longer log onto: that would be an objection if there is any reason to believe the group when more active was different in its composition than the group now. But somehow I doubt that when Cleon was an active member the percentage of death-to-the-Jews folks in it was any lower, as such folks usually dominate any "free Palestine" internet group.

You know, if I were going to smear someone by accusing them of freely and knowingly associating with genocide-promoters, I'd want a bit more evidence than that.

But maybe that's just me.

Anyway I am not saying Cleon is in any way worse than the average far-left "free Palestine" guy. The point is precisely that this sort of not caring about the other guy's genocidal intentions as long as he is for "Palestinian rights", the deliberate closing of one's eyes and ears to the fact that what they are standing shoulder to shoulder with folks who consider "Palestinian rights" as simply the annihilation of Israel, and repeatedly declare this, is quite typical of the useful idiots of this sort.

You're begging the question here. You take it as a given that Cleon doesn't care about the genocidal intentions of his fellow group members (as long as all of those members are pro-Palestinian rights), without first proving that Cleon actually and knowingly did associate with people who did hold such views, at the time he was active in the group.

Again, take the "Marmara" incident. Naturally all the usual gang smeared Israel's "murderous over-reaction". Well, surprise, surprise, surprise -- it turns out that the IHH folks are terrorists whose open goal is genocide and Israel's elimination, for reasons I noted above; but all that didn't matter. They useful idiots are on the IHH's and Hamas' side anyway, simply because it lets them pontificate about "Israel's human rights abuses".

The PLO's "staged plan", the IHH's declarations and actions, the MySpace group member's support of Hamas, the Jihadi mentality -- all that is ignored by the useful idiots who support any anti-Israeli action or group as a matter of reflex. Once more: they are being used as useful idiots by folks whose real goal is genocide, and openly state it too.

And this is another issue entirely, and not nearly as clear-cut as you seem to think it is. While I (as a nominal "leftist" myself) agree with much shame that far too many on my "side" are motivated purely by anti-Israeli sentiment (which is, in most cases, merely a proxy for anti-US sentiment), the issue of Israel vs. Palestine isn't a zero-sum thing.

Or, at least, if it is, then we might as well all agree that peace in the Mideast is impossible, and go ahead and let one side completely wipe out the other.
 
cute
anyway, I fully support the right of the Palestinian people to their own state in the great majority of the West Bank, all of Gaza, and the Arab areas of East Jerusalem with a part of the Old City.

I also think those Israeli settlers who would be willing to live as loyal and law-abiding citizens of Palestine, to be able to stay in their homes...as part of the new Arab State of Palestine. If Israel can have 20% Arabs...Palestine can have 10% Jews. Diversity is good for democracy.

True, should be "a cute irrational person" ;)
 
I do, but cautiously. I think the geography and history of the region makes a two-state solution untenable in the long run. My personal preference is a single state that respects the human and civil rights of all its inhabitants regardless of ethnicity or religion, and shows no preference for one or the other. Regrettably, I don't see that happening at any time in the near future.

I tend to favor the two-state solution, though I agree that if such a solution were to actually succeed, it'd have to beat some really long odds.

The idealist in me prefers the same single-state solution you describe, but the realist in me has read far too much about the demographic plans of the anti-Israel groups supporting a single state to convince me. I'm not sure such a demographic plan as overwhelming Jewish Israeli citizens with Arab Muslim Israeli citizens is actually possible to be implemented (or that, if implemented, it will actually work out the way its promoters intend), but the current demographic situation in the mideast is such that this is, in my view, a reasonable fear (in the way that similar fears of demographic takeover in, say, Europe, is not).

But if I had the solution to the problem, they'd already have given me the Nobel.
 
No, but because those "officially recognized israeli borders" are completely unachieveable and therefore basically irrelevant, I don't need to. I don't support it, I would instead like to see the lines drawn by the UN. But because the israeli version of genocide is actually happening, right now, you do need to explain why their expansion of their borders is a form of self-defence, else you cannot justify it.
Let me know when the UN is going to send troops to enforce such a declared border. Until that happens (and it won't) it is up to Israel and the Palestinians to negotiate. All the UN can do is try to keep the negotiations peaceful via diplomacy. And don't expect any results at all from the UN so long as there are individual states meddling heavily in such affairs.
 
I don't see anyone here standing shoulder to shoulder with hamas, except perhaps thunder, who has long been established as an... irrational person.

Did you see the link I posted? If Cleon isn't "standing shoulder to shoulder with Hamas", at least his online avatar is.

Most people instead seem to be supporting the rights of palestinians to not be removed from their lands. What you appear to be trying to do is inseperably equate the two, so that you can accuse anyone who is anti-israeli expansion of supporting genocide.
But, unfortunately, they ARE. And before you jump and reply in anger, please read on and see what I mean.

Why? Because, wanting to support Palestinian rights, they support a Palestinian state. They THINK that by supporting such a state all they are doing is "supporting Palestinian human rights" or "protecting Palestinian land". In reality what they are doing is supporting genocide through the "staged plan" for Israel's destruction, which is the sole purpose of such a state according to the corrupt, murderous thugs that make up the Palestinian leadership.

It is not their fault that their good intentions are misused. It is the Palestinian leadership's fault for wanting genocide. But it is their fault not to note that, all their good intentions notwithstanding, their wish to do good is merely fuel used to pressure Israel and advance the "staged plan".

If there were any truly moderate Palestinian leadership -- which would be willing to truly stop the conflict after they get a state, or accept Israel as a Jewish state -- then, indeed, the two could be separated. Then one could support a Palestinian state that is to protect the Palestinian land without supporting the genocidal thugs who are the current Palestinian leadership.

But as things are, this is impossible.

What should people do, then, if they want to protect Palestinians rights without being unwilling partners for planned genocide? Gee, I dunno... perhaps pressure the Palestinians to create a truly moderate leadership, instead of constantly pressuring Israel to give more and more to those who openly want it dead? Maybe encourage some alternative leadership outside the usual gang of terrorists?

The situation is comparable to those westerners who supported, say, Stalin's USSR during the 1930s. Did any of these people WANT Stalin to starve millions of Ukrainians? No. All they wanted is to support the building of a better, more beautiful future which is more fair than the current capitalist system, so obviously mishandled.

But had they thought for a minute about what their support for such an ideal really means in the real world -- what their love of the common man building a new future in the paradise of the workers really means there -- they would, or at least could, have discovered that all their good intentions are for naught, that they are merely being used as pawns by a murderous dictator to advance his goals.

This is precisely the situation of the well-wishing, injustice-hating supporters of a Palestinian state today. I do not for a minute suggest they WANT Israel destroyed. But they turn out to be useful idiots for just this goal. I do not for a minute suggest that a Palestinian state per se means support of the staged plan. But a Palestinian state led by the same old terrorists of Hamas and/or the PLO is.
 
I should also say, that while I do support the two-state solution, I do also believe that the hundreds of thousands of illegal Israeli settlers and the right-wing mindset in Israel, has made the two-state solution almost impossible. It would take a miracle to get an agreement...and a double-miracle to get it approved by the Knesset.

After maybe a few more years of fruitless negotiations, I expect Israel to:

a. Annex those parts of the West Bank that are within the Seperation Wall, and force those Israelis on the other side to move west of the wall.

b. declare the rest of the West Bank free of Israeli control.

...though, in all honesty, this ain't soo bad for the Palestinians, as it gives them more than 90% of the West Bank. But none of East Jerusalem.

But still...its 90% better than nothing.
 
Last edited:
Let me know when the UN is going to send troops to enforce such a declared border. Until that happens (and it won't) it is up to Israel and the Palestinians to negotiate. All the UN can do is try to keep the negotiations peaceful via diplomacy. And don't expect any results at all from the UN so long as there are individual states meddling heavily in such affairs.

You appear to have forgotten to explain why expanding your borders is self-defence.
 
This would be the State of Palestine, if Israel withdrew to the Seperation Wall. Its far from perfect, but it ain't bad.



316px-Westbank_barrier.png
 
Last edited:
Why? Because, wanting to support Palestinian rights, they support a Palestinian state. They THINK that by supporting such a state all they are doing is "supporting Palestinian human rights" or "protecting Palestinian land". In reality what they are doing is supporting genocide through the "staged plan" for Israel's destruction,

BS. The Israeli-right will find any and ever excuse they can, to avoid leaving their "Land of Israel".

What do you think the eventual purpose of the Hafrada Wall is??? Its a damn border.
 
Why? Because, wanting to support Palestinian rights, they support a Palestinian state. They THINK that by supporting such a state all they are doing is "supporting Palestinian human rights" or "protecting Palestinian land". In reality what they are doing is supporting genocide through the "staged plan" for Israel's destruction, which is the sole purpose of such a state according to the corrupt, murderous thugs that make up the Palestinian leadership.

Only if you can't distinguish between "supporting a Palestinian state" as a general goal, and "supporting a Palestinian state" as an entity ruled by the likes of Hamas (or even Fatah). And even then, the latter contains an assumption that the thugs who make up the Palestinian leadership are actually capable of driving the Palestinian people as a whole to carry out the entire long-term staged plan.

It's a lot easier to whip up anti-Israeli sentiment among a stateless populace seeing (what it considers as) its territory being occupied than it is to do the same among a populace with its own sovereign state and defined territorial borders. This is the same reason even other Arab Muslim nations like Jordan treat the Palestinians the way they do - the Palestinians are more useful to them the way they currently are.

What should people do, then, if they want to protect Palestinians rights without being unwilling partners for planned genocide? Gee, I dunno... perhaps pressure the Palestinians to create a truly moderate leadership, instead of constantly pressuring Israel to give more and more to those who openly want it dead? Maybe encourage some alternative leadership outside the usual gang of terrorists?

I agree with this. This is why I don't comment much on Israeli actions in this conflict; I may not really agree with (or like) what they're doing, but not only is there little else the Israelis can do in the current situation, facing the enemies they do with the goals that those enemies have, focusing pressure solely on Israel won't actually solve the problem. If, by some strange happenstance, Israel were to surrender tomorrow to every demand made on them, the result would be nothing short of disastrous for all involved.

But by the same token, the status quo cannot be maintained. Something will have to give, sooner or later. Personally, I'd rather that be a peaceful two-state solution with a moderate government in power in Palestine (or whatever the state gets named), ending up (as Imam Rauf himself writes) with the two states becoming each others' strongest trading partners.

But it unfortunately isn't up to me.
 
Last edited:
This is precisely the situation of the well-wishing, injustice-hating supporters of a Palestinian state today. I do not for a minute suggest they WANT Israel destroyed. But they turn out to be useful idiots for just this goal. I do not for a minute suggest that a Palestinian state per se means support of the staged plan. But a Palestinian state led by the same old terrorists of Hamas and/or the PLO is.

Well, I thank you for being civil, but I completely disagree with your analysis. You appear to believe that if palestine exists under hamas, they will always be trying to destroy israel.

For one, the extreme situation is in part brought about by the israeli expansion. There would still be terrorist rocket attacks anyway, but over time, the anger would subside if israel stopped expanding. Part of the reason the palestinians elect an extreme government is because of this anger. I imagine some palestinians hate jews because they are jews, but others will hate jews because those jews keep turfing them out of their homes and building settlements there. Take away this factor, and some of the extremism will drop, over time.

And the other point is, what other options are there? Either israel stops expanding, and puts up with the palestinians on its border, or israel keeps expanding, and eventually exterminates the palestinian race. Given these two options, which do you favour? It is regrettable that this is the situation we are in, but it is what happens if you create a new country in the middle of the most politically volatile region on the planet, and then start expanding it.

To me, the best solution seems to be for the countries to make the following offer: for Israel to stop expanding it's borders, and agree never to do so again. Furthermore, they surrender their illegal nuclear weapons. In exchange, hamas agree to declare their hostilities against israel to be over, and recognise the border between the two countries as it stands. The UN would have to agree to draw up an official border. It's debatable as to how well it would work, but I believe hamas would be willing to accept being seen as an organisation that finally stopped israeli expansion, rather than one that failed to resist and ended up losing more territory. Israel probably wouldn't go for it, but they really should.
 
You appear to have forgotten to explain why expanding your borders is self-defence.
What borders are you talking about? The ones recognized by the Palestinians? Israel?

Those are the players that count. And when they recognize no borders, the conflict and violence will continue. When they agree on a border, there will be peace. Or at least it will be a lot more peaceful.

eta: and it goes without saying that a larger country is more easily defended from complete invasion than a smaller one, in case you were being literal.
 
Last edited:
What borders are you talking about? The ones recognized by the Palestinians? Israel?

Those are the players that count. And when they recognize no borders, the conflict and violence will continue. When they agree on a border, there will be peace. Or at least it will be a lot more peaceful.

The physically existing borders now. Israel is expanding them by building settlements. I am not referring to abstract concepts of potentially desired borders, but where they actually lie as a result of populations and housing.
 
The physically existing borders now. Israel is expanding them by building settlements. I am not referring to abstract concepts of potentially desired borders, but where they actually lie as a result of populations and housing.
Those are called "facts on the ground", and are a powerful bargaining chip. I expect a future agreement would allow these areas to become part of Israel, and sparsely populated Israeli land swapped in exchange.
 
Those are called "facts on the ground", and are a powerful bargaining chip. I expect a future agreement would allow these areas to become part of Israel, and sparsely populated Israeli land swapped in exchange.

Well, whatever you want to call them, how do you justify israel expanding theirs?
 
Well, whatever you want to call them, how do you justify israel expanding theirs?

all of the land between the River and the Sea, was promised to the Jews by God and later by the League of Nations Mandate for Palestine, and the Balfour Letter.

;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom