What the Palestinians Really Want

"Guilt by association" is only a fallacy when it is wrongly that you associate with someone when in reality there is merely an accidental agreement in opinions about something, as in "Hitler was a vegetarian!" as evidence that the vegetarian down the street is wrong.

Here we have something quite different. Here, you knowingly, voluntarily, socially and publicly associate yourself with those who openly support genocidal murder -- it is not something your opponents falsely claim you do. That is like opening a vegetarian restaurant and decorating it with pictures of Der Fuhrer.

its only a fallacy when others use it :rolleyes:
 
See my post above, then link to the PA and Arab League's officially recognized Israeli border.

Can you do that?

No, but because those "officially recognized israeli borders" are completely unachieveable and therefore basically irrelevant, I don't need to. I don't support it, I would instead like to see the lines drawn by the UN. But because the israeli version of genocide is actually happening, right now, you do need to explain why their expansion of their borders is a form of self-defence, else you cannot justify it.
 
"Guilt by association" is only a fallacy when it is wrongly that you associate with someone when in reality there is merely an accidental agreement in opinions about something, as in "Hitler was a vegetarian!" as evidence that the vegetarian down the street is wrong.

Here we have something quite different. Here, you knowingly, voluntarily, socially and publicly associate yourself with those who openly support genocidal murder -- it is not something your opponents falsely claim you do. That is like opening a vegetarian restaurant and decorating it with pictures of Der Fuhrer.

And if there were someone who is a proud and open member of the political party you favor who supports genocide and death camps for all Palestinians, everywhere, that would likewise taint you with the same brush, right?
 
In any large group you will find a few nuts no matter what the group is for. But that's quite different from knowingly joining a group of 300 of people of whom several prominent members are open supporters of genocide, and, what's more, practically think Israel has a right to exist at all (their disagreement is merely about whether the Jews should be expelled or killed) -- and not dissociate yourself from them when you learn this.

Let's take -- again -- the vegetarians in America. I'm sure that of a few million vegetarians there are some nuts who think killing all meat-eaters as "murderers" is justified. But what if you joined the "Atlanta vegetarians association" association, and it turns out that out of about 300 members, quite a few of them support such murder?
 
But that's quite different from knowingly joining a group of 300 of people of whom several prominent members are open supporters of genocide,

The two highlighted parts are the bits you just made up out of thin air. You've been trying to stretch this so far that you've now crossed over into plain old lying.

At no point did APS have anywhere close to 300 people involved. The MySpace account was used for communication; congratulations, you've found the equivalent of a long-disused mailing list from an organization that doesn't exist anymore.

This individual, whoever it was, was not "prominent" in the group. Neither of us even knows his name. And the "several" bit? Cute. Complete crap, of course, but you seem dead-set on fabricating as much crap as possible out of this whatever the reality might be.

Nobody actually involved in APS was, to my knowledge, a supporter of genocide (openly or otherwise). Being "friends" on MySpace does not equate to "involved."
 
Last edited:
Let's take -- again -- the vegetarians in America. I'm sure that of a few million vegetarians there are some nuts who think killing all meat-eaters as "murderers" is justified. But what if you joined the "Atlanta vegetarians association" association, and it turns out that out of about 300 members, quite a few of them support such murder?

It depends on a) what the stated and explicit aims of the association are, b) how influential these nuts are in controlling and directing the dialogue of the association's members regarding the association's aims, c) how active the association is in promoting its aims vs. simply saying "By joining this group I support in general terms the stated aims", and d) how easy it is to join the association and/or declare oneself to be a member.

In other words, joining a group whose stated goals are the genocide of the Israeli people (and Jews in general) and that has regular meetings and is actively working to promote that goal is rather different from joining a group with vague platitudes as its mission statement, conducts no meetings or advocacy activities, and that anyone can join with a simple mouse-click, that has some members that support the genocide of Jews in general and Israelis in particular.

Now, I personally would probably leave a group, even of the second type, that seemed to have a large majority of homicidal nutcases like that. But I also wouldn't assume that anyone who is a member of that group of the second type supports the ravings of those nutcases.

EDIT: There's also the issue of this being a MySpace group. I haven't logged into my own MySpace account in several years. If any of the groups I joined back when I was active were, for example, taken over by murderous nutcases during the years after I simply stopped bothering to log in, I'd be pretty ticked about being smeared by some sort of guilt by association attack for the sole reason that they and I happen to belong to the same group, now in December 2010.
 
Last edited:
EDIT: There's also the issue of this being a MySpace group. I haven't logged into my own MySpace account in several years. If any of the groups I joined back when I was active were, for example, taken over by murderous nutcases during the years after I simply stopped bothering to log in, I'd be pretty ticked about being smeared by some sort of guilt by association attack for the sole reason that they and I happen to belong to the same group, now in December 2010.

Which is essentially the stunt that "Skeptic" is trying to pull. I'm not ticked so much as amused that he thinks this is some sort of legitimate point.
 
So while you, your neighbor and the authorities are in negotiation about the borders, you believe its ok for you to build a fence where you want it?

There are anti-semites here in the JREF forums but I will remain a member.

an on the other side of the coin, there are rabid zionists........
both are despicable.
 
About this being a MySpace account that people no longer log onto: that would be an objection if there is any reason to believe the group when more active was different in its composition than the group now. But somehow I doubt that when Cleon was an active member the percentage of death-to-the-Jews folks in it was any lower, as such folks usually dominate any "free Palestine" internet group.

Anyway I am not saying Cleon is in any way worse than the average far-left "free Palestine" guy. The point is precisely that this sort of not caring about the other guy's genocidal intentions as long as he is for "Palestinian rights", the deliberate closing of one's eyes and ears to the fact that what they are standing shoulder to shoulder with folks who consider "Palestinian rights" as simply the annihilation of Israel, and repeatedly declare this, is quite typical of the useful idiots of this sort.

Again, take the "Marmara" incident. Naturally all the usual gang smeared Israel's "murderous over-reaction". Well, surprise, surprise, surprise -- it turns out that the IHH folks are terrorists whose open goal is genocide and Israel's elimination, for reasons I noted above; but all that didn't matter. They useful idiots are on the IHH's and Hamas' side anyway, simply because it lets them pontificate about "Israel's human rights abuses".

The PLO's "staged plan", the IHH's declarations and actions, the MySpace group member's support of Hamas, the Jihadi mentality -- all that is ignored by the useful idiots who support any anti-Israeli action or group as a matter of reflex. Once more: they are being used as useful idiots by folks whose real goal is genocide, and openly state it too.
 
About this being a MySpace account that people no longer log onto: that would be an objection if there is any reason to believe the group when more active was different in its composition than the group now.

As I've been telling you - the group doesn't exist anymore. So yes, it was considerably different in its composition than it is now.

But somehow I doubt that when Cleon was an active member the percentage of death-to-the-Jews folks in it was any lower, as such folks usually dominate any "free Palestine" internet group.
Of course you do. :rolleyes:

However, oddly, in this case, you're correct; the percentage of "death-to-the-Jews folks" involved in APS has remained at 0%.

Anyway I am not saying Cleon is in any way worse than the average far-left "free Palestine" guy. The point is precisely that this sort of not caring about the other guy's genocidal intentions as long as he is for "Palestinian rights",
Which you establish by the vaguest of associations on a disused website of a defunct organization. Truly, your logical thinking is something to behold.
 
Last edited:
The PLO's "staged plan", the IHH's declarations and actions, the MySpace group member's support of Hamas, the Jihadi mentality -- all that is ignored by the useful idiots who support any anti-Israeli action or group as a matter of reflex. Once more: they are being used as useful idiots by folks whose real goal is genocide, and openly state it too.

Edited by jhunter1163: 
Edited for civility.
Most people instead seem to be supporting the rights of palestinians to not be removed from their lands. What you appear to be trying to do is inseperably equate the two, so that you can accuse anyone who is anti-israeli expansion of supporting genocide.

An easier test than checking someones myspace friends to discover their political allegiance, is to ask them.

So, Cleon, do you support the genocide of the israeli people? Do you, instead, support the palestinian right to a country with UN-set borders that are not invaded by an expanding israel? Or do you have some other opinion?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So, Cleon, do you support the genocide of the israeli people?

No, I most certainly do not.

(See, that's what happens when you ask someone what they think, rather than tell them. Take notes, "Skeptic.")

Do you, instead, support the palestinian right to a country with UN-set borders that are not invaded by an expanding israel? Or do you have some other opinion?

I do, but cautiously. I think the geography and history of the region makes a two-state solution untenable in the long run. My personal preference is a single state that respects the human and civil rights of all its inhabitants regardless of ethnicity or religion, and shows no preference for one or the other. Regrettably, I don't see that happening at any time in the near future.
 
Edited by jhunter1163: 
Moderated content removed.

cute

anyway, I fully support the right of the Palestinian people to their own state in the great majority of the West Bank, all of Gaza, and the Arab areas of East Jerusalem with a part of the Old City.

I also think those Israeli settlers who would be willing to live as loyal and law-abiding citizens of Palestine, to be able to stay in their homes...as part of the new Arab State of Palestine. If Israel can have 20% Arabs...Palestine can have 10% Jews. Diversity is good for democracy.

However, those Israeli settlers who refuse to becoming Palestinian citizens, and do not reside in the 5% or so of the West Bank that will be annexed to Israel, will have to be removed by force if they refuse to leave.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom