What the Palestinians Really Want

Skeptic

Banned
Joined
Jul 25, 2001
Messages
18,312
Details here.

Folks -- those who are supporting the Palestinians are simply supporting genocide. Sorry to ruin the fantasies.
 
Details here.

Folks -- those who are supporting the Palestinians are simply supporting genocide. Sorry to ruin the fantasies.

Hmmmm...........another lie. Never mind there is always a New Years resolution to attempt eh? I also suggest you choose your sources more carefully.
 

Oh, look! You found someone repeating the same ************ you've been spewing here for years! Clearly, you must be 100% correct after all, and the Palestinians are simply human garbage.

Folks -- those who are supporting the Palestinians are simply supporting genocide. Sorry to ruin the fantasies.
You are quite simply full of ****. Sorry to ruin the fantasy.
 
When I read things like:
http://pajamasmedia.com/blog/the-palestinian-agenda-end-israel-not-found-a-state/?singlepage=true

Yasser Arafat turned down Ehud Barak’s overly generous offer at Camp David and Taba.

I stop reading. And, if you have any memory, you know why. And you'll also be expecting a link to this debate:
http://www.democracynow.org/2006/2/14/fmr_israeli_foreign_minister_if_i

I still agree with Finkelstein:

Democracy Now said:
Now, it is correct to say that if you frame everything in terms of what Israel wanted, it made huge concessions. However, if you frame things in terms of what Israel was legally entitled to under international law, then Israel made precisely and exactly zero concessions. All the concessions were made by the Palestinians.

[...] The World Court in July 2004 ruled that all the settlements are illegal. The Palestinians were willing to concede 50%—50% of the Israeli settlements in the West Bank. That was a monumental concession, going well beyond anything that was demanded of them under international law.

[...] On every single issue, all the concessions came from the Palestinians. The problem is, everyone, including Dr. Ben-Ami in his book—he begins with what Israel wants and how much of its wants it’s willing to give up. But that’s not the relevant framework. The only relevant framework is under international law what you are entitled to, and when you use that framework it’s a very, very different picture.

And Shlomo ben Ami, too:

Democracy Now said:
SHLOMO BEN-AMI: Yes, yes. Okay, the last third part of the book, as Dr. Finkelstein says, there is the diplomat, and this same diplomat still behaves in a way as a historian when he says in this book that Camp David was not the missed opportunity for the Palestinians, and if I were a Palestinian I would have rejected Camp David, as well. This is something I put in the book. But Taba is the problem.

[...] it is almost impossible to do things on the basis of international law, but rather, on something that is as close as possible to the requirements of international law. The very fact that, as Dr. Finkelstein rightly says, the Palestinians were ready to make this or that concession is the reflection of them understanding that there is no viability, there is no possibility really to reach an agreement that says let us apply automatically and rigidly the requirements of international law.

I've not said who Shlomo ben Ami is. Maybe this time no one will fall in the trap of calling him an anti-Israel anti-semite.

Going back to Taba: ben-Ami said :"But Taba is the problem."

[Finkelstein] Both sides entered reservations on the Clinton parameters. Dr. Ben-Ami leaves out in the book both sides. He only mentions the reservations by the Palestinians.

[...]

[ben-Ami] Ours was not a document about reservations, it was a statement, basically, that said these were our positions, this is where we stand today. we have gone a very long way, we cannot go beyond that. This was essentially what we sent.

[...]

[ben-Ami, on why Barak's team left] We saw that we are not reaching an agreement, and we need to go back, even if for the electoral campaign. I mean, we were a week before the elections. I mean, we were practically nonexistent. Our legitimacy as a government to negotiate such central issues as Jerusalem, as Temple Mount, the temple, etc., was being questioned, not only by the right that was making political capital out of it, but by the left, people from our own government. "Shlomo Ben-Ami is ready to sell out the country for the sake of a Nobel Prize." This is what Haim Ramon said, one of the labor ministers, so it was unsustainable. We could not go any longer.

So ben-Ami says that Israel had gone as far as it was willing to go. Considering Finkelstein's point, that Israel was giving up things it wanted rather than things it was entitled to under international law, that leaves the Palestinians to give up more of what international law entitles them to. Why should they?

If the Palestinians do have a dastardly plan of always sayiing "no" when they are offered less than everything they are entitled to (and ben-Ami agrees they actually made concessions, giving up what international law says is theirs) then it's easy for Israel to foil this plan: Don't wait on the Palestinians to give the things they have a right to; give up the things you want but are not entitled to. Like the West Bank and Gaza.

(No. The occupation of Gaza didn't end when Israel removed its settlements -- those were illegal under international law, their removal ended the commission of that crime.)
 
The OP is as accurate as "What the Jews really want is to take over the world"
 
Details here.

Folks -- those who are supporting the Palestinians are simply supporting genocide. Sorry to ruin the fantasies.

Most of them ( and I do spend time scourging the ones this does not apply to) want to work, have have family time, a good job, time to be with their friends and occasionally drop by the mosque on a big fun holiday. Just like most other people. They may have been talked or scared into being anti-Jew, but they don't have a hard-on for it. MOST of them. Works the other direction too.
 
Here is another example, from yesterday's paper. Remember the IHH and the Mavi Marmara flotilla incident? And how the useful idiots on this forum were full of rage about Israel's action?

Well, surprise surpise: the IHH and thousand of other Islamic supporters arrange a big carnaval today in Turkey as the Mavi Marmara returned home. In it the IHH's preaches told the adoring crowd that -- surprise! -- Israel's destruction is their goal, and they will not rest until it is achieved.

Of course, the IHH being on the European terrorist list, it telling the Israelies who asked the ship to stop to "go back to Auschwitz", and its 'peace' activists singing the Islamists' death-to-the-Jews song ("Khayabar, Kahybar, oh Jews! Muhammad's army will return!" -- Khaybar being the Jewish tribe Muhammad slaughtered when he had a spare moment), should have been a dead giveaway.

But the useful idiots take the side of genocidal antisemites -- and when I say this, I mean that's the way those genocidal antisemites proudly describe themselves. Why? Due to some fantasy that they are engaged in 'humanitarian actions' or are 'against Israeli occupation'. They seem not to notice that the folks they embrace mean by 'occupation' simply 'the existence of Israel'.
 
I just want to clarify one thing: as always, and as I repeatedly said, I am not saying every Palestinian as an individual wants this. I mean the Palestinians as a group, based on what their leaders and their schoolbooks and television programs say.

It's the same sort of observation as saying that Iran's goal is Israel's destruction, or the USSR's goal was to take over eastern Europe. It doesn't mean every single Iranian or Soviet citizen was full of enthusiatic support for such notions.

I urge everybody to look at MEMRI's web site. It shows a grim picture of what the Arab world really thinks -- but also, in that picture, many individuals that are a force for democracy, peace, and freedom. That's the kind of difference between individuals and wholes I'm speaking about.
 
Headline from the article

The Palestinian Agenda: End Israel, Not Found a State

To prove this he refers to a debate among Palestinians as to whether or not Israel should be recognised as a "Jewish" state. That is quite a different matter, it's like demanding that the USA be recognised as a white state or a xian state.

It takes David Solway to be able to tell us what someone else entirely different really wants. Is he a mind reader?
 
Cleon -- you, personally, are a "Friend" of the Myspace "Atlanta Palestine Solidarity Movement", right?

Did you note that your "friends" includes people whose online icon is Hamas' seal? (You, yourself, are only a few "friends" below him). The same Hamas which openly and repeatedly declares its genocidal antisemitic goals are precisely that?

Numerous others who openly express their desire for Israel to disappear are there, too -- such as the "Al Adwa" friend (the one right below you on the friends list), who advocates the so-called "right of return", that is, destroying Israel by demographic means. And that's just from a cursory look on the first page of "friends". God knows who else is on the other 27 pages of "friends" there.

Now, you remain to this day a "friend" in that group. You would never, I am certain, remain a "friend" in a group which had members whose online avatar was, say, a Swastika or a KKK symbol. Nor would you tolerate having only a few such people in a larger group of your friends. But when it is all about "freeing Palestine", you overlook such genocidal antisemitism, all for the chummy internet togetherness of feeling you are "working for justice in Palestine" or something.

So, yes, as your own personal history proves, those you hang out with do support Israel's destruction, and you know it, and still hang out with them.
 
this thread is pathetic.

Israelis building walls, illegal settlements, and confiscating land, and yet playing victim.

its funny stuff.
 
Last edited:
Cleon -- you, personally, are a "Friend" of the Myspace "Atlanta Palestine Solidarity Movement", right?

Did you note that your "friends" includes people whose online icon is Hamas' seal? (You, yourself, are only a few "friends" below him). The same Hamas which openly and repeatedly declares its genocidal antisemitic goals are precisely that?

Numerous others who openly express their desire for Israel to disappear are there, too -- such as the "Al Adwa" friend (the one right below you on the friends list), who advocates the so-called "right of return", that is, destroying Israel by demographic means. And that's just from a cursory look on the first page of "friends". God knows who else is on the other 27 pages of "friends" there.

Now, you remain to this day a "friend" in that group. You would never, I am certain, remain a "friend" in a group which had members whose online avatar was, say, a Swastika or a KKK symbol. Nor would you tolerate having only a few such people in a larger group of your friends. But when it is all about "freeing Palestine", you overlook such genocidal antisemitism, all for the chummy internet togetherness of feeling you are "working for justice in Palestine" or something.

So, yes, as your own personal history proves, those you hang out with do support Israel's destruction, and you know it, and still hang out with them.

so 1 out of 533 to make your point that all those 533 support genocide?
could it be we could find also 1 in a group of 533 that support Israel that would want to wipe out the camel-jockeys? I am pretty sure Freepers will show a much higher rate.....
 
this thread is pathetic.

Israelis building walls, illegal settlements, and confiscating land, and yet playing victim.

its funny stuff.
Yes, it's hilarious when Jews have to defend themselves against genocidal religious nutcases who consider all of Israel proper "occupied land".
 
Yes, it's hilarious when Jews have to defend themselves against genocidal religious nutcases who consider all of Israel proper "occupied land".

Defending your Home is perfectly fine, as long you do it in your home. You cant build a fence in your neighbors home.
 
Yes, it's hilarious when Jews have to defend themselves against genocidal religious nutcases who consider all of Israel proper "occupied land".

I've still never had it explained to me, satisfactorily, how "expanding your borders into another countries' borders" is a form of self-defence. It seems to me the only way this would ever stop terrorist attacks is by completely eliminating the palestinians as a race, and you guys claim to be firmly against genocide.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom